Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Operations › Governance

Marketing Approvals and Compliance Reviews

How approvals and compliance work in marketing: approval matrices by risk, brand review, legal and regulatory checks, consent and claims, and audit trails.
Guideintermediate10 min readUpdated

Approvals by risk, not by habit

Most approval processes grow by accretion. A mistake happens, a senior person asks to see everything of that kind in future, and the request outlives the mistake by years. After a few rounds of this, every piece of work passes through several reviewers regardless of what it contains, the reviewers stop reading closely because most of what they see is routine, and the work that genuinely needs scrutiny gets the same tired glance as everything else.

Approval by risk reverses this. The question for each piece of work is what could go wrong if it went out with an error: a misleading claim, a breach of data rules, an inaccessible page, damage to the brand, spend committed without authority. The reviews follow from the answer. Work that carries none of those risks needs only the launch check. Work that carries one gets the reviewer for that risk. Work that carries several gets several reviewers, in parallel.

This has two benefits beyond speed. Reviewers see less routine work, so they pay more attention to what they do see. And the matrix becomes a document that can be shown, explained and improved, rather than a set of habits that live in people's memories. Where the review happens in the workflow is covered by the campaign workflow guide; this page decides who reviews and against what standard.

The approval matrix

The matrix maps types of risk to the reviewer and the standard. It is maintained by operations, agreed with each reviewing function, and applied at intake so that the reviewers are known before build starts.

Trigger in the workRiskReviewerStandard reviewed against
Any public-facing workBrand inconsistencyBrand or creative leadBrand guidelines and tone of voice
New product claim, comparison, statistic or testimonialMisleading advertisingLegal or complianceAdvertising codes and substantiation file
Price, discount, promotion or prizeMisleading pricing, unfair termsLegal or compliance, plus commercial ownerPromotion rules and terms
Regulated product or sectorSector-specific rulesSpecialist complianceSector rules and internal policy
New data source, new audience or new contact channelUnlawful processing or contactData protection leadConsent records and data protection policy
New page, email template or interactive contentInaccessible contentAccessibility reviewer or trained builderAccessibility standard adopted by the organisation
Spend above the campaign's approved budgetUnauthorised commitmentBudget holderDelegated spending authority
Content produced with AI toolsInaccuracy, unverified claimsEditor, plus any reviewer triggered aboveAI review procedure
Routine work from approved templates and claimsLowNone beyond launch checkLaunch checklist

Keep the matrix to one page. Each row should be triggered by something observable in the work, which the intake form can ask about, rather than by a judgement call. Where a piece of work triggers several rows, reviews run in parallel and one person consolidates the feedback. Review the matrix itself on a regular cadence: rows that never return work may be unnecessary, and incidents that got through point to a missing row. A campaign run jointly with a partner business often triggers several rows at once, and the co-marketing launch checklist adds each partner's approval of what carries its name. The spend row assumes a written delegation exists; the guide to setting spending authority in a marketing team shows how to write one with finance.

Brand review

Brand review checks that the work looks, sounds and behaves like the brand: correct logos and colours, approved typography, tone of voice, imagery that fits the guidelines, and messages consistent with the positioning. It is the review applied most widely and the one most prone to becoming a matter of taste.

Three practices keep it useful. First, review against written guidelines, and when a reviewer objects to something the guidelines allow, update the guidelines or let the work go. Second, review against the signed brief, so that the question is whether the work delivers the agreed message in the brand's voice, not whether the reviewer would have chosen a different idea. Third, push brand quality upstream: templates and an asset library of approved elements prevent most brand errors before review, which lets brand review concentrate on new and high-visibility work. Requests to depart from the guidelines are best settled before the work reaches review, and the guide to handling brand guideline exceptions and changes gives them an owner, a recorded answer and a route to a new version when the same request keeps arriving.

The content governance guide covers the editorial side of this for content programmes, including standards, ownership and lifecycle. For content produced with AI tools, accuracy becomes a separate review with its own procedure, and the AI accuracy and review workflows guide sets it out. The rules those reviews enforce belong in a short policy, and the tutorial on writing a marketing AI use policy drafts one clause by clause.

Advertising rules in most markets share a core principle: marketing must not mislead, and claims must be capable of substantiation before they are made. In the UK the Advertising Standards Authority publishes the codes and rulings that apply, and in the US the Federal Trade Commission's business guidance covers advertising, endorsements and related topics. Other markets have their own regulators. This guide does not interpret those rules; it describes the operational arrangements that let a legal or compliance reviewer apply them efficiently.

Keep a substantiation file. Every objective claim, such as a comparison, a statistic, a "best" or "fastest", has its evidence recorded in one place, with the date the evidence was checked. Reviewers then check the claim against the file rather than starting from nothing.

Maintain a claims library. Claims that have been approved, with their exact wording and any conditions, can be reused without fresh review. Changes to wording are new claims. The tutorial on building a claims library sets up both records together, from collecting the claims already live to retiring those that no longer hold. When the copy is in a language the approver cannot read, the tutorial on reviewing localised copy in a language you do not speak checks the meaning of each claim through a back-translation before it reaches the market's compliance owner.

Flag at intake. The intake form asks whether the work contains a new claim, a price or promotion, a testimonial or endorsement, or a regulated product. A yes routes it to legal review before build, so that copy is approved before it is designed around. Healthcare is a common example, and the healthcare provider marketing guide sets out why treatment claims and patient testimonials should always take this route.

