Why a media owner is judged on more than its last price
A Media OwnerThe business that owns and sells advertising space, airtime or placements, such as a broadcaster, radio station, publisher, poster site owner or website. sells space, airtime or placements, and on a direct or offline buy it also takes the copy to its own specification, airs or posts what the copy instructions specify and provides the evidence of what ran. Price is only one part of what the business receives. A station that quotes a little less but misses spots, offers make-goods after the moment has passed and bills from its Rate CardA seller's published price list for advertising space, airtime or creator work, treated by buyers as an opening position, not the price paid. rather than the agreed rate may cost more, once the shortfall and the time spent chasing it are counted, than a dearer station that runs as booked.
The negotiation and insertion orders guide scores proposals before a buy against a list of criteria: audience fit, cost on a common basis, reach contribution, placement, guarantees, measurement, flexibility, added value and service. A proposal can only promise those things. A season of buys shows which of them the seller delivered. The post-campaign analysis guide sets a single campaign against its plan and observes that shortfalls grouped by seller or medium can shape the next round of negotiation more than any single figure. Nobody gathers that pattern unless someone sets out to, so a seller's performance can be forgotten between seasons and the next booking is judged on its quote alone.
The review is not adversarial. The negotiation guide reports work published through the IPA stressing that good negotiation ends in deals that buyer and seller can both honour, and adds that a rate forced below what a seller can sustain tends to return as weaker placement or quiet under-delivery. A review that reads the evidence fairly, hears the seller's side and asks for changes the seller can keep is how a buyer gets better terms without that cost. It is also distinct from two neighbouring jobs: the tutorial on reviewing an agency before renewal judges the agency that may book on the business's behalf, and the independent audits described in the auditing guide examine the buy as a whole. This page reviews the sellers themselves.
Before you start
- Every insertion orderThe contract for a direct or guaranteed media buy, recording what will run, where, when, at what price and what happens if it does not run. and booking confirmation for the season, with any revised orders, their make-good, cancellation and audit terms, and the standard terms each rests on. For interactive media the negotiation guide points to the IAB's standard terms, which many buyers and sellers adopt as their base contract; other media are sold on each seller's own terms, so read which applies from each order.
- The reconciled delivery record for each line: delivery evidence from the seller and any independent source, set against the order and the invoice, following the guide to auditing and verifying media.
- The weekly delivery sheets and change log, if the campaigns were run with the weekly in-flight checks for a media plan, so that shortfalls the seller caused can be told apart from changes the business asked for.
- The copy file: copy instructions, confirmations and first-appearance checks for each media owner.
- The media cost history, with this season's rows added, and the post-campaign analyses for the season's campaigns.
- Invoice queries and their answers from finance, and the record of any credit still outstanding.
- The buyer and the budget holder, plus the agency buyer where an agency booked any of the lines.
Where the business uses the campaign wrap-up checklist, its completed records hold much of this already; the review reads across them rather than redoing them.
The steps
List every media owner and line bought in the season
Start with a single list: every media owner the business bought from directly or through an agency in the season, and under each one every line booked, with the medium, the format, the dates, the booked weight, the agreed price and the route. Include small and one-off bookings, because a seller bought from only once is the one most easily rebooked without thought. Mark each owner's role in the plan as the plans described it, such as building reach in an area, adding frequency near a date, carrying an offer or holding a sponsorship. The role decides, later, which criteria weigh most.
Collect the reconciled record for each line
For every line, gather what was bought, what ran and what was charged: what was ordered, the evidence of what ran and what was invoiced, already reconciled where the business does so after each campaign. Use the reconciled figures rather than the seller's first report, as the post-campaign guide advises. Where a line was never reconciled, reconcile it now or mark it as unreconciled; an owner whose lines cannot be checked has already told the review something. Add the weekly sheets and change log, so each difference between order and delivery carries its cause.
Read delivery against the order, owner by owner
Set each line's delivery beside its order: spots aired in the agreed dayparts, sites posted on the agreed dates, insertions in the agreed issues and positions, impressions against any guarantee. Then read across each owner's lines and campaigns. A single missed spot in a season says little; the same daypart short in every campaign says a lot. Separate what the seller caused from what the business changed, using the change log, so an owner is not marked down for a booking the business moved itself. With few lines per owner, read the result as a range and a direction rather than a precise rate, in line with the advice on reading small numbers.
Read the make-good and credit record
For each shortfall, record what the owner offered and when. The negotiation guide expects a Make-GoodReplacement delivery a media owner provides when a booked spot, insertion or placement fails to run as agreed, offered under the order's terms. to be of comparable value, run within an agreed window and give way to a credit where it cannot run in time, and notes that make-goods after a campaign's key period may be worth little. So ask of each one: did it run on comparable placements and audience, inside the period the plan needed, and was it offered without being chased? Where a credit was agreed, has it appeared on an invoice? An owner that under-delivers occasionally but makes good promptly and usefully may be a better partner than one with fewer misses and a slow, grudging remedy.
