Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Media Planning & Buying › Media Buying

Buying Print and Press Advertising

How to buy space in newspapers, magazines and trade titles: choosing titles by readers, sizes and positions, copy deadlines, labelling and checking results.
Guideintermediate11 min readUpdated

What print does in a plan

Print is a medium of chosen attention. A reader picks up a title on purpose, reads it at their own pace and often keeps it, so an advertisement in it sits in a setting the reader trusts and can be read, reread and torn out. That gives print three jobs in a plan. It reaches defined groups that a title has gathered, such as the households of a town, the members of a profession or the enthusiasts of a hobby. It carries more information than a glance medium can: an offer, a range, an argument, a coupon. And it lends the advertiser something of the title's standing with its readers, which matters most for considered purchases.

Its limits are the other side of the same coin. A title reaches only its own readers, so national reach needs many titles and builds slowly. Readership of many printed titles is concentrated in some audiences more than others, so a plan should check rather than assume who reads. Copy has to be supplied well ahead of publication, so print is slow to change. And the evidence of exposure is a circulation figure or a survey estimate rather than a count of views.

Print belongs in the plan when one or more titles reach a useful share of the target audience at a competitive cost per thousand, or when the advertisement needs the space and attention only print gives. The media objectives and reach goals guide sets the Reach and Frequency the line must deliver, and the media planning framework places the line among the others. A title chosen because the business has always advertised there, or because a sales representative called, has not yet earned its place.

Choosing titles by readers

Start from the audience, not from the list of titles. The same group of people may read a local weekly, a regional daily, a national paper's weekend edition, a consumer magazine and a trade journal, and the question is which of these reaches the most of them, most efficiently, in the right frame of mind.

Type of titleWho it reachesTypical job in a planWhat to check
National newspaperA broad readership across the country, varying by titleBroad reach, news of a launch or offerReadership profile against the target; edition and section
Regional or local paperHouseholds in a defined areaLocal presence near where the business tradesDistribution area against the business's catchment
Consumer magazineReaders of an interest or lifestyleReaching an interest group with time to readReader profile; how long issues are kept
Trade or professional titlePeople in an industry, role or professionReaching business buyers and specifiersWho receives it and whether it is requested or unsolicited
Digital replica editionReaders of the printed title on screenExtending a print bookingWhether the quote includes it and how its readers are counted

Three characteristics separate titles that look similar on paper.

Readers. Ask for the reader profile behind the title and compare it with the target audience: how many of the title's readers are in the audience, and what share of the audience the title reaches. A small specialist title can deliver more of the target than a large general one.

Publishing frequency. Daily, weekly, monthly and less frequent titles behave differently. A daily paper offers many insertion dates and a short life for each issue; a monthly magazine fewer dates and a longer life. Frequency also decides how quickly a series builds repetition.

Shelf life and pass-on. Some titles are read once and recycled; others are kept, shared in an office or a waiting room, and returned to. A longer life gives each insertion more chances to be seen, though the evidence for it is the readership estimate rather than the circulation.

Where the business is weighing a placement in a newsletter rather than a printed title, the newsletter sponsorships guide covers that route, and where the aim is editorial coverage rather than paid space, the media relations and pitching guide owns the work. The two should be kept apart: buying space does not buy coverage, and a request to link the two puts both at risk.

Space, size, position and series

A print booking is defined by four choices, each of which changes the cost and the effect.

Size. Titles sell full pages, fractions of a page and smaller units, each with its own price and its own specification. Larger space is more likely to be noticed and can carry more, but the right size is the smallest that does the creative job: a simple brand message may need less space than an offer with several products. Take the available sizes from the publisher's rate card and specification sheet rather than assuming them.

Position. Where the advertisement sits matters as much as its size. Right-hand pages, early pages, the covers, pages facing relevant editorial and particular sections are usually sold at a premium or on request. Positions that are requested but not guaranteed may not be honoured, so the order should say whether a position is guaranteed and what happens if it is not delivered.

