Why reactive comment stalls at approval
Reactive comment answers news the organisation did not make: a published report, a change in the rules, a spell of bad weather, a rival's launch, a question a writer puts out to sources. Because the story is someone else's, reactive commentComment a spokesperson gives on news the organisation did not make, such as a report or a rival's launch, fast enough to be used and within agreed positions. runs to the journalist's deadline rather than the organisation's own timetable. The campaign ideas and data stories guide lists what it takes: spokespeople who are briefed and know their topics, a short path to approval, and a store of the organisation's own data that can be searched quickly. The digital PR for links guide adds an expert able to answer fast, a short list of the journalists who cover the field and a habit of watching for stories that want comment. Both lists assume that the organisation already knows what it thinks, and neither guide writes that part down.
Without that, each request opens an argument. The spokesperson drafts a view, the approver questions a phrase, a colleague in another team worries about customers, someone asks whether legal should see it. Each question is fair; together they outlast the deadline. The PR agency guide names the remedy: a quicker route for comment on the news, resting on subjects and positions settled beforehand, while anything involving a crisis, a legal question or a regulator stays on the organisation's own escalation route. This tutorial writes those positions.
A position, in this sense, is the organisation's considered view on an issue that other people make news about, written down with the reasoning behind it, the proof that supports it and the things it will not say, and approved once. A holding statementA brief first public response in a crisis that acknowledges the issue, tells affected people what to do now and says when more will follow. is something else: the brief opening words a crisis team prepares for the moment before the facts are in. Nor is it the messaging house, which sets out what the organisation says about itself and its offer; a position is about the debate in the field, where the organisation is one voice among several. And when the news is the organisation's own, such as a closure or a price rise, the guide on announcing bad news to the press takes over.
Positions serve both halves of a PR programme. The comparison of digital and traditional PR counts positions on issues among the stories traditional PR tells, and quick reactive work among digital PR's ways of reaching writers. One written position can supply a quick quote for a news site and a considered paragraph for a trade feature.
Before you start
- Read the PR plan. The PR plan tutorial asks for the subjects the organisation can credibly comment on, a spokesperson for each and how fast comment can be approved. If that list exists, test it against the issues the titles raise in the first step; if it does not, this tutorial produces it.
- Name a sponsor. Positions need someone with authority over the subjects they cover, such as the owner, the managing director or a functional head, who will make the final call and hold the approval meeting.
- Gather the proof. The messaging house, the approved facts and the organisation's own data are the raw material. Find out who owns each source before a position leans on it.
- Read the escalation rules. Know the triggers in the crisis planThe short document a team opens when a situation outruns the routine: triggers, who decides and speaks, first-hour actions, holding statements and a log. and who owns legal and regulatory questions, so the positions can say where they stop.
- Book time with the experts. The people who will speak should help write the positions, or the words will not sound like theirs under questioning.
The steps
List the issues your target titles keep returning to
Start from the titles on the media listThe researched list of journalists, outlets and hosts an organisation pitches stories to, recording each one's beat, audience and recent coverage., not from what the organisation would like to talk about. Read their recent coverage and note the debates they keep coming back to, the questions they ask experts, the stories that recur with the seasons and the arguments that run without much evidence. Add what monitoring already catches: the media monitoring and coverage reporting guide gives monitoring a second job beyond the organisation's own coverage, following rival organisations and the issues that matter to the organisation through competitor and topic queries. Social listeningMonitoring public conversation about a brand, its category, competitors and the problems it solves, away from the brand's own accounts. shows how the same issues are argued in public, and writers' published requests for sources show what they could not find. Write each issue as the question a journalist would put to a source, such as "why do costs keep rising" or "is this rule working", and note where it came up.
Decide where the organisation has standing to comment
Test each issue before writing anything. Does the organisation have expertise, data or first-hand experience that a reader would value? The news values framework gives a sharper test: a brand earns conflict with a credible stance in a debate that is still live, or with evidence that ends one, and impact with what changes for the title's readers. The campaign ideas guide adds a plain rule for comment on the news: send it only if it would help the journalist's readers once the brand name is taken out. Sort the issues into three groups. Those where the organisation has standing get a position. Those where it has none get a short line recording that it will not comment, and why, so the question is not reopened under deadline. Those involving a crisis, lawyers or a regulator go to their owners and stay out of this routine.
