Start from the goal, not the follower count
Selection begins with the sentence written in the strategy: what creators are for. A brand that needs to be introduced to people who have never heard of it is buying ReachUnique people who saw an ad. among a defined audience. A brand that people know but do not trust is buying credibility, which comes from a creator whose opinion on the category carries weight. A brand with a product ready to sell is buying action, which comes from creators whose audiences have a habit of acting on recommendations. The See-Think-Do-Care framing on the See-Think-Do-Care framework page is a useful way to name the stage.
Each of those goals points at a different kind of creator. Reach among a broad audience favours larger accounts with a wide spread of followers. Credibility favours specialists, often small, whose content is dense with expertise. Action favours creators whose past sponsored posts show audiences clicking, saving and asking where to buy. Starting from follower count reverses the logic: the brand picks the biggest names it can afford and then hopes the goal will follow. In categories where buyers need to see the product worn, the fashion and apparel marketing guide explains why fit and styling content from well-matched creators often matters more than reach.
The goal also fixes how many creators are needed. Awareness work in a crowded category may need enough creators to lift the brand's Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. among the target audience in a short window, while a credibility play may need only a handful whose word is trusted. The influencer strategy hub covers writing the goal down; this guide assumes it exists. When the goal is a new product's first proof, the guide to influencers for a product launch sets out how to mix tiers inside the launch window. If the real choice is between creators and tying the brand to an event, team or cause its buyers already follow, the comparison of brand sponsorship and influencer marketing weighs the two before anyone is shortlisted.
Creator tiers and what each is for
Tiers are a rough shorthand for audience size, and the boundaries between them vary by platform and by whoever is drawing them. What matters is what each tier tends to be good at, not where the line falls.
| Tier | Typical strengths | Typical weaknesses | Best suited to |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nano | Close, personal audiences; high trust; often willing to work for product | Tiny reach per post; variable production; heavy coordination per result | Local launches, seeding, gathering authentic content at volume |
| Micro | Strong niche authority; engaged comments; easier to brief and re-book | Reach still limited; quality varies widely between creators | Consideration in a defined niche; programmes of many creators |
| Mid-tier | Balance of reach and closeness; more professional delivery | Rates rise faster than relevance; audiences begin to broaden | Category awareness with some credibility; content worth licensing |
| Macro | Large reach in one post; polished production; established processes | Audience less focused; engagement thinner; often managed by agents | Launches that need scale quickly; awareness across a broad audience |
| Celebrity | Mass recognition; press coverage beyond the post itself | Weak fit with most niches; high cost; tight control over messaging | Brand-level moments where fame itself is the point |
Cost per thousand impressions (CPMCost per 1,000 impressions.) is a common way to compare tiers, and it flatters the large ones. The fairer comparison is the cost per thousand impressions among people who match the target, which usually narrows the gap or reverses it. A programme of many small creators also spreads risk: one disappointing partner matters less, and the brand learns faster which kind of creator works.
Tier mixes are common and sensible. A launch might pair a couple of larger creators for reach with a wider group of small creators whose posts give the audience repeated, credible FrequencyAverage times a person saw an ad. in the following weeks.
Audience fit, overlap and authenticity
The core question is whether the people who follow a creator are the people the brand needs to reach. Three checks answer it.
Fit. Compare the creator's audience against the target described in the strategy: location, age band, language, interests and life stage. Creators can share screenshots of their own platform insights, which show these breakdowns directly; discovery tools estimate them from public signals. The audience research guide covers describing the target well enough to test against. A creator whose followers are mostly in another country, or another life stage, is the wrong partner however good the content.
Overlap. When a programme uses several creators in the same niche, their audiences often overlap heavily. Overlap is not always bad, since repeated exposure from different trusted voices can help a message land, but it means the combined reach is smaller than the sum of follower counts. Discovery tools estimate overlap; failing that, look at who comments on both creators' posts.
Authenticity. Purchased followers and engagement pods inflate the numbers without adding people. Warning signs include follower history with sudden jumps, comment sections full of generic praise or emoji strings, engagement that stays flat whether the content is strong or weak, and audiences concentrated in places the creator has no connection to. None is proof on its own; several together are a reason to move on.
Platform choice sits above all three checks. If the audience is not on the platform where the creator publishes, fit does not matter, and the choosing platforms guide covers that decision for organic and creator work alike.
Content quality and past partnerships
Audience fit says who will see the content; the creator's past work says what they will see. Read at least a few months of posts, not the highlights the creator puts in a media kit.
