Scope: what this audit covers and what it does not
The question this audit answers is whether a creator programme is choosing the right creators, working on sound and disclosed terms and producing a return the business can see, and what should change first. It covers a running programme of paid, gifted or long-term creator work: selection and vetting, representation by agents and agencies, contracts, fees and disclosure, seeding, briefs and draft review, controversy readiness, usage rights and paid amplification, tracking, return and the reviews that decide whether a partnership continues.
The brand's own social accounts are out of scope; they are scored by the social media presence audit. A single campaign about to go live is checked, not scored, with the influencer campaign launch checklist, and one draft is reviewed with the creator draft review tutorial. Creator posts run as Spark Ads inside a TikTok account are scored with that account in the TikTok Ads account audit; this scorecard asks only whether the rights behind them are recorded.
It does not re-teach the work. The influencer marketing guide explains the channel and sets out a first creator programme for a brand without one; the strategy, campaign and measurement guides linked in each area own their methods. Every scorecard sits in the audit library.
Before you score: access and evidence
Ask for the contracts folder, the brief and approval records, the tracking set-up and access to any agency or platform used to manage creators. Without the contracts you cannot score rights or terms, so those rows stay provisional until you have them. Fix an evidence window long enough to cover several campaigns and at least the renewal point of any longer partnership, and keep the same window for every rescore.
Collect:
- the list of creators worked with over the window, with tier, fee or gift, content delivered and results;
- contracts, briefs and approval records for a sample of campaigns;
- live posts checked for disclosure on each platform, looking at the post itself rather than the brief;
- usage rights and authorisation records with their expiry dates;
- tracking links, codes and the reporting by creator and campaign;
- the seeding send record and any agent or agency agreements.
Write down what the programme is meant to achieve before you look at results. Where creator work is judged on cost per outcome, the CPA calculator helps check that the target is consistent with the margin the business has told you about, with fees, product, shipping and team time all counted.
Criteria and scoring
Rate each row missing (absent or broken), partial (present but incomplete, inconsistent or out of date) or solid (matches the "what good looks like" column). The scale is your judgement against that column, not a number. Rows marked gate decide the band on their own when they score missing. A row that does not apply, such as running many small creators for a programme of a few partners, is marked not applicable rather than missing.
Choosing creators
| Criterion | What good looks like | Score guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Creator fit and vetting | Creators are chosen from the goal, audience fit and past content, and vetted for brand safety before contact | Missing: chosen by follower count or by who asked / Partial: fit checked, vetting informal / Solid: goal-led shortlist, audience and past content checked, vetting recorded |
| Agents and agencies | Who represents whom is clear, and the brand keeps its contracts, content and creator relationships whoever runs the work | Missing: contracts and content held only by an agency / Partial: brand holds contracts, but no direct contact with creators / Solid: roles clear, brand keeps contracts, content and relationships |
Score fit against the creator tiers and selection guide, which covers audience fit, past partnerships and vetting for Brand SafetyControls that keep ads away from content that would harm the advertiser's reputation., and representation against the guide to working with creator agents and agencies, which sets out what the brand should keep whoever runs the programme. Where an agency does the work, the guide to hiring and evaluating an influencer agency separates judging the agency's own work from judging the programme's results.
Terms and disclosure
| Criterion | What good looks like | Score guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Disclosure on every post (gate) | Every paid or gifted post is labelled as advertising in the way the rules require, and the brand checks it is | Missing: gifted or paid posts without a clear label / Partial: labels required in contracts, live posts not checked / Solid: required, checked on every live post and corrected when missing |
| Written contracts | Deliverables, approvals, usage rights, payment terms and exits are agreed in writing before work starts | Missing: terms agreed in messages / Partial: contracts for paid work, not for gifted or longer deals / Solid: written before work starts, every time |
| Fees against scope | Fees are agreed against a precise scope, with a ceiling the brand set before asking | Missing: rate cards accepted as quoted / Partial: scope defined, no ceiling / Solid: ceiling set first, quotes against a precise scope |
| Seeding practice | Product goes out after asking, with a gifting note on disclosure and a send record | Missing: unsolicited mail-outs, no record / Partial: asked first, but no note or record / Solid: asked, noted and recorded |
Disclosure and contracts are both scored against the contracts and disclosure guide, which sets out the general direction of the FTC's endorsement guidance and of the ASA's and the CMA's approach in the UK as it states them: when a brand has given a creator something of value, the audience should be able to tell that the content is advertising. The scorecard rates the habit, not the legal question, and is not legal advice. Fees are scored against the guide to negotiating creator fees and terms and seeding against the product seeding guide.
