Negative is not the same as wrong
The media relations and pitching guide gives the core rule in one line: correct factual errors politely and only when they matter. This guide expands that line into a routine for the moment when a piece about the organisation has run and someone inside the organisation does not like it.
Three different things tend to get lumped together as "bad press". A factual error is a statement that can be shown to be untrue: a wrong figure, a wrong date, a misattributed quote, a product described as doing something it does not. An opinion is the writer's judgement or a quoted source's view, such as that a price is too high or a decision was unwise. Fair criticism is a negative story that is accurate: customers really were let down, the delay really happened. Each calls for a different response. Errors that matter can be corrected. Opinions are the writer's to hold, and can be answered, if at all, with facts on the organisation's own channels. Fair criticism is answered by fixing the problem and saying so.
Mixing them up causes most of the damage. An organisation that demands a correction of an opinion, or argues with fair criticism, turns one critical story into two, and loses goodwill with the writer and the publication. An organisation that lets a damaging factual error stand leaves it to be repeated by other writers and found in search results long after the original story has been forgotten.
This guide is not for a story that is part of a crisis. If the coverage meets the triggers set in the social media crisis plan, for example because it is spreading fast or concerns safety, it is handled under that plan, with its severity levels, its decision owners and its holding statementsA brief first public response in a crisis that acknowledges the issue, tells affected people what to do now and says when more will follow., and where the business as a whole is affected, the page on leading marketing through a business crisis applies. Any legal question about a piece of coverage goes to the organisation's legal adviser, and this guide does not cover legal remedies.
Reading the piece before reacting
The first reaction to critical coverage is usually emotional, and the first step is to wait until it passes. Read the whole piece, not the headline or a colleague's summary, and read it as a customer would: what would someone with no inside knowledge take from it?
Then go through it line by line and mark every statement about the organisation. For each, decide which of the three it is: a factual claim, an opinion, or a description of something that happened. For each factual claim, check it against the organisation's own records, such as booking data, order records, published prices or the claims library, and note whether it is right, wrong or impossible to tell. Check what the organisation itself said: the enquiry log should show what was asked, what was sent and when, and whether any statement was used accurately. Often the error turns out to have started with the organisation, in an answer that was unclear or a figure that was given wrongly.
Finally, look at where the piece has gone. Has it been shared widely, picked up by other titles, or discussed on social platforms? Social listeningMonitoring public conversation about a brand, its category, competitors and the problems it solves, away from the brand's own accounts., set up as the guide to setting up social listening describes, shows whether the story is spreading or staying put. Log the piece in the coverage logThe consistent record of every piece of coverage, by title, tier, story, prominence, message, sentiment and link, from which PR measures are counted. with its sentiment and a note of the errors found, as the media monitoring and coverage reporting guide describes for every piece.
Deciding whether to respond
Not every negative piece needs a response, and some are made worse by one. The decision should be deliberate, recorded and made by the people who own the subject, not by whoever is most upset. The table sets out the usual options as general practice; no rule fits every case.
| What you found | Usual response | Where | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| A factual error that matters | Ask for a correction or clarification, with evidence | Writer first, then the editor | Asking for more than the error itself |
| A minor factual slip | Usually leave it; mention it politely only if a relationship allows | Writer, informally | Spending goodwill on something readers will not notice |
| Opinion or a quoted critic's view | Usually no response to the publication; answer with facts on owned channels if customers are asking | Own channels | Asking the publication to change an opinion |
| Fair criticism | Fix the problem and say what is changing | Own channels, and to the writer if they would want a follow-up | Defending what cannot be defended |
| A story spreading fast or touching safety | Hand over to the crisis plan | Crisis plan owners | Responding before the crisis owner has decided |
| A possible legal issue | Refer to the legal adviser before anything else | Legal adviser | Raising legal language with the journalist |
Three questions help decide. Will it mislead people who matter? An error customers will act on, such as a wrong price or a wrong safety claim, matters more than one they will not. Will it be repeated? Errors in a widely read piece, or in one other writers are likely to use as a source, travel. Will a response make it worse? A public reply to a piece few people saw can introduce it to many more. Record the decision and the reason, so that if the story returns, the organisation knows what it decided and why.
Asking for a correction or clarification
When an error matters, ask the writer first, politely, in writing. Name the specific statement, say what is correct, and supply the evidence: the record, the document or the published figure. Keep it short and factual; a correction request is not the place to argue with the story's angle or tone. Acknowledge, where it is true, that the error may have come from something the organisation said. Ask for what fits the error: a correction to the online version, a clarification, or an added line with the organisation's position.
If the writer does not respond or declines, and the error still matters, the next step is the editor responsible for the section, with the same evidence and the same tone. Publications handle corrections in their own ways, and some have formal complaint routes as well. Those routes depend on the publication and on where and how it is regulated, and this guide does not set them out; if an organisation is considering a formal complaint or any legal step, that is a question for its legal adviser. Never threaten a journalist, and never imply that coverage will affect advertising, access or anything else. Both damage the relationship far more than the error did, and both can become a story in their own right.
