Why people stay with a supplier they are unhappy with
Ask a business why prospects stay with a rival and it names the rival's price or features. Ask people who eventually moved and most say they were unhappy for a long time first, held in place not by the rival's strength but by a familiar routine, the work of moving and the worry that something would break.
The competitor analysis guide names this directly. Alongside direct rivals, substitutes and intermediaries, it lists inaction: choosing to leave things as they are. It observes that in many categories this is the biggest rival of all, and that its appeal (safe, free, familiar) must be argued against as seriously as any named competitor's. For a business whose growth must come from people already buying the category elsewhere, inaction is the main opponent, and the named rival is only the form it takes.
The jobs-to-be-done framework explains why. As the Harvard Business Review article listed in the sources argues, customers hire a product to make progress in a particular situation rather than simply buying it. The framework page adds a limit worth taking seriously here: habit and loyalty are under-explained by the job alone, many purchases are repeat hires made without fresh thought, and doing the job better is no guarantee that a rival will be chosen. The page on jobs-to-be-done for retention gives the vocabulary: each switch weighs four forces against one another: the push away from the current product, the pull of the alternative, the habit of the existing routine and the anxiety about changing. For a customer the business wants to win, the first two work for it and the last two work for the rival.
| Force | How it shows for someone using a rival | What the business can influence |
|---|---|---|
| Push | Repeated frustrations with the current supplier: gaps, slow service, a price that no longer feels fair | Very little directly; it can only be ready when push peaks |
| Pull | A clearer picture of the progress available elsewhere | Positioning, proof and content written around the job |
| Habit | Routines, trained staff, saved data and workarounds built around the current product | The effort the move demands, and help with every step of it |
| Anxiety | Fear of losing data, disrupting colleagues, looking foolish if the move fails | Reversibility, a trial or parallel run, evidence from people who moved |
This is why a sharper comparison or a bigger discount often changes little: both act on pull while the customer is stuck on habit and anxiety.
The switch journey, from first doubt to settled
The customer journey section and its guide to journey stages describe a person moving from awareness through consideration and decision to retention. Someone who already has a supplier follows a recognisable version of that path, with two differences: the starting point is doubt about an existing choice rather than a new need, and there is a stage first-time buyers never meet, the move itself.
| Phase | What the person is doing | What they ask | What helps them |
|---|---|---|---|
| Settled | Using the current supplier without thinking about it | Nothing; the category is not on their mind | Being known and remembered, so the name is there later |
| Doubting | Noticing gaps and putting up with them | "Is it just us?" "Is this normal?" | Content about the problem, written in their language, with no sales push |
| Looking | Comparing alternatives, often quietly | "What else is there?" "What would the move involve?" | Honest comparisons, clear prices, a plain account of the move |
| Deciding | Weighing the gain against the work and risk | "What could go wrong?" "Who has done this?" | Evidence from switchers, a trial or parallel run, a named contact |
| Moving | Transferring data, people and routines | "Is anything lost?" "When do we stop the old one?" | A planned move, done largely by the new supplier |
| Settling | Learning the new routine while the old one fades | "Did we do the right thing?" | Early proof of progress, and a quick fix for anything that breaks |
The touchpoints guide asks whether the brand is present at the moments a customer needs it, and which encounters really help them along. Run that question for each phase above. Most businesses find they are well represented in the looking phase, through search and comparison content, and almost absent from doubting and moving, where the decision is actually won or lost. A TouchpointAny interaction between a person and a brand, paid, owned or earned, before, during or after a purchase. that answers "what would the move involve?" before the prospect has to ask is often worth more than another page about features. Treat the phases as states, not a funnel: people can doubt for years, look and give up, or move in a hurry when something breaks.
Finding the moments a switch becomes possible
Push builds slowly, but the move tends to happen at a particular moment, and the business's own analytics rarely show which.
Interview recent switchers. The framework page describes the switch interview: an unhurried conversation with a person who has just bought, switched or cancelled, tracing the story back from the decision to the very first doubt and asking about events rather than wishes. Recruit customers who came from a rival or a home-made arrangement, and ask about the day they decided, the weeks before, what nearly stopped them and who else had a say. Look for patterns across the set rather than leaning on one story.
List the trigger events. The guide to products people buy rarely shows how a purchase usually starts with an event, and among business triggers it names a failed supplier and the end of a contract. Switching has its own set. Typical ones include an agreement coming up for renewal, a new person taking charge who did not choose the current supplier, a failure or incident that made the old arrangement look risky, growth or contraction that the current product handles badly, a review or audit that exposes workarounds, and a merger or reorganisation. Which ones matter, and in what order, is for the interviews to tell you; do not borrow another category's list.
Read the signals of a live search. The intent signals guide places "versus" queries, reviews of specific products and return visits to pricing pages at the product-aware level, and lists comparison and "best" queries among solution-aware signals. For someone with a supplier, a search that pairs the current product's name with words such as "alternative" or "pricing" carries more of that intent than the name on its own, as the guide to bidding on competitor names notes. The intent signals guide warns against over-reading intent; one comparison search is a reason to be present and useful, not a reason to bombard the person with offers.
