Why several good agencies can add up to a poor result
Each agency on a roster is hired for a discipline and judged, usually, on that discipline. The creative agency is praised for strong ideas, the media agency for efficient buying, the PR partner for coverage and the search specialist for rankings or paid search returns. Every one of those can be true at once while the campaign misses, because the result the business cares about depends on how the pieces fit together, and the fit belongs to no one.
The in-house versus agency comparison puts it in one line when it describes designing a hybrid: someone in-house must own the joins between agencies, with shared objectives, a single measurement framework and regular joint reviews. The Institute of Practitioners in Advertising has published guidance for many years on how clients and agencies work together, and the comparison draws out a recurring theme: the relationship works best when both sides understand what the agency is there to do. With several agencies, that clarity has to cover each agency's part and how the parts connect.
Coordination problems show up in familiar ways. Work arrives late because one agency was waiting for another's files. Two agencies brief the same supplier differently. A media plan books placements for creative that was never made in the right formats. Each monthly report claims the same sales. The agencies and partners hub lists "several agencies blame each other for results" among its common problems, and this guide is the fuller answer to it.
This guide is about one business and its roster across disciplines. Working with agencies across several countries, with a network agency, a lead agency with local partners or a roster of local specialists, is set out in the international marketing operations hub. Running a single agency's cycle, from selection to exit, is in the guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies. Where the roster includes an influencer agency, the creators' own agents add a further party, and the guide to working with creator agents and influencer agencies sets out who does what between them.
Where the joins are
A join is any point where one agency's work becomes another's input, or where two agencies' work has to reach the customer as one thing. Map them before deciding who integrates, because the map shows how much integration the roster actually needs. The table lists the joins most rosters have; yours will add its own.
| Join | What passes across it | What goes wrong when nobody owns it | Who should own it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brief to every agency | Objective, audience, message, timing | Each agency reads a different version of the campaign | The in-house brief owner |
| Creative to media | Formats, sizes, durations, versions, delivery dates | Placements booked for assets that do not exist | The integrator, with both agencies responsible |
| Creative to search and site | Messages, landing pages, offers | Ads promise what the landing page does not say | The integrator or the channel owner in-house |
| PR to paid and owned channels | Announcement dates, embargoes, key messages | News breaks before the paid and owned channels are ready | The integrator, with the calendar as the record |
| Media to measurement | Tracking, naming, conversion definitions | Each agency counts results its own way | The in-house measurement owner |
| Every agency to results | One results page, one period, one source per number | Several reports claim the same sales | The in-house measurement owner |
| Every agency to approvals | Claims, legal review, brand sign-off | Work waits for sign-offs nobody requested | The in-house approvals owner |
| Incoming to outgoing agency | Accounts, assets, history, live work | Work stalls or knowledge is lost during a change | The integrator, using the onboarding and offboarding checklists |
Give every join one accountable owner. The RACI matrix allows a single accountable role per row; agencies can be responsible for doing the work across a join, but the accountability sits with one named person, usually in-house. A join with two accountable owners is a join with none. Joins nobody owns also reach the invoices, as overlapping work and charges for repairing another agency's files, which the diagnosis for agency fees that keep rising traces alongside the other causes of a climbing bill. The academy exercise on running several agencies as one team for a chocolate maker practises mapping these joins for an inherited creative, media, search and social roster before choosing who integrates.
Who integrates: an in-house lead or a lead agency
Someone has to run the roster day to day: keep the plan, chase the dependencies, call the joint meetings and notice when one agency's delay will break another's deadline. As general practice there are two ways to staff that job, and many businesses combine them.
An in-house integration lead. A person in the marketing team owns the joins, the shared plan and the joint reviews. The business keeps the judgement: the objectives, the measures and the final say on disagreements stay with the side that is not being judged. The cost is time. Integration is a real job, and a manager who takes it on alongside a full workload will do it only when something goes wrong.
