Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Affiliate Marketing › Programme Management

Working With an Affiliate Management Agency

When to hand an affiliate programme to a management agency: what agencies do, what the brand must keep, fee models and incentives, briefing, review and exit.
Guideintermediate10 min readUpdated

What an affiliate management agency does

An affiliate management agency runs the work of a programme on the brand's behalf, on whatever network or platform the programme uses. As general practice, the work it takes on falls into a handful of areas:

  • Recruitment. Finding partners who fit the programme's profile, approaching them and approving applicants.
  • Partner communication. Onboarding, offers and creative, regular contact, and account management of the partners who matter most.
  • Validation. Reviewing pending conversions against the order data the brand provides, and recommending approvals and rejections.
  • Compliance checks. Monitoring partners for brand bidding, coupon misuse, disclosure and fraud signals.
  • Reporting. Monthly and quarterly reports on partners, sales and costs.
  • Strategy and commission advice. Recommending structure, tiers and promotions.

An agency is not a network. The comparison of affiliate networks and in-house programmes explains that a network is a marketplace that supplies partners, tracking and payment and handles much of the administration; an agency is a service provider that runs the programme, on a network or on the brand's own platform. The roles overlap at the edges, so write down which does what. Influencer agencies are a different case, covered in the guide to working with creator agents and agencies.

When an agency makes sense

The guide to in-house teams and agencies sets out the general trade-off: in-house wins on business knowledge, control and continuity; agencies win on specialist depth, scale and outside perspective; most businesses end up with a hybrid. For affiliates, an agency tends to make sense when:

  • the programme is large enough to need more management time than the team has, but not large enough to justify a dedicated hire;
  • the brand is launching a programme and wants experience it does not have in house;
  • the programme has drifted and needs a period of focused recruitment, clean-up and structure;
  • the brand needs coverage across many partner types that one person cannot know well.

It tends not to make sense when the programme rests on a few deep partner relationships the brand should hold itself, such as integration partners or a handful of major publishers; when the brand cannot give the agency timely order data for validation; or when nobody in house has time to brief and review the agency, because then nobody is managing the programme at all.

What the brand must keep

The guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies says the business should own its accounts, data and the work it pays for, and that accounts, data, assets and documentation should be in the business's name from the start. For an affiliate programme, that means:

WhatWhy the brand keeps itWhat goes wrong otherwise
The network or platform accountIt holds the partners, links, tracking and payment historyA change of agency means a new account and every partner relinking
The programme termsThe brand is the party partners contract withTerms drift towards what suits the agency
Rate, approval and removal decisionsThey spend the brand's money and carry its reputationRates rise to buy volume; removals depend on the agency's appetite
The dataClicks, conversions, partners and payments are the programme's memoryHistory stays with the agency when it leaves
Partner relationshipsKey partners should know a person at the brandPartners follow the agency, not the programme
Disclosure and compliance oversightRegulators expect the advertiser to monitor partnersThe brand learns of breaches from a complaint

Account ownership in practice means the brand is the account holder and the agency is a user with the access its work needs, nothing more. The tutorial on reviewing access to marketing tools covers keeping that access current, including removing it when the agency leaves. The agency onboarding checklist asks for access granted through the business's own accounts before an agency changes anything.

The agency can recommend; the brand decides. Agree in writing which decisions the agency can take alone, such as approving applicants who match the written profile, and which need the brand's sign-off, such as any change to a commission rate or a partner's removal. A RACI matrix is a quick way to write that down.

Fee models and the incentives they create

The selection guide covers fee models for any agency: retainers, project fees, time and materials, commission on spend and performance elements. The affiliate-specific point is what each model rewards, because the agency's incentives become the programme's.

Fee modelThe agency earns more whenRisk to the programmePair it with
Fixed retainerThe scope is deliveredLittle pressure to grow or to clean upA clear scope and a scorecard
Share of tracked revenue or commissionTracked sales or commission riseVolume from partners who capture existing demand; higher rates to buy salesMeasures on validated, new-customer and incremental results
Fee per partner recruitedMore partners joinA long list of inactive partnersA measure of active, quality partners
Retainer plus outcome bonusThe outcomes in the bonus improveGaming the bonus measureA bonus on a measure the brand calculates

A fee tied to tracked revenue is the most common source of trouble, because it pays the agency the same for a sale from a voucher partner at checkout as for a new customer found by a content partner, and it pays more when the programme's costs rise. That does not make it wrong, but it means the brand must measure the agency on something else. A retainer with a bonus tied to validated sales to new customers, calculated from the brand's own data, aligns the agency with what most programmes value. The levels of any fee are a commercial matter for the business; this guide gives none.

Briefing and the scorecard

Brief an affiliate agency as the selection guide describes briefing any agency, with the programme-specific facts it needs: the business objective the programme serves, the customers it should bring, the partner types the brand wants and does not want, the commission structure and the margin behind it, the terms, current problems, and the measures the agency will be judged on. If the brand is choosing between agencies, the agency RFP template fixes what every agency must answer and how answers are scored. If the programme has drifted, an audit of the affiliate programme before the brief gives every agency the same starting facts.