Be known before the moment. Most triggers give little warning, and nobody shortlists an unknown name in a hurry, so problem content and referrals have to keep the business in reach beforehand.
Lowering the effort and the risk of switching
The guide to reducing customer effort treats each step the customer is asked to take as work the business has handed over to them, and sorts nearly all fixes into four kinds: remove the step, do it for them, tell them first, and join it up. Each has a clear switching version.
| Kind of fix | In a switch | Example of the work |
|---|---|---|
| Remove the step | Cut anything the move does not strictly need | Skip re-entering settings that can be read from the old system |
| Do it for them | Take on the work the customer dreads | Import the existing data; rebuild templates; set up user accounts |
| Tell them first | Explain what will happen before they have to ask | A written move plan with dates, owners and what to check |
| Join it up | Keep context from sales to setup to support | One named person who knows the account through the whole move |
Risk is the other half. Switchers' anxieties are usually specific: losing records, a gap in service, colleagues refusing the new tool, being blamed if it fails.
- Make the move reversible where possible. A trial on real work, a period of running both arrangements side by side, or an export that lets the customer leave as easily as they arrived lowers the cost of being wrong.
- Show people like them who moved. A TestimonialA named customer's account of a specific result in their own words, used in marketing as proof and treated as an endorsement that must be genuine. is a named customer's account of a specific result in their own words, and it must be genuine. For switchers the most useful proof describes the move itself: what it involved, how long the disruption lasted, what went wrong and how it was fixed.
- Be honest about the hard parts. If some data cannot be moved, or a feature works differently, say so before the decision. A surprise discovered during the move does more damage than the same fact stated upfront.
Contract terms, notice periods and cancellation rules belong to the customer's agreement with the current supplier and vary by sector. This guide does not cover them, and the business should not make statements about another company's terms that it cannot check.
Messages for people who already have a supplier
Someone with a supplier already knows the category and has made a choice the message implicitly questions, so messages written for first-time buyers often fail with them.
| Row label | First-time buyer | Someone with a supplier |
|---|---|---|
| What they know | Little about the category | A lot, from their own experience |
| Their frame of reference | The category in general | The product they use now |
| Main question | "Which of these is right for me?" | "Is changing worth the trouble?" |
| What they fear | Choosing badly | The move going wrong, and having chosen badly before |
| What persuades | Explanation and reassurance | Specific progress, and evidence that the move is manageable |
The positioning guide defines a position against the alternatives a segment is actually considering. For this segment, the frame of reference is the arrangement they already have, and the position has to say what progress is available that the current one does not give. The jobs-to-be-done framework suggests writing it in the customer's own job language: the situation, the progress they want and the outcome that would count, rather than a list of features the rival may also claim.
Three habits keep these messages working. Respect the earlier choice. Telling people they chose badly tends, as a matter of general practice, to put them on the defensive; acknowledging that the current product made sense at the time leaves room to change. Lead with the move as well as the destination. A short line on how the switch is handled often does more than a paragraph on benefits, because it answers the question that is really holding them. Speak to each trigger, in the words the switch interviews supplied.
Naming the rival: comparison pages and competitor searches
The guide to responding to competitors reports the principle that the approvals and compliance guide records: in most markets, advertising rules hold that marketing must not mislead and that a claim needs evidence behind it before it is made, and every new comparison or claim about a competitor is sent to legal or compliance review ahead of any build work. This guide does not interpret those rules, and nothing here is legal advice.
In practice that means four things.
- Use approved wording. Claims about the business itself come from the claims library, with the exact wording, dated evidence and approval recorded for each.
- Hold sales conversations to the same standard. The competitive battlecards guide gives the working rule for a BattlecardA short internal document that tells salespeople how to position against one named competitor in a deal.: keep on it only what the company could defend if a buyer forwarded it to the rival.
- Gate anything that names a rival. The competitor comparison checklist is the release gate for versus pages, competitor ads and comparisons buyers may see. It asks that criteria come from buyers' questions, that both sides are compared on the same tier or version, that each fact about the rival comes from its own public pages, that the page says where the rival fits a buyer better, and that someone owns keeping it current.
- Judge competitor search on new customers. The guide to bidding on competitor names explains that Competitor BiddingBidding on searches for a competitor's brand or product names so your ad appears when people look for them, also called conquesting. reaches only the minority of searchers who are still comparing, that the advert cannot lean on the rival's name because of Google's trademark policy as that guide describes it, and that each rival's ad group should be judged on the cost of genuinely new customers rather than on clicks.
The comparison that persuades switchers is the one a current user of the rival recognises as fair, because it describes their product accurately.
The first weeks after a switch
A switcher arrives with an old routine and colleagues who may not have wanted the change. If the first weeks go badly, habit pulls them back and the anxiety they overcame looks justified.
The tutorial on onboarding customers for services and products starts by defining first value, the moment a customer actually gets what they paid for, then drawing the path to it, removing steps, timing each message to the moment, making the first human contact count and spotting stalls in the records. Switchers need that path drawn separately, for three reasons.
