Why not every product deserves the same support
A plan that promotes the whole range equally is a plan that has not chosen. Products differ in what a sale leaves behind once the costs that vary with it are paid, in how many people already look for them, in whether the business can actually supply more, and in what a first purchase leads to. Treating them alike means the money follows whatever the channels happen to favour, which is usually the products with the most history and the cheapest clicks rather than the ones that matter most to the business.
The default is also hard to see. In automated campaigns, spend gathers around the lines the system can predict, and the product lifecycle guide describes the result inside Shopping and Performance Max: best-sellers take the spend and the rest of the catalogue waits. That guide decides how products are grouped and bid inside those campaigns. The decision here sits one level higher, across the whole plan and for services as well as goods: which lines does marketing exist to sell this year, and which does it leave alone?
Three questions frame the choice for each line:
- Can extra marketing change the outcome? A line that sells steadily to people who already know it may gain little from paid support; a line with untapped demand may gain a lot.
- Can the margin pay for it? The contribution a sale leaves sets the most a customer can cost, and that ceiling differs line by line.
- What happens after the first sale? Some lines lead to repeat purchases and other products; others end the relationship at checkout.
The budget allocation guide splits money between channels by marginal return. The same thinking applies between products: the next unit of spend should go where it buys the most profit, not where it buys the most revenue.
What to score each line on
Score at the level the business makes decisions: a range, a category or a group of similar products, not every item. A shop with hundreds of products might score a dozen ranges; a services business might score each service.
| Criterion | What it asks | Where the evidence comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Contribution margin per sale | What a sale leaves after product, delivery, fees and expected returns | Finance and the order system, as the contribution margin guide sets out |
| Existing demand | Do people already look for this, and how many? | Search volumes, site search, enquiries, marketplace and competitor activity |
| Stock or capacity | Can the business supply more without letting service slip? | Stock on hand and on order, staff hours, booking slots, fulfilment |
| Repeat and cross-sell potential | Does a first purchase lead to more? | Order history: repeat rates by first product, products bought together |
| Return rate | How many sales come back, and what does each return cost? | Returns data by product or category |
| Strategic role | What does the line do for the brand and the range? | The positioning and the plan's objectives |
Contribution margin per sale is the first gate. Contribution MarginRevenue left after every cost that varies with each sale. is what a sale leaves once every cost that varies with it has been paid, and the contribution margin guide walks from revenue to that figure and on to the break-even return and cost per acquisition for each product group. The break-even calculator does the arithmetic. A line whose margin cannot pay for a customer at the prices the channels charge will not become profitable through better ads.
Existing demand decides whether marketing captures interest or has to create it. Capturing is cheaper and faster, so a line people already search for is usually the easier place to start.
Stock or capacity is a gate as well as a score. A line that will sell out, or a service the team cannot deliver more of, should not be pushed whatever its margin; the guide to planning marketing around capacity and stock covers how to match demand to what the business can supply.
Repeat and cross-sell potential changes the value of a first sale. Order history shows which first products lead to second orders and which are bought together; the GA4 merchandising analysis guide reads product funnels and basket behaviour from item-level data. A line with a strong Repeat Purchase RateShare of customers who placed more than one order in the period. or natural companions, the case for the phone that the cross-selling entry describes, can justify a higher cost per first order, but only with evidence about what customers go on to buy. That is a LTVTotal value a customer brings over time. judgement and needs the same care.
Return rate quietly removes margin. Ad platforms keep a returned order's value, so a line with a high Return RateShare of orders or units sold that customers sent back. can look best on return on ad spend and worst on profit. Use the return rate for the line, not the shop's average.
Strategic role is the judgement the numbers cannot make, covered in the next section.
To combine them, use a weighted scoring matrix. Agree the weights before scoring any line, treat must-haves such as a margin above break-even and stock to fulfil as pass-or-fail gates rather than heavy weights, back every score with its source, and re-run the ranking with other plausible weights. If the leading lines stay the same, the choice is robust; if they change, the decision turns on one judgement that can now be argued directly.
