What news values are
Every newsroom is offered far more possible stories than it can run, so someone chooses. News values are the names for the qualities that tip that choice: the event is recent, it happened near the readers, it involves someone they know, it changes something for them, it is unusual, it involves disagreement, or it centres on a person they can identify with. No editor scores stories against a formal checklist, but these qualities explain most of what is selected and most of what is ignored.
For marketing and PR, the useful move is to apply the list before the newsroom does. Most failed pitches fail here rather than in the writing: the organisation had something it wanted to say, and nothing about it met any quality an editor selects for. The guide to media relations and pitching sets out what a journalist needs from a source, such as relevance, proof and access; news values come one step earlier and ask whether there is a story worth sourcing at all. The digital PR guide to campaign ideas and data stories generates the candidates; this framework is the filter they pass through before anyone spends money on them.
News values describe a story, not the coverage it will earn. The framework improves the odds that an idea deserves a pitch; it does not predict which titles will run it.
The values
The seven values below are the set most PR teams work from. Some newsrooms add others, such as exclusivity or the strength of the pictures, but these seven cover most of what decides selection.
| Value | Question an editor asks | How a brand story earns it |
|---|---|---|
| Timeliness | Why publish this now rather than last month or next? | A real change, new data, or a link to a moment readers already care about, such as a season or a policy coming into force |
| Proximity | Does this happen to, or near, our readers? | Regional cuts of national data, local people and places; for trade titles, closeness to the sector rather than to a place |
| Prominence | Is anyone involved someone our readers know? | A recognised organisation, a public figure or an expert with standing; rarely the brand itself unless it is already widely known |
| Impact | How many of our readers does this affect, and how much? | A change in cost, safety, time, rules or health that readers will feel, stated in their terms rather than the company's |
| Novelty | Is this new, unusual or contrary to what readers assume? | Original data, a genuine first, a finding that overturns received wisdom, or an unusual method |
| Conflict | Is there disagreement, competition or tension? | A credible position in a live debate, or evidence that settles one; never a quarrel manufactured for attention |
| Human interest | Is there a person whose experience readers can share? | A customer, employee or volunteer whose story illustrates something larger, told with consent and in their own words |
Two things about reading the table. First, the editor's question is always about the readers of that publication, not readers in general. Proximity for a regional paper is a town; for a trade newsletter it is the sector; for a hobby magazine it is the hobby. Second, the right-hand column is about earning each value with facts. A launch described as revolutionary has not earned novelty. A launch that does something nobody in the category has done, and can show it, has.
Testing a story idea
Run the test on every idea before money goes into research, design or distribution. Start by writing the story as a single sentence in the publication's own voice, the way it would appear as a headline or the first line of an article. Then work through the seven values and, for each, write down the specific fact in the idea that earns it, or leave the line blank. Vague answers do not count: "people care about this" is not impact, and "it is new for us" is not novelty. Ideas that sounded promising in a meeting often end up with one filled line and six blanks.
Next, match the strongest values to the target publications. A story with strong proximity for one region is a good regional story and a weak national one. A story whose impact falls on small-business owners belongs in the titles those owners read. This is where the test meets the media list: the values say what kind of story you have, and the list says who wants that kind.
Then decide. An idea that genuinely earns two or three values for the readers of named titles is worth developing. An idea that earns none should be dropped or honestly improved, and honest improvements are often available:
- Timeliness comes from tying the story to a moment that matters to its subject, such as a season, a rule change or a related publication, rather than to the company's internal calendar.
- Proximity comes from cutting national data by region or by sector, so that each title receives the slice its readers live in.
- Impact comes from translating a finding into what changes for the reader: money, time, risk or comfort.
- Human interest comes from finding the person the story happened to and asking their permission.
- Novelty comes from answering a question nobody has answered with data, often using data only the organisation holds.
Inflating a weak finding, implying a conflict that does not exist or presenting old news as new does not count as improvement.