The scorecard should measure what the brand values, from the brand's data. As general practice, a useful affiliate scorecard covers validated sales and their cost including fees; the share of sales from new customers; active partners and the share of sales they produce; compliance issues found and how quickly they were resolved; and the quality of reporting and communication. Add an Incrementality measure where the programme has run a test. Each KPI should be one the agency can influence and the brand can check.

Checking the agency's numbers

An agency's report is usually built from the platform's figures, which credit conversions by the platform's own rules and cannot see other channels. The reporting and incrementality guide explains why tracked sales overstate what a programme adds, and which quality signals and tests show the difference. The brand should check the agency's report against three figures it calculates itself:

  • Deduplicated sales, from the order system and the brand's own attribution view, so affiliate credit is not double counted with other channels.
  • Validated sales, after returns, cancellations and rejections, so the report shows what the brand actually paid for.
  • Incremental results, where a coupon, brand-term or partner-type test has been run, so the report shows what the programme added.

Where the agency's figures and the brand's differ, ask why, in writing, before the next review. Differences are not proof of anything, but an agency that cannot explain them is not managing the numbers it is paid to manage.

Changing agency or bringing the programme in house

The tutorial on reviewing an agency before renewal turns renewal into a decision, from collecting the scope and fee history to reading results against the business's own measures. If the decision is to change, the selection guide's section on transitions applies, and for affiliates the brand's position depends almost entirely on what it kept.

If the account, the terms, the data and the partner contacts are in the brand's name, a change of agency is a handover: brief the new agency, transfer access, introduce key partners, and remove the old agency's access. If the brand runs more than one agency, the guide to coordinating several agencies covers adding or replacing one. If they are not in the brand's name, the change is closer to moving to a new platform, with partners to relink and history to recover. Either way, tell key partners before the change, so they hear it from the brand, and keep validation and payment running without a gap. The programme management hub sets out the operating rhythm the brand inherits if it brings the work in house, and the recruitment guide's section on programme terms lists the areas the brand's terms should already cover. The tutorial on writing affiliate programme terms covers drafting them so they stay the brand's document whoever runs the programme.

A phone case brand hires and reviews an agency (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Quobbel Cases and its affiliate agency

Quobbel Cases, an invented phone case brand, runs its programme on a network with one marketing manager who spends about a day a week on it. It hires an affiliate agency to run recruitment, partner communications, validation and reporting. Before the agency starts, Quobbel confirms that the network account is in its own name with the agency added as a user, that the terms are its own document, and that rate changes and removals need its sign-off.

The agency's first proposal is a fee of 10% of tracked revenue. Quobbel's analysis shows that voucher partners already produce 55% of tracked revenue but only 20% of its new customers, so a revenue share would reward the agency for growing the part of the programme Quobbel values least. It agrees instead a retainer of £3,000 a month and a quarterly bonus of £20 for each validated sale to a new customer above a baseline of 900 a quarter, calculated from its own order data.

Each month, Quobbel checks the agency's report against its own deduplicated and validated figures. In the third month, the agency reports 2,400 sales; Quobbel's figures show 2,050 after removing orders also credited to its paid search and orders returned within the validation period. The agency traces the gap to a partner whose orders were approved before returns were checked, tightens validation, and the figures match the following month. After two quarters, new-customer sales are 1,140 a quarter, and Quobbel renews the agency on the same structure.

Common mistakes

  • The agency owns the account. If the network or platform account is in the agency's name, the programme leaves when the agency does. Put it in the brand's name from the start.
  • Paying for tracked revenue and measuring tracked revenue. The agency then has every reason to grow the easiest sales. Measure it on deduplicated, validated and new-customer results.
  • Delegating decisions along with the work. Rates, removals and the terms carry the brand's money and reputation. The agency recommends; the brand decides.
  • Reading the agency's report as the truth. Check it against the brand's own figures every month.
  • No one in house. An agency still needs a client. Without someone to brief and review it, the programme is unmanaged.
  • Key partners who only know the agency. Introduce a brand contact to the partners who matter most.
  • Changing agency without telling partners. Partners should hear it from the brand, with payment and validation running without a gap.
  • Access left open after exit. Remove the old agency's users and credentials on the day the handover completes.

Frequently asked questions

Is an affiliate network the same as an affiliate management agency?

No. A network is a marketplace and technology provider: it brings partners, tracking and payments together for a fee, and handles much of the administration, as the networks comparison explains. An agency is a service provider that runs the programme on the brand's behalf, on a network or an in-house platform. A brand can use a network with no agency, an agency on a network, or an agency on its own platform; the roles should be written down separately.

Should we pay an affiliate agency a share of tracked revenue?

Be careful. A fee tied to tracked revenue rewards the agency for volume, whichever partners produce it, including voucher and cashback partners who often capture customers already on their way to buy. If you use it, measure the agency on deduplicated, validated and, where you can test it, incremental results, and consider a retainer with a bonus tied to the outcomes you value, such as validated sales to new customers. The general agency guides cover fee models; the affiliate point is what each one rewards.

What should we own if an agency runs the programme?

The network or platform account, in the brand's name, with the brand as the account holder and the agency as a user. The programme terms, and the decisions on rates, approvals and removals. The data: click, conversion, partner and payment history the brand can export at any time. And the partner relationships, with contact details held by the brand. If any of these sit with the agency, a change of agency becomes a programme rebuild.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Related