When to run this checklist
Run it before anything that names a competitor or compares the business with one goes out: a versus or alternatives page, competitor-name search ads, a comparison video or a battlecard buyers may see. Run it at the draft stage, before filming or before the campaign is built, because the first two groups decide what is compared and how; a comparison built on the wrong criteria cannot be fixed by better wording afterwards. Run it again whenever a comparison is materially changed or a rival changes its offer.
The person who ticks it is whoever owns the comparison, usually a product marketer, a content lead or a paid search manager, with whoever approves claims for the sign-off line. A RACI matrix is a quick way to record who owns, who approves and who is told when several teams touch the same comparison. Four guides own the method, one per format: comparison and alternatives pages, competitor keywords in Google Ads, competitive battlecards and product review and comparison videos. They agree on the same layer of checks, which is why one list serves all four. Where a line names one format, such as search ad text or an on-screen disclosure, it applies only when that format is in front of you.
Neighbouring lists and procedures take the cases this one does not. Creative that names no rival goes through the creative approval SOP, which routes any work through brand, claims and compliance review. Once a comparison passes this list, the SEO page publishing checklist gates the page itself and the YouTube video publishing checklist gates the upload. Written reviews and best-of roundups of products the business does not make follow the guide to writing product reviews and roundups. Where a comparison is one part of a wider effort to win a rival's users, the guide to winning customers who use a competitor places it in the switch journey, beside the moments a move becomes possible and the work of lowering its effort and risk.
Before you start
- The draft: the page, the script, the ad copy or the battlecard, and the name of the person who approves it.
- The buyers' questions, from sales conversations, win-loss notes and search queries, that set the criteria.
- The rival's public pages each fact will come from: pricing, documentation, published terms.
- The latest competitive intelligence, so the draft can be checked against what has changed since it was written.
- The claims library, with the approved wording and evidence for each claim the business makes about itself.
- The test method and scoring weights for any comparison that rates products, fixed before testing.
- The channel's rules: the ad account's competitor campaign settings, or the disclosure plan for a video.
The checklist
The groups follow the order of the work: decide what is compared, source the facts, settle the wording, apply each channel's rules, then sign off and plan the upkeep. A line in the first four groups that cannot be ticked stops the release until it can; the last group can be finished on the day, but not skipped.
What is compared
Facts about the rival
Fair wording
Channel rules
Sign-off and upkeep
Where each check is explained
The widget keeps the lines short so they can be ticked; the reasoning lives in the guides. Each check links to the page that explains it, and the other format guides make the same point for their own format.
| Check | Explained in |
|---|---|
| Criteria from buyers' questions | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Like with like on both sides | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Own product through the same test | Product review and comparison videos |
| Weights fixed before the result | Product review and comparison videos |
| Rival facts from its own public pages | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| List of rival pages kept | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Facts checked against current intelligence | Competitive intelligence |
| Last-checked date near the top | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Opinions labelled as experience | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Where the rival fits better | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Nothing the business could not defend | Competitive battlecards |
| Own claims checked against the library | Building a claims library |
| Rival's name out of ad text | Competitor keywords in Google Ads |
| No keyword insertion in competitor ad groups | Competitor keywords in Google Ads |
| Separate campaign and budget | Competitor keywords in Google Ads |
| On-screen disclosure of how products arrived | Product review and comparison videos |
| Sign-off by whoever approves claims | Approvals and compliance reviews |
| Owner and review date | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Correction route published | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Checked date changed only after a check | Comparison and alternatives pages |
| Redirect planned if the rival leaves | Comparison and alternatives pages |
If an item fails
The facts and wording groups are the hard stop. A fact about the rival with no source on the rival's own pages, a price row from a plan the rival no longer sells, or a line the business could not defend if the rival read it comes out before release, whoever wrote it. The guides record the position the site relies on: a comparative claim is subject to advertising rules in most markets, and the battlecards guide describes the UK codes administered by the ASA as expecting comparisons with identifiable competitors to be like with like, verifiable and neither misleading nor denigrating. That is general direction rather than legal advice, and where a particular comparison matters to the business, take advice on it. Every claim the business makes about itself needs its SubstantiationThe evidence a business holds, before a claim is published, that the claim is true; advertising rules in most markets expect claims to be capable of it. on file; the claims library guide shows how to keep approved wording and evidence in one place, and the messaging hierarchy and proof points guide shows where each proof point belongs.
