When to run this checklist
Run it before each upload goes public, including scheduled premieres and Shorts cut from a longer video. The right time is after the edit is locked and before the publish button, when the thumbnail and the title can still be changed together. Run the packaging group again whenever you change a title or thumbnail on a live video, because a new title can easily stop matching the thumbnail it was designed alongside.
The person who publishes runs the list, ideally with whoever edited the video, since the opening and the end screen items are edit decisions. A Short and a long-form video pass through the same groups; the items that only apply to long-form, such as chapters and end screens, can be ticked as not applicable for a Short, which is better than skipping them unread.
Before you start
- The final export of the video, watched once from start to finish at normal speed.
- Two or three thumbnail options, viewed at the size they appear on a phone home feed.
- The draft title and description, with the one link the video should send people to.
- The caption file, edited by a person rather than accepted from automatic captions.
- The campaign tagging convention, so description links are tagged the same way as other channels.
- Any sponsor or gifting agreement that applies to the video.
The checklist
The groups follow the order a viewer meets the video: the packaging in the feed, the description and structure on the watch page, the video itself, the settings that decide where it is shown, and the first days after publishing. Ticks are saved in your browser only, so record the sign-off in the content calendar.
Packaging
Description and structure
The video
Settings
After publishing
Where each check is explained
The widget keeps each line short enough to tick; the guides hold the reasoning. Each check links to the page that explains it.
| Check | Explained in |
|---|---|
| Title states the question or promise | Titles, descriptions and chapters |
| Thumbnail readable small and true to the video | Thumbnails and click-through rate |
| Title and thumbnail complement each other | Thumbnails and click-through rate |
| Main point and key link early in the description | Titles, descriptions and chapters |
| Clearly named chapters | Titles, descriptions and chapters |
| Accurate captions | Titles, descriptions and chapters |
| Opening with the payoff or question | Reading retention curves |
| Short or long-form decided | Shorts vs long-form video |
| End screens and cards lead onward | YouTube views but no subscribers |
| Audience, category and language settings | YouTube video not showing in search |
| Paid promotion declared | Influencer contracts and disclosure |
| Description links tagged | UTM and naming conventions |
| Pinned comment and early replies | Community management |
| Click-through rate and early retention checked | YouTube impressions click-through rate low |
If an item fails
A failed packaging item is worth holding the video for. The title and thumbnail are the only parts of the video most people ever see, and once the first audience has scrolled past, a later fix reaches fewer of them. If the thumbnail does not survive being viewed at phone size, or it promises something the video does not deliver, redesign it before publishing; the thumbnails guide explains why a misleading thumbnail raises click-through rateShare of impressions that result in a click. and then costs it back in watch time.
Two settings items also stop the upload. A video made for adults that is marked as made for children loses comments and personalised recommendations, and a sponsored video without the paid promotion declaration is a disclosure problem, not a missed optimisation. Correct both before the video goes public.
Description, caption and link items can ship with a note if the deadline is fixed, as long as they are fixed within the day: edit the description, upload the caption file, swap the link. Whether this video should carry a website link at all, and where it should land, is settled by the guide to sending YouTube viewers to your website. If the caption file was drafted by an AI tool, the guide to AI for alt text, captions and transcripts sets out the review it needs before upload. An opening that drags is the hardest failure to fix, because it means re-editing. If there is time, cut the introduction; if there is not, publish and use the retention curves guide to judge from the curve whether the next video needs a different opening. Low early Average View DurationTotal watch time of a video divided by its number of views. on a video with a slow start is a lesson for the next edit, not a reason to delete this one.
A violin-repair workshop's first long-form tutorial
A violin-repair workshop publishes a tutorial on replacing a bridge. The checklist catches two problems before upload. The title, "Bridge Replacement Part One", repeats the thumbnail text word for word, so the title is rewritten as the question viewers ask: why a violin buzzes after a string change. And the opening spends about 40 seconds on the workshop's history before any tool appears, so the editor cuts it to a five-second shot of the finished bridge. After four days the video shows an impressions click-through rate of 6.1% and a retention curve with no sharp early drop. The owner pins a comment linking to the tools list, answers the eleven early comments, and logs the result in the calendar beside the next video's plan.
Common mistakes
- Choosing the thumbnail at full size. It looks clear on a monitor and turns into an unreadable smudge in a phone feed.
- Writing the title and thumbnail separately. Both say the same words, so the pair carries half the information it could.
- Trusting automatic captions. Product names, technical terms and accents come out wrong, and the captions are what many viewers read with the sound off.
- Leaving the audience setting on a default. A wrong made-for-children answer quietly removes features the video relies on.
- Untagged description links. Traffic from the video arrives in analytics as generic referral traffic, and the video's contribution disappears from the report.
- Judging the video in the first hour. Early numbers are noisy; read click-through rate and retention after a few days, against the channel's own previous videos.
- Mixing paid and organic signals. When the video is also promoted as an ad, its paid View RateShare of video ad impressions that became counted views. says how the ad performed, not whether the video works for organic viewers; read the two separately.
The checklists library holds the other pre-flight lists, including the publishing checks for the web pages these videos link to.