Colour and format. Colour, mono, inserts loose in the copy and special formats each carry their own price and specification, and inserts can carry more than a page can.

Series. Booking a run of insertions across several issues builds frequency among regular readers and usually earns a better rate than single insertions. A series also commits the budget, so match its length to how certain the plan is, and agree whether creative can change between insertions.

The buying models and pricing guide describes the convention: print is sold by page or fraction of a page per insertion, with rate cards that vary by position and frequency. Treat the rate card as a starting point; the negotiation and insertion orders guide covers how rate, position, series and added value are traded.

What a quote rests on: circulation and readership

Every print quote has an audience figure behind it, and the figure is either a circulation or a readership estimate. Circulation counts copies distributed, sold or free, usually under an independent audit. Readership estimates how many people read an average issue, usually from a survey, and is normally larger than circulation because copies are shared. As the media auditing and verification guide notes, print audiences rest on audited circulation and readership surveys, and readership estimates lag and rely on survey answers. In the United States the Media Rating Council accredits measurement services against published standards, and other markets have their own bodies overseeing print measurement.

The buyer's questions follow from that:

  • Is the figure circulation or readership, and from which source?
  • Is the source independently audited or accredited, or is it the publisher's own claim?
  • Does it cover the printed edition, the digital replica or both, and how are replica readers counted?
  • Is it all readers or the target audience, and if the target, how was that estimated?
  • How recent is it?

To compare a print line with others, convert the quote to cost per thousand target readers, including colour, position premiums and production, using the cost per thousand calculator. Treat each target reader of an issue as one opportunity to see, the print equivalent of an Impression, and the CPM sits on the same scale as the other lines in the plan. A title that quotes only a circulation figure for a mass audience may look cheap per copy and expensive per target reader.

Copy deadlines, specifications and proofs

Print is unforgiving about timing. Each title sets a booking deadline for the space and a later copy deadline for the finished advertisement, and both are earlier than the publication date by an amount that varies by title and format. Ask what happens if the copy deadline is missed; under many orders the space is still charged, with either nothing or a previous advertisement in its place. Write both deadlines into the order, along with the specification: the size, bleed and safe area, colour requirements, file format and the delivery route. The insertion order sign-off checklist asks for creative deadlines and specifications on the order before anyone signs it.

Before the copy goes, check it as an advertisement and as a file. As an advertisement: the claims are true and can be backed up, the offer and its terms are clear, the response mechanism works and the brand is unmistakable. In the UK, the advertising codes the Advertising Standards Authority administers require claims to be substantiated and not misleading, and require marketing to be obviously identifiable as such, so an advertisement designed to look like the surrounding editorial needs a clear label. Paid articles and advertorials are a different product, and the guide to sponsored articles covers how they are bought and labelled. As a file: the size, resolution, colour and bleed match the title's specification, and the right version is going to the right title for the right issue.

Ask for confirmation that the copy was received and passes the publisher's checks, and where the title offers a proof, check it. After publication, ask for a tear sheet or a digital copy of the published page showing the advertisement in place, and check it against the order: right issue, right size, right position, right version, printed cleanly. Errors in reproduction or position are raised under the order's terms before the invoice is approved.

Response mechanisms and reading the result

Print rarely produces a click, so the evidence has to be designed into the advertisement. The guide to measuring offline media sets out the options, and for print the most useful are these:

  • A code printed only in the press advertisements, used at booking, at the till or online, which counts the people who remembered it.
  • A short dedicated web address or a QR code that redirects to the landing page with campaign parameters attached, so the visits that use it arrive tagged.
  • A dedicated telephone number for the press advertisements, or one per title where several run.
  • Asking customers where they heard of the business.
  • Comparing areas where a regional or local title covers some of the business's catchment and not the rest.

