Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Affiliate Marketing › Troubleshooting

Top Affiliates Leaving the Programme

Why the partners who brought most new customers have gone quiet: terms below the market, slow payment, credit lost at checkout and no account manager.
Troubleshootingintermediate17 min readUpdated

First, list the partners whose share of new customers fell and ask each what changed

Start from the order system, not from the platform's league table. Rank every partner by the new customers it brought in each of the last few periods, read from the order system's own new-customer flag, and set the current period beside the earlier ones. The Pareto principle is the right tool for the reading: rank by the value measure that matters, new customers and contribution after commission rather than tracked sales, add a running total, and look at where it climbs steeply. A programme whose top few partners bring most of its new customers shows the loss in that head of the list, and the running total says how concentrated it is; a fall at three partners is a different problem from a small fall across hundreds. The framework also warns about mix: a blended total can move because the tail shrank or grew, so read each partner's own line beside the total.

Then separate leaving from pausing. Partners publish on their own schedule, and a seasonal guide goes quiet between peaks. Open each partner's live pages and look for your links: still there and working, replaced by a rival's, or gone with the brand from the roundup. Read clicks beside sales, because a partner whose clicks hold while credited sales fall has not stopped sending customers, it has stopped being paid for them, and that is a credit problem rather than a relationship problem. New-customer share by partner says which of the losses matter most to the programme.

Then ask. A partner who is unhappy about a rejection, a rate or a rival's offer rarely announces it in a report; a named contact who talks to them regularly hears it first, and where nobody at the brand has that relationship, the call that starts this diagnosis is the moment to begin one. Say what you have seen in the figures and ask what changed. The answers sort into the causes in the table below, and most partners give them plainly: the rate, the money, the clicks, the silence, the change nobody told them about, or the move.

Three neighbouring problems belong to other pages. If the partners never produced sales in the first place, affiliates not generating sales is the page to read; if the worry is what keeping or winning back the partners will cost, start with affiliate commission costs rising. A programme whose results fell after a handover to a new agency or manager rather than a new platform has the shape of results dropped after changing agency, where lost account history and dropped exclusions do the damage. The affiliate troubleshooting hub routes the other symptoms.

Diagnosis table

Diagnosis

SymptomCheckLikely causeFix
Partners say another programme pays better, or a rival's link now sits where yours used toWhat each partner earned per visitor sent under your rate, conversion and order value, against the ceiling your margin allowsA base rate or tiers below what comparable programmes pay the partners the business most wantsPay more for the new customers you want from the partners you want, inside the margin ceiling, with partner-specific rates that carry a reason and a review date
Partners ask where their money is, or dispute rejections they were never given a reason forThe time from tracked to approved to paid against the terms, and the reason recorded on each rejectionValidation and payment slower than the terms promised, or commission rejected without explanationValidate monthly inside the platform's window, reject only on the grounds the terms state with the reason shown, and pay on the schedule promised
Review sites' credited orders fell while voucher or extension partners' orders roseThe click path of the orders a review site says it startedContent partners' clicks overwritten by voucher or extension partners, so their work goes unpaidProtect content partners' clicks in the credit rule, write it into the terms, and show partners the click path
Partners who used to feature the brand now hear about launches from their readersWhether each key partner has a named contact, a joint plan and early notice of offersNo named contact, no joint plan and no early notice of launches and offersName a contact for each key partner, agree a plan with each and brief them before launches and offers
Partners went quiet in the month a rate, window or rule changedThe version log and the platform's history against the date the change took effect and the notice givenTerms or rates changed without notice, which the terms tutorial treats as the fastest way to lose trustHonour the previous version for conversions tracked before the change, then re-issue it with notice and a version log
Partners' sales fell on the new platform, or they never joined itEach moved partner's sales before and after, their live links, and pending commission still on the old platformA move to a new platform that lost partners' links, history or payment detailsCall the partners who matter, carry over their deals and links, and settle every pending commission on the old platform

Fix, verify and prevent each cause

A base rate or tiers below what the partners you want can earn elsewhere

The commission structures guide treats a commission as a price for an outcome and describes the partner's side of the bargain: a partner judges a programme on what it earns per click or per visitor sent, which depends on the commission rate, the conversion rate and the order value together, and a programme that sets the price too low finds that good partners go elsewhere. The ceiling, in the same guide, comes from the business's own numbers, contribution margin per order less platform cost and required profit, and the value of a customer over time (lifetime value) can justify paying more than the first order earns where the payback is acceptable. Copying competitors' rates is the mistake it names first, because their margins, customers and partners are not yours.