Treat endorsements and influencer content explicitly. Disclosure of paid relationships is a recurring issue for regulators, so any work involving creators or testimonials should carry the disclosure requirement in the brief and be checked for it at review. Generated copy, AI-written reviews and synthetic presenters raise the same questions in new forms, which the guide to AI claims and consumer protection works through.

Data rules decide who may be contacted, through which channels and on what basis. The GDPR sets the framework in the EU and, in retained form, the UK; the UK regulator's direct marketing guidance explains how it applies to marketing alongside the electronic marketing rules. Operationally, the review question is narrow: does this work use personal data or contact people in a way the organisation's consent records and policies support? New data sources, bought or shared lists, new channels and new uses of existing data are the triggers. The implementation of consent in tracking and tags, including how the consent banner interacts with the tag container (GTM), belongs to the analytics root, and the privacy and consent guide covers it.

Accessibility is the check most often missing from marketing approvals. The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines are the widely used standard for web content, and they apply to landing pages, emails and interactive content as much as to the main website. The practical approach is to build accessibility into templates, such as colour contrast, heading structure, alternative text fields and link text, and to train builders to check new work against a short list, with a specialist review only for new templates and complex interactive work. For the conversion side of the same checks, the guide to accessibility as conversion work explains where barriers sit between the first screen and payment and how to find them before customers do.

Tracking parameters are not a compliance matter in themselves, but personal data should never be placed in a UTM parameter or any other part of a URL, and the launch check is the place to confirm it.

Audit trails and periodic audits

An approval that cannot be shown later is only slightly better than none. The audit trail is the record, attached to the work item, of what was reviewed, which version, who reviewed it, when, what they decided and what evidence they relied on. The work management system is the natural home, because the record then sits next to the work and the final version. Approvals given in email, chat or conversation should be copied onto the item, and the workflow should not let an item reach the launch check without them.

Periodic audits test whether governance is working in practice. Three are worth scheduling. An approval audit samples recent live work and checks that each item had the reviews the matrix required, with records. An access audit lists who has administrative or publishing rights in each platform, including agencies and former staff, and removes what is no longer needed. A claims audit reviews the substantiation file and the claims library for evidence that has aged or claims that are no longer true. The tutorial on reviewing who can access your marketing tools runs the access audit across every tool at once, from each tool's own user list to the triggers for joiners and leavers. The tutorial on auditing marketing approvals runs the approval audit, from drawing the sample to tracing each gap to the matrix, the workflow or the records.

Report the results alongside the team's operational measures: share of work with complete approval records, review turnaround, return rates by gate. These describe the health of governance; they should not become a KPI that rewards reviewers for speed at the expense of scrutiny. When the return rate at the legal gate stays high, the diagnosis for legal rejecting marketing work sorts recent returns by reason and by when the reviewer first saw each piece to find which of these habits is missing.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A supplements brand introduces a claims library

Verdant Labs, a direct-to-consumer supplements brand, sent all marketing to an external legal adviser, with a turnaround of about six working days and costs that the team tracked at £4,200 a month. An audit of a quarter's reviews showed that 70% of items used claims that had already been approved at least once. The team built a claims library with exact wording and conditions, added a claims question to the intake form and routed only new claims, comparisons and promotions to legal. Over the following quarter, legal review volume fell by roughly two-thirds, turnaround for the remaining items fell to three days, and an approval audit of forty live items found complete records on all but one.

Common mistakes

  • Approval by seniority. The most senior person becomes the bottleneck and reviews routine work as closely as risky work.
  • Reviewing finished work. Legal and compliance see claims after creative is built, and the build is redone. Flag claims at intake and approve copy first.
  • Sequential reviews. Each reviewer reopens the last round; review in parallel and consolidate.
  • No substantiation file. Reviewers rebuild the evidence for the same claim every time.
  • Leaving accessibility out of the matrix. It is then checked by nobody, and fixed only after a complaint.
  • Approvals in email and chat. They cannot be found when someone asks who approved a live ad.
  • Never auditing access. Former staff and agencies keep publishing rights for years.
  • Treating this guide as legal advice. It describes operational arrangements; what the rules require in your market is for your advisers. The governance hub and the operating model comparison cover where these reviews sit in a larger organisation.

Frequently asked questions

Does every piece of marketing need legal review?

No. Legal review should be triggered by content that carries legal risk, such as new claims, comparisons, prices, promotions, regulated products or new uses of personal data. Routine work built from pre-approved claims and templates can go out with brand and launch checks only. An approval matrix makes the trigger explicit so that it does not depend on judgement each time.

What counts as an audit trail for a marketing approval?

A record, attached to the work item, of what was reviewed, which version, by whom, when, and what they decided, together with any evidence relied on, such as substantiation for a claim. An approval given in a chat message or a hallway conversation is not an audit trail, because it cannot be found or linked to the version that went live.

How do we stop reviews slowing every launch?

Route only risky work to specialist reviewers, review in parallel rather than in sequence, agree turnaround times with reviewers, and build a library of pre-approved claims and templates. Then measure turnaround and return rates at each gate, and remove reviews that never change anything.

Terms used on this page

Where this page is used

Part of these learning paths

Also related

Sources

  1. Advertising Standards Authority — ASA
  2. Direct marketing guidance — Information Commissioner's Office (UK)
  3. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR) — EUR-Lex
  4. FTC business guidance — Federal Trade Commission
  5. Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) — W3C

Related