Who the competitors are
The list starts with the customer, not with the industry. Audience research asks what alternatives people considered and what they chose instead; the answers define the competitive setThe fixed list of brands a measure such as a brand tracker, share of search or share of voice compares against, chosen from what buyers really consider., and they usually include things the business did not count as rivals:
- Direct competitors — same product, same segment.
- Substitutes — a different product that does the same job: a spreadsheet instead of software, a second-hand purchase instead of new, a service instead of a product.
- Intermediaries — marketplaces, comparison sites and aggregators that sit between the customer and all the direct competitors, and that compete for the same searches.
- Inaction — the decision to keep the current arrangement. In many categories it is the largest competitor, and its "position" (safe, free, familiar) has to be argued against like any other.
Analysing the wrong set — the companies the founders watch rather than the ones customers weigh — is the most common way the exercise fails before it starts. When the question is how much pressure the whole market puts on price and acquisition cost, rather than what each rival is doing, the five forces model reads rivals, substitutes, entrants, buyers and suppliers together. The comparison of SWOT and the five forces covers when to run that market-wide read and how its high-rated pressures enter a SWOT as threats with evidence.
What to look at
The surfaces where customers compare are the surfaces to analyse.
Search. For the category and problem terms the audience uses: who ranks, with what page types and what promises in the SERPThe page of results a search engine shows. snippet; who advertises, with what copy and offers; what share of the results each competitor holds. Keyword tools show their estimated visibility and the terms they rank for that you do not; the SEO traffic estimator puts rankings into expected visits. Ad platforms' auction reports show overlap and Impression ShareShare of eligible impressions you received. directly for paid search. For organic positions over time, the rank tracking guide sets up a stable query set by location and device and turns competitors' positions into a share-of-voice measure. The competitor keyword gap tutorial turns the comparison of terms into a method, from choosing search competitors to adding rows to the keyword map.
Advertising. Platform ad libraries show competitors' current ads, formats and how long each has run — the long-running ones are the ones working. Messaging, offers, creative style and which segments the ads address are all visible.
Website and offer. Positioning on the homepage, the pricing model and price points, the proof offered (reviews, guarantees, case material), the conversion path (forms, checkout, trials), the content they publish and how deep it goes. The SEO page checker reads the on-page basics of any public page.
Social and content. Which platforms, how often, what formats, what engagement, which creators they work with, which topics they claim authority over, how they respond to customers in public.
Reviews. On review sites, marketplaces and app stores: what customers praise and complain about, in their words. Competitors' complaints are a map of unmet needs; their praise is a map of occupied positions. For a business that serves one area, the tutorial on benchmarking nearby competitors applies this to the few firms shown beside it in the local map results, comparing their profiles, reviews and replies with its own.
Links and mentions. Who links to them and writes about them (BacklinkA link from another site to yours. analysis) shows which publications and partners matter in the category, and where earned attention is available.
Share of voice. Across search, social and advertising, how often each competitor is the one the audience sees (Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility.). The trend matters more than the level.
The comparison of impression share and share of voice explains why a paid search coverage figure cannot stand in for a brand's share of its category.
Organising the findings
Raw observations are useful only once arranged for a decision. Two structures work:
- A comparison grid — competitors as columns, dimensions as rows (segment served, position claimed, price model, proof, channels, content depth, strengths from reviews, weaknesses from reviews). Reading across a row shows where the market clusters and where there is space.
- A position map — two attributes the segment cares about on two axes, each competitor placed where its claims and reviews put it. Empty regions are candidate positions; crowded regions are where competing means outspending.
SWOT applied to each major competitor, and PESTEL applied to the category, add the outside-in view: which external changes (regulation, platform shifts, economic conditions) help or hurt each player. The competitor analysis template sets out the grid, a teardown per competitor and the position map as a document to copy, ending in actions with owners.