Fix: work out what each departed partner earned per visitor under your rate and conversion, then find room inside the ceiling for the outcomes you want from them: a higher rate on new customers, a partner-specific rate recorded with its reason and a review date, a bonus for a seasonal feature, or a tier on new-customer share rather than volume. Raise rates for the valuable segments before cutting anything, and announce every change with notice.

Verify: the partners you called publish again, their new customers return at a cost per new customer that sits inside the ceiling, and each segment stays above the break-even floor at the next review.

Prevent: review the structure quarterly, as the guide sets out, asking which partners bring new customers and whether they are paid enough to keep doing so, and keep every partner-specific rate on a list with its reason and review date so that no deal is forgotten and no partner is quietly underpaid.

Validation and payment slower than the terms promised, or rejections with no reason

The commission guide sets the balance: a validation period should cover the returns window plus the time the checks need, and one that runs too long makes partners wait unreasonably for money they have earned, which drives the best ones away. The validation period entry describes the same trade-off. The tutorial on closing the month on affiliate commissions runs the routine that keeps the promise: pull the month's conversions by status, validate pending conversions against the order system, approve or reject inside the platform's window with the reason recorded where the partner can see it, apply only the rejection grounds the terms state, open a case rather than rejecting in bulk when a partner's pattern looks wrong, match the invoice or payout to the approvals, and compare the estimate with what finally arrived.

Fix: run the next close on that routine and clear the backlog of pending conversions whose returns window has closed; go back over the rejections partners disputed, record a reason against each or reverse those that had none, and tell the partners what was done; and where the validation period in the platform runs longer than the returns window and the checks need, shorten it and update the timing clause so the document and the settings agree.

Verify: the time from tracked to approved to paid matches what the terms promise, every rejection in the platform carries a reason, and the disputes stop arriving.

Prevent: keep the close on a fixed date with a named approver, and never let commission be approved by default because nobody acted before the platform's approval date.

Content partners' clicks overwritten at the checkout

The attribution and deduplication guide explains the quiet version of leaving: the platform's default credits the last affiliate click in the window, the partners clicked last are the voucher, cashback and extension partners at the checkout, and the review site that introduced the customer goes unpaid while its clicks hold steady. The guide's remedy is last click with protection, under which the last click wins unless an earlier partner belongs to a protected group, and its override list lets the programme say that an extension partner's click never overwrites a content partner's. It is also explicit that deduplication applied in secret loses the best partners first.

Fix: define the protected group, usually content and review partners, and the period the protection covers; put extension and voucher partners on the override list; write the rule into the terms before applying it; and show each partner the click path for the orders it says it started, so the conversation is about the rule rather than about trust.

Verify: take a sample of orders credited to checkout-stage partners after the change and look for an earlier protected click; those orders now sit with the content partner, and its credited orders recover without its clicks changing.

Prevent: keep the override list current and visible in the terms, read the gap between tracked and paid conversions in the monthly reconciliation as the early warning the guide describes, and explain any change to the rule before it appears in anyone's statement.

No named contact, no joint plan and no early notice of launches and offers

The guide to managing key affiliate partners makes the point that a brand which only sends its best partners the monthly newsletter competes for their attention with every other programme they belong to, while a brand that knows their plans and gives them what they need before they ask gets a partner who plans content around its launches. Its list of what a key partner needs is practical: product information and approved claims before launch, samples and access, advance notice of launches, range changes and promotions, creative and deep links, their own performance figures, and one contact who answers quickly and resolves rejected commissions fairly.

Fix: choose the key partner list on new customers and margin rather than tracked sales, keep it to the number the team can genuinely manage, name a contact for each partner, and agree a short joint plan with each that says what the partner will publish and when, what the brand will brief and provide, and which figures both sides will read. Record any exclusive and any tenancy the partner offers for a fee in the plan, and judge each on its own terms. Then meet on a fixed rhythm with figures both sides have seen beforehand, and end each review with what each side will do next.

Verify: the partners on the list publish around your launches rather than learning of them from their readers, the plan's items are ticked or explained at each review, and rejected commissions are resolved before they become complaints.

