Two intermediaries, two loyalties
The words are used loosely, so start with loyalties. Ask of any intermediary: whose interests are they paid to serve?
| Row label | Creator's agent or talent manager | Influencer agency |
|---|---|---|
| Works for | The creator | The brand |
| Paid by | The creator, under their own arrangement | The brand |
| Main job | Win the best deal and protect the creator's reputation and time | Run some or all of the brand's creator programme |
| Controls | The creator's rates, diary, terms they will accept, often the contract paper | Whatever the brand hands over: sourcing, contracting, briefing, review, reporting |
| What the brand needs from them | Clear terms, a working route to the creator, timely sign-off | Good creators, sound contracts, honest reporting, and the brand's data and rights returned |
| Where it goes wrong | Terms dictated by the agent's paper; the brand never speaks to the creator | The agency owns the relationships and the data; the brand learns nothing |
Some firms do both, representing creators and running campaigns for brands. That is not wrong in itself, but it means an agency could recommend creators it also represents. Ask the question directly when choosing an agency and record the answer.
The costs of both show up in the brand's accounts. The influencer ROI and incrementality guide lists agent commission among the creator costs often missed, and agency or platform fees among the tools and agency costs. Neither is a reason to avoid intermediaries; both belong in the cost per outcome.
Working with a creator's agent or manager
The influencer contracts and disclosure guide notes that larger creators usually arrive with an agent and their own paper. Working well with an agent starts with recognising that their job is to get the best deal for their client, and that a good agent also wants the work to go well, because a creator's reputation is their business too.
Practices that help:
- Agree the route at the start. The agent handles the deal: fee, terms, contract, invoicing. Ask whether the brand can work with the creator directly on the brief, the draft and the review once terms are signed. Most agents agree; it saves time for everyone.
- Send a precise scope. A vague request lets the agent fill the gaps in the creator's favour. The guide to negotiating creator fees and terms sets out the scope and the ceiling to prepare before asking for a quote.
- Read the agent's paper against your own terms. Agents often send their standard contract. Check it clause by clause against the contracts guide's table, especially usage rightsThe terms in a creator or influencer agreement that set how, where and for how long a brand may reuse the content, organically or in paid ads., exclusivityA contract term that stops a creator, sponsored property or partner working with competing brands for an agreed category, scope and period., approvals, disclosure and the correction right after posting. Where the brand's terms must survive, say so and mark up the agent's draft rather than signing it as sent. A legal adviser should review anything unusual; this guide does not cover contract law.
- Know who signs. Confirm whether the agent signs for the creator or the creator signs, and that the contract names the creator's obligations, not only the agent's.
- Keep the creator in view. The agent negotiates the price; the creator makes the work. What matters to the creator, such as creative freedom, a product they believe in or a fair review, may not come through the agent, so ask.
- Be a brand agents want to work with. Clear briefs, fast and fair review, and prompt payment are remembered, and agents decide which brands their clients hear about first.
When an influencer agency earns its fee
An influencer agency takes on work the brand would otherwise do itself. The general case for and against agencies is set out in the comparison of in-house and agency teams; for creator work, an agency tends to earn its fee when:
- The programme is larger or faster than the team. Many creators at once, several markets or a tight launch window can swamp a small team.
- It brings relationships or skills the brand lacks. Contacts in a category, production capability, or experience of running creator content as ads.
- The brand is testing creator work. An agency can run a first programme while the brand learns what it would need to bring the work in-house.
- The brand needs capacity, not a hire. Seasonal or campaign-based programmes may not justify a permanent role.
Choose, scope and contract an influencer agency as you would any agency. The guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies covers the shortlist, pitch, scope, fee models, service levelsA published promise between teams, or with a supplier, about what each type of request needs and how quickly it will be handled, agreed rather than imposed., briefing, scorecards and exits; the agency request for proposal template and the agency onboarding checklist hold the documents. What differs for creator work is what the scope should say about creators: how they are found and vetted (the creator tiers and selection guide sets the checks, and the agency should show its Brand SafetyControls that keep ads away from content that would harm the advertiser's reputation. vetting for each creator), who contracts with them, how disclosure is checked, and what comes back to the brand. Ask whether the agency is paid by creators or platforms it recommends as well as by the brand, and how it handles that. The guide to hiring and evaluating an influencer agency turns these points into written questions, a way to weigh proposals, reports the brand can test and the steps for leaving.
What the brand keeps whoever runs the work
The selection guide's section on transitions says accounts, data, assets and documentation should be held in the business's name from the start. For creator work, that means a short list of things the brand keeps in its own files however much it hands over:
- The creator list and relationships. Every creator worked with, their contact or agent, what they were paid, how they performed and whether the brand would work with them again. If the agency leaves, the relationships should not leave with it.
- The contracts. Copies of every creator agreement, with the brand named as the party entitled to the content and licence, or with clear terms on how rights pass to the brand.