A lead agency. One agency on the roster, often the creative or the media agency, takes on the running of the others' workflow: collecting assets, keeping the production schedule and calling the working meetings. It can bring process the in-house team lacks. The trade-off is that the lead agency is also one of the parties being coordinated, so it is not a neutral judge of disputes or of results. Where a lead agency runs the workflow, the business should still own the objectives, the measurement and the arbitration, and should write the lead role into the lead agency's scope rather than assume it.
| Question | Points to an in-house lead | Points to a lead agency |
|---|---|---|
| Does someone in-house have the seniority and time? | Yes | No, and hiring is not an option yet |
| Are disputes between agencies common? | Yes: the judge should be neutral | Rarely |
| Is most of the coordination production flow? | Partly | Yes: assets, formats, schedules |
| Does the business want to build integration skill in-house? | Yes | Not for now |
Whichever model you choose, write it down. Each agency's scope should say who integrates, who it takes direction from and who it hands work to. The scope section of the guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies covers what a scope contains; any fees for the lead role, and any terms that bind one agency to work with another, are for the business's legal advisers and whoever manages suppliers, and the costs themselves belong with the budget, as the marketing finance hub sets out.
One plan, one calendar, one brief
Coordination fails first when agencies work from different documents. Three shared documents prevent most of it.
One plan. Every agency should see the same objectives for the year and the quarter, and know which ones its work serves. Invite agency leads to the parts of planning that affect them, as the agency guide recommends, and share the result with all of them rather than a version tailored to each.
One calendar. A single calendar shows every agency's launches, announcements, deadlines and dependencies on one timeline. The guide to building a campaign calendar covers the layers a calendar needs and how to protect always-on work around peaks, and the guide to work management and marketing calendars covers keeping it as the single view of the work. Give every agency read access, make the integrator its keeper, and treat a date that is not on the calendar as not agreed.
One brief. Brief the campaign once, to every agency together, from a single campaign brief, then let each agency's discipline-specific brief descend from it. A Creative BriefA short document telling the people making creative work what it must achieve, for whom, with which message and within which limits. written with the creative brief template should carry the same objective, audience and message as the media brief and the PR brief. Briefing all agencies in the same session surfaces the dependencies early: the media agency hears which formats the creative will produce, and the PR team hears when the paid launch is planned. The creative production playbook sets out the production stages that most of these dependencies run through. The tutorial on writing a media brief sets out what the media agency's brief adds on top: the media task, the audience in buyable terms, what the budget covers and which choices are fixed or open.
One set of measures and one version of the results
When each agency reports on its own measures from its own tools, every report can show progress while the business does not move, and agencies end up competing for credit rather than working together. The fix is to set the measures once for the whole roster.
Start from a measurement plan that records, for each objective, the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. that shows progress, the source of truthThe system whose figure is treated as authoritative for a given number, such as billing for revenue or the CRM for pipeline, with other tools reconciled to it. for each number, the naming conventions every agency uses and the business's stance on AttributionAssigning conversion credit to touchpoints.. Every agency works to that plan, and none defines its own version of a conversion. Hold the measurement in-house, for the reason the in-house versus agency comparison gives: measurement should sit with the side that is not judged by it.
Then publish one results page for the whole roster, built from the business's own data, with each agency's platform figures shown beside the business total and never added together. The diagnosis of agency reports that look good while sales are flat explains why platform figures summed across agencies overstate what happened and how to line them up against the business's own record. When every agency sees the same page, conversations move from whose number is right to what the shared result needs next. The academy capstone on a strategy leadership plan for a sauna maker practises integrating an inherited roster inside a plan that also covers the business's markets, its crisis readiness and a learning agenda.
Joint planning and joint reviews
Separate meetings with each agency keep each relationship healthy but hide the joins. Add a joint rhythm on top of the individual one.
Joint planning. Bring the agency leads together when the quarter's plan is set, so each hears the others' plans and the dependencies are agreed in the room. The quarterly session described in the planning hub is the natural place; agencies doing a significant share of the work belong in it.
Joint working sessions. For live campaigns, a regular working session with every agency involved, run by the integrator, covers what is due, what is blocked and which join is at risk. Keep it short and focused on dependencies; each agency's detailed work stays in its own meetings.
Joint reviews. Review results with all agencies against the one results page. The two-way scorecard in the agency guide still applies to each agency, and can gain a line on how well the agency works with the others. Ask each agency to score the business on the joins too: late files from one agency often trace back to a late decision from the client.
