What these audits are for
Most marketing reviews end as a long document of observations with no order to them. Twenty things are wrong, all of them are written in the same tone, and the team fixes the easiest ones first. A scored audit exists to stop that. It forces each observation onto a common scale, separates the criteria that make every other number untrustworthy from the ones that merely cost a little efficiency, and produces a result that can be compared with the next audit of the same thing.
The library covers reviews that come up again and again, and it gains scorecards as it grows. They include reviews such as a paid search account, a paid social account on Meta, TikTok or LinkedIn, a product feed and the Shopping or Performance Max campaigns built on it, a programmatic buy, the technical health of a website, the on-page quality of key pages, the analytics implementation and the wider measurement behind budget decisions, a single landing page or a whole online store, an email programme, an organic social presence, an app's marketing, a creator programme, the handling of leads, a content programme, customer retention, customer reviews, customer service, the research behind decisions and marketing across established markets. Each one is written for the person doing the review, not for the person being reviewed. It assumes you know the channel, so it does not re-teach set-up; instead it points to the guides that own the method and the checklists that own the tick-box pass.
Audits are also useful outside a crisis. Running the same scorecard every quarter shows whether fixes held, whether new problems crept in, and whether a channel has moved from fragile to dependable. That trend is often more persuasive in a budget conversation than any single KPIA metric tied directly to an objective., because it shows the foundations the numbers rest on.
How the scoring works (audits score, checklists tick)
A checklist in this library's sister collection is binary: each item passes or fails, and the list is done when every box is ticked. That suits launch and publishing work, where a single miss can be fixed on the spot. An audit is graded instead. Each criterion is rated on a three-level scale written in words: missing (absent or broken), partial (present but incomplete, inconsistent or out of date) and solid (matches the "what good looks like" column). Some criteria are marked as gates. A gate is a foundation, such as conversion tracking or indexation, where a weak score makes every other score unreliable.
The overall result is a band, not a total. Red means at least one gate is missing: stop optimising and repair the foundation. Amber means the gates are at least partial but a large share of other criteria are partial or missing: build a short, ordered fix list. Green means the gates are solid and most other criteria are too: move effort into testing and growth. Bands avoid the false precision of a percentage and keep the conversation on what to do next.
The two formats work together. The audit tells you where the weaknesses are; the matching checklist is what you run while fixing them, and the compact checklists on the resources page are the quick reference for the most common passes. Recurring work that comes out of an audit belongs in a marketing playbook for the ongoing rhythm, or a standard operating procedure when a single task needs doing the same way every time.
Which audit when
Choose the audit by the question you are being asked, not by the channel you know best. Several questions need two audits in sequence, because a paid account cannot be judged fairly on data the analytics audit would reject.
| Situation | Start with | Then |
|---|---|---|
| You have inherited a paid search account and need a view within days | Google Ads account audit | Analytics implementation audit if conversions look doubtful |
| Paid social results are falling and nobody knows why | Meta Ads account audit | Landing page audit for the pages ads send to |
| Organic traffic has dropped or a migration is planned | Technical SEO audit | On-page SEO audit for the pages that lost visibility |
| Key pages rank but do not win clicks or hold readers | On-page SEO audit | Landing page audit if those pages also convert |
| Leadership does not trust the reported numbers | Analytics implementation audit | Each channel audit once the data passes |
| A page receives paid traffic but converts poorly | Landing page audit | Analytics implementation audit to confirm the form is tracked |
| Email revenue has flattened or complaints are rising | Email programme audit | Analytics implementation audit for attribution of email visits |
| Social accounts take time but their value is unclear | Social media presence audit | Meta Ads account audit if paid support is planned |
| You have inherited a TikTok Ads account and do not know whether its results can be trusted | TikTok Ads account audit | Landing page audit for the pages ads send people to |
| You have inherited a LinkedIn Ads account and cannot see which campaigns create pipeline | LinkedIn Ads account audit | Lead management audit for what happens to its leads once they reach the CRM |
| A product catalogue is advertised in Shopping or Performance Max but will not scale | Product feed and Performance Max audit | Online store audit for the store the ads send shoppers to |
| A programmatic buy is moving in-house and nobody can say what it bought | Programmatic advertising audit | Analytics implementation audit for the site analytics the buy is compared against |
| A store gets traffic but few repeat customers | Online store audit | Customer retention audit for the system that keeps customers across channels |
| An app wins installs but few of those users stay active | App marketing audit | Email programme audit for email to app users |
| Creator work takes budget but nobody can say what it is worth | Influencer programme audit | Social media presence audit for the brand's own accounts |
| Sales reject the leads marketing sends them | Lead management audit | Landing page audit for the pages that capture leads |
| Content is published steadily but has no measurable job | Content marketing programme audit | On-page SEO audit for single pages that should win search traffic |
| Customers leave and nobody knows why | Customer retention audit | Email programme audit for lifecycle email in depth |
| Channel reports add up to more conversions than the orders | Marketing measurement audit | Analytics implementation audit first if nobody trusts the raw numbers |
| The business's rating is falling or reviews go unanswered | Customer reviews and reputation audit | Online store audit, where product page reviews sit beside the rest of a shop |
| Complaints keep rising and every agent answers differently | Customer service audit | Customer retention audit for why customers leave |
| A decision rests on research nobody can vouch for, or studies come back and change nothing | Marketing research audit | Marketing measurement audit for the data side of the same decision |
| Several markets are live but each runs its own calendar, edition and report | Multi-market marketing audit | Technical SEO audit for locale signals |
The scorecards beneath this introduction are listed automatically, so a new audit appears here once it is published.
Audits and the guides behind them
Every scorecard is the scoring layer over guides that already exist, and it links to them rather than repeating them. The technical SEO scorecard, for instance, sits on top of the technical SEO audit tutorial, which explains how to crawl a site, read the coverage reports and trace a problem to its template. The scorecard does not teach that; it tells you how to rate what you found and which fix to schedule first.
The same pattern holds across the library. The paid search scorecard rates account health, including how far ad relevance and Quality ScoreGoogle's 1–10 keyword diagnostic. problems are dragging on cost, and links the account audit guide for the walkthrough. The analytics scorecard rates whether a GA4Google's event-based analytics platform. property and tag set-up can be trusted, and links the set-up checklists for the work itself. When an audit flags a weakness, follow the link in that criterion's row to the guide that fixes it, then run the matching checklist to confirm the fix, and rescore at the next review. That loop of score, fix, verify and rescore is what turns an audit from a report into a working tool.
