Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Management › Agencies and Partners

Selecting, Briefing and Reviewing Agencies

How to select and manage an agency: the pitch and selection process, scope and fee models, contracts and service levels, briefing, reviews, and exits.
Guideintermediate14 min readUpdated

Selecting: shortlist, chemistry, pitch

Selection starts with knowing what you need, which is why the decision covered in in-house vs agency marketing comes first. Write down the work the agency will do, the objectives it serves, the budget range, the in-house people it will work with and what success looks like. That document becomes the basis of the shortlist, the conversations and the eventual scope. For search engine optimisation, the guide to hiring and evaluating an SEO agency adds the questions and warning signs Google itself publishes for anyone hiring an SEO. For paid search, the guide to hiring and evaluating a Google Ads agency adds account ownership, conversion definitions and reports the business can check against its own sales. For a market research study, the guide to commissioning a research agency or freelancer adds what to ask about the sample, the people doing the fieldwork and participants' data. For conversion optimisation, the guide to hiring and evaluating a CRO agency adds who keeps the testing accounts and the test log, how test results should be reported and how winners reach the site. For analytics and tracking work, the guide to hiring and evaluating an analytics agency adds which tracking objects stay with the business, the questions particular to tracking and how to accept tracking nobody in-house can read in code. For paid social on Meta, the guide to hiring and evaluating a Meta Ads agency adds the Meta assets a business keeps in its own portfolio, what to ask about creative supply and the conversion signal, and which reports can be checked against the business's orders. For email, the guide to hiring and evaluating an email marketing agency adds the platform account, sending domain, consent records and suppression list that stay in the business's name, the questions on list sources and authentication, and the reports that tie back to orders. For organic social, the guide to hiring and evaluating a social media agency adds the accounts, voice guide, approvals and permissions that stay in the brand's name, the questions on reply drafting, hours and escalation, and the reports that can be checked against the brand's own history. For content marketing, the guide to hiring and evaluating a content marketing agency adds the briefs, sources, interview records and publishing accounts that stay in the business's hands, the questions on expert access, sourcing and AI use, and the reports grouped by pillar and stage. For business-to-business demand and account-based work, the guide to hiring and evaluating a B2B demand agency adds the profile, account list, stage definitions and CRM records that stay with the business, the questions on sellers, sources and contacts, and the reports that can be checked against its own pipeline. For apps, the guide to hiring and evaluating an app marketing agency adds the store, measurement partner and ad network accounts that, as general practice, stay in the business's name, the questions on listings, installs, messaging and measurement, and the reports that can be reconciled with the store consoles and the measurement partner. For planning and buying media, the guide to hiring and evaluating a media agency adds the trading status, rebate and audit access questions to put in writing before proposals are weighed, the accounts, plans and records the business holds under its own name, and the reports that can be tested against its orders and invoices. For a new logo and visual system, the guide to hiring and evaluating a brand identity studio adds the strategy, cue list and master files that stay with the business, the questions on testing, accessibility and handover, and how to weigh proposals. For creator and influencer programmes, the guide to hiring and evaluating an influencer agency adds the creator list, agreements, rights record and tracking that stay with the brand, the questions on vetting, representation and label checks, and the reports that can be tested against its own links and orders. For growth work across the customer journey, the guide to hiring and evaluating a growth marketing agency adds the model, definitions, cohort table and learning log that stay with the business, the questions on who calls tests and what counts in acquisition cost, and the reports that can be tested against its own cohorts, ledger and orders. For a business channel on YouTube, the guide to hiring and evaluating a YouTube channel agency adds the strategy, briefs, query register, footage and change log the business keeps in its name, the questions on briefs, packaging and openings, and how a provider's reports can be read against the business's exports and tagged visits. For paid media run across several platforms, the guide to hiring and evaluating a performance marketing agency adds the register of events, targets, customer lists and test record that stay with the business, the questions on who sets targets and what counts as a result, and the reports that can be tested against its own orders and records. For paid work on TikTok, the guide to hiring and evaluating a TikTok Ads agency adds which jobs to hire out, the Spark Ads code list, rights record and original files that stay in the business's name beyond the account assets, the questions on creative, codes and the pixel, and how to compare a provider's reports with the business's own record. For a provider whose product is the process, the approvals and the records around the work rather than the work itself, the guide to hiring and evaluating a marketing operations consultant adds the decisions and records that stay with the business, the questions on starting from its own records and on who approves, and the tests for accepting each delivery. For local marketing work on a Business Profile, listings, reviews and local ads, the guide to hiring and evaluating a local marketing agency adds the profile, accounts and records the business holds in its own name, the questions on naming, duplicates and review practice, and reports it can check against its own bookings.

