Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Comparisons

SWOT vs Five Forces

SWOT and the five forces model compared: what each looks at, what each hides, and how the forces feed a SWOT's opportunities and threats in a marketing plan.
Comparisonbeginner9 min readUpdated

SWOT and the five forces at a glance

The five forces framework treats a market as a set of pressures. Rivalry between existing competitors, the threat of new entrants, the threat of substitutes, the bargaining power of buyers and the bargaining power of suppliers each take a share of the value the market creates. Rated together, with evidence beside each rating, they explain why a category is cheap or costly to compete in. For a marketer those pressures surface as a rising CAC, dependence on platforms and intermediaries, constant discounting and customers lost at renewal. The model's blind spots are the business itself and the response: it describes the pressure on everyone in the market and leaves the choice of what to do to positioning, channel, retention and pricing decisions.

The SWOT framework is a sorting device. It places what a plan has to work with into internal strengths and weaknesses and external opportunities and threats, and its useful half is the pairing that follows: strengths matched with opportunities, weaknesses with threats, each written as a candidate strategy. Its blind spots are weight and evidence. Every entry gets the same box, nothing in the format asks for a source, and the external quadrants are only as good as the analyses that fed them.

So the relationship is one of supply. The forces are an input; SWOT is where inputs are summarised and turned into choices. The five forces page says as much in one line, that a high force becomes a SWOT threat with evidence attached, and this page sets out when each tool is the one to reach for. It does not re-teach either tool or the rival-by-rival study in the competitor analysis guide, which the forces sit beside.

Compare table

SWOT analysis vs Five forces analysis

Row labelSWOT analysisFive forces analysis
What it looks atThe business's position: inside and outside, helpful and harmfulThe structure of a market and the pressure it puts on price and margin
Unit of analysisOne business, or one decision that business facesOne market, defined by product, buyers and geography
Internal or externalBoth: strengths and weaknesses inside, opportunities and threats outsideExternal only; the analysing business is one participant among many
Evidence neededThe internal audit plus every external analysis the plan has runMarket evidence for each force: auction prices, intermediaries' share, entrants, fees, switching costs
OutputPairings that become candidate strategiesA rating per force, low to high, with its evidence and its marketing consequence
Time horizonThe plan's period, from the current position to the next cycleThe market's structure now, which moves slowly until a fee, entrant or substitute changes it
What it hidesThe weight of each entry and where its evidence came fromThe business's own strengths and weaknesses, the detail of any one rival, and what to do
Where it sits in a planEnd of the situation analysis, leading into objectives and strategyEarly in the situation analysis, as an input to the SWOT and to channel choices
Typical failureA grid of adjectives written from memory, never pairedRating only rivalry, with no boundary drawn and no evidence beside the ratings
Review cadenceEach planning cycle, and when a major change arrivesEach planning cycle, and sooner when a structural change hits the market

The rows on unit of analysis and output carry the comparison. The forces describe a market that every competitor shares, so two businesses in the same category could run the same forces review and reach the same ratings. They would never reach the same SWOT, because the pairing step sets those shared pressures against each business's own strengths. That is why the forces cannot replace a SWOT, and why a SWOT without some account of market structure tends to blame the business's own campaigns for pressure that comes from the market.

When to choose SWOT

Reach for SWOT when the plan needs to move from findings to choices. Once the audit, the competitor analysis, the environmental scan and any forces review exist, SWOT is where their conclusions are sorted and set against each other. The pairing produces candidate strategies with verbs, concentrate, defend, fix or exit, and the plan keeps the few that fit its objectives. The guide to writing a marketing plan is clear that the output is a short list of situations the plan must address, each with its evidence, not the grid itself.

SWOT also suits a focused decision with research already in hand: launching a product, entering a segment or changing a Go-to-Market Strategy approach. A SWOT built for that one decision keeps the strengths and weaknesses that matter to it and the opportunities and threats in the target market. The market entry and prioritisation guide uses a per-market SWOT in exactly this way, to refresh an assessment at a gate without re-running the full scoring.

SWOT is the wrong first tool when the business cannot explain why its costs are rising. If the threats quadrant reads "competition is getting tougher" with no account of where the pressure comes from, the grid will produce defensive strategies aimed at the wrong target.

When to choose the five forces

Reach for the five forces when something is squeezing the business that its own campaigns do not explain. The cost of winning a customer climbs while conversion rates hold; more sales arrive through comparison sites or marketplaces that take a share; new advertisers appear in the same auctions; a platform changes its fees or policies. Each is a market pressure, and the forces name which one it is. The answer matters because each force points at a different part of the plan: strong rivalry and substitutes are positioning problems, strong buyer power through intermediaries is a channel and retention problem, and strong supplier power is a concentration problem.

The forces also suit a decision about where to compete. Two candidate markets of the same size can carry very different pressure, and the market with fewer entrants, weaker intermediaries and no strong substitute is often the better first choice. A forces review here pairs naturally with a look at Unit Economics, because pressure on price and acquisition cost is pressure on what each customer is worth once won.

The forces are the wrong tool for deciding anything on their own. They rate the market, not the business, so they cannot say whether a pressure is something this company can turn to its advantage. A high buyer-power rating is a threat to a business that relies on intermediaries and an opening for one with strong direct relationships; only a SWOT holds the strengths that settle which.