Each mechanism counts only the people who used it, so it is a floor rather than the whole effect: some readers will search for the brand or walk in without the code. A rise in branded search or direct visits in the weeks after publication adds to the picture. Where several titles run, give each its own code or address so the titles can be compared with one another, and read the result per title as cost per response alongside the cost per thousand target readers, because a title that reaches many target readers but produces few responses may be doing awareness work that the codes do not capture. For broad Brand Awareness objectives, the codes are a supporting signal, and the post-campaign analysis should say so.

An opticians group books local and specialist titles (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Vexilunt Opticians books a press series

Vexilunt Opticians, an invented group of independent opticians with practices in Region A and Region B, books its first press series to promote eye examinations for people over 50 in the autumn.

The buyer asks three titles for quotes against the target audience: two local weekly papers covering the practices' catchments and one specialist magazine for retired readers distributed across both regions. The first weekly quotes £3,600 for six half-page colour insertions, with an audited circulation and an estimated 48,000 target readers per issue, giving £12.50 per thousand target readers across the series. The second weekly quotes £2,700 for six quarter pages with an estimated 22,000 target readers per issue, or £20.45 per thousand. The magazine quotes £4,200 for three full pages with an estimated 70,000 target readers per issue, or £20.00 per thousand, and its readership figure comes from a survey rather than an audit. The buyer books all three, negotiates a right-hand page position in the first weekly, and writes every copy deadline into the orders.

The studio supplies each title's advertisement to its own specification three days before each deadline, each with a different appointment code. The tear sheets show one insertion in the second weekly on a left-hand page next to an unrelated advertisement block; the title agrees a free seventh insertion. Over the series, 186 appointments are booked with the codes: 92 from the first weekly, 31 from the second and 63 from the magazine, which works out at £39, £87 and £67 per appointment. The group keeps the first weekly and the magazine for spring and asks the second weekly for a larger size or a better position before booking again.

The CPM calculator guide for offline media works through a regional paper that is cheap per copy but dear once its full cost is divided by target readers.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing titles by habit. A title the business has always used still needs to show how many of the target audience it reaches, and at what cost.
  • Comparing circulation with readership. The two measure different things; put every quote on the same basis before comparing.
  • Booking position on request and assuming it. A position that is not guaranteed in the order may not be delivered.
  • Missing the copy deadline. The space may be charged whether or not the copy arrived; check the order.
  • Making display advertisements look like editorial without a label. Advertising must be identifiable as such; advertorials belong with the sponsored articles guide.
  • No response mechanism. Without a code, address or number per title, the titles cannot be compared.
  • Not checking tear sheets. A wrong size, position or version found after the invoice is paid is hard to recover.

The media buying hub places print among the other media and buying routes.

Frequently asked questions

Is print advertising still worth buying?

For some jobs, yes. A title read by a defined group, such as a local paper in the area a business serves or a specialist magazine read by the people who buy in its category, can reach that group in a setting where they are paying attention and keep the advertisement in front of them for as long as the copy is kept. Whether it is worth buying for a particular plan depends on how many of the target audience the title reaches and at what cost per thousand, compared on the same basis as every other line.

What is the difference between circulation and readership?

Circulation counts the copies distributed, usually through an audit of sales and free distribution. Readership estimates the number of people who read a copy, usually from a survey, and is normally larger because copies are shared. The two answer different questions, and a quote can be built on either. Ask which one stands behind the figure, whether it covers the printed edition, the digital replica or both, and whether it describes the target audience or all readers.

Should an advertisement in a magazine look like an article?

Only if it is clearly labelled as advertising. In the UK, the advertising codes the Advertising Standards Authority administers require marketing to be obviously identifiable as such, so an advertisement designed in the style of the editorial pages needs a clear label, and the publication will usually apply its own. Paid articles and advertorials are a separate product with their own guide; a display advertisement should normally look like what it is.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Also related

Sources

  1. Advertising Standards Authority — ASA
  2. Media Rating Council — Media Rating Council

Related