Why this matters
Pricing is the growth lever most teams touch least, because it feels like a finance decision. Yet the pricing metric decides whether revenue grows as customers grow, the free plan boundary decides whether free users ever have a reason to pay, and the way a change is handled decides whether it raises revenue or triggers churn. The pricing and packaging guide covers the decisions, the pricing page layout test the experiment, and the customer retention strategy guide the diagnosis of why customers leave. The intermediate growth level covers the cohort reading this exercise relies on.
The tool and its flat price
Rotaplan is an invented appointment scheduling tool for physiotherapy, dental and beauty clinics. Every clinic pays the same monthly price. The free plan has no limits that prompt an upgrade, and the largest clinics leave once they open a second site or hire staff who need their own access.
Rotaplan: accounts, churn and usage by clinic size
| Clinic size | Free accounts | Paid accounts | Paid monthly churn | SMS reminders a month per paid clinic |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Solo, one practitioner | 2,400 | 380 | 2.5% | 80 |
| Small, two to five | 700 | 420 | 2.0% | 330 |
| Multi-room, six to twenty | 100 | 100 | 4.5% | 1,300 |
- Price: £49 a month per clinic. Free plan: unlimited practitioners and appointments. Paid adds SMS reminders, online payments and removes Rotaplan branding. Each SMS costs Rotaplan £0.04.
- Free accounts that start paying within 90 days of sign-up: 6%.
- Exit reasons: multi-room clinics mostly cite multiple sites, staff permissions and reporting; solo practitioners mostly say they did not send enough reminders to justify the price.
- Pricing page: about 9,000 visitors a month, 3.0% of whom start a paid plan. The team's calculator says a 25% relative lift needs about 8,300 visitors per arm, and a 15% lift about 23,000.
Choosing a pricing metric and tiers
Start from the segments the data already shows, not from the feature list. A good metric grows with the value the clinic gets, is easy for a clinic owner to predict and is easy for Rotaplan to measure. Tiers then give each segment one natural fit, with fences that follow value: limits only growing clinics reach, controls only larger clinics need. The free plan should be genuinely useful to the segment it serves and end where a clinic starts to get more value than a free product can carry.
Task
- Choose the pricing metric and explain why the alternatives lose.
- Propose tiers, fences and the free plan boundary, with the segment each tier is for.
- Plan the willingness-to-pay research to run before any price is fixed.
- Design the pricing page test: what changes, the primary metric, guardrails, duration and what the traffic allows.
- Name the retention moves that ship with the change, for existing and new customers.
Worked answer
Metric. Charge per practitioner calendar. It rises with clinic size, a clinic owner can predict it, and Rotaplan already counts it. Per appointment would make bills unpredictable and tax the usage that makes the product valuable; per reminder turns the price into a cost line that invites rationing.
Tiers and boundary. Free: one practitioner calendar, online booking and email reminders, with branding, for solo practitioners starting out. Solo: one practitioner with text reminders and payments, for the solo segment that leaves today because the flat price outweighs its use. Clinic: per practitioner from two upwards, the recommended tier for small clinics. Group: per practitioner with multiple sites, staff permissions and reporting, the features multi-room clinics leave to find. The free boundary at one calendar means a clinic meets it when it hires, the moment it can afford to pay.
Rotaplan: why the flat price fails, and hypotheses for research
- A multi-room clinic sends about 1,300 reminders a month: 1,300 × £0.04 = £52 of text costs against a £49 price.
- Free accounts already beyond one practitioner: 700 + 100 = 800, the first group the boundary affects.
- Price hypotheses to test in research, not to launch: Solo £24–£32 a month; Clinic £16–£22 per practitioner; Group £24–£32 per practitioner.
Research first. Interview recently lost multi-room clinics and current small clinics about what they compare the price with and where it starts to feel expensive. Run a price sensitivity survey across the three sizes to find an acceptable range per tier, and a trade-off study on the Group features. Read behaviour alongside: practitioners per account, reminder volume and which clinics hit limits.
The test. Launch the new packaging to every new sign-up on one date and compare cohorts with care; showing different prices to similar clinics is a trust problem. Then test the layout, never the price: a recommended Clinic plan for clinics of two or more practitioners and a plain comparison of what each tier includes, against the current layout. Primary metric: paid plan starts per pricing page visitor from billing. Guardrails: revenue per account, first-month refunds and downgrades, and the plan mix. At this traffic an A/B TestControlled comparison of two variants. of about two months can confirm only a large change in the pricing page's CVRShare of visits or clicks that convert.; accept that, keep existing customers out, and keep it clear of the migration emails.
Retention moves. Tell existing customers early and explain why. Keep current paid clinics on their price for a fixed period, with a clear path into the new tiers. Give multi-room clinics onboarding into sites and permissions before their price changes. Offer a downgrade or pause in the cancellation flow, an annual option, and retries for failed payments. Track the cohorts by size, as the retention and payback guide sets out: the change succeeds if multi-room churn falls and lifetime value (LTVTotal value a customer brings over time.) rises, not if starts rise for a month.
Common mistakes
- Testing prices on live visitors. Test presentation; set prices from research.
- A free plan with no boundary. Users who never outgrow it never pay.
- Fences that feel like penalties. Withhold what growing clinics need, not what every clinic needs.
- Raising prices for existing customers without notice. The invoice becomes the announcement.
- Judging the change on plan starts alone. Revenue per account and churn by size decide it.
