Definition
A comparative claim compares the advertiser's product, service or price with something a reader can identify: a named competitor, a competitor recognisable without its name, or the product's own previous version. Comparative advertising is the wider practice of making such claims in marketing communications.
The comparison does not have to be in an advert to count. The guide to competitive battlecards points out that what a sales representative says to a buyer is a claim made on the company's behalf, and the guide to AI claims and consumer protection treats "smarter than" or "more accurate than" a rival or a previous version as a comparative claim with the same evidence expectations as any other comparison.
The conditions
Comparative claims are subject to rules in most markets, and those rules vary by country. In the UK the Advertising Standards Authority's codes set conditions for comparisons with identifiable competitors, which the battlecards guide summarises as:
- Like with like. The comparison sets equivalent things side by side: the same plan tier, size, billing period or version.
- Verifiable. The reader, or the competitor, can check the facts compared.
- Not misleading. The overall impression is accurate, not only each individual fact.
- Not denigrating. The comparison describes the rival fairly rather than disparaging it.
Behind those conditions sits the general rule that objective claims must be capable of substantiation before they are made. The guide to building a core sales deck notes that comparative claims are treated with particular care, and takes proof from the same evidence file the website uses.
In practice: sourcing every fact about the rival
The site's guides turn the conditions into habits that apply wherever a comparison appears:
- Source every fact about the rival from its public pricing page, documentation or published terms, and link the source where possible.
- Date the comparison, and correct it promptly when the rival changes.
- Label opinions as opinions. A buyer's experience is reported as that, not as a measured fact.
- Send external comparisons through claims approval before publication and after every material change, as the guide to comparison and alternatives pages requires.
The same practices carry over to video. The guide to product review and comparison videos asks for the same test and scoring for every product, the business's own included, and for the script to be checked by whoever approves claims before filming.
A bookkeeping platform replaces a speed claim with a dated comparison
Glauppott Bookkeeping Platform's comparison page said it was "3x faster than" a named rival. Nobody could produce the test behind the line; it came from a sales demo in which Glauppott's newest plan ran against the rival's entry plan on different data. When the page came up in a quarterly claims review, the team removed the line. In its place it published a feature comparison of 12 capabilities on equivalent plans at the same billing period, each row sourced to the 2 products' public documentation and pricing pages, with the date checked at the top. Where the rival did something Glauppott did not, the table said so. The page now goes back through claims approval whenever either product changes a plan.
Related terms
SubstantiationThe evidence a business holds, before a claim is published, that the claim is true; advertising rules in most markets expect claims to be capable of it. is the evidence held before a claim is made, and a comparative claim needs it for both sides of the comparison. A Claims LibraryA record of every marketing claim in its exact approved wording, with the evidence behind it, the conditions and markets it is approved for and the approver. stores approved wording with its evidence, so an approved comparison can be reused without fresh review until a fact changes. A BattlecardA short internal document that tells salespeople how to position against one named competitor in a deal. is an internal document that often contains comparisons; anything from it that reaches a buyer is held to the same standard. A Reference PriceThe price a promotion compares against to show a saving, such as a 'was' price; the site's pricing guides say it should be one customers were genuinely charged. is a comparison too, between today's price and an earlier or recommended one, and it raises the same question of whether the comparison is genuine.
Common confusions
- Not naming the rival avoids the rules. The conditions the guides describe apply to identifiable competitors, and a rival readers can recognise may be identifiable without its name. Whoever approves claims decides.
- Internal materials are exempt. A battlecard is internal, but what a representative says from it to a buyer is a claim made on the company's behalf.
- Comparing with our own old version is not comparative. "Faster than the previous version" carries the same evidence expectations as a comparison with a rival.
- Each fact is true, so the comparison is fair. True facts can still mislead if the items compared are not equivalent, such as a premium plan against an entry plan.
