What a PR agency can and cannot do
The PR and earned media hub describes the trade at the centre of PR: an advertisement says what the advertiser wants, while an article says what the journalist decided was true. That trade shapes everything an agency can offer. A good agency can find the angle in what the organisation has, know which writers cover it, write a pitch they will read, time it well, prepare spokespeople and keep relationships alive between stories, which is the craft set out in the media relations and pitching guide. What it cannot do is decide what a publication prints.
So no agency can honestly guarantee earned coverage. An offer to guarantee placement in a named title describes paid space: a sponsored article, an advertorial or a paid feature. That is advertising, and it is labelled as such, as the sponsored articles guide explains. Paid placements have their uses, but they are bought media and should be planned, labelled and reported as bought media, never presented as earned coverage.
The other limit is supply. An agency works with what the organisation gives it: news, data, customers willing to talk, experts who can comment, decisions made quickly. An agency that is starved of stories and access will produce thin results however skilled it is, and the organisation will often blame the agency for what is its own gap. Most of the practical advice in this guide is about the organisation's side of the relationship.
When an agency or a consultant fits
The broader choice between building a team and hiring one is covered in the in-house versus agency comparison. For PR, a few situations favour outside help. The organisation needs relationships with writers it does not know, in a sector or a market where the agency already has them. It has a burst of activity, such as a launch, that needs more hands for a while. It needs a level of craft, such as media training, data stories or crisis support, that nobody in-house has. Or it has nobody in-house at all.
The type of help varies more than the label suggests:
| Option | Typical fit | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Independent consultant | A small programme, one sector, a founder or marketing lead who wants an experienced partner | Capacity during busy periods and cover when the consultant is away |
| Specialist PR agency | A sector or a discipline, such as trade press, technology or consumer, where its relationships are deep | Whether the people who pitched will do the work |
| Full-service PR agency | Several audiences, several kinds of activity, larger programmes | How the account is staffed and how often senior people are involved |
| Project-based support | A launch, a data campaign, media training or an awards entry | A clear end point and what is handed over at the end |
| Agency alongside an in-house lead | An organisation with a PR or communications lead who needs reach or capacity | Who decides, who approves and who owns the relationships |
Shortlisting, chemistry meetings, pitches, scope and fee models are covered in the guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies, and the agency RFP template gives the structure for a formal request. A useful test specific to PR is to ask each candidate how it would judge its own work against your objective, and to treat an answer built on clippings counts or advertising value equivalenceA measure that prices press coverage as if it were paid space, multiplying its size or duration by the advertising rate; the PR guides say to retire it. as a warning sign.
Writing the PR brief
A PR brief follows the general shape of the campaign brief, and the habits in the agency guide apply: brief by conversation as well as document, brief the problem rather than the solution, and ask the agency to play it back. Two things make a PR brief different from a Creative BriefA short document telling the people making creative work what it must achieve, for whom, with which message and within which limits..
The first is that the objective is an audience change, not an output. "Coverage in the trade press" is an output. "Practice managers in our sector should know us as the people who understand scheduling" is an audience change, and coverage is one way to get there. State who the audience is, which titles and writers they trust, what they should know or believe after a year, and how the organisation will tell whether that has happened. If the organisation has a written PR plan, as the guide to writing a PR plan describes, the brief takes its objective and audiences from it.
The second is the supply of stories. List what the organisation can give the agency over the period: planned announcements, data it holds or can gather, customers who will talk, experts who can comment and on what, events, and the topics on which the organisation has a credible view. Be honest about the gaps. An agency that knows there is no news for three months can plan comment and data work; an agency promised news that never comes wastes the time.
Add the practical constraints: subjects that are off limits, approvals, budget and any work already under way with other agencies.
The access the agency needs
PR runs on access, and the organisation controls all of it. An agency needs:
- Spokespeople. Named people who can be quoted, the subjects each can speak on and their availability, including at short notice. A spokesperson who is never free makes reactive opportunities impossible.
- Information. Plans, product details, data, customer stories and the approved facts and figures the agency can use without asking each time. A shared folder kept current saves both sides time.
- Decision-makers. A single day-to-day contact with authority to decide routine questions, and a route to the senior people who decide the rest.
- Context. Early warning of anything that might become news, good or bad, so the agency is not surprised by a journalist's call.
Media enquiries that reach the organisation directly still need a route. Agree whether the agency or an in-house person handles them, using a routine like the one in the guide to handling media enquiries, and make sure staff know where to send journalists. Spokespeople the agency will put forward need preparing before they face a journalist; the guide to preparing a spokesperson for an interview sets out what that involves, whether the agency or the organisation does it.
Approvals, spokespeople and speed
Journalists work to deadlines the organisation does not choose. A comment approved the day after the deadline is worthless, and an agency whose every pitch waits for several sign-offs will stop proposing reactive work. Approval speed is a contribution to the results that only the organisation can make. Reactive commentComment a spokesperson gives on news the organisation did not make, such as a report or a rival's launch, fast enough to be used and within agreed positions. on other people's news depends on it, because the journalist has set the deadline before the request arrives.