StagePurposeWhat to look forCommon trap
Long listFind agencies with the right capability and category experienceRelevant work, client types, size fit, referencesShortlisting on awards or reputation alone
Request for informationNarrow the list with a short written responseClear thinking, honesty about fit, team structureAsking for a lengthy document nobody reads
Chemistry meetingsMeet the people who would do the workCuriosity about the business, quality of questions, team fitMeeting senior leaders who will not work on the account
Task or pitchSee how the agency thinks about your problemReasoning, use of evidence, willingness to challengeRewarding the slickest presentation
ReferencesTest concerns raised in the processHow the agency handles problems and changesTreating references as a formality
Negotiation and appointmentAgree scope, fees and termsClarity and fairness on both sidesSqueezing fees until the agency loses interest

Keep the shortlist short. Each agency invited to pitch invests significant time, and the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising has long encouraged clients to run proportionate processes, limit the number of pitching agencies and consider paying for speculative work. A small, well-run process attracts better agencies and produces a better decision. For reading the case studies the shortlisted agencies offer and the figures their referees give, the tutorial on checking an agency's claimed results asks each of them for the same result sheet, grades the evidence behind each result and scores it against weights fixed in advance.

Insist on meeting the team who will work on the account, not only the people who win the business. Ask how the team will be staffed, how much of each person's time you will get, and what happens when someone leaves. Give every agency the same brief and the same information, score against criteria agreed in advance, and include someone from the in-house team who will work with the agency day to day. The agency request for proposal template puts that shared brief, the questions every agency must answer and the published scoring criteria into one document. For language work, the guide to choosing and managing translation suppliers adds paid test pieces judged by an in-country reviewer and keeps the termbase and translation memory with the business.

Scope, fee models and contracts

The scope is the most important document in the relationship. It should state the services the agency provides, the deliverables and their frequency, what is out of scope, the in-house team's responsibilities, the measures the agency will be judged against and how changes to scope are handled. A vague scope causes most fee disputes, because neither side can tell whether a request is included. A freelance specialist needs the same written scope, and the guide to starting out as a freelance digital marketer sets it out from the freelancer's side, with the exclusions and the decision-maker named. For the business's side, the agency scope of work template lays these points out as fields to fill after selection and before the contract is drafted.

Match the fee model to the work. Retainers suit continuous work with a stable scope. Project fees suit defined deliverables. Time and materials suits uncertain work but needs tracking. Commission on media spend is common in buying but rewards spending rather than effectiveness. Performance-related elements align incentives when the measures are fair and within the agency's influence. Whatever the model, agree how scope changes are priced before the first one happens. For media agencies, the terms of buying, including how rates such as the CPM are negotiated and how insertion orders are managed, are covered in negotiation and insertion orders.

The contract should cover ownership of work and data, confidentiality, payment terms, notice periods, the handover obligations at exit and how disputes are resolved. Ownership deserves particular care: the business should own its ad accounts, analytics properties, customer data and the creative it pays for, subject to any third-party rights such as image or talent licences. Contracts are legal documents, and their drafting is a job for the business's legal advisers; this guide covers only what a marketing manager should make sure is addressed. Agencies now use AI tools on much of the work they deliver, and the guide to setting AI rules for agencies and contractors covers what to agree on permitted uses, the business's data in their tools, declarations at approval and what comes back at exit.

Service levels and ways of working

Service levels make expectations explicit. Typical ones cover response times for routine requests and urgent issues, turnaround times for common deliverables, reporting frequency and content, account team availability and notice of staff changes. They should be realistic for both sides and reviewed when the scope changes. Service levels for the client are just as useful: how quickly feedback and approvals will be given, and how much notice the agency will get of new work.

Ways of working cover the rest. Agree who the day-to-day contacts are on each side and who can approve work and spend. Set a meeting rhythm, usually a short weekly or fortnightly working session and a monthly performance review. Decide which tools are shared, such as a project board, shared drives and dashboards, and give the agency the access it needs to the business's results. An agency that cannot see sales data cannot optimise for sales. The agency onboarding checklist turns these first agreements into a list to tick before a new agency touches a live account.

Treat the agency team as an extension of yours. Invite them to relevant planning sessions, share the quarter's objectives and tell them about changes in the business early. The more context the agency has, the less its work depends on the literal wording of each brief.

Briefing well

The brief is where most agency work succeeds or fails. A good brief states the business problem, the objective and how it will be measured, the audience, what the audience should think, feel or do, the key message and the evidence for it, mandatory elements, budget, timing and approval process. It is short, specific and agreed internally before it reaches the agency. The campaign brief guide covers the contents in detail, and the creative brief template gives a usable format. A PR agency's brief differs in two ways: its objective is an audience change rather than an output, and it lists the stories the organisation can supply, as the guide to working with a PR agency sets out.

Three habits make briefs better. First, brief in person or by call, not only by email, and invite questions; the conversation surfaces misunderstandings the document hides. Second, separate the problem from the solution. Brief the objective and let the agency propose the answer, rather than briefing a solution and asking them to execute it. Third, invite a response: ask the agency to play the brief back in its own words before work starts, and challenge it if its reading differs from yours.

Feedback on the work is the other half of briefing. Give it in one consolidated round, from someone with authority to decide, against the brief rather than personal taste. When the work is a media agency's proposed plan, the tutorial on reviewing a media plan before sign-off turns that round into written questions about the plan's reach claim, cost assumptions and measures. Contradictory feedback from several stakeholders is one of the main causes of late, expensive work. For a new logo and visual system, where the brief also has to fix the cues to keep, the touchpoints and the files to be handed over, the tutorial on briefing a brand identity project applies these habits from the brief to the handover.