In the first group, a comparison whose criteria were chosen from where the business wins, or whose sides are not the same tier, period or size, goes back for a rebuild rather than a reword. A rating with weights set after testing is retested with weights agreed first. The comparison pages guide uses Google's helpful content guidance as its editorial test, asking whether content is clearly sourced, free of easily verified errors and leaves the reader able to decide; a comparison that wins every row fails that test with a sceptical buyer, and the guide to honest persuasion applies the same discipline to the rest of the site.
The channel rules group is specific to its format. For search ads, the competitor keywords guide reads Google's trademark policy, as the Google Ads policies centre sets it out, as limiting a rival's name in ad text, and warns that dynamic keyword insertion can put the rival's name into a headline without anyone writing it; the responsive search ads guide states the same limit. A Competitor BiddingBidding on searches for a competitor's brand or product names so your ad appears when people look for them, also called conquesting. campaign mixed into a generic one hides its cost and can take budget from terms that pay better, so it moves to its own campaign before launch. For video, the review videos guide describes the FTC's expectation that material connections are disclosed clearly and conspicuously, which points to a disclosure spoken and shown near the start, not only in the description.
The sign-off and upkeep group can often be finished the same day, but a comparison released with no owner and no review date is the one most likely to go stale and draw a complaint. Sign-off follows the business's approvals and compliance reviews route, and a BattlecardA short internal document that tells salespeople how to position against one named competitor in a deal. that buyers may see is signed off on the same terms as a public page. Keep the Claims LibraryA record of every marketing claim in its exact approved wording, with the evidence behind it, the conditions and markets it is approved for and the approver. and the list of rival sources up to date, and the next review is quick.
An invoicing app releases three comparisons in one sprint (illustrative)
A versus page, a campaign and a battlecard, fixed before release
Fyldrovak Invoicing, an invented invoicing app for sole traders, prepares three pieces in a two-week sprint against the two rivals it meets most often, called rival A and rival B here: a versus page against rival A, a search campaign on both rivals' names with a budget of £900 a month, and an updated battlecard for its 4 sales representatives. The product marketer runs this list for each, with the head of finance, who approves claims, signing off.
Three lines fail. The versus page's price row compares Fyldrovak's £12 monthly plan with rival A at £19, taken from a screenshot saved in March; rival A's pricing page now shows a £14 plan with the same invoice limit. The row is rebuilt like with like and the page states the date it was checked. The search campaign's draft ads use keyword insertion in the headline, which would have put each rival's name into the ad; it is switched off and the headlines say instead that Fyldrovak sends recurring invoices on every plan. And the battlecard says rival B "loses data on export"; nobody can find a source, so the line comes out and is replaced with a question for representatives to ask buyers about their export needs.
All three are signed off on the same day, each with an owner and a review date 3 months out. The versus page adds a section saying that rival A suits firms that need multi-currency invoicing, which Fyldrovak does not offer.
Common mistakes
- Choosing criteria where the business wins. Buyers notice a table built to win every row, and it fails the editorial test the guides apply.
- Comparing a cheap plan with a rival's premium one. The same tier, period, size or version on both sides is the first fairness test.
- Facts from memory or an old screenshot. Every fact about the rival comes from its current public pages, and the list of those pages is kept for the review.
- Changing the date without checking. A "last checked" date that has not been earned is itself misleading.
- Letting keyword insertion write the ad. A competitor ad group with insertion switched on can name the rival in the headline without anyone typing it.
- Treating battlecards as internal. Cards are forwarded; anything on one should be something the business could defend if the rival read it.
- Releasing without an owner. A comparison nobody owns goes stale on the day a rival changes its prices.
The checklists library holds the lists that sit beside this one, from SEO page publishing to YouTube video publishing.
