When to run this checklist
Run it in the days after a campaign or a flight ends, before results are presented and before the team moves on. The close-down group should be ticked on the end date itself, or the first working day after it; the rest can wait until final delivery figures are in and late conversions have landed, but not so long that the people who ran the campaign have forgotten why they made the choices they did.
The campaign owner runs it, with the analyst for the numbers and effect groups and whoever owns creative for the learning group. Run it for always-on activity too, at the end of each planned flight or quarter: an always-on campaign never ends, which is exactly why its learnings are rarely written down.
Before you start
- The brief, with the objectives, the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. targets and any measurement plan agreed at the start.
- The media plan and any insertion orders, so delivery can be compared with what was bought.
- Access to every platform the campaign ran on, including any partner or influencer reporting.
- The budget line and the invoices received so far.
- The launch QA record, which lists every ad, page and audience that was set live.
- Any test or survey design planned for the campaign, such as a holdout or a brand lift study.
The checklist
Work through the groups in order. Closing down comes first because every day it waits costs money or confuses customers; the numbers come before the effect because an incrementality read built on broken tracking is worse than none; and sharing comes last because results presented before the learning is written down tend to become the only record.
Close down
Numbers
Effect
Learning
Share
Where each check is explained
The widget above keeps the lines short so they can be ticked; the reasoning lives in the guides. Each check links to the page that explains it.
| Check | Explained in |
|---|---|
| Every ad, flight and sponsored post stopped | Post-campaign analysis for media plans |
| Time-limited offer pages retired or redirected | Content governance |
| Final delivery and spend from every platform | Post-campaign analysis for media plans |
| Spend reconciled with invoices and the budget | Tracking marketing spend against budget |
| Tracking held up for the whole campaign | Marketing data quality |
| Results compared with the brief's objectives | Writing a campaign brief |
| Incremental effect separated from the baseline | Incrementality testing |
| Brand lift or survey results read | Brand awareness and brand lift |
| Sales after the campaign ended, not only during it | Post-campaign analysis for media plans |
| What worked, what did not and why | Post-campaign analysis for media plans |
| Creative and audience learnings logged for the next brief | Creative production playbook |
| Final creative, plan and report archived together | Work management and marketing calendars |
| Results presented with caveats stated | Performance marketing reporting and reviews |
| What the next campaign will do differently | Writing a campaign brief |
If an item fails
Close-down failures are fixed immediately, whatever else is happening. An ad still running after the flight is spending money nobody approved; an expired offer page that still takes orders at a price the business no longer honours is a customer-service problem and, depending on the market, an advertising standards one. Redirect the page to the nearest relevant live page rather than deleting it, so links and search results from the campaign still land somewhere useful.
Numbers failures change what can be claimed. If tracking broke for part of the campaign, say which days and exclude them from any rate or ratio rather than quietly averaging across them. If spend cannot yet be reconciled because invoices are outstanding, present the figures as provisional and say when they will be final.
Effect failures are often planning failures: an incrementalityConversions caused by marketing. read needs a holdout or a comparison designed before launch, and a brand liftThe difference in brand measures between people exposed to a campaign and a comparable unexposed group. result needs the survey booked before the flight. If neither was planned, say so plainly when presenting, use the best available comparison, such as matched regions or the period before and after, and record the gap as a learning for the next brief. Do not present platform-attributed conversions as the campaign's effect.
Learning failures are the most common and the most costly over time. If the team has already moved on, book a short session with whoever ran the campaign and write the notes there and then; a short, honest note is worth more than a thorough deck nobody finishes.
A greenhouse kit maker's spring campaign
A greenhouse kit maker runs a six-week spring campaign across search, social and a gardening magazine's website, with £22,000 of media. On the day after the end date, the marketing executive finds a social ad set still running because it was duplicated mid-flight without an end date; it is stopped, having spent £340 extra. The spring discount page is redirected to the main product range. The numbers: 380 kit orders against a brief target of 350, but tracking was missing for three days after a site update, so the team reports orders from the order system rather than the platforms. The campaign ran in all regions but one, held out by design, and orders there rose only slightly less than elsewhere, so the team presents the incremental effect as modest and states that caveat on the first slide. Sales in the four weeks after the campaign fell below the previous year's level, suggesting some orders were pulled forward. The note for the next brief: plan a larger holdout, set end dates on every duplicate, and test whether the discount was needed at all.
Common mistakes
- Trusting the end date in the plan. Duplicated ad sets, boosted posts and partner placements keep their own settings. Check each one is actually off.
- Leaving offer pages live. An expired price that can still be ordered becomes a dispute, and an indexed offer page keeps attracting visitors to something that no longer exists.
- Reporting the platforms' totals as the result. Platform conversions add up to more than the business sold, and they say nothing about what would have happened anyway.
- Stopping the analysis on the end date. Sales pulled forward from the weeks after a campaign are a cost of the campaign, not a separate event.
- Presenting before writing down. The deck becomes the record, and decks rarely say what did not work.
- Archiving pieces in different places. Creative in one tool, the plan in another, the report in an inbox: the next team cannot reconstruct what ran.
The campaign launch QA checklist is the matching list at the start of the next campaign, and the checklists library holds the rest.