Roles: entry, hero, profit and clearance lines
Scores rank lines; roles say what each line is for. Most ranges need lines in four roles, and a line's role changes what success looks like for it.
| Role | What it does | How it is judged | Typical marketing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry | Brings in first purchases from new customers | New customers won, and what they buy next | Prospecting campaigns, first-order offers, starter sets |
| Hero | Defines the brand and what it is known for | Share of new customers, branded search, reviews, contribution | The lead creative, the home page, launch and seasonal campaigns |
| Profit | Earns the margin that funds the rest | Contribution after marketing | Capture of existing demand, cross-sells, email to past customers |
| Clearance | Turns stock that will not sell at full price into cash | Cash recovered against the alternative of writing it off | Short, contained campaigns aimed at bargain-seekers and existing customers |
Entry products lower the risk of a first purchase: a smaller, cheaper or easier item that introduces the brand. They often earn little on the first sale and are justified by what follows, so judge them on the second order, not the first. The kit for a new customer that the average order value levers guide describes is one form of entry product, and the paid trial sizes and sample packs in the guide to samples and trial sizes for online stores are another.
Heroes are the lines the business wants to be known for. They carry the creative, the reviews and the word of mouth, and they set expectations for everything else. A hero must be reliably in stock and good enough to carry the brand's promise; a hero that keeps selling out teaches customers to look elsewhere.
Profit lines sell to people who already know what they want, often at a good margin and with little need for prospecting. They benefit most from capture channels, cross-sells and email, and least from expensive awareness work.
Clearance lines have a different margin from the same product a month earlier, and the product lifecycle guide explains why clearance needs its own target, separate from the core range. Clearance should be contained, so it does not teach regular customers to wait for reductions. For an online store, the guide to clearing excess stock covers choosing the route, containing the clearance and keeping reference prices honest.
Within a single line, the good-better-best framework decides which version leads. Its middle tier is built for the main target segment and acts as the honest default, so it is usually the version that belongs in the lead creative, with the entry and top versions visible beside it.
Services businesses: which service to lead with
A services business faces the same choice with different evidence. Margin comes from the price against the time, materials and travel each job takes; capacity is staff hours and diary slots rather than stock; repeat potential is whether one job leads to the next.
Lead with the service that has the clearest demand, a margin that can pay for an enquiry at the conversion rate the business actually achieves, spare capacity to deliver, and a natural path to other work. That is often not the service the owner finds most interesting. A decorator might lead with a single-room job that people search for and that leads to whole-house work; an accountant might lead with a year-end service that brings in clients who later need payroll and advice.
Two cautions apply. A service that wins enquiries the business cannot schedule creates waiting lists and lost goodwill, so capacity gates the choice. And a service that is cheap to win but rarely leads anywhere should be priced and judged on its own margin, not on hopes of follow-on work the order history does not show.
Lines that should get no paid support
Some lines are better left to the website, owned channels and word of mouth. Deciding which ones, out loud, stops money drifting back to them by habit.
- Lines whose margin cannot carry a customer. If contribution per sale is below what a sale costs to win in the channels available, promotion loses money however well it is run.
- Lines eaten by returns and delivery. Bulky, fragile or frequently returned items can show healthy revenue and leave little after the costs that follow the sale.
- Lines that will run out. Promoting a product the business cannot restock in time wastes money and disappoints customers.
- Lines that sell without help. Spend on products customers already seek out by name may buy sales that would have happened anyway.
- Lines with no role. A product that is not an entry point, a hero, a profit line or a clearance line may not need marketing at all; it may need a decision about whether to keep it.
The hardest case is a line that reports a strong return on ad spend and still loses money. The diagnosis of a high ROAS that is not profitable traces the usual reasons: a target set without the margin, revenue counted before returns and discounts, conversions the platforms claim that would have happened anyway, budget concentrated on people already about to buy, and costs outside media left out. Each can apply to one line more than another. Rebuild the line's return from the ledger before deciding, and use the ROAS calculator to compare the return it needs at its own margin with the return it reports.
Turning the choice into channel plans
A product choice that stays in a spreadsheet changes nothing. It has to reach the places where products meet customers.
- Feeds and catalogue campaigns. Grouping, labels and targets inside Shopping and catalogue ads are where the choice becomes spend. The Shopping and catalogue ads guide covers margin-aware targets by product group, and the product lifecycle guide covers structure by stage. This guide supplies the decision those pages implement.
- Creative. Heroes lead; entry products feature in prospecting; profit lines appear in capture and email. Creative that shows the whole range at once usually sells none of it in particular.
