Why this matters
The advanced marketing strategy level designed an operating model from a blank page. A new director rarely gets one. The tutorial on taking over an existing marketing programme inventories what was inherited before anything changes, ending with a BaselineAn estimate of what a metric would have done without a given change, campaign or promotion, against which the effect is measured. and a change log. The guide to coordinating several marketing agencies then makes the roster one team, because good agencies add up to a poor result when nobody owns the places their work meets.
The chocolate maker and its four agencies
Zolvenard Chocolate is an invented maker of premium chocolate sold as gifts through its website, delicatessens and department stores. A new marketing director joins before the gifting season, beside an ecommerce manager and a brand executive.
Zolvenard Chocolate: the roster and what the first weeks found
| Agency | Scope as written | Monthly fee | Its headline last quarter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Creative | Brand campaigns, film, packaging artwork | £9,000 | Gift film watched 1.4 million times |
| Media | Paid social and online video | £7,500 | 1,640 purchases |
| Search | Paid search and Shopping | £4,000 | 1,980 purchases |
| Social | Organic social, creator gifting, paid boosts | £5,000 | 520 purchases through creator codes |
The shop recorded 2,900 orders last quarter from every source, against 2,750 a year earlier.
| Inventory step | Finding |
|---|---|
| Accounts | Google Ads sits under the search agency's manager account with no Zolvenard administrator; the social agency boosts posts from its own ad account |
| Tracking | Analytics purchases match orders within 2%, but 19% of sessions are unassigned: creator links carry no campaign tags |
| Spend and renewals | The creative contract renews for 12 months in 5 weeks; £1,100 a month of retargeting promotes a range discontinued in June |
| Assets | Film and packaging source files sit only with the creative agency; licensed photography expires in January |
| Data | A giveaway collected 3,800 emails into the social agency's own tool, consent wording unclear |
| Calendar | The advent promotion is promised to stockists for mid-November; the search agency plans a new Shopping structure that week |
Last Easter the film arrived in landscape only, so vertical placements ran a crop. Search and media each claim the other's sales. The creative agency offers to become lead agency for £2,500 a month more.
Inventory first, then the joins
Until the baseline exists, change only what is clearly broken or plainly wasted. Ownership comes first: a dispute or a departure can cost it. Then map the joins: every hand-off from one agency to another, and every place two agencies' work meets the same customer. Each join gets one accountable owner, usually in-house.
Task
- Sort the findings into fix now, decide before a date and record as a known gap.
- Write the baseline from the business's own records, with its gaps, and open the change log.
- Map the joins between the agencies and name one accountable owner for each.
- Choose an in-house integrator or a lead agency, and answer the creative agency's offer.
- Set one plan, calendar and brief for the gifting season.
- Agree one set of measures and one version of results.
- Write how disputes are settled, using the credit argument between search and media as the test.
Worked answer
The findings sorted. Fix now: transfer the Google Ads account with its history to two in-house administrators, not a new account; stop the retargeting; suppress the giveaway contacts until whoever handles data protection decides. Decide before a date: notice on the self-renewing creative contract, the most urgent item, and the Shopping restructure, which moves out of advent week. Known gaps: untagged creator links, the paid social overlap, and files and photography rights held outside the business, which the agency offboarding checklist would otherwise find only at an exit.
The baseline. Orders, revenue and cost from the shop and the ledger for last quarter and the same quarter a year earlier, because gifting is seasonal, with definitions and gaps beside them.
The joins. Brief to every agency: the director. Creative work to paid placements, covering formats and delivery dates: the integrator owns it, while the creative and media agencies do the work. Campaign messages and offers to search ads and site pages: the ecommerce manager. Creator posts to paid boosting: one buyer, the media agency, in Zolvenard's own ad account. Every agency to results: the ecommerce manager, because measurement sits with the side not judged by it.
The integrator. In-house. Disputes are frequent, and a lead agency is one of the parties, so it cannot judge them. The offer is declined as integration, but a production schedule for every booked format goes into the creative scope, where the Easter failure sat. The director clears time for the role.
Plan, calendar and brief. All four agencies are briefed together from one campaign brief template, with the Creative BriefA short document telling the people making creative work what it must achieve, for whom, with which message and within which limits., media and social briefs descending from it. One calendar, kept by the integrator, holds the advent promotion, film deliveries in every format, creator dates and the moved Shopping work; a date not on it is not agreed.
Measures and results. A measurement plan sets each objective's KPIA metric tied directly to an objective., one naming convention and the shop's orders as the Source of TruthThe system whose figure is treated as authoritative for a given number, such as billing for revenue or the CRM for pipeline, with other tools reconciled to it.. One results page leads with Zolvenard's own order total; each agency's platform count sits in a column beside it and is never summed, for the reason the page on agency reports that look good while sales are flat gives.
Disputes. Settled on the record: scopes, calendar, join owners and the results page; where the record is silent, fill the gap rather than pick a winner. Whether video creates the searches that search converts goes on the learning agenda as an assumption to test before next year's split. Questions about contract obligations or fees, including what the creative agency charges for the added production schedule, go to whoever manages suppliers and to the business's legal advisers; the two-way reviews in the guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies gain a line on teamwork.
Zolvenard Chocolate: the baseline beside the agency reports
| Measure, last quarter | Figure | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|
| Orders from every source | 2,900, against 2,750 a year earlier, about 5% up | The baseline, from the shop |
| Purchases the agencies claim | 1,640 + 1,980 + 520 = 4,140, about 1.4 times the orders | Beside the total, never summed |
| Sessions with no campaign | 19% | A known gap until creator links are tagged |
Common mistakes
- Opening new accounts. History and learning stay with the agency.
- Letting a lead agency judge itself. The plan, the measures and the final say stay in-house.
- Summing agency reports. Platform figures overlap, so the sum flatters everyone.
- Hiring another agency to sort out the roster. It adds a join and owns none.
The strategy leadership capstone puts the same work inside a full plan.
