Owner, trigger and scope
The creative lead owns the procedure, receives submissions and is responsible for moving each asset through it. The brand reviewer decides whether the asset is on brand. The compliance reviewer decides whether its claims, offers and endorsements are acceptable. Each reviewer approves only within their own scope; comments outside it are suggestions, not blockers.
The trigger is any creative asset intended for external release: ads in any format, emails, landing page hero sections, social posts from brand accounts, print, video and creator content commissioned by the brand. New versions of approved assets also trigger it when copy, claims or offers change.
The scope is review and release, not production. How creative is planned and made sits in the creative production playbook. How the organisation decides which reviews are needed for which risk level, and who sits on them, is governance covered in the approvals and compliance reviews guide. This SOP runs inside whatever that governance decides.
Before you start: inputs and access
| Input | Owner | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Creative brief | Requesting marketer | Written using the creative brief template |
| Final asset files | Designer or agency | All formats and sizes to be released |
| Claims evidence | Requesting marketer | Substantiation for every factual or comparative claim |
| Brand guidelines | Brand reviewer | The current version only |
| Approval tracker | Creative lead | Shared tool or sheet showing status by asset |
| Asset library | Creative lead | Where approved versions are stored and released from |
Reviewers need access to the approval tracker and the files at full resolution, not screenshots. Agree response windows in advance so a submitter knows when to expect an answer. Generated or AI-edited images should arrive with their production log and having passed the review gate in the AI ad image production tutorial.
The procedure
Submit with the brief
The requesting marketer submits the final asset files to the approval tracker with the brief attached, the channels and dates, and the evidence for any claim. An asset without a brief is returned unreviewed, because no reviewer can judge whether it does its job without knowing what the job is. The creative lead logs the submission time and gives the asset a version label.
Check against the brief
The creative lead compares the asset with the brief: does it address the stated audience, carry the single proposition, include the mandatories and exist in every required format and size? Check that the call to action and the destination match the brief. If the asset is meant for an A/B TestControlled comparison of two variants., confirm the variants differ only in the element being tested. Return anything that misses the brief before other reviewers spend time on it.
Brand review
The brand reviewer checks the asset against the current brand guidelinesThe document recording how a brand looks and sounds, organised so anyone making material can find the rule, the reason and an example without asking.: logo use, colour, type, tone of voice, imagery and any rules about how the brand appears next to partners. The brand identity and voice guide explains the thinking behind those rules; this step applies them. Feedback is specific and actionable: what to change and why, not a general preference.
Claims and compliance check
The compliance reviewer checks every claim against its evidence, and checks offers, prices, endorsements, testimonials and disclosures. Advertising regulators such as the ASA in the UK and the FTC in the US publish guidance on misleading claims and endorsements, and the reviewer applies the organisation's reading of it. Regulated categories need the organisation's specialist review. This is general direction rather than legal advice. Ads bound for Google also face the platform's own review, and the guide to Google Ads policies and disapprovals lists the pre-launch checks on claims, trademarks and destinations that keep approved creative from being disapproved there. For ads bound for Facebook and Instagram, the guide to Meta ad review and rejected ads gives the equivalent pre-launch policy check, covering personal attributes, before-and-after images and special ad categories.
Accessibility check
Check text contrast and size, that important information is not carried by colour alone, that video has captions and that images carry alt textThe text alternative to an image, read by screen readers and used by search engines. where the channel allows it. For web and email assets, check against the relevant WCAG guidance. An accessible asset also tends to be easier to read on a small screen, which helps CTRShare of impressions that result in a click. as well as inclusion. Return assets that fail with specific fixes.
Sign off and version
Once every reviewer has approved, the creative lead records the sign-off with each reviewer's name, date and the version approved. The approved files are saved to the asset libraryThe single home for approved marketing files, holding one current copy of each with its version, rights, expiry, alternative text and usage notes. with the version label in the file name. Any later change, however small, creates a new version that goes back through the steps the change affects. Superseded versions are marked as such. Which steps a given change affects is set out in the guide to handling changes after approval.
Release to channels
Release only from the asset library, never from email attachments or a designer's drafts. Tell the channel owners which version is approved, where to find it and any usage restrictions such as end dates or market limits. The campaign manager confirms at launch that the live asset matches the approved version. Close the item in the tracker once every channel has confirmed. When a released asset later has to be pulled because its licence ends or a claim stops holding, the tutorial on withdrawing an asset from every channel works back from these release records. For direct buys with radio stations, publishers and site owners, the tutorial on delivering creative and copy instructions to media owners takes the approved version from release to a confirmed first appearance.
A comparative claim caught before release
Oakridge Mattress Co, an invented bedding brand, submits 12 social ad variants for a spring sale. The brief check returns 2 variants missing the end date of the offer. The compliance reviewer then questions the line "rated the comfiest mattress in Britain", which rests on a survey of 300 of the brand's own customers; it is changed to "rated 4.7 out of 5 by our customers", supported by the review platform. Accessibility checks add captions to 3 video variants. The remaining assets are signed off as version 2 within 3 working days and released from the asset library.
QA checks
The checks repeat parts of the review on purpose. Reviewers approve their own scope; this final pass confirms that the separate approvals all refer to the same files and that nothing changed between them.
Before an asset is released, the creative lead confirms:
- Brief attached and the asset meets it, including formats, sizes and mandatories.
- Brand approval recorded against this exact version.
- Every claim has evidence on file and compliance approval.
- Offers and prices match what the business will honour, with dates and conditions shown.
- Endorsements and paid partnerships are disclosed as the applicable guidance expects.
- Accessibility checks passed: contrast, captions, alt text, no meaning carried by colour alone.
- Version label is in the file name and matches the sign-off record.
- Asset library holds the approved version and superseded versions are marked.
Hand-offs and records
Approved assets are handed to channel owners and campaign managers through the asset library, with the version, dates and restrictions. Feedback that recurs, such as the same brand rule being missed, goes back to the creative lead as input to briefing and production. Where performance against the campaign KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. later shows a variant failing, the replacement goes through this SOP as a new version. If a channel owner finds an asset will not fit a placement, they ask for a new version rather than cropping it themselves.
The approval tracker, the sign-off record and the claims evidence are the lasting records. Keep claims evidence for as long as the asset might be challenged, so that a question from a regulator or a customer can be answered from the file rather than from memory. For assets with generated elements, keep the provenance record described in the open questions on AI copyright and training data alongside the claims evidence. The tutorial on auditing marketing approvals samples live work against these sign-off records to check that the version approved is the version that ran.
Common mistakes
Most of these come from deadline pressure, which is exactly when the procedure matters most.
- Reviewing without a brief. Reviewers fall back on personal taste. Return the asset first.
- Reviewers outside their scope. Brand comments on legal points, and the reverse, slow everything. Keep scopes clear.
- Approving a screenshot. The released file differs from what was seen. Review the actual files.
- Editing in the ad platform. Small copy fixes bypass review. Create a new version.
- Releasing from email. Old versions escape. Release only from the asset library.
- Unsupported superlatives. Claims like "best" need evidence. Ask for it at submission.
- Approving in chat. A thumbs-up in a message thread is not a sign-off record. Record approvals in the tracker.
