Why brand bidding is the commonest affiliate dispute
The partner recruitment, compliance and fraud guide explains the problem. A partner running paid search ads (SEMPaid search advertising (sometimes used to include SEO).) on the brand's own name, or on variations and misspellings, intercepts people who searched for the business. The partner's ad may take the click that the brand's own ad, or its organic listing, would have taken, at a cost that includes commission. The brand search holdout test names affiliates bidding on the brandAn affiliate running paid search ads on the brand's own name, variants or misspellings, taking clicks the brand would have had and earning commission on them. as one of its pitfalls for the same reason: where terms allow it, an affiliate can take the paid position and claim commission on sales the organic listing would have delivered.
The dispute is common because both sides can see a case. The partner sees a click, a tracked sale and commission it was not told it could not earn. The brand sees someone it already reached being charged back to it. Without a written rule, every case becomes a negotiation, and the partner who has built a business on brand-term traffic argues hardest.
Branded search is also where the brand's own costs sit. The comparison of branded and non-branded search lists competitors bidding on the brand's name as the clearest reason to run a branded campaign. A partner bidding in the same auction is another advertiser in it, whatever its relationship with the brand.
Choosing the default: ban, allow-list or conditions
Start by choosing the default the policy applies to every partner.
| Default | What it means | Suits | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ban | No partner may bid on the listed brand terms or use them in ads | Most programmes; brands with their own branded campaign | Exceptions requested informally; enforcement must be real |
| Allow-list | Banned by default; named partners may bid on named terms under written conditions | Brands with a partner that adds something the brand's ad does not | The list growing without review |
| Conditions | Allowed for all partners within rules on terms, ad text, links and markets | Rare; brands without their own search activity | Partners competing with each other and the brand in the same auction |
The recruitment guide's answer to whether affiliates should bid on the brand is usually not, or only under tight conditions, with exceptions where a partner adds something the brand's own ad does not, such as a genuine comparison. The ban with a narrow allow-list follows from that.
The one-way and two-way doors framework helps with the choice. Starting strict and loosening later is a door that swings both ways: a partner given a new permission is pleased. Starting loose and tightening later is harder to walk back, because partners will have built campaigns and income on the permission and will treat its removal as a cut. Where the business is unsure, the stricter default keeps more options open.
Whether any brand-term activity adds sales is a separate question, answered by a test. The reporting and incrementality guide describes restricting brand-term activity for a period and measuring total brand-search traffic and orders: if the brand's own listings recover the same customers, the partner activity was not adding them.
Which terms, ad text and links the rule covers
A rule that says "do not bid on our brand" leaves too much to interpretation. Write the boundary out.
- Terms. The brand name, product and range names that are distinctive to the brand, common misspellings, the name run together or split, and the domain name. List them in an appendix to the terms and keep it current.
- Brand plus modifiers. Searches such as the brand plus "voucher", "discount code", "sale", "review" or "login". Say which are covered. Most programmes cover them all, because a person searching the brand plus "discount code" is already at or near the checkout, often looking for a discount codeA code a customer enters at checkout to receive an offer, also used to identify sales from a creator, partner or channel that links cannot capture. to apply there.
- Match behaviour. Partners who bid on broad terms can still appear on brand searches. Require partners using paid search to exclude the listed terms from their campaigns with negative keywords (Negative KeywordsKeywords that stop an ad from showing for searches containing them.). The negative keywords guide, from Google's page on negative keywords, explains that negatives stop a campaign entering auctions for searches it excludes; the same mechanism keeps a partner's generic campaign off the brand's terms.
- Ad text and display URLs. Say whether the brand name may appear in a partner's ad text or display URL. Most programmes prohibit it unless allow-listed. The site's ad policies guide records that the Google Ads policies centre lists trademarks among its restricted policies, and the competitor keywords guide that the trademark policy limits naming another business in ad text; the programme's own rule is set in the terms either way.
- Direct linking. Say whether a partner's ad may link straight to the brand's site through a tracking link, rather than to the partner's own page. A direct link makes the partner's ad look like the brand's ad.
- Markets. Say which countries and languages the rule applies to. The recruitment guide advises monitoring search results for the brand terms in the markets that matter.
The tutorial on writing affiliate programme terms places this rule in the methods clause and the term list in an appendix, so the rule and the list can be updated separately.
Exceptions and how partners ask for them
Exceptions should be rare, written and reviewed. A partner who wants to bid on a brand term or use the brand in ad text asks in writing, saying which terms, in which markets, with what ad text and landing page, and why its ad adds something the brand's own ad does not. A comparison site that compares the brand's products with others, for example, may offer searchers something the brand's own listing cannot.
Approve or decline in writing, and if approved, set conditions: the exact terms and match behaviour, the ad text, the landing page (the partner's own page, not a direct link), a review date and what happens if the conditions are broken. Record the exception against the partner and tell the brand's own search team. An exception that exists only in someone's email is a breach waiting to be argued about.