Campaign work
| Criterion | What good looks like | Score guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Creator briefs | Briefs give the goal, the must-say and must-not-say, and room for the creator's own voice | Missing: a script or no brief / Partial: a brief that reads like an advert / Solid: goal, mandatories and freedoms, walked through with the creator |
| Draft review | Drafts are checked for must-fix points such as claims, disclosure and facts, while voice stays the creator's | Missing: no review, or rewrites on taste / Partial: reviewed, but must-fix and suggestion mixed / Solid: one consolidated reply, must-fix points separated, approval in writing |
| Running many small creators | Briefing, shipping, payment and tracking follow standard steps when many small creators are involved | Missing: every creator a one-off deal / Partial: a roster, but payments and links handled by hand / Solid: one offer, one roster driving every step |
| Controversy readiness | There is an agreed way to pause, talk to the creator and withdraw content if a creator becomes the story | Missing: no plan / Partial: someone knows what to do, nothing written / Solid: agreed steps, contract terms that support them |
Briefs are scored against the creator brief tutorial, draft review against the draft review tutorial, the operation against the micro-creator programme tutorial and readiness against the guide to handling a creator controversy, which also explains what the vetting process should learn afterwards.
Rights and amplification
| Criterion | What good looks like | Score guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Usage rights tracked | Rights, authorisations and their expiry are recorded before creator content runs as an ad | Missing: content running with no rights record / Partial: recorded for some creators, expiries not watched / Solid: a record for every piece, expiries watched |
| Amplification choices | Content is chosen for paid use on fit and results, and refreshed when fatigue shows | Missing: everything boosted, or the brand's favourite / Partial: chosen on results, never refreshed / Solid: chosen on fit and results, refreshed on a plan |
Both rows rest on the guide to amplifying creator content with paid ads, which compares whitelisting, partnership ads and Spark Ads and the Usage RightsThe terms in a creator or influencer agreement that set how, where and for how long a brand may reuse the content, organically or in paid ads. and authorisation each needs; platform specifics are left to the platform guides.
Measurement and relationships
| Criterion | What good looks like | Score guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Tracking by creator (gate) | Every creator has tagged links or codes, and results are reported by creator and by campaign | Missing: no links or codes, or one shared link / Partial: links for some creators, reports by campaign only / Solid: every creator tagged, reported by creator and campaign |
| Return and incrementality | Return is judged on cost per outcome and tests, not on earned media value | Missing: views, likes or earned media value as the result / Partial: cost per outcome with costs left out / Solid: full cost per outcome, with a test behind the main spend |
| Partnership reviews | Longer partnerships are reviewed and renewed on results, with ending terms agreed | Missing: renewed by habit / Partial: reviewed, but ending terms never agreed / Solid: reviewed on results, renewal and ending terms written |
Tracking is scored against the influencer KPIs and tracking links guide, which covers UTMURL tags identifying traffic source. naming, codes, landing pages and the data gaps that remain. Return is scored against the guide to influencer ROI and incrementality, which explains why earned media value and other Vanity MetricsMetrics that look impressive but do not inform a decision or track a business outcome. should be retired and how practical tests give evidence of IncrementalityConversions caused by marketing.. Reviews are scored against the guide to long-term creator partnerships.
