Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Templates

Agency Request for Proposal Template

An agency request for proposal template: company and context, scope and objectives, budget range, questions to answer, scoring criteria, timeline and terms.
Templateintermediate10 min readUpdated

What this template is for

Use the template when a business is choosing a marketing agency through a competitive process: appointing a first agency, replacing an incumbent, consolidating several agencies into one, or moving work that was done in house to an agency. It suits a performance, creative, media, SEO or social agency; the scope and questions change, the structure does not. It is sent after a long list has been narrowed, usually to a small number of agencies who have shown relevant capability and interest.

The RFP is not the only document in the process and should not try to be. The agency selection guide covers the stages — long list, request for information, chemistry meetings, pitch, references, appointment — and the scope, fee models, service levels and reviews that follow. The campaign brief briefs work once an agency is appointed. The guide to negotiating media buys covers requests for proposal sent to media owners and sellers, which ask for inventory and rates rather than a partner's thinking. Research studies follow the same structure with questions of their own about design, sample and participants' data, which the guide to commissioning a research agency or freelancer lists. This template is the document a client sends to the agencies it is choosing between.

Writing the RFP also tests the client. If the business cannot state the scope, the objectives and a budget range, it is not ready to choose an agency, and an agency chosen anyway will be judged against expectations nobody wrote down.

The template

Copy the table into a document and keep the section order; agencies will answer in the same order, which makes responses comparable side by side.

FieldWhat to write
Company and contextWho the business is, its market and customers, its marketing team, and why it is looking for an agency now
ScopeThe services in scope and out of scope, the channels, and the split of work between the agency and the in-house team
Objectives and measuresThe outcomes the agency will be judged on, how each is measured and where the data comes from
Budget range and fee modelMedia and fee ranges, and the fee models the business will consider
Questions to answerThe specific questions each response must answer, numbered, in a fixed order, with any length limits
Data, access and ownershipWho owns ad accounts, analytics, data and creative; what access the agency gets; what happens at exit
Scoring criteriaThe criteria and their weights, published in advance, and who scores
Timeline and processDates for questions, submission, shortlist, chemistry meetings, pitch, decision and start
Terms and contactsConfidentiality, pitch fee policy, contract basis, and the single point of contact

Send supporting material as appendices: recent performance summaries, the brand guidelines, a sample of reporting. Mark what is confidential and ask for it to be returned or destroyed after the process.

How to fill each section

Company and context

Describe the business, its customers and market, the marketing team and its skills, and the reason for the search. The reason matters most: an agency answering "we have outgrown doing this in house" proposes something different from one answering "our incumbent has stopped improving results". Where the search follows a renewal review, the tutorial on reviewing an agency before renewal shows how to reach a re-tender decision from the evidence, and its findings on scope and results make a sound basis for this section. The agency selection guide recommends writing down the work, objectives, budget and in-house team before any conversation; this section is that document, cut to what an outsider needs.

Scope

List the services in scope and, just as clearly, those out of scope, with the channels covered and who does what between agency and in-house team. The team models and organisation design guide covers responsibility matrices and interfaces between teams, which is the right frame for the split of work. A vague scope is the most common cause of later fee disputes, because neither side can tell whether a request is included.

Objectives and measures

State the outcomes the agency will be judged on and how each is measured. The objectives and KPIs guide explains one primary KPI per objective and how targets should be set. Measures must be within the agency's influence and measured on data the agency can see: an agency judged on CPA or ROAS needs access to the conversion data behind them, and an agency judged on sales needs to see sales.

Budget range and fee model

Give the media budget range and the fee range, and say which fee models the business will consider: retainer, project, time and materials, a share of media, a performance element. The agency selection guide explains what each model rewards; commission on media, for example, rewards spending rather than effectiveness. Agencies cannot propose a sensible team without a range, and withholding it produces proposals that are not comparable.

Questions to answer

Write the questions every response must answer, numbered, in a fixed order, with a length limit where it helps. Ask about the business's problem, not the agency's credentials alone: how they would approach the first few months, what they would change in the current set-up and why, how they measure, who exactly would work on the account and for how much of their time. Questions answered in the agency's own format cannot be compared; questions answered in yours can. For a Google Ads scope, the guide to hiring and evaluating a Google Ads agency lists the paid search questions worth adding, from conversion definitions to what may change without approval. Once the answers come in, the tutorial on checking an agency's claimed results shows how to test the results an agency presents and to score the evidence behind them against weights fixed in advance.

Data, access and ownership

State that the business owns its ad accounts, analytics properties, customer data and the work it pays for, subject to third-party rights such as image licences, and describe the access the agency will receive. The agency selection guide covers ownership and exit handover; putting them in the RFP means every agency prices them in and nobody is surprised at contract stage. Contract wording is a job for the business's legal advisers. For a PR agency, add the media list, the coverage log and the materials produced, as the guide to working with a PR agency suggests agreeing at the start.