Review cadence and scorecards

Reviews keep the relationship honest. Operational reviews, weekly or fortnightly, cover work in progress and blockers. Performance reviews, monthly, cover results against each agreed KPI and the plan. A fuller scorecard review, quarterly or half-yearly, covers the relationship as a whole, and once a year the scope, fee model and terms should be revisited. The tutorial on reviewing an agency before renewal turns that yearly look into a decision timed ahead of the notice date in the agreement.

A scorecard works best when both sides complete it. The client scores the agency on a few areas, such as quality of thinking, quality of execution, results against objectives, proactivity, responsiveness and value for money. The agency scores the client on briefing quality, feedback, timeliness of approvals and access to information. The comparison is often revealing: many agency problems turn out to be client problems.

Results should be judged against measures both sides trust. Platform-reported figures are a starting point, not a verdict. Where possible, judge performance on the business's own data and on contribution to commercial outcomes such as ROI, using the same measurement framework for every partner so results are comparable.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Larderstile Foods introduces a two-way scorecard

Larderstile Foods, an invented chilled-food manufacturer, worked with 3 agencies and reviewed them only when renewing contracts. The marketing manager introduced a quarterly scorecard with 6 criteria scored from 1 to 5 by both sides. In the first round, the creative agency scored Larderstile 2 out of 5 for feedback, citing contradictory comments from 4 stakeholders. Larderstile appointed a single approver per brief. By the third quarter the creative agency's average score had risen from 3.1 to 4.0, the number of revision rounds per project had halved, and the media agency had been given a clear improvement plan rather than a surprise exit.

Transitions and exits

Every agency relationship ends eventually, and the business should be ready for it from the start. That means accounts, data, assets and documentation held in the business's name, contracts with clear notice periods and handover obligations, and a working knowledge in-house of what the agency does.

Before deciding to exit, check whether the problem can be fixed. Many failing relationships improve with a better scope, a better brief or a change of account team. Raise problems early, document them in reviews, and give the agency a clear chance to improve. An exit that follows several documented reviews is fair to the agency and defensible inside the business. The tutorial on turning round an underperforming agency relationship runs that chance to improve as a written plan, with changes on both sides, measures and review points.

When the decision is made, plan the transition before giving notice. List everything that needs to move: accounts, assets, data, live campaigns, scheduled work, supplier relationships and the knowledge of how things are set up. Agree a timetable, keep the outgoing agency paid and engaged through the notice period, and overlap with the incoming agency where possible. The agency offboarding checklist lists what to collect, hand over and remove between notice and the last day of access. Where the agency built or ran the analytics property, the GA4 property handover checklist covers the access, documentation, links and exports that must move with it. Explain the reasons honestly and professionally; agencies talk, and the way an exit is handled affects the business's reputation with the next partner. The agencies and partners hub lists the common symptoms that suggest a relationship needs attention before it reaches this point.

When the agency's report shows growth that the sales ledger does not, the diagnosis of agency reports that look good while sales are flat separates measurement gaps from performance gaps. When results fall soon after a switch, the page on results that dropped after changing agency checks what the handover lost. When the outgoing agency still holds the accounts themselves, the diagnosis for an agency that won't hand over the ad accounts works out why it can, account by account, and in what order to take them back.

Common mistakes

  • Pitching too many agencies. A long pitch list wastes everyone's time and puts off the best agencies. Shortlist hard.
  • Meeting only the leaders. The people who win the account are rarely the people who run it. Meet the team.
  • A vague scope. If neither side can tell whether a request is included, every change becomes a dispute.
  • Briefing the solution. Telling an agency what to make wastes its thinking. Brief the problem and the objective.
  • Feedback by committee. Contradictory comments from several stakeholders produce late, expensive work. Name one approver.
  • Reviewing only at renewal. Problems found once a year are big problems. Review on a cadence, both ways.
  • Leaving the agency owning the accounts. An exit without access to your own data and accounts is a crisis. Own them from the start.

Frequently asked questions

Should we run a full creative pitch to choose an agency?

Only when the scale of the account justifies the cost to both sides. Full speculative pitches consume a lot of agency time and often reward presentation skill over working fit. For most appointments, a shortlist, chemistry meetings and a paid or limited task that shows how the agency thinks give a better basis for the decision.

How often should we formally review an agency?

Hold a short working review weekly or fortnightly, a performance review monthly against agreed measures, and a fuller scorecard review each quarter or half-year that both sides complete. Include a once-a-year conversation about the relationship itself, the scope and the fee model. Regular reviews make problems small and make an eventual exit less of a surprise.

How do we end an agency relationship without disrupting the work?

Follow the contract's notice terms, agree a transition plan with dates and responsibilities, and make sure accounts, data, assets and documentation are in the business's name before notice is given. Keep the outgoing agency engaged and paid through the handover, and overlap with the incoming partner where you can. Explain the decision honestly; a respectful exit protects your reputation with the next agency.

Terms used on this page

Where this page is used

Part of these learning paths

Also related

Sources

  1. Institute of Practitioners in Advertising — IPA

Related