Why businesses end up with several sites
Extra sites usually arrive for organisational reasons rather than because searchers asked for them:
- Acquisitions. The bought company keeps its domain because nobody has decided what happens to its brand, and the decision drifts for years. The tutorial on combining marketing after a merger or acquisition puts that brand decision first and times the site merge after it.
- Brand teams. Each product brand gets a domain because its team owns a budget and wants a site it controls. Whether the brands should be separate at all is the subject of the brand architecture guide; this guide takes that decision as an input and asks what follows for search.
- Campaigns. Launches, competitions, events and data stories are built on new domains because a fresh domain is quicker than a slot in the main site's release process.
- Agencies and vendors. A partner's platform publishes on its own domain by default, and the arrangement outlives the contract.
- Defensive registrations. Misspellings and alternative endings bought to protect the brand. These are harmless as long as they redirect to the main site and never publish content of their own.
None of those reasons concerns the person searching. That is why an inventory of a group's sites tends to show the same subjects covered several times over, by teams who never compared notes, and why the first job in any review is simply to list every domain the business owns and who is responsible for each.
What separate domains cost in search
A separate domain is not penalised for being separate. The cost is that nothing is shared by default: each site builds its own standing from nothing and pays its own running costs.
| Cost | What happens | Where it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Links are split | A BacklinkA link from another site to yours. earned by the campaign site supports that site; the main site benefits only through whatever links the campaign site passes on | The main site's key pages gain nothing from coverage the campaign earned |
| Content is split | Two or three thinner pages on one subject instead of one complete page | Several of your domains ranking modestly for the same query |
| Navigation does not join them | Links between your own domains are ordinary links between sites, not the navigation of one site | Visitors and crawlers reach the smaller sites mainly through the few links pointing at them |
| Upkeep multiplies | Hosting, certificates, software updates, legal pages, accessibility, analytics and a Search Console property for each domain | Neglected sites with expired offers, broken pages and outdated prices |
| Measurement fragments | Sessions, conversions and queries spread across properties nobody reads together | No single view of what search does for the business |
| Brand searches divide | A branded searchSearch queries that contain a company's or product's brand name. returns several of your sites, and the searcher has to work out which one is official | Group and brand domains alternating for the company's own name |
The upkeep row is the one that hurts slowly. A campaign site launched with care is rarely maintained with care: its offers expire, its links break, its software goes unpatched and eventually its registration lapses. A lapsed domain with a history of links attracts people who buy such names to repurpose them, which Google's spam policies describe as expired domain abuse when the purpose is to manipulate rankings. Keeping your own domains registered and redirected is the simplest protection, for your visitors as much as for your rankings.
When a separate site is justified
A separate site earns its place when it serves people the main site cannot serve well. The common legitimate cases are these:
- A genuinely separate brand. Brand architecture has decided that customers should not connect the brand with the parent, for instance a premium range that must not borrow the meaning of a value range. The site then exists for the brand's own customers and is planned as a whole site, not as a campaign.
- A separate audience with separate needs. A trade portal for distributors, with its own catalogue, prices and accounts, may sit better apart from a consumer site, although a section of the main site often works as well.
- Legal or regulatory separation. A product sold by a separately regulated entity may need its own site, terms and disclosures.
- A separate platform. A web application, a community or a store run on another system, where the subfolder versus subdomain comparison decides where it lives under the same brand.
Four questions test any proposal for a new domain. Would a customer be confused or put off if this content sat on the main site? Is there a named owner who will maintain it for as long as it exists, including after the campaign or the product has ended? Will it target queries the main site does not already target? Will it have content, and a reason for others to link to it, that the main site lacks? If the answers are mostly no, the content belongs in a section of the main site, planned with the site architecture guide.
Overlap between your own sites
Once there are several sites, the same subjects appear on more than one of them and the sites compete. This is keyword cannibalisationTwo or more pages on one site competing for the same query and intent, splitting signals. across domains. The symptoms are the same as within one site, two pages alternating for a query with neither doing well, with one extra complication: the pages belong to different teams, so nobody owns the fix. The cannibalisation guide explains how to judge whether two pages compete and how to consolidate them; the cross-domain version needs the same reader test plus an agreement between the owners.
To find overlap, export the queries from each site's Search Console property for the same period, join them on the query, and list every query where two or more of your domains earn impressions. Sort by impressions and read the top of the list with each page open. Some overlap is expected: a brand site and a group site may both appear for the brand's name, and the brand site should usually be the one that leads. Overlap on product, problem and category queries is the expensive kind.
Duplicated text is the second form of overlap: the same product descriptions on a brand site and the group's shop, or one guide republished on two domains. Google's documentation on consolidating duplicate URLs describes how to indicate the preferred version, with a Canonical TagTells search engines the preferred URL. or a redirect, and explains that these are signals its systems weigh when choosing which URL to show. For your own sites the cleaner fix is to stop duplicating: write for each site's audience, or keep the content in one place and link to it.
The third form carries policy risk. Google's spam policies describe doorway abuse as sites or pages created to rank for specific, similar queries that lead users to essentially the same destination, or to intermediate pages less useful than the final one. The examples include multiple websites with slight variations of the URL and home page made to maximise reach for a query, and multiple domains aimed at regions or cities that funnel users to one page. Few businesses set out to build doorways, but a set of thin brand or regional sites that each send visitors to the same checkout reads exactly that way. The guide to Google's spam policies covers the rest of the policy page.