- The rights record. Each licensed asset with its permitted uses, channels, markets and expiry, held in the brand's asset library as the tutorial on setting up a marketing asset library describes, so ads stop when licences end.
- The tracking data. Links, codes and results in the brand's own analytics, set up as the KPIs and tracking links guide advises, and creator insights shared in a form the brand stores.
- Disclosure oversight. The brand's own check of live posts, even when the agency checks too.
The agency's report should be judged against the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. the brand set, using the brand's data, not the agency's summary of it.
Disclosure and responsibility across three parties
Adding intermediaries does not dilute the duty to disclose; it spreads it. The contracts guide's FAQ sets out the direction from the FTC's endorsement guidance: responsibility for disclosure can fall on the brand and any agency as well as the creator. The affiliate partner recruitment, compliance and fraud guide describes the same regulators' direction for partners generally: advertisers are expected to require disclosure, monitor what partners publish and act on breaches. In the UK, the contracts guide records that the Advertising Standards Authority applies the advertising codes to creator content where the brand has paid and has control, and that marketing must be obviously identifiable as such.
In practice:
- The brand writes the disclosure requirement into its agreement with the agency and requires that every creator contract carries it, then checks a sample of live posts itself.
- The agency puts the requirement in each creator contract and brief, checks drafts and live posts, and reports missing labels and corrections to the brand.
- The creator's agent confirms the creator has accepted the disclosure terms and helps get corrections made quickly.
- The creator labels each post clearly and fixes problems when asked.
None of this is legal advice, and the rules and their interpretation change; the contracts guide links the regulators' own guidance.
Who does what in a programme run through both
When a brand runs a programme through an influencer agency and some creators have agents, the number of hands makes gaps likely. A responsibility table, built with the RACI matrix, settles who is accountable for each task. The framework allows one accountable role per row; others may be responsible for the work.
| Task | Brand | Influencer agency | Creator's agent | Creator |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Programme goal and budget | Accountable | Consulted | ||
| Creator long list and vetting | Approves the shortlist | Responsible | ||
| Fee and terms negotiation | Sets the ceiling | Responsible | Responsible for the creator | Consulted |
| Creator contract | Accountable for the terms | Responsible for drafting | Reviews for the creator | Signs or authorises |
| Brief | Accountable | Responsible | Informed | Consulted |
| Draft review | Accountable for must-fixes | Responsible | Informed | Responsible for revisions |
| Disclosure on live posts | Accountable | Responsible for checks | Helps with corrections | Responsible for the label |
| Licence and rights record | Accountable | Responsible for the paperwork | Consulted | Grants the licence |
| Tracking and reporting | Accountable for the data | Responsible for the report | Shares insights | |
| Payment | Accountable | Responsible if it pays creators | Invoices for the creator |
The table is a starting point; the brand's own version should name people, not just parties. Where the creator programme sits beside other agencies, such as a media agency running the paid layer, the joins between them belong in the roster map that the guide to coordinating several agencies describes.
A board game publisher's programme through an agency (illustrative)
Yollick Games runs a launch programme through an agency
Yollick Games, an invented board game publisher, has a two-person marketing team and a new family game launching in 10 weeks. It hires an influencer agency on a project fee to run a launch programme with 12 creators who review and play tabletop games.
The scope says the agency sources and vets creators against Yollick's checks, negotiates within a ceiling Yollick sets for each creator, drafts contracts on Yollick's template with Yollick named as the licensee, briefs, reviews drafts and reports weekly. Yollick approves the shortlist, keeps final say on must-fix review comments, and owns the tracking links and codes in its own analytics. The agency confirms it represents none of the shortlisted creators.
2 of the 12 creators have managers. One manager sends her own contract with a 24-month paid licence and no correction right; the agency, with Yollick's agreement, marks it up to a 6-month licence with a correction right and the brand's disclosure clause, and the manager accepts. The other asks for exclusivity across all games; it is narrowed to family board games for 4 weeks.
Yollick keeps the creator list, every signed contract and a rights record with each licence's expiry in its asset library. In launch week, its marketing manager checks every live post herself and finds 1 story frame without a label; the agency has the creator fix it within the day and logs the correction. After the programme, Yollick re-books 3 creators directly, using the relationships and records it kept.
Common mistakes
- Confusing the two intermediaries. A creator's agent works for the creator; an agency works for the brand. Treat each accordingly.
- Going around an agent on the deal. It damages trust with the agent and the creator; agree a working route instead.
- Signing the agent's paper as sent. Check it against the contracts guide's clauses and keep the brand's essential terms.
- Letting the agency own the relationships. Keep the creator list, contracts, rights record and data in the brand's own files.
- Assuming the agency handles disclosure. Responsibility can fall on the brand too; keep your own check of live posts.
- Leaving intermediary costs out of the numbers. Agent commission and agency fees belong in the cost per outcome.
- No one accountable. Without a responsibility table, tasks fall between brand, agency, agent and creator.