- Their first value is different. A first-time buyer's first value is often simply getting started. A switcher's is usually doing what they did before, without loss, and then something they could not do before.
- Their stalls are different. Switchers tend to stall where data or habits did not carry over: a missing history, a familiar shortcut that works differently, a colleague still using the old tool on the side.
- Their comparison point is fresh. Every small problem is measured against the old product, not against nothing. Anything that worked better before needs an answer quickly.
The retention page makes a useful point here: once the customer has moved, habit and anxiety become allies. Help the new routine form early, with prompts that show the job being done, and the same forces that kept the customer with the rival start to keep them with the business. Close the move properly too: confirm what was transferred and ask what is still missing.
Measuring switchers apart
Mixed with first-time buyers in the reports, switchers disappear, and nobody can tell whether the switching work pays.
Mark them at the start. Add a question to every enquiry, trial or order form asking what the person used before, with the main rivals, a home-made arrangement and "nothing" as options, and record the answer against the customer. Self-reported answers are imperfect, but they are often the only record of where a customer came from.
Track them as a cohort. The cohort analysis tutorial groups customers who share a starting event and period and follows each group over time, replacing a blended retention figure that hides differences between groups. Splitting each starting cohort into switchers and first-time buyers shows whether one group's Churn RateShare of customers at the start of a period who left during it. differs from the other's, and whether a change to switcher onboarding moved it. A CohortA group of customers who share a starting event and period, tracked together over time. of switchers from one rival can be compared with switchers from another, which shows which rivals' customers the business serves best.
Read the counts honestly. Switchers are often few in any given month, and the guide to reading small numbers explains why rates built on small counts jump around by chance, and recommends showing the count behind every rate, using ranges instead of single figures and pooling periods until a figure means something.
| Question | Measure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| How many new customers come from rivals? | New customers by what they used before | Form answers joined to customer records |
| Which rivals do we win from? | Switchers by rival, pooled over a long enough period | The same answers |
| What does it cost to win a switcher? | Cost per new customer from switching activity, per rival where possible | Spend records and customer records |
| Do switchers stay? | Retention and churn by cohort, switchers against first-time buyers | Cohort table |
| Where do switchers stall? | Progress to first value, by group | Onboarding records |
| Why did they move? | The recurring situations and anxieties | Switch interviews, repeated over time |
A rota software firm courts its rivals' users (illustrative)
Hextovian Rota times its offer to the moment of change
Hextovian Rota, an invented maker of shift-rota software for care homes, finds that almost every prospect already runs rotas in a rival product or a spreadsheet. Its campaigns, written for first-time buyers, produce plenty of demo requests and few customers, and it decides to study the people who did move.
It runs 14 switch interviews with customers who joined in the previous 18 months. Twelve describe frustration building for many months before they acted. All 14 moves came at one of three moments: a contract renewal with the old supplier (6 interviews), a new home manager (5) or an inspection that exposed gaps in the rota records (3). The fear named most often, by 10 of the 14, is losing a month of rotas in the middle of the change and leaving shifts uncovered.
It makes five changes. It writes guides for new managers and for homes preparing for an inspection, and runs them beside a small campaign on searches for the 2 main rival products paired with "alternative" and "pricing". It offers to import the existing rota and to run both systems side by side for 4 weeks. It publishes one comparison page, built against the competitor comparison checklist, with every claim taken from its claims library and a section on where each rival fits a home better. It adds a "what did you use before?" question to the demo form. And it tracks switchers as a separate cohort from homes buying rota software for the first time.
| Measure, over 2 quarters | Switchers | First-time buyers |
|---|---|---|
| New customers | 31 | 19 |
| Still active at the end of the period | 27 | 17 |
| Reached a full published rota in week 1 | 13 | 15 |
The counts are small, so the firm reads them as a direction rather than a rate. The biggest difference is in the first week: switchers stall on recreating complicated shift patterns from the old system, while new homes stall on adding staff. It builds a separate first-week plan for switchers, in which its team rebuilds the shift patterns during the parallel run. Of the 2 rival names it bid on, one produced 8 of the new switchers at a cost per customer it could afford; the other produced 1, at a cost per new customer well above what a customer is worth, and its ad group is paused.
Common mistakes
- Treating the rival as the main opponent. For most prospects the real competitor is staying put, held in place by habit and the fear of a difficult move.
- Answering every objection with a discount. Price acts on pull; switchers are usually stuck on the effort and risk of the change.
- Being absent at the moment of change. Renewals, new managers and failures give little warning; the business has to be known before the trigger arrives.
- Writing for first-time buyers. People with a supplier know the category and are asking whether changing is worth the trouble.
- Running down the customer's earlier choice. In general practice it puts them on the defensive.
- Publishing comparisons nobody owns. A versus page that is out of date, one-sided or unsourced costs trust with the very readers who know the rival best, and every claim in it needs review.
- Judging competitor searches on clicks. Only genuinely new customers, rival by rival, show whether the spend pays.
- Onboarding switchers like everyone else. They arrive with old routines and a fresh comparison point, and stall in different places.
- Blending switchers into one retention figure. Without a separate cohort, nobody can tell whether the switching work is paying.