Campaign microsites and what happens after the campaign
Campaign sites follow a predictable life. They launch quickly, earn attention and often links from press coverage, and then the campaign ends. The team moves on, the site is left as it was, and over the following months it decays or disappears, taking whatever the campaign earned with it.
The default should be to host campaigns on the main site, in a stable section that outlives each campaign. The campaign ideation guide recommends hosting digital PR assets on the organisation's own site for exactly this reason: coverage that links to them then supports the site that matters. A recurring campaign, such as an annual index or survey, is worth more at one stable address updated each edition than at a new domain each year.
When a separate domain cannot be avoided, because a partner runs the platform or a rule requires separation, plan its end at the start:
- Name an owner for the domain, its renewal and its redirects after the campaign.
- Decide the destination on the main site for each part of the campaign: a permanent campaign page that keeps the useful content, the results and the methodology.
- Redirect page by page when the campaign ends, with a permanent redirect (301 RedirectA permanent server redirect telling browsers and search engines a URL has moved for good.) from each URL to its closest equivalent, never every URL to the home page.
- Keep the domain registered and the redirects running long after the last visitor arrives, because links from coverage do not expire when the campaign does.
Consolidating sites into one
Merging one site into another is a site move with URL changes, and Google's documentation for that case sets out the shape of the work: prepare the destination, map every old URL to its new address, send old URLs to new ones with server-side permanent redirects, update what you control to point at the new addresses, and monitor both sites while the change is processed. Google's redirects documentation describes permanent server-side redirects as the best way to send people and Google Search to the right page, and as a strong signal that the target should be treated as the canonical URL. The site migrations guide holds the mechanics, from the redirect map to launch-day checks; what follows is the part specific to merging several sites.
- Inventory each site separately. URLs, organic visits, queries, links from other sites and conversions, page by page. Pages with links and pages with traffic are the ones whose destinations matter most. Run the key templates of each site through the SEO page checker so that titles, headings and markup are known before anything moves.
- Decide per page. Merge into an existing page on the main site, move as a new page, or retire. Where a page on the old site overlaps one on the main site, choose the surviving URL for each pair before building the map, and fold the better material from the losing page into the winner.
- Keep the old names findable. People keep searching for a retired brand or campaign. A page on the main site that explains what happened to the name, and links to what replaced it, answers those searches.
- Change one thing at a time. Merging the sites is enough for one release; a redesign or a rewrite on top makes any loss impossible to attribute.
- Keep the domains. Redirects from merged domains should run for at least the period the migration guide sets out and, in practice, indefinitely, because links from other sites never update themselves.
A drinks group with eleven sites chasing the same queries
Frothwick Drinks Group, an invented drinks company, runs a group site, three brand sites (a premium cider, a tonic range and a cold brew coffee) and seven campaign microsites built by agencies over five years. The inventory finds 1,180 indexable URLs across the eleven domains. Joining the Search Console exports shows 214 queries where two or more Frothwick domains earn impressions, including the group's own name, for which the group site and the tonic site alternate. Four campaign sites hold links from press coverage; three have no links and almost no visits; two campaign domains are due to expire within the year. The group's brand review keeps the premium cider site separate, because that brand is meant to stand apart from the group. The tonic and cold brew sites become sections of the group site: 310 URLs are mapped one to one and 95 thin or duplicate pages are merged into their closest equivalents. The four linked campaign sites are redirected page by page to a permanent campaigns section, and the other three to the relevant brand sections. Every retired domain stays registered and redirecting. Six months after the move, the overlap list has fallen to 31 queries, most of them the cider brand's name, for which the cider site and the group's page about the brand both appear, as intended.
A decision table
| Situation | Separate site? | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Acquired company whose brand is being retired | No | Merge as a migration; redirect one to one; keep a page that answers searches for the old name |
| Acquired or owned brand kept separate for its own customers | Yes | Keep and maintain it; remove duplicated content; link between the sites where it helps visitors |
| Product brand within a branded house | No | A section of the main site with pages for the brand's own queries |
| One-off campaign or launch | No | A page or section on the main site that stays after the campaign |
| Campaign that must run on a partner's platform | Temporarily | Agree the owner, destination and redirects before launch |
| Recurring index, survey or report | No | One stable URL on the main site, updated each edition |
| Separately regulated product or legal entity | Often | A separate site with its own owner, terms and maintenance plan |
| Regional sites in the same language with the same products | Rarely | Follow the international SEO guidance; never one domain per city or region funnelling to one shop |
| Defensive and misspelled domains | No content | Redirect to the main site |
Common mistakes
- Launching a domain because it is quicker. The speed is borrowed from every year the site then has to be maintained.
- Letting campaign domains lapse. The links go, and the name becomes available to whoever wants its history.
- Redirecting a whole site to the home page. Each URL needs its closest equivalent; a blanket redirect throws away what each page earned.
- Copying content to the main site and leaving the old site live. Two copies now compete, and neither is clearly preferred.
- Treating more sites as more space on the results page. Thin sites aimed at the same queries are the doorway pattern, not a strategy.
- Leaving the brand question undecided. Whether a brand keeps its own site is a brand architecture decision; while it stays open, every cost in this guide keeps running.
- Forgetting the old name. Searches for a retired brand continue, and without a page that answers them the searcher finds an old review, a directory listing or a competitor.