Check proof of delivery, copy handling and invoices
Read each owner's Proof of DeliveryEvidence that offline ads ran as booked, such as posting photos, play and airing logs, transmission logs and tear sheets, checked before invoices are paid. for completeness and timeliness: station logs for radio; for out-of-home, posting reports with photographs, and play logs for screens; tear sheets or digital copies for print, as the channel guides describe. Then read its copy handling from the file kept under the copy delivery tutorial: were confirmations sent, did the first appearances match the instructions, and when the wrong version ran, how was it put right? Finally read its invoices: were they accurate first time, at the agreed rate, with media and fees apart? The purchase order and invoice approval tutorial covers how queries are raised; the review counts how many each owner needed and how fast they closed.
Set each owner's prices against your own cost history
Put each owner's lines on a common basis, the cost per thousand target impressions (CPMCost per 1,000 impressions.), working it out with the cost per thousand calculator where needed, using the conversion the buying models and pricing guide sets out. Then read each against the rows in the media cost history for the same medium, audience and season, and the conditions noted beside them: how early the line was booked, whether it was guaranteed, any added value or make-goods. Place each owner within the business's own range rather than against any outside figure. Recalculate the price on verified delivery as well as booked delivery, because a cheap line that under-delivered was not cheap.
Judge audience evidence, service and flexibility
For audience, ask what evidence each owner gave for the audience its price rested on, and whether it held. The auditing guide describes the measurement behind each medium and records that the Media Rating Council accredits specific measurement products against published standards in the United States, with joint industry bodies overseeing measurement elsewhere; a seller's own unaudited claim is weaker evidence than an audited or accredited source. The guide to buying radio advertising, the out-of-home buying guide and the print and press buying guide list the audience questions to ask stations, site owners and publishers. For service, read the record: responsiveness, reporting on time, help when plans changed. For flexibility, read how the owner handled requests to move, reduce or change bookings under its cancellation termsThe terms in a media booking or insertion order that set how late it can be cancelled or changed without penalty, and what is non-cancellable., which are read from each order, not assumed.
Score each owner on the criteria its role makes important
Turn the evidence into a score with the weighted scoring matrix: agree the criteria and their weights before scoring, back every score with the evidence gathered above, and test whether the order of owners holds when the weights shift a little. Weight by role, as the negotiation guide does for proposals: for a line bought to add frequency around a date, delivery in the agreed weeks and make-goods inside the window weigh heavily; for a line carrying a detailed offer, copy handling and placement matter more; for a sponsorship, context. Treat some requirements as gates rather than scores, such as proof that the advertising ran at all. Score owners of the same medium side by side where the business buys from more than one.
Share the findings and hear the owner's side
Send each media owner its own findings before deciding: the lines, the reconciled delivery, the make-goods and credits, any copy or invoice problems and the questions they raise. Ask for its account. An owner may hold evidence the business lacked, such as a log showing a spot did air or a copy change the business requested late, or may propose a fix, such as a guaranteed daypart split or a tighter make-good window. The post-campaign guide suggests sharing the analysis with the main media owners where relationships allow, because what was learned about placement and delivery feeds the next negotiation. Share each owner's own record only, never another seller's prices or scores. Where an agency books the line, hold the conversation with the agency present.
Decide to keep, renegotiate, re-tender or drop, and record why
Make one decision per owner and write it down with its evidence. Keep an owner that delivered, made good and billed accurately at a price within the business's range. Renegotiate with an owner whose audience the plan needs but whose terms let it down, asking for the specific changes the review points to: make-good windows, daypart or position guarantees, delivery evidence, invoice basis. Re-tender a line where price or performance sits poorly and other sellers can reach the same audience, by inviting proposals and scoring them as the negotiation guide sets out. Drop an owner whose failures repeat and whose role another seller can take. Carry agreed changes into the next orders, checked with the insertion order sign-off checklist, and set the date of the next review against the next booking round.
