Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Social Media Marketing › Expert

Auditing Creator Work and an Inherited TikTok Account for an Oral Care Brand

You audit an invented oral care brand's year of paid and gifted creator work and the TikTok Ads account it has just taken back from an agency. You finish with both scorecards banded from the evidence, gates first, the findings in plain words and one fix list that orders the work across both audits, with owners, the guides behind each fix and rescore dates on the same evidence windows.
ExerciseExpert levelModule 3: Audits and standards for the programme7 minUpdated

Why this matters

At the advanced social media level you built a creator programme from scratch. At expert level you inherit one, with an ad account someone else set up, and the urge is to change things before scoring them. The influencer programme audit scorecard and the TikTok Ads account audit scorecard rate what is running as missing, partial or solid, and each makes two rows gates that set the band before any result is read. The two audits also meet: creator videos running as Spark Ads are a rights question in one and an authorisation question in the other.

The oral care brand's creators and account

Tryvussan Oral Care is an invented maker of bamboo toothbrushes, toothpaste tablets and floss sold online, much of it on refill subscriptions. A creator and social manager runs creators in-house; a paid social manager joined when the agency's contract ended.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Tryvussan Oral Care: twelve months of creator work

EvidenceWhat the audit finds
Creators20: 8 paid (£19,200 in fees), 12 gifted (£1,500 of product), taken on from creators who wrote in asking
ResultsA monthly deck of likes, comments and "£88,000 of earned media value"
Live postsAll 28 checked carry an ad label; labels are required in every contract and the gifting note, but nobody at the brand has looked at a live post
ContractsOne per paid campaign and a one-page gifting agreement; the 3 longest-running creators still work on their first campaign's contract
SeedingProduct sent only to creators who asked, with the gifting note; no record of what went to whom
TrackingEvery creator shares one discount code and one tagged link
DraftsReviewed by the founder in one list mixing must-fix points and taste; one live video says the tablets "repair enamel", a claim the brand has never made
Rights5 creator videos run as Spark Ads; rights and expiry recorded for 2; 1 of the other 3 had its authorisation expire last month
PartnershipsThe same 3 creators renewed each quarter without review
Illustrative example — not a real result

Tryvussan Oral Care: the TikTok account, last twelve weeks at £5,000 a month

  • Ownership: the ad account moved into Tryvussan's Business Center at handover, but the pixel sits in the agency's login and the agency keeps an admin role. The founder is the only business admin.
  • Events: purchase fires with a value but no content identifiers; browser only, no Events API.
  • Attribution setting changed by the agency in week 7; the earlier setting was never recorded.
  • Prospecting excludes pixel purchasers only; no customer file has been uploaded.
  • Ads carry the platform's default names, so spend cannot be split by creator video.
  • The 5 Spark Ads are the creator videos above, "repair enamel" included.
  • The monthly deck shows TikTok's total, view-through included, never compared with shop orders.

Gates before results

The creator scorecard's gates are disclosure on every post and tracking by creator; the TikTok scorecard's are Business Center ownership and pixel events. A gate scored missing makes the band red whatever the results say, and makes the rows that depend on it provisional. The creator deck reports Vanity Metrics only, and without tracking nobody can say which creator caused anything, let alone answer the Incrementality question this level's first module tested.

Task

  1. Score each scorecard's gates and band both audits.
  2. Score the other rows the evidence supports, marking which are provisional.
  3. Write the findings in plain words, each with its evidence and why it matters.
  4. Decide what the Spark Ads mean for both audits, the "repair enamel" video included.
  5. Write one fix list with owners, the guide behind each fix and rescore dates.
  6. Say what stays unchanged while the first fixes settle.

Worked answer

The gates. Disclosure scores partial, not solid: every post checked is labelled, but the brand requires labels on paper and never looks at what went live. The contracts and disclosure guide says a brand that checks posts once they are live, and asks for corrections, stands far stronger than one that leaves labelling to creators. Tracking by creator scores missing: a code and a link shared by every creator cannot show who caused an order, so the return and partnership rows are provisional. On TikTok, ownership scores missing, since a pixel in the agency's login is an asset the business could lose; pixel events score partial. Both audits band red: no new creator bookings and no budget increase until the gates hold.

The other rows. Creator fit missing, taken on from whoever asked; contracts, seeding, draft review and Usage Rights tracking partial, since rights are recorded for some videos and nobody watches expiries. Return scores missing, judged on earned media value, and partnership reviews missing, both provisional. On TikTok, Events API, naming, reconciliation and incrementality evidence missing; partner access, the attribution record, purchaser exclusions and Spark Ads authorisation partial, the last because it is tracked for some creators only.

The Spark Ads. The same videos sit in both audits, a rights row in one and an authorisation row in the other, so one rights record fixes both, and ad names that carry the creator and video let that record be matched to spend. The "repair enamel" video cannot wait for the list: the influencer audit treats claims as must-fix points in draft review, and a must-fix point already running as a paid ad is handled as a live error. It is paused now under the live ad and page error response SOP, and the creator is asked to correct the organic post.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Tryvussan Oral Care: one fix list across both audits

OrderFixOwnerGuide
1Pause the "repair enamel" ad; creator asked to correct the post; must-fix points listed apart from suggestionsPaid social manager, creator managerReviewing creator drafts
2New pixel in Tryvussan's Business Center; agency admin removed; second business adminFounderBusiness Center set-up
3Content identifiers on purchase; Events API with matching event identifiers; test eventsWeb developerPixel and Events API
4A code and tagged link for every active creator, reported by creator; live posts checked for labels each monthCreator managerKPIs and tracking links; contracts and disclosure
5Rights and expiry recorded for all 5 Spark Ads; the expired authorisation renewed or its ad removed; ad names carrying creator and videoPaid social managerAmplifying creator content; Spark Ads
6Updated contracts for the 3 long-running creators; a send record for giftsCreator managerContracts and disclosure; product seeding
7Customer-file exclusion after a consent checkPaid social managerCustom and lookalike audiences
8Attribution setting recorded; view-through on its own line; monthly check against shop ordersPaid social manager, financeMonthly TikTok report

Rescore: the TikTok audit once the repaired set-up has run for a whole month, over a 12-week window again; the creator audit after the next full campaign, over a 12-month window again.

Why this order. The live claim is an exposure today, and a pixel in the agency's login could be lost any day. Ownership precedes the event fix, because events repaired in a pixel the business does not own must be rebuilt. Event Deduplication through matching identifiers follows, then the creator gate, then rights with the naming that makes them visible, then terms and the exclusion. Naming moves up from its usual last place because default names hide which creator video spent what, and the rights record needs to see that. New creators, new creative, partnership reviews and a test of what creators add wait for the rescore. For the first month, budgets, ad groups and the creator roster stay as they are: the TikTok audit warns that big edits made together restart learning and leave nobody able to say which change did what.

Common mistakes

  • Reading likes and earned media value before the gates. Neither says what any creator caused while every creator shares a code.
  • Scoring disclosure solid from the contracts. A label required on paper stays partial until the brand checks what went live.
  • Two fix lists. The Spark Ads sit in both audits; two lists give them two owners and no record.
  • Leaving the claim for the rescore. A must-fix claim already running as an ad is a live error.
  • Fixing events inside the agency's pixel. Move ownership first.
  • Changing everything at once. Rescore on the same windows, or nobody can tell which fix worked.

The governance capstone for a swimwear brand puts both audits into a governed year.

Pages this lesson applies

Terms used on this page

Also related

Related