How to score and prioritise
Score the gates first. Undisclosed paid or gifted posts are a legal and trust exposure, and work without tracking cannot be judged at all. If disclosure scores missing, correct the live posts before anything else, whatever the programme's results. If tracking scores missing, mark the return and partnership rows provisional: a creator who seems to perform may simply be the one whose code was shared most widely.
Then rank the remaining weaknesses in this order:
- Terms: content running as ads without recorded rights, and work started without a written contract. These carry risk now, not later.
- Selection and briefs, because the wrong creator or a brief for an advert wastes the fee whatever happens next.
- Measurement depth, partnership reviews and programme operations next.
- Amplification refinements last, unless rights are missing, which the terms group already covers.
Within each group, rank by the spend or the reach the weakness touches. A missing rights record on content carrying most of the paid budget outranks the same gap on a post that ran once.
Reading the result: what to do with each band
Red means a gate scored missing. Pause new creator bookings, ask creators to correct live posts that lack a clear label, and put tracking links or codes in place for every active creator before trusting any result. Rescore after the next full campaign has run on the repaired set-up.
Amber means the gates hold at least partially but several other rows are partial or missing. This is the usual outcome. Work a short ordered list, one area at a time, starting with rights and contracts.
Green means the gates are solid and most rows are too. Move effort into tests of what creator work adds and into turning the creators whose work paid back into longer partnerships, and rescore each year or when the programme changes hands.
From findings to a prioritised fix list
Write each partial or missing row as a finding in plain words: what you saw, the evidence and why it matters. A screenshot of a live post without a label, or an ad still running after its rights expired, is worth more than a paragraph. Then turn the findings into one fix list with a line per fix: the finding, the fix, the owner, the guide that explains it and the rescore date. Order the list by the priorities above, not by how easy each fix is.
Group the lines by who does the work, because disclosure corrections and contracts sit with the programme owner and whoever manages creator relationships, rights records with whoever runs paid media, tracking with the analyst, and briefs and selection with the people who plan campaigns. Where an agency runs the programme, name which lines it owns and which the brand keeps. Present the band, the gate findings and the first few fixes to the budget holder, and keep the full scorecard as the working copy for the rescore. The academy exercise on auditing creator work and an inherited TikTok account for an oral care brand practises scoring a creator programme whose results were reported as total views against these criteria and gates, beside an inherited TikTok Ads account, with one ordered fix list for both.
Illustrative example
A hiking boot brand audits a year of creator work
Grivnath Boots, an invented hiking boot brand that spent about £48,000 on creators over the last twelve months, runs the audit across 31 creators. Disclosure scores missing: 9 of the 14 gifted posts checked carry no label, and the gifting note never mentioned one. Tracking by creator scores missing, because results are reported as total views across the programme and only 4 creators have codes. Usage rights score missing: 2 creators' videos are still running as ads after their licences expired. Contracts score partial, written for paid work but not for gifts, while creator fit scores solid and briefs partial. The band is red. The fix list puts asking the 9 creators to add labels and rewriting the gifting note first, pausing the 2 expired ads and building a rights record second, issuing codes and tagged links to every active creator third and contracts for gifted work fourth, and holds the search for new creators. After the next campaign, both gates score solid and the band moves to amber.
Common mistakes
- Scoring results before disclosure. A programme with strong results and unlabelled posts is not a good programme. Score the gates first.
- Checking the brief instead of the post. A contract that requires a label proves nothing about the live post. Look at each post as a follower would.
- Reading reach as return. Views and earned media value say how many people saw something, not what it caused. Score return on cost per outcome and tests.
- Forgetting gifted work. Gifts carry disclosure and rights questions too. Score seeding and gifted posts alongside paid ones.
- Leaving rights to memory. Expiries pass quietly while ads keep running. Without a record, score the row missing.
- Fixing everything at once. Changing creators, briefs and tracking together makes the next campaign impossible to read. Work the list in order and rescore on the same evidence window.