Prevent: watch each key partner's share of the programme's new customers and build alternatives deliberately where one share grows large; move a partner off the list with notice and a reason rather than letting the plan lapse. The guide to building long-term creator partnerships covers the same questions for creators paid a fee.

Terms or rates changed without notice

The tutorial on writing affiliate programme terms gives the change-notice rule its own clause: how the business announces changes to commission or terms, how much notice it gives, and from when a change applies to conversions already tracked, with a version log and each partner's acceptance of each version behind it. The commission guide supplies the reason: changing windows or rates without notice is one of the fastest ways to lose partners' trust, and an abrupt cut damages relationships across the programme rather than only with the partner affected. A rate changed in the platform during a cost review, a window shortened to trim the bill, or a credit rule applied from a date nobody announced all look the same from the partner's side: a statement that no longer matches the terms they accepted.

Fix: find the change in the version log, or in the platform's history where no log exists; honour the previous version for conversions tracked before the change took effect; write to every partner affected with what changed, why and from when; and either withdraw the change or re-issue it with the notice the terms state. Where a rate had to fall, prefer the structural change the commission guide describes, paying more for what the business wants and less for what it does not, over a flat cut.

Verify: each partner can see which version of the terms applied to each conversion on its statement, and the next change reaches partners before it reaches their figures.

Prevent: keep the version log and the acceptance records, and put every change to rates, windows, validation or credit rules on a change calendar that cannot be shortened by a budget meeting.

The tutorial on moving an affiliate programme to a new platform lists where moves lose partners: they hear about it from someone else, the new terms are worse or merely different, the tracking has never seen a real sale, old links keep working on the old platform, pending commission is forgotten, and the history needed to judge partners stays behind. Each of those shows up later as a partner who did not move or whose sales fell after moving.

Fix: for the partners who never joined, call the most valuable personally, explain what changes and what stays the same, give them terms at least as good as before with every partner-specific deal carried over, and send their new links with a date for replacing the old ones; for the partners whose sales fell, check their live pages for old links and trace the gap rather than assuming they stopped promoting; and on the old platform, keep validating to the last conversion inside the window, make sure the final payments reach partners, and reconcile approved with paid, because unpaid commission from the old platform is the fastest way to undo the trust the move needed.

Verify: each moved partner's sales on the new platform match what it produced on the old one, no partner is owed money on the old platform, and the reporting history notes the date each partner moved so that later comparisons do not read the move as a change in performance.

Prevent: run the next move in the tutorial's order, scope and date, contract and exports, terms, tracking tested before any partner moves, partners in order of value, a parallel period under one deduplication rule, settlement and closure, and keep it outside the business's peak.

Prevention: a key partner list with a named contact, a review rhythm and notice before any change

Every cause above was visible to someone at the partner's end long before it was visible in the brand's report, and the prevention habit is to be the person they tell. The key partner list comes first: the partners chosen on new customers and contribution after commission, ranked as the Pareto reading ranks them, with the movers watched as closely as the leaders because next year's key partners are climbing the list now. Keep it to the number the team can meet on the planned rhythm, give every partner on it a named contact, and give every contact the time to call.

The rhythm comes second, and most of it already exists in the owning guides. The month closes on a fixed date, with pending conversions validated, every rejection carrying a reason and payment on the schedule the terms promise. The same month includes a look at the top partners' figures and a conversation with each. Each quarter places every partner in a tier on quality signals and reviews the commission structure against the margin ceiling and the market the partners can see. The key partner reviews sit alongside that rhythm with shared figures, a joint plan and two short lists at the end. A review that changes nothing on either side is the first sign the relationship is drifting.

Notice comes third. No change to rates, windows, the validation period or the credit rule goes into the platform before it has gone to partners with the notice the terms state, a version log entry and a date from which it applies to tracked conversions. A credit rule is written before it is applied; a rate cut is replaced with a structural change where one exists; a platform move is a project with an owner, an export, tested tracking and the most valuable partners called first. The change calendar is the document that stops a cost review from becoming a partner exodus. The affiliate commission change checklist turns these habits into a gate to tick between deciding a change to rates, windows, validation or credit and telling partners about it.