Analysing the alternatives to a project-management tool
Research shows the real competitive set is two established tools, a general-purpose spreadsheet, and the option of staying with email and meetings. Search analysis finds the two tools own the category terms with feature-led pages, while the questions small agencies ask ("how to track client approvals") are answered by nobody. Ad libraries show both competitors running long-lived ads about scale and integrations. Reviews praise both for power and criticise both for set-up time and for being too much for small teams. The grid shows a crowded "powerful and complete" region and an empty "running in an afternoon, built for agencies" region. The positioning that follows targets the empty region, the content programme answers the unanswered questions, and the ads argue against inaction (the email-and-meetings alternative) rather than against the big tools.
Turning analysis into decisions
The analysis feeds three places:
- Positioning. Occupied positions are ruled out; empty positions the segment values are candidates; competitors' weaknesses from reviews become reasons to believe.
- Channel and content choices. Where competitors are absent (a platform, a content topic, a query set) is cheap to enter; where they are strong, entering means a clear difference or a bigger budget. The channel mix guide uses this.
- Go-to-market and segment choice. Segments the competitors serve badly, revealed by reviews and by the queries nobody answers, are candidate first segments.
What the analysis should not feed is a to-do list of competitor tactics. Their choices fit their position, resources and history; copying the visible part without the invisible part produces an inferior imitation at full cost.
Competitor analysis checklist
A monitoring routine between passes
| Signal | Where | How often | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rankings on the key terms | Rank tracker or Search Console | Monthly | Who is gaining in organic visibility |
| Auction overlap and impression share | Paid search auction reports | Monthly | New entrants; rising competition on your terms |
| Ad creative and offers | Platform ad libraries | Monthly | Messaging shifts; promotions |
| Pricing pages | Direct check | Monthly | Price and packaging changes |
| Review trends | Review sites, app stores | Monthly | Emerging complaints or praise |
| Brand mentions and new entrants | Mention alerts | Continuous | Launches, press, funding |
The paid-search auction reports deserve a special mention: impression share, overlap rate and position above rate are the only competitor data that comes directly from the platform rather than from a third-party estimate, and a sudden change in them is often the first visible sign of a new competitor's budget. When one of these signals shows a move that matters, the guide to responding to competitor moves reads it against the business's own numbers and chooses the response.
Reading what competitors do not say
The most informative signals are often absences. A competitor that runs no ads on a query cluster the audience uses has either found it unprofitable or has not noticed it; a short test tells you which. A competitor with no content on a problem their customers ask about leaves the consideration stage open. A competitor whose reviews praise everything except delivery has a weakness that no comparison grid of features would show. A rival's pricing page is informative for what it omits: a missing tier is a segment they have chosen not to serve. And a competitor who has not changed its position in years is either confident or inattentive, and its customers' complaints will say which. Treat each absence as a hypothesis about an opportunity, size it with search and research data, and test it cheaply before building a strategy on it. The analysis should produce a few of these, prioritised, rather than a complete portrait of every rival.
Keeping it current
Competitors move. A light monitoring routine — monthly checks of rankings on the key terms, ad library snapshots, pricing pages, review trends, and auction overlap reports — catches changes between the annual passes that the planning cycle includes. Alerts on competitor brand mentions and on new entrants in the ad auctions cost little and surface shifts early.
Common mistakes
- Analysing the wrong set. The companies you watch rather than the ones customers weigh; forgetting substitutes and inaction.
- Copying. Adopting the leader's tactics without the leader's position.
- Features over positions. Comparing feature lists when customers compare promises and proof.
- One-off analysis. A deck from two years ago describing a market that has moved.
- Treating estimates as facts. Third-party traffic and spend figures are models; use them for direction, not precision.
- Fear-driven decisions. Matching every competitor move produces a strategy that is the average of everyone else's.
The analysis sits between audience research, which supplies the competitive set, and positioning, which uses the gaps it finds; the SEO hub shows how the author uses search data in this kind of work.
