Brief
Fieldmarsh Forms is an invented online form builder used by small businesses, schools and charities. It grew through its free plan and organic search, helped by the "Made with Fieldmarsh" badge on every free form, then added paid search and paid social when growth slowed. The board now wants faster growth. The team runs many small tests that rarely produce a clear result, the paid channels report low costs that nobody has tested, and paid accounts lapse faster than expected after their first renewal.
The strategy assumes the cohort, payback and loop work of the intermediate growth level. It should be something the board, the founder and a growth team of four could each act on.
Inputs and constraints
Fieldmarsh Forms: an average month by source
| Source | Sign-ups | Activated within 7 days | Paying within 60 days |
|---|---|---|---|
| Organic search | 6,000 | 45% | 5.0% |
| Badge on free forms | 2,500 | 50% | 4.0% |
| Paid search | 1,800 | 38% | 6.0% |
| Paid social | 2,200 | 22% | 1.5% |
| Paid channel | Monthly spend | Sign-ups the platform credits | Last quarter's budget step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid search | £14,000 | 2,100 | From £10,000: about 20 more paying accounts a month |
| Paid social | £11,000 | 3,000 | From £7,000: about 5 more paying accounts a month |
Activated means a form built and shared. Budget step results are before-and-after comparisons, not tests.
Fieldmarsh Forms: plans, retention, tests and limits
- Plans: Free (3 forms, 100 responses a month, badge shown); Starter £15 a month (unlimited forms, 1,000 responses, no badge); Pro £29 a month or £240 a year (payments, logic, integrations). About 9% of active free accounts hit the response limit each month.
- Starter accounts still paying: 80% at month 3, 50% at month 12. Annual Pro accounts renewing at the first anniversary: 58%, against the 80% the plan assumed.
- Contribution margin: about 85% of revenue. Contribution per new paying account within a twelve-month payback window: about £150.
- Test log, last year: 26 tests; 19 had no sample plan, 4 reached a planned sample, median run 9 days, 3 declared winners, and the sign-up-to-paying rate did not move.
- Sign-up page traffic: about 30,000 visitors a month. Product capacity: one pricing or plan change per half-year.
The figures are invented to make the brief concrete; the reasoning is what is assessed.
Task
- Name the growth model and its constraint. Map Fieldmarsh's loops with the growth loops framework: the badge loop, the search loop and the paid loop, each with its return and what feeds it. Find the stage that limits growth, with the evidence, and choose the one measure the strategy is judged on.
- Build the experiment portfolio. Choose a few tests aimed at the constraint, not at every page. For each, set the minimum detectable effect and the sample with the sample size and significance guide, and drop or redesign any that the traffic cannot support. Write each in the experiment hypothesis template with its stopping rule, and run the portfolio under the sign-off and learning-log rules of the experimentation programme playbook, as in the tutoring marketplace audit.
- Set incremental acquisition limits. Define the threshold a marginal paying account must clear from contribution within the payback window, with acquisition cost (CACCost to acquire one new customer.) defined as the LTV and CAC guide requires. Plan a budget-increase or holdout test for each paid channel, as in the budgeting app exercise, and set each channel's spend limit until its test reads, using the marginal returns and forecasting guide.
- Plan the pricing and packaging change. Choose the one change for the first half-year (the free plan boundary, the response limits or the annual offer) with the reasoning from the pricing and packaging guide. Plan the willingness-to-pay research and the pricing page test, as in the scheduling tool exercise.
- Write the retention plan. Diagnose the first-renewal loss and choose the lead levers with the customer retention strategy guide. Include the renewal communication, the downgrade and pause options, failed-payment recovery and a control group for each retention change.
- State the investment rules. Say what evidence moves money between acquisition, activation, pricing and retention, how much is committed up front and how much waits for results, and when the strategy is reviewed.
- Write the strategy. A one-page summary for the board, using the one-page marketing plan template, with appendices for the model, the portfolio, the channel limits, the pricing plan and the retention plan.
Evaluation criteria
| Criterion | What a strong answer shows | Common gap |
|---|---|---|
| Growth model | Names the loop or engine that drives growth and the constraint that limits it, with evidence | Lists tactics without a model |
| Experiment portfolio | Prioritises fewer, adequately powered tests tied to the constraint, with stopping rules | Keeps running many underpowered tests |
| Incremental acquisition | Sets channel limits from tested incremental cost and payback | Scales on attributed sign-ups |
| Pricing and retention | Changes plans or limits with a test plan and retention moves to protect revenue | Raises prices without a retention plan |
| Investment rules | States the evidence that moves budget and when the plan is reviewed | Commits the full budget up front |
A strong submission notices what the inputs already say. Organic search and the badge bring most sign-ups and convert well, so the free plan is an engine, not a cost. Paid social's credited sign-ups are cheap and its paying accounts are few, and both channels' last budget steps bought paying accounts at a cost a marginal account cannot repay. And the first-anniversary loss means the lifetime value (LTVTotal value a customer brings over time.) the plans were built on does not exist yet. Together they say the constraint is turning sign-ups into lasting paid accounts, not finding more sign-ups; spend should be held until IncrementalityConversions caused by marketing. is tested, and the A/B TestControlled comparison of two variants. budget should move to activation and renewal.
Fieldmarsh Forms: the first figures a strong answer reaches
- Paying accounts a month by source: organic 300, badge 100, paid search 108, paid social 33.
- Cost per credited sign-up: paid search £14,000 ÷ 2,100 ≈ £6.67; paid social £11,000 ÷ 3,000 ≈ £3.67.
- Cost per paying account on analytics sources: paid search ≈ £130; paid social ≈ £333.
- Marginal cost of last quarter's steps: paid search £4,000 ÷ 20 = £200; paid social £4,000 ÷ 5 = £800, against about £150 of contribution within the payback window.
- Test capacity: at about 30,000 sign-up page visitors a month, only a few properly powered tests a quarter can run on that page, not the two a month the log shows.
