What the five forces model is
The model is an industry analysis. Instead of asking what one competitor is doing, it asks how the structure of the whole market shares out value between the businesses in it, their customers, their suppliers and anyone who could replace them. When the forces are weak, a business can charge a fair price and keep a healthy margin. When they are strong, value leaks away: buyers push prices down, suppliers push costs up, rivals and entrants bid for the same customers, and substitutes cap what anyone can charge.
Marketing teams use it at two moments. The first is planning, when the situation analysis needs an account of the market that goes beyond a list of rivals. The second is a decision about where to compete, such as entering a new market, launching on a marketplace or choosing which segment to defend, where the pressure in each option matters as much as its size.
What the model makes visible is the source of pressure. A team that sees its cost per customer rising may blame its own campaigns, when the cause is a new wave of entrants bidding in the same auctions or a comparison site that now sits between it and most buyers. What the model hides is the detail of any one rival, which belongs to a proper competitor study, and anything about how to respond. It describes the weather, not the route.
The five forces
| Force | Question | Marketing evidence | What high pressure means for the plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rivalry among existing competitors | How hard do current competitors fight for the same buyers? | Rising auction prices, frequent promotions, shifts in share of voice, competitors copying offers | Acquisition gets dearer and differentiation matters more; price cuts invite matching cuts |
| Threat of new entrants | How easily can a new business start selling to these buyers? | New advertisers in paid auctions, new brands in marketplace results, low set-up costs, easy access to suppliers and channels | Any advantage that can be copied erodes fast; brand memory, customer relationships and owned channels are harder to copy |
| Threat of substitutes | What else could buyers use to get the same job done? | Searches for alternatives, lost sales to non-competitors, customers doing the job themselves | The message must argue against the alternative, not only against rivals, and the substitute sets a ceiling on price |
| Bargaining power of buyers | How much can buyers, or the intermediaries that gather them, dictate price and terms? | Share of customers arriving through comparison sites or marketplaces, price-led reviews, low switching costs, a few large accounts | Margin pressure, dependence on intermediaries and higher churn; retention and direct relationships matter more |
| Bargaining power of suppliers | How much can the businesses the company depends on dictate cost and terms? | Reliance on one advertising platform or marketplace, fee and policy changes, single-source inputs, scarce specialist partners | Costs are set elsewhere and can change overnight; channel concentration becomes a strategic risk |
Rivalry is the force marketers see first, because it shows up in their own numbers. A competitor gaining Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. or flooding a category with promotions raises the price of attention for everyone. Rivalry is usually fiercest when competitors are similar in size, products are hard to tell apart and growth in the category has slowed, so the only way to grow is to take buyers from someone else.
New entrants and substitutes are easy to miss because they are not yet on the list of competitors. Entrants arrive where starting up is cheap, which in many digital categories means almost everywhere. Substitutes are the alternatives buyers use instead of the category altogether, including doing nothing or doing the job themselves, and they set the price above which buyers simply walk away.
The two power forces are about who sits on either side of the business. Buyer power is high when customers are few and large, when switching is easy, or when an intermediary such as a marketplace or comparison site has gathered them and can sell access back. Supplier power, for a marketing team, includes the advertising platforms, marketplaces and data providers the business depends on as well as the suppliers of the product. Some intermediaries count on both sides, because they control the customer and charge for reaching them.
Applying it to a marketing plan
Begin by drawing the boundary of the market: which product, which buyers and which geography. The same business can face very different forces depending on where the line sits, so write the definition down and keep it fixed for the analysis. Then rate each force as low, medium or high, and attach the evidence for the rating. Ratings without evidence are opinions, and they tend to rate rivalry high and everything else low because rivalry is what the team talks about.
Next, translate each high rating into a marketing consequence. Strong rivalry and strong substitutes are positioning problems: the plan needs a difference that buyers value and a message that argues against the alternative they would otherwise choose. Sales teams often carry this in a BattlecardA short internal document that tells salespeople how to position against one named competitor in a deal. that sets out how to answer each rival and each substitute. Strong buyer power through intermediaries is a channel problem: the plan needs routes to customers that the business owns, and a retention programme so that customers won once are not bought again at full price. Strong supplier power is a concentration problem: the plan should reduce reliance on any single platform where it can, or at least model what happens if fees rise.
