Why a repeated study can earn more than a new one
The campaign ideas and data stories guide ranks a refreshable asset, an annual index for example, above a one-off piece, because every refresh hands journalists a fresh story. The digital PR for links guide goes further in its section on assets that keep working: an annual index or a recurring ranking can become something journalists expect and cite, and the price it names is consistency. The comparison of digital and traditional PR shows the same index serving both disciplines, pitched online as a data story and briefed to trade editors as well.
Three things separate a second edition from a fresh study. It carries a comparison: this year against last, the year-on-year comparisonComparing a period with the same period a year earlier, aligned by weekday and by holidays that move, so that the seasonal pattern drops out of the change. that a single study cannot offer. It carries a record: the last edition's coverage shows which writers found the data worth using and which angles worked. And it carries a page: the address that the last edition's coverage points to.
Each advantage can be lost. An edition that cannot be compared with the last is a new study wearing an old name; one that repeats last year's finding has nothing to pitch; one published at a new address strands the old coverage. Tests of whether a change between editions is statistically meaningful, sample sizes and weighting are for a trained researcher, and no page on this site sets how many editions a series needs.
Before you start
- The last edition's record: source and extract, definitions and filters, period, boundaries, any questionnaire, the analysis files and the method note as published.
- The last edition's coverage log and campaign plan, the log showing each piece's writer, angle, cut and link.
- The permanent page, its address and its owner.
- The people: the analyst who produced the figures, or their notes; whoever owns data protection, if customer data is used; and the spokesperson who will defend the findings.
The steps
Decide whether the study deserves another year
Start with the evidence, not the habit. Read the last edition's coverage log for fit rather than volume: did the pieces run in titles the audience reads? Then ask whether the question still matters to those readers, whether the same data can be gathered again on the same terms, and whether someone can own the series this year and the next. A question that mattered for one season may serve better as the seed of a new idea than as a series. Record the decision and its reasons in this edition's copy of the digital PR campaign plan template; each edition gets its own plan, started from the last one.
Keep the series comparable as the survey wave SOP and brand tracker tutorial set out, and say in the method note what changed
Two pages own the method of keeping a repeated measurement comparable, and this tutorial does not restate them. For a survey, each edition is a survey waveOne round of fieldwork in a repeated survey or tracker, drawn, worded and coded the same way as earlier rounds so the results can be compared over time., and the customer survey wave SOP sets out what stays fixed and when a change starts a new series. The brand tracker tutorial covers freezing a questionnaire and logging every change. A study built on the organisation's own data or a public dataset applies the same idea to its definitions, filters, period and boundaries.
Where a change cannot be avoided, because a category has grown, a source has been revised or a question turned out to be unclear, make it deliberately. New survey wording is designed with the survey and questionnaire design guide and tried on people from the audience with the questionnaire pretest tutorial, which also catches a leading questionA survey or interview question whose wording contains or suggests its expected answer, producing measurement bias rather than evidence. before it reaches the sample. The campaign ideas guide points to research codes on sampling, question wording and reporting from the Market Research Society and ESOMAR, and asks that any survey meant for publication be planned with that standard in view or by someone trained in it; that holds for each edition of a survey sent to the press, not only the first.
The PR side of this step is the method note. Each edition's note carries a short section on what changed since the last: what, why, from which edition, and how earlier figures were treated. A journalist who used last year's figure should be able to see at once whether this year's can be set beside it.
Keep one permanent page with every edition dated
The microsites and multiple domains guide argues that a series repeated each year, an index or a survey, gains more from one fixed address that each edition updates than from a fresh domain every year, and the campaign ideas guide asks for assets to sit on the organisation's own site. As the digital PR hub records, Google's SEO Starter Guide names links from other websites as one route by which search engines find a page and work out what it covers; a single address means every edition's coverage points to the same place.
Put the newest edition at the top, with its date, its headline finding and its method note one click away. Keep every earlier edition below it with its own date and method note, and never overwrite an old figure. The guide to updating and correcting content gives the house rules for the page itself: the published date stays, the updated date moves, and a short note says what the new edition added. If an error turns up in an earlier edition, correct it openly with a dated note rather than quietly.
Run the analysis and compare like with like
Repeat last year's analysis step by step before adding anything new, on the same period of the year, the same definitions and the same boundaries. Where a definition changed, recalculate last year's figure the new way if the data allows, and say in the method note that the comparison uses the recalculated figure; where it does not allow it, show both and say why they cannot be set side by side.
Read the count behind every figure before calling anything a movement. In the guide to reading small numbers, a rate built from a handful of records can swing from period to period with nothing changed, and the top and bottom places in a ranking fill up with the units that have the least data. A regional league table is exactly that kind of ranking, so a small region that jumps several places has to be checked before it is pitched. Check every figure in the release against the analysis as well; if one turns out wrong after the release has gone, the tutorial on correcting a sent release takes over.
Find this year's story, including a flat or reversed result
Write the headline before writing anything else, as the campaign ideas guide asks, and test it against the news values of the titles you will pitch. That guide also asks for a campaign with a story in most plausible results, and a series has to meet that test every year. The story can sit in several places:
- A change: a rise, a fall or a ranking reshuffled.
- A reversal: last year's direction turned round, which is new precisely because last year's finding was reported.
- A figure that held when readers would have assumed it moved.
- A part against the whole: one region, segment or category moving the other way.
- A new cut that this year's data supports and last year's did not.
What the story cannot be is a movement the small-numbers reading says is noise. If last year's headline finding has reversed, say so plainly and early: the writers who printed it can set the two editions side by side, and an edition that buries the reversal invites a worse story. A finding that holds up can serve between editions too, as the evidence behind the positions the organisation agrees in advance for reactive comment.
