When to run this checklist
Run it in the first weeks after a new agency is appointed and before it changes any live account or campaign. The natural owner is whoever on the business side manages the relationship, usually a marketing manager, with the analyst or whoever looks after tracking for the measurement group. The agency should see the list, because half the items need its input, but the business ticks it: these are the client's safeguards, not the agency's onboarding pack.
Run it again, in full, when the agency's scope grows to a new channel or market, and whenever the business replaces the agency's lead contact. A new channel brings new accounts to grant access to and a new baseline to record; a new lead contact is a fresh set of assumptions about what was agreed. If the agency is taking over from another agency, run the agency offboarding checklist for the outgoing one first, so the accounts, history and tracking documentation are in hand before the new team arrives. The same list works for a freelance specialist, and the guide to starting out as a freelance digital marketer shows it from the other side, as part of scoping work on accounts the client owns.
This list covers a relationship with people. Adding a piece of marketing software to the stack is a different job with its own access, privacy and integration steps, covered by the marketing tool onboarding SOP. When the new agency, freelancer or consultant is appointed to set up and run the tools themselves, the guide to hiring and evaluating a marketing technology partner covers which accounts, credentials and copies the business keeps, how to scope that work and how to accept it.
Before you start
- The signed contract or statement of workA supplier's written confirmation of what it will deliver, by when, at what price and how it will invoice, against which the order is raised., so scope, fees and service levels are to hand.
- A list of every account the agency will need: ad platforms, analytics, tag manager, social pages, CRM views and any reporting tools, with who currently administers each.
- The current brief or plan, written down; the campaign brief template is a starting point if none exists.
- The last few months of reporting, in the form the business already trusts.
- The naming convention and tracking plan, if the business has them, or a note that they need writing.
- An hour with the analyst who knows where the numbers come from and why they differ.
The checklist
Work through the groups in order. Access comes first because nothing else can be checked until the agency can see the accounts; measurement comes before ways of working because the reporting cadence depends on the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. definitions. The last item, the date of the first review, is what turns the rest from good intentions into commitments.
Access
Brief and history
Measurement
Ways of working
Where each check is explained
The widget above keeps the lines short so they can be ticked; the reasoning lives in the guides. Each check links to the page that explains it. For a media agency, the access and approval checks rest on terms agreed before onboarding, and the guide to setting up a media agency agreement covers account ownership, approval of buys and audit access. Sharing the business's AI use policy belongs in the same first weeks, and the guide to setting AI rules for agencies and contractors explains what to agree with the agency about AI tools and data.
| Check | Explained in |
|---|---|
| Access through the business's own accounts and roles | Selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies |
| Ownership of ad accounts, analytics and tag containers stays with the business | GA4 setup, step by step |
| Record of which agency staff hold each access level | Tag governance |
| Brief with objectives, budgets and constraints shared | Writing a campaign brief |
| Brand guidelines, approved claims and past creative shared | Brand identity and voice |
| Past tests and their lessons shared | Experimentation programme playbook |
| KPIs and how each is measured agreed | Setting objectives and KPIs |
| Baseline recorded before changes begin | Results dropped after changing agency |
| Which numbers count when sources disagree | Why platforms and analytics disagree |
| Naming and tracking conventions agreed | UTM and naming conventions |
| Approval route for budgets, creative and changes | Marketing approvals and compliance reviews |
| Reporting cadence and report contents | Marketing reporting cadence playbook |
| Account changes logged | Agency reports look good but sales are flat |
| Date of the first performance review | Selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies |
If an item fails
The rule is simple: until the access and measurement groups pass, the agency observes and proposes but does not change live campaigns. That can feel slow when a new agency is keen to show early wins, but a change made before the baseline is recorded is a change whose effect nobody can ever measure, and a change made in an account the agency owns is a change the business may lose when the relationship ends.
Access failures are the most urgent. If the agency asks to run campaigns from an ad account it creates under its own business manager, the answer is to create the account under the business's own and grant the agency a role in it. If someone has already shared a personal login, replace it with named access and rotate the password. Ownership mistakes compound quietly and surface only at the exit, which is when they are most expensive to fix.
Measurement failures hold the start date. If the KPIs cannot be agreed, the brief is usually the problem, and it goes back to whoever owns the objective. If the platforms, analytics and the CRM tell different stories, agree a reconciliation rule now rather than letting the agency report platform numbers by default; platform-reported ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend. is the number most likely to flatter a new agency's first quarter. Missing UTMURL tags identifying traffic source. conventions can be fixed in parallel, but the agency should not launch tagged links until they exist.
Ways-of-working failures can ship with a note and a date. A reporting template that is not finished, or an approval route that needs one more signature, can be resolved in the first fortnight, as long as the change log starts on the first day and the first review is in the calendar.
A skateboard maker's first month with a paid social agency
A skateboard maker appoints a paid social agency and the agency proposes to restructure the account in its first week. The maker's marketing manager runs the list first. Two items fail: the maker's Meta ad account had been created years earlier by a freelancer and sat in the freelancer's business manager, and nobody had written down where performance stood. The manager moves the ad account into the maker's own business manager, grants the agency an advertiser role, and records a baseline for the previous eight weeks: spend of £6,400 and 410 online orders in the shop's own system, against platform-reported purchases the analyst marks as roughly a third higher. The restructure goes ahead in week three. When the agency's first monthly report shows orders up to 470 at similar spend, both sides read the change against the same baseline and the same definition of an order, and the conversation is about what to test next rather than whose numbers are right.
Common mistakes
- Letting the agency build in its own accounts. It is quicker on day one and costly on the last day, when the account history, audiences and pixel data stay with the agency.
- Skipping the baseline because results are poor anyway. Poor results are exactly the ones a new agency will be judged on improving; without a written starting point, any improvement is a matter of opinion.
- Sharing the brief but not the history. The agency reruns tests the business already ran, relearns what the last agency learnt, and repeats creative the brand team already rejected.
- Accepting the agency's KPIs by default. Platform metrics are easy to report and easy to improve. Agree measures tied to the business's own outcomes, with the method written down.
- Leaving changes unlogged. When results move, nobody can say which edit moved them, and the review turns into storytelling.
- No date for the first review. Without one, the relationship drifts until a problem forces the conversation, which is the worst time to have it.
The comparison of in-house and agency models helps if the question is still whether to use an agency at all, and the checklists library holds the rest of the lists.