Write each position with its reasoning and proof
For each issue with standing, write the view in one plain sentence a spokesperson could say aloud. Under it, write the reasoning: why the organisation holds this view, what it has seen, what it would want readers to understand. Then attach the proof. Facts and figures come from the claims libraryA record of every marketing claim in its exact approved wording, with the evidence behind it, the conditions and markets it is approved for and the approver., which the claims library tutorial builds with the exact approved wording, the evidence and the conditions for each claim, so a quote never carries a number nobody has checked. Where the organisation's own data supports the view, record which data, from when, and who can query it; a study repeated each year, which the annual study tutorial walks through, refreshes a position's proof with every edition. Name the strongest argument on the other side and why the organisation still disagrees; a position that ignores the debate falls at the first follow-up question. Keep it short enough to read while a journalist waits on the line.
Mark what the position will not say
Every position needs edges. Write down what the spokesperson will not discuss under it and the polite words for saying so: named competitors, individual customers or clients, the terms of any contract, predictions the data cannot support, the motives of other organisations, and anything with lawyers or a regulator involved. The edges protect the fast route as well as the organisation: comment that stays inside them can go quickly, and comment that crosses them is, by definition, a new decision that takes the normal route.
Name the spokesperson and the approver for each position
Match each position to the spokespersonThe person an organisation names to speak to journalists on its behalf, briefed on likely questions and on what they can and cannot say. who knows the subject best, not to the most senior person, and name a deputy who has read and rehearsed it. Then name one approver. A RACI matrix helps here: it allows exactly one accountable role on each row, and it treats every consulted role as a possible delay, because work waits for their input. Write a short matrix with one row per position, marking who drafts it, who signs it off, whose advice is needed before sign-off and who simply hears the outcome. Anyone consulted gives their view while the position is being written, not on the day a journalist calls.
Approve each position once, in advance
Hold the full review now, while nothing is urgent. The approver reads each position with its proof and its edges, the subject owners confirm the facts, and legal or compliance review it only where the subject needs it. Record who approved it, when, and exactly what the approval covers: comment that stays within the position's view, uses its proof in the approved wording and respects its edges. The approval does not cover a new figure, a named party, a change of view or a different subject. Written down, the approver's judgement becomes something the PR lead can apply without ringing them.
Set the fast route for comment inside a position
The PR programme playbook asks the business to agree which statements the PR lead may give without going back to the approvers, among them facts already public and lines already agreed. Approved positions are those lines. Write the fast route down: comment that falls inside a position goes out with the PR lead's sign-off, or that of the PR lead's named deputy when the PR lead is away; comment that falls outside goes through the normal approval route at whatever speed it can manage. The social media approval workflow builds a fast lane on social, with pre-approved lines for replies and a named approver on the day for reactive posts, and sends any post that involves a claim, a price or a sensitive topic back to its normal check. Social posts stay in that lane; positions cover what spokespeople tell journalists. Write down when the fast route stops altogether: when the news concerns the organisation itself, when a crisis trigger is met, or when the question moves into legal or regulatory ground.
Brief spokespeople and put the positions where enquiries land
Prepare each spokesperson on their positions as the tutorial on preparing a spokesperson prepares them for an interview: likely and difficult questions with honest answers, rehearsed aloud. It notes that an expert comment can rest on nothing more than a clear view with its reasons, which is what a position supplies. Then put the positions where requests arrive. In the routine for handling media enquiries, three steps call for a decision on every request: whether to respond at all and in what form, who answers, and who approves. A position settles all three before the call, so keep the positions beside the enquiry log, give a copy to any agency pitching on the organisation's behalf, and note in the story bankThe PR plan's list of stories the organisation could offer, each with audience, message, proof, titles, spokesperson and materials, tested for news value. any issue where a position could also become a planned story.