Return first to the writers who used the last edition
The last edition's coverage log is the first page of this edition's target list. Each writer who used the data can be told something specific: what changed since their piece, and above all whether a figure they printed has moved.
Decide who hears first. The writer whose piece did most for the last edition may be offered this one as a media exclusiveA story offered to one writer or title first and alone, used when one prominent piece is worth more than several smaller ones., with the terms agreed before anything is shared, as the media relations and pitching guide sets out; never offer the same exclusive to two writers. Other returning writers hear before the wider release, with a note in their own terms. A writer who used last year's data without citing it can receive one polite request for a link to the permanent page, as the checklist allows, and a backlinkA link from another site to yours. is never made the condition of the story. Only then does the wider, segmented list follow.
Refresh the regional and trade cuts
Cut the new edition the way the last one was cut, with the same boundaries, so that each regional title can report its own area's change rather than a fresh ranking with no history. Re-read each cut for its count: a region thin enough to swing on a handful of records gets its figure and a caution rather than a headline, and a cut so small that it could identify a person or a client comes out, as the checklist's data lines require. The trade pressThe newspapers, magazines and sites that cover one sector for the people who work in it, read by its decision-makers and used in PR, advertising and research. wants the detail behind the headline, such as the category split or the method change, so give trade writers that cut rather than the consumer headline.
Replace and date every chart image, so that last year's is never sent as this year's, then run the digital PR data story checklist before the first pitch, as if the study were new.
Log coverage against the last edition and decide on the next
Record each piece in the coverage logThe consistent record of every piece of coverage, by title, tier, story, prominence, message, sentiment and link, from which PR measures are counted., using the fields that the monitoring and reporting guide lists and one more for the edition. Then compare editions by title and by kind of piece rather than by a single total: which returning writers used it, which new ones found it, which regional and trade titles ran a cut, and how many pieces linked to the permanent page. Put the strongest pieces to work, while the data is current, as the coverage reuse guide describes.
Close with the decision on the next edition, using the questions from the first step with this year's evidence. Stop when the question no longer matters to the readers the study was built for, when the data can no longer be gathered on the same terms, or when nobody can own the series. Stopping is done openly: a dated note on the permanent page says the series has ended, and every edition stays where coverage can still find it.
What each edition's page, release and pitch carry over
Each edition is part repetition and part fresh work, and the table keeps the two apart.
| Element | Carried over unchanged | New in each edition |
|---|---|---|
| The question the study answers | Its wording and scope | Nothing, unless the series is deliberately restarted |
| Data source, definitions, period and boundaries | All of them | Only the changes the method note records |
| Method note | Its structure and its record of earlier changes | A section on what changed since the last edition |
| Permanent page | The address, earlier editions and their dates | The newest edition at the top, an updated date and a short note |
| Headline | Nothing | Written from this edition's finding and tested again |
| Release | Its structure, contacts and notes to editors | The finding, the quote and this edition's method note |
| Pitch | The order: returning writers first | The finding and what changed since each writer's piece |
| Regional and trade cuts | The boundaries and segments | The figures, and any cut now too thin to read |
| Chart images | Style, labelling and dating | The data |
| Coverage log | Its fields | A field for the edition, and the comparison with the last |
A used-car marketplace repeats its price index (illustrative)
Motrevalia Cars publishes the second edition of its regional price index
Motrevalia Cars, an invented online marketplace for used cars, published the first edition of its regional price index a year ago: the average asking price of cars listed in each of 12 regions over the 12 months to September, from 186,000 listings, with every region up on the year before. It earned 14 pieces, the first in the motoring section of a national consumer site.
For the second edition the analyst repeats the same extract: the 12 months to September again, the same 12 regional boundaries and the same filters, which leave out test listings and cars listed for fewer than 3 days. This time 203,000 listings qualify. One change is made. Electric cars, 7% of listings against 3% a year earlier, are now reported as a separate figure, because in its own listings their higher asking prices had started to lift the averages in the regions where they are listed most. The method note records the change, the edition it took effect in and last year's figures recalculated without electric cars, so that the main index compares like with like: the national average for other cars moves from £11,840 to £11,920.
The new edition goes at the top of the same page with an updated date and a note; the first edition stays below it.
The regional ranking barely moves: the same region is dearest and the same region cheapest, and 10 of the 12 regions move by less than 2%. The analyst flags the 2 smallest regions, each with fewer than 6,000 listings, as the ones most likely to swing by chance. The story is in a large region where average prices fell by 3%, the first fall in any region since the index began. The headline is tested for novelty and proximity, and the finding is offered first, with a day's head start, to the motoring writer who covered the first edition, with a line on what changed since that piece.
The regional cuts are refreshed for all 12 regions, the 2 smallest with their counts but no ranking line, and a motor trade title gets the electric car split.
The coverage log records 12 pieces against 14 for the first edition: 5 by writers who had covered the first, 3 in trade titles against 1, and 10 linking to the index page. The team agrees a third edition with the same boundaries and the electric car figure kept separate, and writes that decision into next year's campaign plan.
Common mistakes
- A new page for every edition. Keep one permanent address and date each edition on it.
- A quiet change of method. Every change goes in the method note, with what it did to the earlier figures.
- Comparing a new definition with an old figure. Recalculate where the data allows; otherwise say why the two cannot be compared.
- Calling noise a trend. Read the count behind each figure, and keep small regions out of the headline.
- Burying a reversal. Report it plainly, and tell the writers who printed last year's finding first.
- Pitching the old list cold. Returning writers hear first, with what changed since their piece.
- Reusing last year's cuts and charts unchecked. Re-cut, re-count and re-date every one.
- Running the series on habit. Decide each year whether it still deserves another edition, and stop openly when it does not.