How often each meeting happens depends on the pace of the work and the size of the roster; set it from what the calendar needs rather than from habit, and drop a meeting that no longer changes any decision.
Settling disputes between agencies
Disagreements on a roster are normal: about credit for results, about whose delay caused a slip, about whose idea a campaign should follow. They become damaging when they are settled by whoever argues hardest, or not settled at all.
Three habits keep them small. First, settle disputes about results on the business's own data, using the one results page and the measurement plan, never on one agency's report against another's; the agency reports page sets out how to read the two side by side. Second, settle disputes about work on the record: the scope says who owns what, the calendar says what was agreed and when, and the RACI rows say who was accountable. When the record is silent, the dispute has found a gap, and the fix is to fill the gap rather than to pick a winner. Third, keep the final say in-house. A lead agency can raise and organise a disagreement, but the business decides.
Where a dispute turns on what a contract obliges an agency to do, or on fees, hand it to the business's legal advisers and whoever manages suppliers. Most disputes on a roster are about ownership and information, and they end when both are written down.
Adding or replacing one agency
Changing one agency touches every join it sat on. Before a new agency starts, revisit the joins map, update each affected scope and RACI row, and tell the other agencies what is changing and who they will work with. The agency onboarding checklist covers access, history, measures and approvals for the new agency; add the roster's own items, such as the shared calendar, the measurement plan and an introduction to the other agency leads.
When an agency leaves, the agency offboarding checklist covers accounts, assets and access, and the integrator should check that nothing the remaining agencies depend on leaves with it: files in production, tracking it set up, or relationships with suppliers the others use. Overlap the outgoing and incoming agencies where you can, as the agency guide recommends, and keep the other agencies informed so that work across the joins does not stall. If results fall after the change, the page on results that dropped after changing agency checks what the handover lost.
For roster changes in other markets, the guide to choosing media and channels by market covers local media and partners, and the international operations hub covers how central and local partners fit together.
A paint maker's four agencies (illustrative)
Kweldaris Paints puts one integrator in charge of its roster
Kweldaris Paints, an invented paint manufacturer, worked with 4 partners: a creative agency, a media agency, a PR consultancy and a search specialist, each managed by a different person in a marketing team of 7. Its spring range launch slipped by 3 weeks. The creative agency delivered the hero film on time but in only 2 of the 6 formats the media plan had booked; the PR consultancy secured coverage 10 days before the range was on the website; and the search specialist had not been told the range names. Each monthly report showed success: the PR consultancy reported 40 pieces of coverage, the media agency reported its buying targets met, and the four reports together claimed more online orders than the business had taken.
The head of marketing named one in-house integration lead, the senior brand manager, and gave her ownership of 8 joins mapped in a single table. All 4 agencies were briefed together from one campaign brief for the autumn range, every date went into one shared calendar, and a single results page built from the order system replaced the 4 separate headline figures, with each agency's platform numbers shown beside the business total. A short working session with all 4 agencies ran every fortnight during the launch period.
The autumn range launched on its planned date with every booked format delivered. Arguments about credit gave way to a discussion of the shared page, which showed that orders from new customers had come mostly in the weeks when search and media ran together.
Common mistakes
- Managing each agency in isolation. Good individual relationships do not make the parts fit. Map the joins and give each one an owner.
- Two accountable owners for a join. Shared accountability means nobody acts. One accountable person per join, usually in-house.
- Letting a lead agency judge itself. A lead agency can run the workflow, but the objectives, the measures and the final say on disputes stay with the business.
- A separate brief for each agency. Agencies working from different documents produce work that does not fit. Brief once, together, and let discipline briefs descend from it.
- Summing each agency's reported results. Platform figures overlap. Publish one results page from the business's own data and show agency figures beside it.
- Only one-to-one meetings. Separate meetings hide the dependencies. Add joint planning, working sessions and reviews.
- Settling disputes by who argues hardest. Decide on the record: the scope, the calendar, the RACI rows and the shared results.
- Changing one agency without telling the others. Every join it sat on changes. Update the scopes, the RACI rows and the calendar before the new agency starts.
