What an award can and cannot do
An award does one thing well: it tells people that an independent panel looked at the work and rated it. That is a form of Social ProofEvidence that other people have chosen, used or approved something, used to reduce a buyer's doubt., and like all proof it is worth only as much as the audience's respect for the people giving it. The trust and proof guide puts it plainly: awards from bodies the visitor has never heard of prove little, and awards that were bought are a claim dressed as proof. A scheme where winning appears to depend on payment beyond an entry fee belongs in that second group, whatever its name.
An award is also a modest piece of news at best. The press releases and online newsroom guide notes that releases about awards readers have not heard of are not news, and most award results interest the trade titlesThe newspapers, magazines and sites that cover one sector for the people who work in it, read by its decision-makers and used in PR, advertising and research. that cover the sector more than anyone else. A win can give a reporter a reason to call, a salesperson a line to use and a recruiter something to point to. It does not substitute for a story, a product people want or a reputation earned elsewhere.
What an entry can do, win or lose, is force the organisation to state what a piece of work achieved and prove it. Teams that enter well usually measure well, and the evidence gathered for an entry often serves the campaign post-mortem, the next pitch and the case study as well.
This tutorial does not describe any particular scheme. Every scheme sets its own categories, criteria, rules, fees, deadlines and judging, and those rules decide what an entry must contain.
Before you start
- Know your measures. Read the PR KPIs guide on outputs, outcomes and impact, because an entry has to separate activity from results.
- Find the records. Locate the campaign's objectives, the KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. it was set, the BaselineAn estimate of what a metric would have done without a given change, campaign or promotion, against which the effect is measured. it started from and the results it reported, and check whether a campaign wrap-up or post-mortem already exists.
- Check your claims process. If the organisation keeps a claims library and substantiation file, every figure in the entry should be in it or added to it.
- Know who can approve. Identify who can approve the entry internally and who, at each client or partner named, can give written approval.
- Set aside writing time. An entry is a short document with a lot of evidence behind it; the gathering takes longer than the writing.
The steps
Decide what the award is for
Write down, in a sentence, what the organisation wants an award to do. It may be to give prospects in a sector a reason to trust a newer supplier, to help recruitment by showing the team's work is recognised by peers, or to give the trade press a reason to cover a project. The purpose decides which schemes count, which work to enter and how the result will be used. If nobody can say what an award is for, the time is better spent on the work itself or on the case study the work deserves.
Choose schemes the audience respects
List the schemes in the field and test each against the purpose. Ask customers, prospects and new recruits which awards they have heard of and which they would take seriously. Look at who has won before and whether the organisation would be glad to stand beside them. Look at who judges and whether those judges are respected by the audience. Read how the scheme is paid for: an entry fee is normal, but a scheme where winning appears to depend on buying tables, sponsorship or a winner's package is weak proof, as the trust and proof guide says of bought awards. Pick the one or two that pass rather than entering everything.
Read the criteria and the rules
Read the category descriptions, the judging criteria and the entry rules in full before choosing what to enter. Note the criteria in the scheme's own words, any weighting, the sections the entry form asks for, the limits on length and supporting material, what counts as eligible work and over what period, whether entries are confidential to the judges or published, and how results may be used afterwards. Write each criterion at the top of a blank page; the entry will be built under those headings. If a rule is unclear, ask the organiser rather than guessing.
Pick the work with the strongest evidence
Choose the work by the evidence, not by the pride. The best entry is usually the project with a clear objective set in advance, a measured starting point and results that moved, rather than the most creative or the largest. For each candidate, check whether the objective was written down before the work began, whether the results can be traced to records, and whether the contribution of the work can be separated from other things happening at the same time. Enter one strong piece in the category it fits best rather than several weak ones across categories.
Gather results, baselines and permissions
Collect the evidence the criteria ask for, from the organisation's own measurement. Keep outputs, outcomes and impact apart, as the PR KPIs guide sets out: coverage counts and reach are outputs, changes in the audience are outcomes, and contribution to the business is impact. Give every result its baseline and its period, and note the source of each figure. Claim contribution only as far as the evidence goes: if sales rose while the campaign ran, say what the evidence shows about the link and what it does not. Where a client, customer or partner is named or their results are used, get their written approval for exactly what will be stated, as the customer case study guide describes, and check the customer references and advocacy guide for how approvals are recorded.
Write the entry to the criteria
Write each section to answer one criterion, under the criterion's own heading, in the order the scheme gives. Start each section with the answer, then the evidence, then the context. The What, So What, Now What framework helps: what happened, why it mattered against the objective, and what the organisation did or learned as a result. Use plain language and specific figures, each with its baseline and source. Cut anything that does not answer a criterion, however good it sounds. Judges may read many entries, and an entry that makes them search for the answer risks losing marks it might have earned.