- Landing pages. Each promoted line needs a page that answers the buyer's questions and shows the next step, including the cross-sells that make the line worth more.
- Search. Keywords and budgets follow the chosen lines; non-promoted lines are reached through the website and organic search rather than paid terms.
- Email and owned channels. Profit lines and companions to past purchases suit messages to existing customers, who cost nothing to reach.
- Budget. The split by line becomes part of the allocation, alongside the split by channel.
Write down each line's role, its target and the evidence behind it in one place, so the people building feeds, creative and campaigns are working from the same decision.
Reviewing the choice
Margins, demand, stock and returns move, so the choice needs a rhythm. Review it every quarter, with the same scores and weights, and outside the cycle whenever the range changes: a new line arrives, a supplier changes its prices, a line is discontinued or returns jump.
At each review, look for lines whose role has changed. An entry product whose customers stopped buying a second time is no longer doing its job. A hero that is out of stock more often than not is damaging the brand it was meant to carry. A profit line that now relies on discounts has become something else. And check the lines given no support: some may have gained demand or margin that earns them a place.
Keep the review short. One table, the change since last time, and a decision for each line that moved. The product choice should also agree with the other choices the strategy makes, from the segments it targets to the position it claims, which the strategy section covers one decision at a time: a hero that does not fit the positioning, or an entry product aimed at a segment the plan does not target, is a sign that one of the two needs revisiting.
An outdoor-gear shop picks its lead lines (illustrative)
An outdoor-gear shop scores its ranges
Dapplefinch Outdoor, an invented online outdoor-gear shop with about 600 products, spends £6,000 a month on Shopping and search ads. Spend has gathered around tents and sleeping bags, which have the longest sales history, while new customers mostly arrive through small items. The owner scores eight ranges on a 1 to 5 scale, with weights agreed first: contribution margin 30%, existing demand 20%, stock 15%, repeat purchase 15%, returns 10% and strategic role 10%. Two gates apply: margin per sale must clear the break-even cost of a sale in the shop's own account, and stock must cover the season.
| Range | Margin | Demand | Stock | Repeat | Returns | Role | Weighted score | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Waterproof jackets | 4 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 4.20 | Hero: lead creative and most of the budget |
| Insulated flasks | 3 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4.10 | Entry: prospecting and first-order offers |
| Walking socks | 4 | 3 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 2 | 4.00 | Profit: email and cross-sell only |
| Sleeping bags | 3 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2.85 | Reduced: capture searches only |
| Tents | 1 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 | 3 | 2.25 | Fails margin gate: no paid support |
Tents fail the margin gate. They sell for an average of £240 and contribute £61 before delivery and returns, but delivery averages £22 and about 1 in 6 is returned, each return costing around £60 in courier fees and resale loss, so contribution falls to about £29, below the £35 the account typically pays to win a tent sale. Their reported return on ad spend of 6.9 looked strong because returns and delivery never reached the platform's figures.
The plan takes the £2,700 a month that tents had been receiving and moves £1,800 of it to jackets and £900 to flask prospecting, keeps tents visible on the site and in organic listings, and uses the flask as the first-order product: about 40% of flask buyers place a second order within 6 months, against 18% of tent buyers. The weights are re-run with demand at 30% and margin at 20%; the top three ranges stay the same, so the choice holds. The next review is set for the start of the following quarter, or earlier if the tent supplier's delivery terms change.
Once a line takes the clearance role, the break-even calculator applied to stock clearance shows how much paid support it can carry and whether its stock is deep enough to need any.
Common mistakes
- Promoting the whole range equally. The money follows the channels' preferences instead of the business's.
- Choosing on revenue or reported ROAS alone. A line can lead on both and lose money once margin, delivery and returns are counted.
- Pushing lines that will sell out. Stock and capacity are gates, not afterthoughts.
- Judging entry products on their first sale. Their job is the second order; measure that.
- A hero that is often out of stock. The line meant to carry the brand teaches customers to go elsewhere.
- Setting weights after seeing the scores. Weights drift towards the favourite; agree them first.
- Leaving the decision out of feeds and creative. The choice changes nothing until it reaches the campaigns.
- Never revisiting it. Margins, demand and returns move; review every quarter and when the range changes.