Review positions when the facts or the debate change
A position is only as good as its proof and its fit with the current debate. Review it when the organisation's own data changes, when new research or a rule change moves the argument, when the organisation's own practice changes, when a spokesperson leaves, when a quote under it came out badly, and ahead of any date already in the sector's calendar, such as a rule coming into force. Rewrite and reapprove it, or withdraw it and tell everyone holding a copy, including any agency. In the coverage log, whose campaign or story field marks pieces as reactive, check: were the positions used, did the fast route hold, and which requests fell outside every position? The page on PR for brand awareness describes a standing programme of expert comment, with a named expert, a short list of topics and a quick way to respond; reviewed positions are what keep such a programme honest from one news story to the next.
What a position holds
Keep every position in one shared document with the same parts, so the PR lead can tell at a glance whether a request falls inside one.
| Part | What it records | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Issue | The question journalists ask, in their words, and where it came up | Shows the position answers a real request, not an internal wish |
| View | One plain sentence the spokesperson can say aloud | The quote a journalist can use as it stands |
| Reasoning | Why the organisation holds the view, and the strongest argument against it | Survives the follow-up question |
| Proof | Approved claims and the organisation's own data, with their owners | Keeps unchecked numbers out of quotes |
| Edges | What the spokesperson will not discuss, and the words for declining | Marks where the fast route ends |
| Spokesperson and deputy | Who speaks on this issue, and who covers | Matches expertise to the subject |
| Approver and date | Who signed it off, when, and what the approval covers | Lets the PR lead act without ringing the approver |
| Fast route | Who may sign off comment inside the position | Turns the approval into speed |
| Review triggers | The changes that send it back for rewriting | Stops an old view being quoted as current |
A position that runs to pages probably covers several issues and should be split.
A business waste collector prepares its positions (illustrative)
Skardivex Waste agrees its positions
Skardivex Waste, an invented collector of general waste and recycling from 1,400 offices and shops, has an operations director who is quoted now and then and a managing director who approves every quote personally. Twice in one winter a trade writer's request expired while the quote waited for sign-off.
The PR lead reads 6 months of coverage in the 5 trade and regional titles on its media list and finds 4 issues that keep coming back: missed collections in bad weather, contamination in mixed recycling, the rising cost of collection and fly-tipping. Skardivex decides it has standing on 3. On fly-tipping enforcement it has no data and no role, so it records a line saying it does not comment on enforcement and refers writers to the authorities responsible.
Each position is written with its reasoning and the company's own collection data. The contamination position, for instance, says that rejected loads come mainly from a few familiar mistakes that customers can fix, backed by its records showing 18% of mixed recycling loads rejected at the sorting site last year. The edges for every position rule out any council's contract and any named competitor.
The operations director becomes spokesperson on missed collections and costs, and the head of recycling on contamination, each with a deputy. The managing director approves all 3 positions in one 90-minute meeting, and the RACI records that comment inside a position needs only the PR lead's sign-off.
In February a storm disrupts collections across the region. At 10:00 a trade writer asks for comment by 14:00. The PR lead checks the request against the missed-collections position, signs off a 3-sentence quote from the operations director at 11:15, and the piece runs that afternoon with the quote in full.
By the summer a customer guide has cut rejected loads to 12%, so the head of recycling rewrites the contamination position with the new figure, the managing director reapproves it, and the old version is withdrawn from the shared folder and from the agency's copy.
Common mistakes
- Starting from what the organisation wants to say. Positions answer the questions the titles already ask.
- A view on everything. Record the issues the organisation will not comment on, and why.
- No edges. Without them, every quote is a new decision and the fast route collapses.
- Unchecked proof. Figures come from the claims library or a named data owner, never from memory.
- Consulting on the day. Advice is given while the position is written, not while the journalist waits.
- Approving without saying what the approval covers. The PR lead needs to know where the fast route ends.
- Using a position in a crisis. Once a crisis trigger is met, the position is set aside and the crisis plan leads.
- Never reviewing. A position built on last year's figures is a correction waiting to happen.
The digital PR hub sets reactive comment beside the planned campaigns that supply the data positions draw on.