Finally, watch dependence and read the whole programme now and then. A programme that relies on one or two partners for most of its new customers is exposed to their rankings and their choices, so each key partner's share of new customers is watched over time and alternatives of the same type are recruited before they are needed. The programme management hub sets the monthly and quarterly routine in which the list, the rhythm and the notice sit, and when several of these causes are present at once, the tutorial on auditing an affiliate programme checks the economics, the terms against the settings, the partner mix and the reporting in one pass and asks whether the key partner list still matches the figures.

A bike accessories brand wins back two review sites (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Ysendrake Cycling

Ysendrake Cycling, an invented cycling accessories brand, sees new customers from affiliates fall by a third in two months, from 1,240 to 830 a month. Ranked by new customers, three review sites had brought 58% of the programme's affiliate new customers; all three have stopped publishing about the brand, and two have replaced its links in their lighting roundups with a rival's. Their clicks over the same two months fell by 71%.

Calls to the three reveal three causes. During a cost review the base rate was cut from 8% to 5% in the platform with no notice, and the first the partners knew was a smaller statement. A returns rule changed at the same time, and 212 of their conversions were rejected with no reason recorded. One site shows the brand its own click path on 40 orders: a cashback extension inserted its link on the checkout page within 15 seconds of purchase on 31 of them.

Ysendrake restores an 8% rate on new customers for content and review partners with 30 days' notice and leaves 5% on returning customers, records a reason against each of the 212 rejections and reverses 147 of them, and writes last click with protection for content partners within a 7-day window into version 4 of its terms. It names a contact for each of its five key partners and agrees a plan with each for the autumn season that includes test units of the new lighting range before it goes on sale. Two of the three review sites publish again within the month; the third stays with the rival. Three months later new customers from affiliates are back to 1,180 a month, and no single partner brings more than 24% of them.

Common mistakes

  • Reading the platform's league table instead of new customers by partner. The partners at the top of tracked sales are rarely the ones whose leaving hurts.
  • Matching a competitor's rate. Their margins and customers are not yours; start from your own ceiling and pay more for the outcomes you want.
  • Rejecting commission without a reason. A rejection the partner cannot read is a dispute, and enough of them are a departure.
  • Deduplicating in secret. A credit rule applied before it is in the terms loses the best partners first.
  • A key partner list longer than the team. Partners nobody has time to call are key in name only.
  • Changing a rate in the platform before the notice goes out. The partner learns of the change from a smaller statement.
  • Announcing a move before the tracking is tested. Partners who move to a platform that does not record their sales do not move twice.
  • Treating silence as a pause. A partner whose pages now carry a rival's link has decided; ask before the next one does.

Frequently asked questions

The partners have already gone. Is it worth asking them to come back?

Yes, once the cause is fixed and you can say so in one sentence. Partners belong to several programmes and leave one when it stops being worth their effort, not out of loyalty to a rival, so a call that names what changed carries weight: the rate on new customers is restored and the notice period is written into the terms, every rejection now carries a reason, content partners' clicks are protected at the checkout, or here is the person who will answer you quickly. Ask what would make them publish again and write it into a joint plan with a review date. Calling before the fix, with an apology and nothing else, teaches the partner that nothing has changed.

Should we match the rate a competitor's programme is paying?

Not by copying it. Their margins, customers and partners are not yours, and a rate that fits their order value and conversion may lose money on every order of yours. Start from the ceiling your own contribution margin allows, with the value of a customer over time where repeat orders justify it, and then look for room to pay more for the outcomes you want from the partners you want: a higher rate on new customers, a partner-specific rate with a reason and a review date, or a bonus for a seasonal feature. A partner judges a programme on what it earns per visitor sent, so a modest rate on pages that convert well can beat a generous one that does not, and a change announced with notice keeps the partners you have while you win back the ones you lost.

How do we tell whether a partner has left or only paused?

Partners publish on their own schedule, and a seasonal content partner goes quiet between peaks without leaving. Open the partner's live pages: if your links are still there and still work, the partner has paused or is being overwritten at the checkout; if a rival's links have replaced yours or the brand has dropped out of their roundups, the partner has moved on. Read clicks beside sales, because a partner whose clicks hold while credited sales fall has not stopped sending, it has stopped being paid. Then ask. A partner with a named contact tells you what changed; a partner who only receives the newsletter tells the next programme instead.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Sources

  1. Performance Marketing Association — PMA

Related