Definition
To substantiate a claim is to hold evidence that supports it, as the audience would understand it, at the time it is made. Substantiation is that evidence and the habit of collecting it first. It applies to objective claims: statements that could be shown true or false, such as a comparison with a competitor, a statistic, a test result, a feature, a guarantee, a speed or a "best". Statements of the brand's view or style, such as a tone-of-voice phrase, usually make no checkable promise; where a line could be read as a measurable promise, it is treated as a claim.
The scope of the evidence has to match the scope of the words. A test on one product does not support a claim about a range, and a result for one group of customers does not support a claim about all of them. Comparative claims are treated with particular care, because they say something about another business as well as one's own.
In the UK the Advertising Standards Authority publishes the advertising codes and rulings that apply, and other markets have their own regulators and codes. The site does not interpret those rules.
What a substantiation file records
A substantiation file keeps the evidence for each objective claim in one place, so a reviewer checks a claim against an entry instead of rebuilding the proof each time. The tutorial on building a claims library sets up the file and the library together. For each claim, an entry records:
- The exact wording and any conditions attached to it, because a change of wording is a new claim.
- The evidence relied on, such as test reports, data extracts, certifications or customer research, linked from the entry.
- The date the evidence was last checked, and who owns checking it again.
- Where the claim may be used, including the markets it has been cleared for.
A claim with no evidence is marked unsupported and kept out of new work until the evidence exists or the claim is narrowed to what the evidence shows.
In practice: claims library, approval and translation
The approvals and compliance guide routes new product claims, comparisons, statistics and testimonials to legal or compliance, keeps the substantiation file as the record they check against, and schedules a claims audit for evidence that has aged. The guide to writing a brand tagline applies the same rule to a line that may run for years: if the tagline states a checkable fact, the evidence goes on file before the line is used, and someone checks it stays true.
Channels and markets add their own checks. The guide to buying print and press advertising checks copy as an advertisement before it goes to the publisher, including whether its claims are true and can be backed up. And when a campaign travels, the tutorial on rolling out a campaign across markets treats each comparative, environmental, health or price claim as something to check in each market rather than translate, because evidence accepted at home may not be enough elsewhere.
A tutoring firm narrows a claim to fit its evidence
Mirrumb Tutoring drafted a poster reading "Most of our pupils go up a grade". Before approval, its marketing lead pulled the records behind the line. Of 412 pupils enrolled the previous year, 236 had stayed a full term, and 158 of those had improved by at least one grade at their next school assessment, which is 67%. The 176 who left early had no follow-up result at all, so the records could not support a claim about every pupil. The firm rewrote the line as "Two in three pupils who stayed a full term went up a grade at their next assessment", filed the extract, the method and the review date in its substantiation file, and had the reviewer approve the new wording before the poster ran.
Related terms
Social ProofEvidence that other people have chosen, used or approved something, used to reduce a buyer's doubt. such as reviews, ratings and customer counts makes a claim about other customers, so it needs substantiation like any statistic. An Editorial Style GuideThe house rules a writer checks while drafting, so spelling, names, numbers, formatting, links and sources are handled the same way by everyone. sets out how a house handles sources and corrections, which overlaps with how claims are worded and checked. ScarcityA persuasion device that tells buyers stock, places or time are limited, prompting a decision; it must be true to be fair to customers. claims about stock, places or deadlines are statements of fact too, and are true or not at the moment they are shown.
Common confusions
- Substantiation can be found if someone complains. The principle the site's guides record is that claims must be capable of substantiation before they are made, so the evidence comes first.
- Any evidence will do. The evidence has to support the claim as the audience would read it; a narrower result supports only a narrower claim.
- The claims library and the substantiation file are the same record. They are two halves of one record: the file holds the evidence, the library holds the approved wording and where it may be used. Many teams keep them together.
- A claim cleared once is cleared for ever. Evidence ages, products and competitors change, and a claim that was true at launch can stop being true.
- A claim cleared in one market travels. Advertising rules differ between markets, so a translated claim is checked again.
- This page says what evidence is adequate. It does not. That judgement belongs to a legal or compliance reviewer, and nothing here is legal advice.