Launch announcements need the test most, because they are written from inside the company. The page on PR as a product launch channel sets out when a launch is news and when it belongs in the changelog; running the seven values is the quickest way to tell which case you are in. When a story passes, the guide to press releases and the online newsroom covers writing it up, and the press release template puts the value the story earns into the headline and the lead paragraph.
Digital PR adds a search consideration. A BacklinkA link from another site to yours. from coverage exists only if a publication runs the story, so a weak idea fails twice: no coverage and no link. Ideas built on proximity tend to travel furthest, because each regional or sector cut of the same data extends ReachUnique people who saw an ad. without a new study.
Worked example (illustrative)
A hedgehog rescue charity tests three story ideas
Hedgewyck Rescue Trust, an invented hedgehog rescue charity, has budget for one press push before summer and three ideas. The first is an appeal for volunteers. Run against the seven values, it earns none clearly: nothing has changed, few readers are affected and nobody new is involved. The second is a profile of a volunteer who has nursed animals for 20 years, which earns human interest and nothing else, so it suits a magazine feature rather than news. The third uses the charity's own intake records: 1,840 garden rescues over 3 years, logged by area and by cause. Released in late May, ahead of the months when strimmer and netting injuries peak, it earns timeliness. Cut into 14 area summaries, it gives each local paper its own figure, which earns proximity. Pairing each area's injury count with one practical step for gardeners earns impact. The charity pitches the data study, keeps the profile for a magazine, and moves the volunteer appeal to the closing paragraph of every version. Of the 14 local titles, 9 run their area's figures, and the appeal is printed in 6 of those stories.
Limits and criticisms
The lists are not fixed. Different newsrooms work from different lists, the weight of each value shifts with the format and the audience, and online publishing adds pressures of its own, such as whether a story is likely to be searched for or shared. Treat the seven values as a shared vocabulary for discussing an idea, not a scoring system with a pass mark.
News values describe what editors select, not what serves the brand. A story can be rich in conflict and human interest and still say nothing about why anyone should choose the organisation, or tie the brand to a subject it would rather not be known for. The test answers whether something is news. Whether it is the right news, and whether the coverage would move Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. in the conversations the plan cares about, is a separate judgement made against the objectives.
Manufacturing a value damages trust. Conflict invented for a headline, novelty claimed for something routine and urgency created by an artificial deadline all work against the sender once a journalist sees through them, and the cost is a name whose next email is read with suspicion.
A strong story can still miss. An idea can carry three values and still not suit a particular publication, because the title ran something similar last week, because its readers are not the people the story affects, or because a bigger story breaks on the same morning. The values are close to a necessary condition for coverage, never a sufficient one, which is why the media list, the timing and the pitch still matter.
Finally, the framework can pull a team toward stories that are easy to place rather than stories that build something. Use the values to sharpen stories that serve the strategy, not to choose the strategy.
Related frameworks
News values decide whether there is a story; other frameworks in this library shape how it is told. The inverted pyramid orders the release and the pitch so that the value the story earns sits in the first lines, which is where an editor decides. The features, advantages and benefits framework helps when the story is a product, by turning what the product does into what changes for the reader, which is usually where impact is found. AIDA applies to the pitch email itself, which has to win attention and interest in the story before it asks the journalist for anything.
Common mistakes
- Testing after building. The values are cheapest to apply while the idea is still a sentence.
- Treating the brand as prominence. Unless readers already know the organisation, its name adds nothing; a recognised expert or partner might.
- Mistaking internal dates for timeliness. An anniversary or a sales quarter matters to the company, not to readers.
- Sending one version everywhere. Proximity changes with the publication, so national data pitched unchanged to regional titles wastes the value it could earn.
- Inventing conflict. A disagreement staged for attention is found out, and the sender's credibility goes with it.
- Stating impact in company terms. "Our most advanced release yet" is not impact; what changes for the reader is.
- Counting coverage instead of fit. A story that ran in titles the audience never reads passed the news test and failed the plan.