Working with the brand's own search team
The affiliate team owns the rule; the brand's paid search team owns the auctions it applies to. The two need one shared boundary.
Agree the term list together, so that the brand terms in the affiliate terms and the brand terms in the account describe the same searches. The recruitment guide suggests the brand's own team can add affiliate-related terms, such as the brand plus "voucher", to their campaigns, and use negative keywords to keep their own targeting tidy, for example excluding brand terms from generic campaigns so brand searches reach the brand campaign. Tell the search team about every exception, so they can tell an allowed partner from a breach when they read the account.
Brand bidding by competitors (Competitor BiddingBidding on searches for a competitor's brand or product names so your ad appears when people look for them, also called conquesting.) is a separate matter that the competitor keywords guide covers. The search team will see both in the same reports, so agree who looks into which.
Monitoring: what to look for and what to keep
Monitoring has two sources: what appears on the search results, and what the account's own reports show.
Search checks. Search the listed terms, with their common modifiers, in each market the rule covers, on a regular rhythm, and record what appears: the advertiser, the ad text, the display URL and where the ad leads. Capture a screenshot of each result with the date, time, market and query, so the record does not depend on anyone's memory.
Auction insights. The auction insights tutorial explains that the report shows which other advertisers appeared in the same auctions as the brand's ads, with their Impression ShareShare of eligible impressions you received., overlap and position-above rates. Read it for brand terms on its own. A new domain in the list, or an affiliate's domain whose overlap rises, is a reason to check the search results for that advertiser.
Programme data. Partners whose conversions arrive within moments of a brand search, or whose sales cluster on customers who were already searching for the brand, are worth a closer look. The attribution and deduplication guide covers how credit between search and affiliates is decided.
Keep a log: date, market, query, advertiser, ad text, landing page, screenshot and the partner it relates to. The log is what turns "we think a partner is bidding on us" into a case the partner can answer.
Handling a breach
Handle a breach as the terms say, through the enforcement ladder. Contact the partner with the evidence: the query, the date, the market, the ad and the screenshot. Ask them to stop and to confirm, and to explain if they believe the activity was not theirs, for example a sub-affiliate's campaign. Withhold commission on the conversions affected, as the terms allow, and only those. Escalate repeat or deliberate breaches up the ladder to suspension and removal.
Treat a breach that looks like something more than a misunderstanding, such as hidden redirects or a domain built to look like the brand's, as a possible fraud case and run it through the tutorial on investigating suspected affiliate fraud. Questions about trademark rights, complaints to search engines or the law in any market go to the business's legal adviser; this guide does not cover them. Brand misuse in partners' published content, rather than in search ads, is part of the routine in the tutorial on checking affiliate content.
A furniture retailer tightens its rules (illustrative)
Hobvane Furniture finds partner ads on its brand name
Hobvane Furniture, an invented online furniture retailer, has a one-line rule: "Partners must not bid on Hobvane." Its search team notices partner ads on "hobvane discount code" and "hobvane sofa sale". Two partners point out that the rule does not mention modifiers or misspellings.
Hobvane rewrites the rule. The term list covers "hobvane", "hob vane", "hobvain", the domain, its three range names and every combination with "voucher", "discount", "code", "sale" and "review". Partners using paid search must add the list as negative keywords. The brand may not appear in partner ad text or display URLs, and partner ads may not link directly to hobvane pages. One comparison partner asks to bid on "hobvane sofa beds" for a comparison of sofa beds across eight retailers; Hobvane approves it in writing, on exact match, with its own ad text and landing page, for six months.
The search team adds the brand plus "voucher" terms to its brand campaign. Each month the affiliate manager runs 24 searches across the term list in its two markets, logs what appears, and reads auction insights for the brand campaign. In the second month a cashback partner's domain appears in the brand auctions with an overlap rate of 18%; the search checks find its ads on "hobvane discount code". Hobvane sends the partner the screenshots and log entries, withholds commission on 212 orders tracked through those ads under the enforcement ladder, and issues a written warning. The ads stop within two days, and the partner disappears from the brand auctions the next month.
Common mistakes
- A rule with no term list. "Do not bid on our brand" leaves misspellings, modifiers and range names open to argument; list them.
- Ignoring modifiers. The brand plus "discount code" is where most of the money is, because those searchers are ready to buy.
- Exceptions agreed by email. An exception not recorded against the partner and shared with the search team will be misread as a breach, or a breach misread as an exception.
- Two teams, two lists. The affiliate terms and the search account should describe the same brand terms.
- Accusing without evidence. A screenshot with the date, market and query gives the partner something to answer.
- Withholding everything. Withhold commission on the conversions the breach produced, as the terms allow, not the partner's whole balance.
- Treating the rule as legal protection. The terms govern the programme; trademark questions belong to legal advisers.
- Never testing the assumption. Whether brand-term activity adds sales is measurable; the reporting guide and the holdout test show how.
