Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Digital Marketing › Customer Journey

When the Buyer Is Not the User

How to market when the person who pays is not the person who uses the product: gifts, parents, carers and employers, and how messages and journeys split.
Guideintermediate11 min readUpdated

Payers, users and the people in between

A simple journey model gives one person every part of a purchase: they notice the need, research, choose, pay and use. Many purchases spread those parts across people. It helps to name the parts plainly, as roles rather than as people, because one person can hold several and a role can be shared.

RoleWhat the person doesWhat they usually worry about
Starts the searchNotices the need and begins looking, or asks someone else toWhether the problem is worth solving at all
InfluencesSuggests, recommends, vetoes or sets conditionsWhether the choice fits their own standards and rules
PaysHands over the money and carries the risk of a bad choiceValue, safety, being seen to choose well
UsesLives with the product every dayWhether it is enjoyable, easy and worth the effort
DecidesHas the final say, which may sit with the payer, the user or neitherWhether the decision can be defended later

When all the roles sit with one person, a single journey map and a single message are enough. When they split, the business is marketing to a small group, and every message reaches someone whose concerns it may not answer. In business purchases this group is familiar as the Buying Committee; the buying committee entry describes the roles inside an organisation and why business marketing plans by role. The same logic applies, at a smaller scale, to a large share of consumer purchases.

Common patterns

The split takes a few recurring forms. Each has a different balance of power between the payer and the user, and that balance decides where the marketing effort goes first.

PatternWho paysWho usesWhere the tension lies
GiftsThe giverThe recipientThe giver wants to seem thoughtful; the recipient wants something they will actually like
Parents and childrenA parent, sometimes a grandparentThe childThe child wants fun; the parent wants safety, value and a house that stays manageable
Adult children and older parentsThe adult childThe parentThe buyer wants peace of mind; the user wants independence and nothing that feels patronising
CarersThe carer, a family or a funding bodyThe person cared forPracticality and cost against dignity and comfort
Employers and staffThe employerThe employeeThe employer wants adoption and value; the employee wants ease and relevance to their work
Procurement and end usersA purchasing functionTeams in the businessPrice, terms and risk against fitness for the daily job

Two features matter in every pattern. First, who holds a veto: in many families the parent decides what is allowed in the house even when a grandparent pays, and in many businesses the end users can quietly refuse to adopt what procurement bought. Second, who comes back: the payer of a one-off gift may never return, while the user's household or team may become a repeat customer if the first experience is good.

Map a journey for each role

The Harvard Business Review article on customers' jobs, listed in the sources, frames purchase as hiring a product to make progress in a particular circumstance. When the buyer and the user differ, they hire the same product for different jobs. A grandparent buying a wooden toy is trying to give a present that shows they know the child and that the parents will welcome. The parent is trying to keep the child occupied and the house safe and uncluttered. The child is trying to play. The jobs-to-be-done framework shows how to write each job down, and the comparison of buyer personas and jobs-to-be-done explains why the strongest audience work writes the job into each Buyer Persona rather than choosing one lens.

Then map each role's journey separately, using the method in the journey mapping tutorial: stages, actions, questions, emotions, obstacles and the touchpoints where each role meets the business. The stages guide notes that a purchase with several people needs a row per role, and the role-by-role maps show why. The giver's journey starts with an occasion and ends at delivery; the recipient's starts when the parcel is opened and runs through first use, everyday use and, sometimes, a return. The parent's journey may start before either, with a view of what kind of toys belong in the house.

Mark the hand-off points, where one role's journey passes to another's: the gift being opened, the employer's licence being assigned to an employee, the carer setting up a device for the person cared for. Hand-offs are where products fail quietly. The buyer has done their part and moved on, and the user meets the product with no instructions, no context and no reason of their own to persist.

What each role needs to hear

Each role needs a message that answers its own worry. As a general pattern, the payer needs reassurance and value, the user needs desire and ease, and whoever holds a veto needs to see their conditions met. The messaging hierarchy guide puts the principle in business terms: the economic buyer wants the cost case and the risk removed, and the user wants to see the product doing their job. The pillars stay the same; the emphasis and the proof change by role.

RoleLead messageProof that persuadesWhat to avoid
Payer (giver, parent, employer)This is a good, safe, sensible choiceSafety information, guarantees, reviews from people like them, clear price and deliverySelling only the fun or the features the user cares about
User (recipient, child, employee)This will be enjoyable and easySeeing it in use, simple first steps, other users' enthusiasmBurying the product under the payer's reassurance
Veto holder (parent, procurement)Your conditions are metMaterials, standards, terms, the specifics they checkTreating them as an obstacle to work around
Influencer (relative, colleague)This is worth recommendingSomething easy to pass on, such as a gift guide or a short summaryAsking them to sell on the business's behalf

Keep the message and the destination aligned for each role. An ad written for grandparents should lead to a page written for grandparents, with gift wrapping, delivery dates and age guidance, not to a page that speaks to parents about storage. The message match guide covers keeping the promise and the page in agreement, and Message Match matters more here because two audiences are easy to confuse.

Reaching each role at the right moment

Roles meet the business at different times and through different channels, so the plan needs a channel and a moment for each. The payer is usually reached before the purchase: gift-intent searches and gift guides before occasions, parenting communities and reviews, the business channels where employers and purchasing teams look. The user is often reached after it: on the packaging, in the first-use experience, in onboarding emails, in the product itself. Influencers are reached through whatever the user or payer passes on to them.