Agree in advance what the agency may do without asking, what needs the day-to-day contact's approval and what needs senior or legal review. A RACI matrix makes those decisions explicit. Keep the route for routine material short, name deputies for absences, and agree a faster route for reactive comment on the news, with the subjects and positions agreed in advance so the comment can be approved quickly. Anything that touches a crisis, a legal matter or a regulator follows the organisation's own escalation route, whatever the agency's role. Writing those positions, each with its spokesperson, approver and limits, is the subject of the tutorial on agreeing positions for reactive comment.
Who owns the media list and the relationships
When the contract ends, the organisation keeps whatever it has kept. Agree at the start, and write into the contract with the organisation's own adviser, what happens to the media list, the coverage logThe consistent record of every piece of coverage, by title, tier, story, prominence, message, sentiment and link, from which PR measures are counted., the materials produced and any images or data, and in what form they are handed over. The agency onboarding checklist and the agency offboarding checklist cover access and handover in general.
Relationships are harder, because they belong to people. A writer who knows the agency's account director does not automatically know the organisation. The protection is for spokespeople to build their own relationships alongside the agency: meeting writers, being the person quoted, and being introduced in their own right. The media list should record who the organisation has dealt with directly, not only who the agency knows. Journalists' contact details are personal data, and the media relations guide's general direction applies: keep only what is needed, record the source and honour removal requests.
Reporting and measures
A monthly PR report should help someone outside PR understand what happened and whether it is working. The PR KPIs guide sets out the ladder from outputs through outcomes to impact and explains why advertising value equivalence should be dropped; the media monitoring and coverage reporting guide covers the coverage log and the report itself. The table applies them to an agency's report.
| Report section | What it should hold | What to push back on |
|---|---|---|
| Activity | Stories pitched, to whom, and what came of each, briefly | A long list of emails sent |
| Coverage | Pieces in target titles, scored for relevance, message and prominence, with links | Total pieces and total audience, including syndicated copies |
| Outcomes | Earned Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. against named competitors, branded search trends, referral visits, enquiries that mention coverage | Advertising value equivalence or any figure that prices coverage as space |
| Pipeline | Stories planned, opportunities in progress, what the agency needs from the organisation | No forward view |
| Learning | What worked, what did not and what changes | Every month described as a success |
Counts of clippings and impressions are Vanity MetricsMetrics that look impressive but do not inform a decision or track a business outcome. when they stand alone: easy to grow and unrelated to whether the audience changed. Agree the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. set in the brief and keep the report to it. The PR programme playbook shows where the agency's pitching, monitoring and monthly report sit in an always-on routine alongside the in-house PR lead, spokespeople and approvers. Where the agency works alongside paid, social and search partners, the guide to coordinating several agencies covers announcement dates, embargoesAn agreement that a journalist receives news before its release but publishes nothing until a stated date and time, agreed before the substance is shared., shared key messages and one version of the results.
Reviewing the relationship
Review the relationship regularly against the brief, not against a feeling. Judge the agency on what it controls: the quality of its ideas and pitches, the relevance of the titles it reaches, the accuracy of its reporting and its responsiveness. Judge the organisation on what it controls: stories supplied, access given and approvals returned on time. A review that looks at only one side will reach the wrong conclusion.
When results disappoint, find the cause before changing anything. The guide to improving an underperforming agency sets out an improvement plan, and the guide to reviewing an agency before renewal covers the scope and fee review when the agreement comes up. Sometimes the fix for poor PR results is on the organisation's side: more stories, a spokesperson who is available, an approval route that fits a journalist's deadline.
A software firm's first PR agency (illustrative)
Snevrolt Software hires its first PR consultancy
Snevrolt Software, an invented maker of appointment software for dental practices with 60 staff, hires a small consultancy that specialises in healthcare trade press. The brief names one audience change: practice managers should see the firm as the expert on reducing missed appointments. It lists the stories the firm can supply over 12 months: 2 product updates, anonymised data on missed appointments from its own system, 3 clients willing to be interviewed and the head of product as expert commentator.
The firm names the head of product as spokesperson and agrees a same-day approval route through the marketing lead for comment within agreed positions, with the managing director approving anything else within 2 working days. The contract states that the media list and coverage log belong to the firm and are handed over in a spreadsheet if the engagement ends.
The first quarter is slow. The monthly reports show 14 pieces of coverage, 9 of them reprints of a short news item on small sites. At the quarterly review, the firm and the consultancy agree that the count tells them little. From the fourth month the report shows coverage in 8 agreed target titles, earned share of voice against 3 named competitors in those titles, and enquiries where the practice mentions an article. Over the next 2 quarters, coverage in target titles rises from 2 pieces to 7 a quarter, and 11 enquiries mention an article. The firm also notices that 2 of its own delays on approvals had cost the consultancy a reactive opportunity, and shortens the route.
Common mistakes
- Expecting guaranteed coverage. Earned coverage depends on the journalist; guaranteed placement is paid space.
- Briefing outputs instead of an audience change. "Coverage" is not an objective.
- Starving the agency of stories and access. It can only work with what it is given.
- Slow approvals. A comment approved after the deadline is worthless.
- Letting the relationships live only with the agency. Spokespeople should know the writers too.
- Not agreeing who keeps the media list and materials. Settle it in the contract at the start.
- Accepting a clippings count as the report. Ask for target titles, quality and outcomes.
- Reviewing only the agency's side. The organisation's supply, access and approvals are part of the result.
The PR fundamentals hub sets the craft an agency brings beside the guides on media relations and press materials.