Look first at whether the content suits the brand's category and tone. A creator who is very funny may be the wrong voice for a product people buy when anxious; a creator whose content is beautifully shot may struggle to explain something technical. Then look at how the creator handles sponsored posts. The best creators integrate a product into the kind of content they already make, so the post feels like theirs and the audience responds as it normally would. Weak sponsored work is easy to spot: a sudden change of tone, a script read to camera, comments that ignore the product or mock the ad.
Past partnerships tell you three further things. Whether the creator has recently worked with a direct competitor, which may create an exclusivity problem or simply muddy the message. Whether they disclose paid work clearly, which the ASA expects and which indicates how they will treat your brand. And how often they post sponsored content: a feed that is mostly advertising has an audience that has learned to scroll past it.
Vetting for brand safety
Brand-safety vetting asks whether anything the creator has said, done or published would embarrass the brand if it surfaced next to the partnership. The principle is the same one programmatic buyers apply to placements, described in the brand safety and viewability guide, but with a person rather than a page the stakes are more personal and the review is manual.
A practical vetting pass covers:
- Content history: a search of the creator's posts, captions and comments for language, topics or stances that conflict with the brand's values or would alienate its customers.
- Off-platform record: news coverage, other platforms and podcasts, where creators often speak more freely than on their main channel.
- Audience behaviour: what the comment section tolerates. A creator whose community is hostile to outsiders will turn that hostility on a brand that misjudges the tone.
- Commercial conflicts: current or recent partnerships with competitors, and categories the brand will not sit beside.
- Disclosure habits: whether past paid posts were labelled clearly. A creator who habitually hides sponsorship exposes the brand to regulatory complaints.
Record what was checked and when. A vetting note is useful again when the creator is re-booked, and it shows that the brand took reasonable care if a problem surfaces later. If a creator does become the story mid-campaign, the guide to handling a creator controversy covers what to pause, how to decide whether to continue, and how to feed the missed signal back into this note.
Shortlisting and outreach
A workable process moves from a long list to a shortlist in stages, dropping names at each. Start wide: discovery tools, platform search, hashtags the audience uses, creators the brand's customers already follow, and recommendations from creators the brand already works with. Then apply the checks in order of cost: platform and audience fit first, because they rule out most names quickly; content quality next; vetting last, on the few that remain.
Shortlisting creators for a plant-based snack
Fernleaf Foods, an invented maker of plant-based snacks, wants consideration among health-conscious office workers in two UK cities. Its long list has 120 creators from a discovery tool and hashtag search. Audience fit cuts it to 34: 52 had most followers outside the UK and 34 skewed to students. Content review cuts it to 15, dropping creators whose sponsored posts read as scripts. Vetting removes 3, two for a recent competitor deal and one for undisclosed paid posts. Of the 12 approached, 8 reply and 6 agree to terms, giving a programme of micro creators whose combined target-audience reach the team estimates at 140,000 people, at a cost per thousand target impressions roughly a third of a macro creator's quote.
Outreach works best when it is specific. A message that names a post the creator made, explains why the brand thinks their audience would care, and states the basic shape of the deal gets more replies than a template. Be clear early about what the partnership involves: number of posts, rough timing, whether the brand wants usage rights and whether paid amplification is planned. Those terms are then written into the contract, which the contracts and disclosure guide covers in full. Selection is not only for strangers: the guide to building long-term creator partnerships explains when a creator who has already delivered should be kept on a standing deal instead of replaced. The same checks apply when a creator writes to the brand first, and the guide to answering creator requests for free product and paid work runs those requests through them before anyone replies.
| Stage | Check | Typical reason to drop a creator |
|---|---|---|
| Long list | Platform and topic | Wrong platform or category |
| Fit | Audience insights | Audience in the wrong market or life stage |
| Quality | Recent posts and sponsored work | Tone mismatch or weak integrations |
| Vetting | History, conflicts, disclosure | Safety concern or competitor tie |
| Outreach | Interest and terms | Unavailable, or terms do not fit the budget |
To compare quotes from creators of different sizes on one basis, convert each fee into a price per thousand verified impressions with the influencer sponsorship CPM calculator.
Common mistakes
- Choosing by follower count. Size is the easiest number to see and the least useful on its own; start from the goal and the audience.
- Trusting the media kit. Media kits show a creator at their best. Ask for current audience insights and read the feed yourself.
- Ignoring overlap. Several creators in one niche may reach the same people; the combined audience is smaller than it looks.
- Skipping vetting for small creators. Nano and micro creators are vetted less often and are no less likely to carry a problem.
- Missing competitor ties. A creator who praised a rival last month is a weak advocate this month, and may be under exclusivity.
- Generic outreach. A template message signals that the brand has not looked at the creator's work, and the best creators ignore it.