Write each role into the brief. The campaign brief template asks for the audience as a situation first and targeting criteria second; where the buyer and the user differ, a campaign may need two audience descriptions with their own messages, or two campaigns. In segmentation terms, the role is a segment variable as strong as any demographic: a grandparent and a parent of the same child behave differently at every stage. Treat Segmentation by role as a planning choice, then find the targeting that reaches each role rather than assuming one audience reaches both.

Timing matters as much as channel. A gift buyer acts against a deadline, so delivery promises and cut-off dates belong in the message; for an online store, the guide to selling gifts online covers gift guides, gift options at checkout and last order dates the store can keep. An employer's decision follows budget cycles. A carer often acts in a hurry after a change in circumstances. The user's moment comes later and is easy to neglect, because no ad budget is attached to it.

Products for children and other protected groups

When the user is a child, the rules change. Advertising to children is tightly controlled by regulators and by the platforms' own advertising policies. This guide does not state those rules, because they differ by market and by product and change over time, and nothing here is legal advice.

Two pages on the site set out the practical consequences. The education industry guide explains why marketing for under-age students goes mainly through parents, schools and advisers, with audience building and follow-up aimed at the adults who make or share the decision. The approvals and compliance guide explains how to route work with regulated products, new audiences or new uses of personal data to a specialist reviewer before it is built. Take professional advice for the markets you sell in.

The same care applies, as general practice, when the user is an older or vulnerable adult. Messages aimed at the person buying on their behalf should not frighten or pressure, and products should be described in a way the user could read without feeling diminished, because they often will.

Measuring when the buyer and the user differ

Most tracking records the payer: their visit, their click, their order. The user's verdict arrives later and elsewhere: whether the product is kept or returned, used or left in a cupboard, recommended or quietly abandoned. Measure both.

  • The payer's journey is measured as usual: reach, visits, conversion and cost per order, read by role where the campaign targets roles separately.
  • The user's verdict shows in returns, activation (first use, an account set up, a licence assigned and used), continued use, repeat orders from the user's household or team, and reviews written by users rather than buyers.
  • The link between them needs a deliberate record: a gift option at checkout, a question about who the purchase is for, or, in business, measures read at the level of the account rather than the individual lead, as the account-based marketing guide describes.

As general practice, do not market to a gift recipient or an end user on the strength of the payer's details or the payer's consent; contact them once they have given their own permission, as the list building and consent guide describes in principle. Until then, measure through the payer, for example with a follow-up question about how the gift was received, or through aggregate signals such as return rates by product.

A toy maker sells to parents and grandparents (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Toddlewhim Toys splits its journey by role

Toddlewhim Toys, an invented maker of wooden toys, adds a question at checkout asking who the purchase is for. Over three months, 58% of orders are gifts, and of those 71% come from grandparents. Interviews with 12 parents show that many have rules about what enters the house: no batteries, no loud noise, nothing that needs much storage. Two parents had returned or given away gifts that broke those rules.

The company gives each role its own plan.

RoleMessagePageTiming
GrandparentsA lasting present that parents welcomeGift page with age guidance, materials, wrapping and delivery cut-off datesFour weeks before birthdays and holidays, with reminders a week before cut-off
ParentsQuiet, safe, easy to store, made to lastPage on materials, finishes and storageAlways on, plus a card in every gift box inviting parents to a simple care guide
ChildrenFun to open and easy to play with at onceThe unboxing itself and a picture card of games to playAt delivery

It measures the result over the following year. Gift orders from grandparents rise from 410 to 520 a year at a similar cost per order. More telling, 9% of parents who receive a gift and follow the care card sign up to the email list with their own consent, and 34% of those place an order of their own within the year, compared with 18% of other new subscribers. The gift returns rate falls from 6% to 3% after the gift page starts carrying the parents' concerns. The business now judges gift campaigns on both the grandparents' orders and the parents' later orders.

Common mistakes

  • One message for everyone. A message that tries to satisfy the payer and the user at once usually satisfies neither.
  • Selling to the user and forgetting the veto. A product the child loves and the parent bans does not stay in the house.
  • Ending the journey at the order. The user's verdict decides returns, use, reviews and repeat purchase, and it happens after the tracking stops.
  • Ignoring the hand-off. The moment the product passes from payer to user needs instructions, context and a reason to persist.
  • Mixing audiences on one page. An ad for gift buyers that lands on a page for parents breaks the promise the ad made.
  • Treating a payer's consent as the user's. Market to a recipient, an employee or a person cared for only once they have given their own permission.
  • Stating rules about children without advice. Route products for children through the specialist pages and professional advice rather than guessing at the rules.

Frequently asked questions

Should I market to the buyer or the user?

Usually to both, with different jobs. The person who pays has to be persuaded that the purchase is safe, sensible and good value; the person who uses it has to want it and find it easy, because their verdict decides whether it is kept, used and bought again. Where one role holds a veto, such as a parent deciding what is allowed in the house, that role gets the reassurance first. Map who does what for your own product before deciding where the budget goes.

How do I find out who is buying for whom?

Ask, and look at what customers already tell you. A checkout question asking who the purchase is for, gift options and gift messages, delivery addresses that differ from billing addresses, enquiry forms that ask about the person being cared for, and interviews with recent buyers and users all show the split. The answers usually reveal more than one pattern, which is why each pattern needs its own journey.

Is this the same as a business buying committee?

It is the same idea at its smallest. A buying committee in a business purchase has several people who influence, evaluate and approve, including the people who will use the product. A gift has two: the giver and the recipient. The business case is covered in the buying committee entry and the account-based marketing guide; this guide applies the same thinking to consumer purchases and to the simpler business cases.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Sources

  1. Know Your Customers' Jobs to Be Done — Harvard Business Review

Related