Most of these pressures meet in one number, the cost of winning a customer. When CACCost to acquire one new customer. is rising, the forces explain which pressure is responsible, and therefore which part of the plan should change. The competitor analysis guide supplies the evidence for rivalry and substitutes, rival by rival. The market sizing guide shows how large the obtainable market is once that pressure is taken into account, which is often smaller than the headline figure. For online retailers, the choice between selling on marketplaces and selling through your own store is largely a decision about buyer and supplier power, and that guide sets out the trade-offs in detail.
Worked example (illustrative)
A pet insurer reads the pressure on its acquisition costs
Tindlebrook Pet Insurance, an invented insurer, has seen its cost per new policy rise from £68 to £95 over two years, while 64% of new customers now arrive through comparison sites. A five forces review rates buyer power high: the comparison sites hold the customer, rank policies largely on price and charge £45 to £60 per sale. Supplier power is high too, because vets set the treatment prices that drive claims costs, which rose 11% last year. New entrants rate high, with four app-only insurers launching in eighteen months, each bidding on the same search terms. Substitutes, such as savings accounts set aside for vet bills, rate medium, and rivalry rates high. The insurer cannot change the industry, but it can change its exposure. It cuts comparison-site bids by 30% on its lowest-margin policies, moves £150,000 into partnerships with 120 vet practices that recommend it to new pet owners, and funds a renewal programme after finding that 22% of customers left at their first renewal. It reviews the ratings again in twelve months.
Limits and criticisms
The model is a static snapshot. It describes the forces at one moment, while markets move: an entrant scales, a platform changes its fees, a substitute catches on. An analysis that is not revisited hardens into a picture of a market that no longer exists, so date it and review it in each planning cycle.
The result depends heavily on where the market's boundary is drawn. Drawn too narrowly, substitutes look like outsiders and rivalry looks mild; drawn too broadly, every business in sight becomes a rival and the analysis says nothing useful. There is no correct boundary, only one that suits the decision being made, which is why the definition should be written down before any force is rated.
It ignores complements, platforms and cooperation. Many markets depend on products that make each other more valuable, on platforms that are supplier, channel and competitor at the same time, and on partnerships between businesses that also compete. The model treats every other party as a source of pressure, which can hide opportunities to cooperate and misread platform markets.
The ratings are judgements rather than measurements. Two teams with the same evidence can rate the same force differently, and the ratings are easily shaded towards what the team already believes. Writing the evidence beside each rating, and asking someone outside the team to challenge it, reduces but does not remove the bias.
Finally, the model describes pressure without saying what to do about it. It can show that buyer power is the main problem without telling a team whether to build an owned channel, change its pricing or leave the market. The response has to come from strategy work that the model only informs.
Related frameworks
The forces feed directly into the opportunities and threats of a SWOT analysis, where a high force becomes a threat with evidence attached. The PESTEL framework covers the wider political, economic, social, technological, environmental and legal conditions that change the forces over time, such as regulation that lowers barriers to entry. When the analysis is part of a decision about where to grow, the Ansoff matrix lists the growth directions, and the forces show how much pressure each candidate market would bring.
Common mistakes
- Rating only rivalry. The pressure that hurts most often comes from buyers, suppliers or substitutes that are not on the competitor list.
- Leaving the boundary undefined. Ratings change with the market definition, so write it down before scoring anything.
- Forgetting the platforms. Advertising platforms and marketplaces are suppliers and sometimes buyers; heavy dependence on one is a high force.
- Ratings without evidence. A force marked high needs the data that shows it, or it is the team's mood.
- Stopping at the diagnosis. Each high force should map to a change in positioning, channels, retention or pricing.
- Treating the analysis as permanent. Date it and review it each planning cycle, or sooner when a fee, entrant or substitute changes the picture.