What to review and where the evidence lives
Each criterion has a natural source in records the business already keeps. The table is a prompt for the steps, not a scoring scheme; weights belong to each owner's role.
| Criterion | What to look for | Where the evidence lives | What a weak record looks like |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delivery against the order | Booked weight run in the agreed dayparts, dates, positions and issues | Orders, reconciled delivery, weekly sheets | The same shortfall in successive campaigns |
| Make-goods and credits | Comparable replacements inside the window; credits that reach the invoice | Make-good correspondence, change log, invoices | Make-goods after the key period; credits promised but never issued |
| Proof of delivery | Complete, timely logs, posting reports, photographs and tear sheets | The seller's proof filed against each line | Proof only on request, late or incomplete |
| Copy handling | Confirmations, correct first appearances, prompt correction of errors | The copy file and first-appearance checks | A wrong version that ran and was never put right |
| Invoice accuracy | Agreed rates, media and fees apart, order numbers present | Invoices and the query log | Repeated queries; rate-card prices billed |
| Price | Position within the business's own range for comparable conditions | The cost history on a common basis | Top of the range with no condition to explain it |
| Audience evidence | An audited or accredited source that held | Quotes and the measurement source named on the order | Unaudited claims; no named source |
| Service and flexibility | Responsiveness, reporting, help when plans changed | Correspondence and the change log | Late reports; changes refused that the order allowed |
The media planning framework places channel roles before the budget split; the review is where the business learns which sellers can fill each role reliably, and that knowledge feeds the next plan.
A removals firm reviews its media owners (illustrative)
Drelkosti Removals reviews a year of spring and autumn buys
Drelkosti Removals, an invented home removals and storage firm in Region B, books four media owners directly each spring and autumn: two local radio stations (Station A, £18,000 a year, and Station B, £14,000), a regional newspaper (£12,000) and a set of eighteen roadside panels near its storage depots (£20,000). Moves cluster in the last week of each month, so the radio lines are there to add frequency in the days before.
Collecting the reconciled record, the buyer finds that Station A ran 246 of 260 booked spots in spring and 231 of 240 in autumn. Both times the make-goods ran in the first week of the following month, after the moving peak they were bought for, and were offered only after the firm chased. Station B ran every spot. Station A's breakfast audience reaches many movers Station B's does not, so the plan still needs it. The newspaper printed last season's price in one autumn insertion; a credit was requested and, eight weeks on, has not appeared. Five of the eighteen panels were posted three days late in autumn, and the panel owner sent the photographs and credited the days at once.
Against the firm's cost history for regional press, the newspaper's cost per thousand readers came to £9.40, the top of the firm's own range of £6.10 to £9.40 over four seasons, with no early-booking or position condition to explain it. Station A's cost per thousand target listeners on verified delivery was £5.20, against £4.90 as booked, because the missed spots fell in its breakfast show, where more of the target listens than in its other dayparts.
The buyer weights the criteria by each owner's role. For the radio stations, delivery carries 30%, make-goods 25% and the other three 15% each; for the newspaper, proof, copy and invoices and price carry 25% each, delivery 20% and the other two 15% each; for the panels, delivery carries 30%, make-goods and proof 20% each and the other two 15% each. Each owner is scored out of five:
| Media owner | Role | Delivery | Make-goods and credits | Proof, copy and invoices | Price | Audience and service | Weighted score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Station A | Frequency before moving dates | 2 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 2.6 |
| Station B | Frequency before moving dates | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 3.85 |
| Regional newspaper | Offer detail and local reach | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 3 | 2.45 |
| Roadside panels | Presence near the depots | 3 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3.9 |
Each owner receives its own findings. Station A explains that its breakfast show was oversold in both peaks and offers make-goods within the same month, in the same daypart, written into the order. The newspaper issues the outstanding credit but declines to move on price.
The decisions are recorded before the spring booking round: keep the panels and Station B; renegotiate with Station A on make-good windows and a daypart guarantee for the last week of each month; re-tender the press line against a second title covering Region B; drop nobody this year. Each decision sits in the review file with its evidence, and the next review is set for after the autumn campaign.
Common mistakes
- Judging an owner on its latest quote. A low price that under-delivers, makes good late and bills wrongly is not low. Read delivery, make-goods and invoices before price.
- Using the first report rather than the reconciled record. The seller's first delivery figures leave out the make-goods, credits and corrections the review is meant to judge.
- Marking an owner down for the business's own changes. Without the change log, a booking the business moved looks like a seller's shortfall.
- Reading a few lines as a precise rate. One season of buys from one owner is a small sample; read the direction and look for repetition across campaigns.
- Weighting every criterion equally. A frequency line near a date lives or dies on timing; a sponsorship on context. Weight by role.
- Comparing prices with outside figures. A benchmark describes other buyers in other conditions; the business's own cost history is the measure.
- Deciding without hearing the owner. The seller may hold the log that settles a dispute or the fix that keeps a useful audience in the plan.
- Sharing other sellers' prices. Each owner sees its own record only.
- Recording no decision. A review that ends in a conversation and no written outcome is forgotten by the next booking round, and the same owner is rebooked on the same terms.
The media buying hub sets the review beside the other buying guides, from pricing and negotiation to copy delivery and the cost history.