Have someone outside the work review it
Ask someone who did not work on the project to read the draft against the criteria, ideally someone senior and sceptical. They should mark each section on whether it answers the criterion, whether every claim has evidence, and whether anything would confuse a judge from outside the organisation. Then check every figure against its source and every named party against its approval. Rewrite where the reviewer stumbled; their confusion is the judges' confusion.
Submit and plan for each result
Submit before the deadline, with the supporting material the rules allow and nothing they do not. Keep a copy of the entry, the evidence file and the approvals together. Before results are announced, decide what the organisation will do if it is shortlisted, if it wins and if it does not: who is told, what is said, where it is published and when. Draft the short statements in advance, because results can come with a request for a quote or an image at short notice.
Use a shortlisting or a win accurately
Describe the result exactly as it happened, with the scheme, the category and the year. A shortlisting is a shortlisting, a commendation is a commendation and a win is a win; none becomes a general "award-winning" line unless the organisation won. In the UK the advertising codes administered by the Advertising Standards Authority require marketing claims to be substantiated and not misleading, as the customer references guide states, so any line about an award used in marketing needs the evidence behind it and should keep its date. Put the result on the newsroom, tell the trade writers who cover the sector if it is news to their readers, and let the sales team use it in the words agreed. Remove or date the claim when it becomes old. Any coverage the result earns can be put to work the same way, as the guide to using press coverage in your marketing explains. Whatever the result, feed the evidence and the judges' feedback, if the scheme offers it, into the post-mortem.
What judges need from each section
Entry forms differ, but most ask for some version of the sections below. The table shows what each section has to prove and the common way it fails. Treat it as a checklist against your draft, not a template to copy over the scheme's own headings.
| Section | What it has to prove | Evidence that works | Common failure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Summary | What was done, for whom and what changed | One or two sentences with the main result and its baseline | A description of the activity with no result |
| Challenge or objective | That the goal was clear and set before the work | The written objective and the KPI chosen at the start | An objective written after the results were known |
| Insight or strategy | Why this approach, rather than another | Research, data or customer evidence behind the choice | A list of tactics with no reason given |
| Execution | That the work was done well and on plan | What was produced, when and to whom, with examples | Detail that buries the point |
| Results | That the objective was met, measured fairly | Outcomes and impact with baselines, periods and sources, outputs kept separate | Coverage counts or impressions presented as results |
| Learning | That the team understands what worked and why | What would change next time, and what was changed | A claim that everything went perfectly |
Results carry most entries. Keep counts behind any rate, so a judge can see the size of the base, and read small numbers with care, as the reading small numbers guide explains: a large percentage change on a small base is easy to state and hard to believe.
A payroll bureau's first awards entry (illustrative)
Lufreska Payroll enters a client-service award
Lufreska Payroll, an invented payroll bureau serving small employers, wants an award to help it win clients against larger bureaux. Its marketing lead asks 12 clients and prospects which awards in the sector they know; 2 schemes are named more than once, and the bureau picks the one with a client-service category judged by practitioners.
The work it enters is a project that changed how clients submit hours. From its own records, payroll errors needing correction fell from 46 in the 6 months before the change to 11 in the 6 months after, across the same 38 clients. The bureau notes in the entry that it also added a checking step in the same period, so it claims the fall for the project as a whole rather than for the new submission form alone.
Two clients give written approval to be named and to have their own error counts stated. The first draft runs as a narrative; the operations manager, who was not on the project, reads it against the 5 criteria and cannot find the objective. The marketing lead rewrites it so each section answers one criterion under its own heading, with the objective, written before the project began, in the first line.
The bureau is shortlisted but does not win. It publishes a short note on its newsroom saying it was shortlisted in the category, with the year, and a trade title includes the bureau in its round-up of the shortlist. The bureau does not call itself award-winning. The error counts and the judges' feedback go into the project's post-mortem.
Where the aim is a place on buyers' shortlists, PR for the consideration stage treats a shortlist in a scheme the category's buyers already cite as one piece of independent proof beside the reviews and comparisons they read.
Common mistakes
- Entering schemes the audience has never heard of. Proof is worth the audience's respect for whoever gives it.
- Choosing the proudest work rather than the best evidenced. Judges score the evidence.
- Ignoring the criteria's headings. Answer each criterion where the judge expects to find it.
- Presenting outputs as results. Coverage and impressions are outputs; show the outcome they led to.
- Claiming more contribution than the evidence supports. Say what else changed and claim only what you can show.
- Naming clients without written approval. Get it before the entry is written, for exactly what will be stated.
- Turning a shortlisting into "award-winning". Describe the result exactly, with the scheme, category and year.
- Leaving an old award claim in place for years. Date it, and retire it when it no longer describes the organisation.
The PR fundamentals hub sets awards beside the other materials that support media relations, and the media relations and pitching guide covers taking a result that is genuinely news to the writers who cover the sector.