Decision table

SituationUseWhy
Acquisition costs rising with no change in the business's own campaignsFive forcesIt names which market pressure is responsible
Turning research findings into strategic choices for the planSWOTIts pairing step produces candidate strategies
Starting the situation analysis for an annual plan in a crowded marketFive forces, then SWOTThe forces give the threats quadrant evidence
Comparing candidate markets of similar sizeFive forces for eachPressure on margin differs even where size does not
A focused decision with research already in handSWOT built for that decisionA narrow scope keeps the grid relevant
Regulation, technology or the economy shifting under the marketSee SWOT against PESTELThat is the wider-environment scan, not market structure
Turning the SWOT's choices into goals and trackingSee OKRs against KPIsThe analyses end where objectives begin

Feeding the forces into a SWOT

The hand-off follows the ratings. A force rated high, with evidence that holds up, enters the SWOT's external quadrants with that evidence attached: "buyers arriving through comparison sites now outnumber those arriving direct, and the sites rank largely on price" is a threat a plan can act on in a way that "competition is fierce" is not. Forces rated medium are given an owner who checks them at each planning review. Forces rated low are recorded with their evidence and left.

Whether a high force lands as a threat or an opportunity is decided in the SWOT, not in the forces review. The same force can be either depending on the business's strengths. Strong rivalry from look-alike entrants is a threat to a business with nothing distinctive and an opening for one with a brand customers already remember. So carry the force in neutrally, as a described pressure with its evidence, and classify it only when it sits next to the strengths and weaknesses.

Two other inputs join the forces in the external quadrants. The PESTEL framework covers the political, economic, social, technological, environmental and legal conditions that change the forces over time, and the competitor analysis supplies what named rivals are doing about the same pressures. A desk research pass often gathers the evidence for all three at once, organising the market findings by PESTEL and the forces so the summary feeds the situation analysis directly. Keep each SWOT entry labelled by its source, so a reader can see which threats come from market structure, which from the wider environment and which from a rival. All of this sits in the situation stage of the SOSTAC framework, before objectives are set.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A cycle shop chain explains its rising acquisition costs

Joskrevan Cycles, an invented chain of five cycle shops with an online store, sees its cost per new online customer rise from £31 to £47 over two years while its site conversion rate holds at 2.1%. Its draft SWOT lists "tougher competition" as the only threat. The marketing lead runs a five forces review first, with evidence beside each rating. Rivalry rates high: nine new advertisers now bid on the chain's main bike-category search terms. Buyer power rates high: 38% of new online customers arrive through a price-comparison site that charges £22 per sale. Supplier power rates medium: two brands make up 60% of bike revenue and have raised trade prices once. New entrants rate high, substitutes (bike subscriptions and second-hand marketplaces) medium. The rewritten SWOT carries three evidenced threats, comparison-site dependence, auction crowding and brand concentration, and pairs the first with a strength the review surfaced: workshop customers who buy again in store. The strategy that follows moves £18,000 a year from comparison-site bids into a service-plan email programme for workshop customers, with a target of cutting the comparison-site share to 25% within the year.

The comparison library lists the other pairs of strategy tools and measures that are easy to confuse.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the two as alternatives. The forces are an input; SWOT is where inputs become choices.
  • Writing the threats quadrant from memory. Without a forces review or a competitor analysis behind it, the threats reflect the loudest opinion in the room.
  • Rating only rivalry. Buyers, suppliers, entrants and substitutes often explain more of the pressure than the named competitors do.
  • Classifying forces as threats inside the forces review. Whether a pressure hurts or helps depends on strengths that only the SWOT holds.
  • Leaving the market boundary undefined. The forces ratings change with the definition; write it down before rating anything.
  • Stopping at either grid. Ratings and quadrants describe; the plan needs the pairings and the changes they lead to.
  • Copying last year's analyses forward. Both decay as entrants, fees and substitutes change; date them and revisit them each planning cycle.

Frequently asked questions

Which comes first, the five forces or SWOT?

When both are run, the five forces usually come first. The forces describe the pressure the whole market puts on price and margin, and their high-rated pressures are among the inputs a SWOT summarises, alongside the competitor analysis, the environmental scan and the internal audit. Running the forces first means the SWOT's threats quadrant arrives with evidence rather than from memory. A SWOT built for a narrow, quick decision can skip the forces if the market structure is well understood and has not changed.

Is a five forces analysis just the threats quadrant of a SWOT?

No. The forces feed the threats quadrant, and sometimes the opportunities quadrant, but they do more than list threats. They explain where pressure on margin comes from, including buyers, suppliers and substitutes that never appear on a list of competitors, and they rate each pressure with evidence. A SWOT then decides whether a given pressure is a threat or an opening for this particular business, which depends on its strengths and weaknesses, something the forces never look at.

Can a small business skip the five forces?

It can, if its market is stable and its costs of winning customers are steady. The forces earn their place when something is squeezing the business that its own campaigns do not explain: acquisition costs rising, more sales arriving through intermediaries that take a share, new competitors bidding for the same customers or a platform changing its terms. In those cases a short forces review, with evidence beside each rating, usually explains the squeeze faster than another round of campaign changes.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Also related

Related