Whatever the outcome, record it: what was asked, of whom, when, and what changed. A correction that is made should be added to the coverage log entry for the piece.
Answering on your own channels
Opinions and fair criticism are answered, if at all, on the organisation's own channels, where it controls the words and customers can find them. A short, dated statement on the website, a note in the newsroom, a reply on social platforms where customers are asking, or a message to affected customers can each do this. The tone is factual and calm: acknowledge what is fair, correct what is wrong with evidence, and say what the organisation is doing. Do not attack the publication or the writer; an attack invites a reply and keeps the story alive.
Where the organisation's own content has been wrong, the guide to updating and correcting content covers how to correct a published page openly. Where customers have posted reviews that repeat the story, the local reviews and reputation management guide covers replying to them, and the diagnosis for a sudden wave of negative Google reviews sorts a burst of reviews sent by a story from genuine complaints arriving at the same time. Where the story is about a customer's own complaint, the service recovery and complaints guide covers fixing the problem for that customer, which matters more than any statement.
Briefing colleagues and customers
A critical story reaches staff and customers before the organisation has said anything. Tell the people who will be asked about it, such as customer service teams, sales, shop staff and senior leaders, what the story says, what is true and what is not, what the organisation is doing, and what to say if asked, in a few plain sentences. Remind them that journalists who call are routed to the press contact, as the tutorial on handling media enquiries sets out, because a follow-up story can start with a member of staff who answered a reporter's call.
Customers directly affected by the issue the story describes should hear from the organisation directly, not learn of its response from the press. Where a spokesperson may be asked to discuss the story in a follow-up interview, the tutorial on preparing a spokesperson for a media interview covers the briefing, the difficult questions and the rehearsal. The press releases and online newsroom guide covers keeping the newsroom's facts current, which is where a writer covering a follow-up will look first.
Learning from the story
A negative story is evidence. Once the immediate response is done, ask what it revealed. Was the criticism about a real problem the organisation had not fixed, or not explained? Did the error start with an unclear answer, a figure given wrongly or a spokesperson who had not been briefed? Was the journalist unable to reach anyone, so the piece ran with "did not respond"?
The five whys is a simple way to trace the cause past the first answer, and the guide to reviewing a marketing error covers a blame-free review with owned actions when the organisation's own communication was at fault. Record the lesson in the coverage log and in the review of the PR programme. Over time, the log will show whether negative coverage is rising or falling, and whether it is affecting earned Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. or the outcome measures the PR KPIs guide sets out. One critical piece rarely moves those measures; a pattern of them, or a problem left unfixed, can.
A heating installer answers a critical story (illustrative)
Glimvarro Heating responds to a story about delays
Glimvarro Heating, an invented boiler installer, finds a story on a regional news website headlined "Families left waiting weeks for new boilers". It says 300 homes are affected, quotes 2 customers and includes the company's statement that it is "working to clear the backlog".
The marketing manager reads the piece line by line with the operations director. The customers' accounts are accurate. The statement is quoted correctly. The figure is wrong: the booking records show 74 installations delayed by more than a week, not 300. The figure is likely to be repeated and will sit in search results, so they decide to ask for a correction, and to answer the criticism, which is fair, on their own site.
The marketing manager emails the reporter the same afternoon: the specific sentence, the correct figure, a summary of the booking records, and a note that the company's own statement had not given a number, which may have caused the confusion. The reporter checks the summary and amends the online story the next day, with a line noting the correction.
On its website, Glimvarro Heating publishes a dated update: installations have been delayed, the cause is a supplier shortage of one boiler model, affected customers will be offered an alternative model or a confirmed date, and the update will be revised weekly. Call handlers receive a 5-line briefing. All 74 affected customers receive a phone call within 3 days.
In the review, a five-whys session traces the story back further: the supplier problem had been known for a month, but nobody had told customers, so the first they heard of it was a missed appointment. The company adds a rule that any known delay is explained to affected customers within 2 working days.
Common mistakes
- Treating every negative story as wrong. Opinion and fair criticism are not errors and cannot be corrected away.
- Reacting before reading. Read the whole piece, check each claim and decide calmly.
- Responding to everything. A reply to a piece few people saw can spread it further.
- Asking for more than the error. A correction request names one statement, the correct fact and the evidence.
- Going over the writer's head first. Ask the writer, then the editor, and keep the same tone.
- Threatening or pressuring. It damages the relationship more than any error and can become the next story.
- Handling a crisis as a correction. If the crisis plan's triggers are met, hand over.
- Fixing the story but not the problem. Fair criticism is answered by changes customers can see.
The PR fundamentals hub sets this routine beside the enquiries, pitching and press materials that make negative coverage less likely in the first place.