Scoring criteria

Publish the criteria and weights before responses arrive, and name who scores. The guide to choosing and evaluating tools describes the same discipline for software: every candidate is judged on the same questions, written before anyone saw a proposal, with evidence noted against each score. Include someone who will work with the agency day to day among the scorers, not only the senior sponsor.

Timeline and process

Give dates for clarification questions, submission, shortlist, chemistry meetings, the pitch or task, the decision and the start. The agency selection guide notes that the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising has long encouraged proportionate processes with few pitching agencies; a short, well-run process attracts better agencies. Share answers to clarification questions with every agency, not only the one that asked.

Terms and contacts

State the confidentiality terms, whether pitch work is paid and on what basis, who owns pitch ideas that are not used, the expected contract basis and the single point of contact. The guide to negotiating media buys covers commercial terms on the media side, which matter when the agency will also buy media. One named contact stops agencies lobbying different people in the business and keeps the process fair.

Filled example

Below, the RFP is completed for an invented business. The figures, dates and names are illustrative.

Illustrative example — not a real result

Kennelspire Veterinary Group: paid search and paid social agency RFP

FieldKennelspire's RFP
Company and contextEleven small-animal practices across Cheshire and North Wales, two with out-of-hours cover. Customers are pet owners within a short drive of each practice. Marketing team of three: a marketing manager, a content and social executive, a practice liaison. Paid search and paid social have been run in house for two years; results have plateaued and the team lacks time for testing and reporting. Looking now because two new practices open in the spring
ScopeIn scope: Google Ads and Microsoft Ads search, Meta paid social, landing page recommendations, conversion tracking upkeep, monthly reporting. Out of scope: SEO, organic social, website development, local listings, email. In-house team writes practice news and approves all clinical claims
Objectives and measuresPrimary: new pet registrations at practices with capacity, measured by the practice management system. Secondary: cost per new registration against a ceiling of £45; online vaccination bookings. Guardrail: no paid activity for practices marked "at capacity" in the weekly capacity sheet
Budget range and fee modelMedia £18,000 to £22,000 a month across both channels. Fees £3,500 to £5,000 a month. Retainer preferred; open to a retainer with a performance element tied to registrations. Not considering a percentage of media
Questions to answer(1) What would you change in our current accounts in the first ninety days, and why? Two pages. (2) How would you plan spend around practice capacity? (3) How would you measure registrations, given they complete in the practice system? (4) Who would work on the account, at what seniority and share of their time? (5) Describe a multi-site client where results plateaued and what you did. (6) How do you report, and how often? (7) Your proposed fee, what it includes and how scope changes are priced
Data, access and ownershipKennelspire owns all ad accounts, the analytics property and all creative. The agency receives admin access for the term. On exit: thirty days of handover, all assets and documentation returned, access removed on the final day
Scoring criteriaUnderstanding of our problem and the ninety-day plan 25%; team and seniority 20%; measurement approach 20%; relevant multi-site experience 15%; fee and value 15%; chemistry 5%. Scored by the marketing manager, the operations director and a practice manager, independently, then discussed
Timeline and processRFP issued 3 February. Clarification questions by 10 February; answers to all by 12 February. Responses by 24 February. Shortlist of two by 3 March. Chemistry meetings with the working team 6 and 7 March. Pitch, presenting answer (1), 17 March. Decision 21 March. Start 1 April
Terms and contactsMutual confidentiality agreement signed before the RFP is shared. Each shortlisted agency is paid £1,500 for pitch work; unused ideas remain the agency's. Twelve-month contract, three months' notice after the first six. Single contact: Gemma Rhys, Marketing Manager

Four agencies received the RFP and three responded. Question three separated them: only one proposed matching registrations from the practice system back to campaigns with an offline import, which was the gap the in-house team had not solved.

Common mistakes

  • No budget range. Agencies guess, propose teams that do not fit and cannot be compared. Give a range for media and for fees.
  • Scope without exclusions. What is out of scope causes as many disputes as what is in it. List both.
  • Questions in the agency's format. Inviting a credentials deck produces credentials decks. Ask numbered questions and require answers in that order.
  • Criteria written after the pitch. Weights chosen once the favourite is known are a justification, not a decision. Publish them in the RFP.
  • Meeting only the senior team. The people who win the business are rarely the people who do the work. Ask who would work on the account and meet them.
  • Ownership left to the contract. Account and data ownership raised after selection becomes a negotiation. State it in the RFP so every agency prices it in.
  • Too many agencies. A long pitch list costs every agency time and discourages the best. Shortlist a few and pay for real work where it is asked for.
  • Several points of contact. Agencies lobbying different people distort the process. Name one contact.

The campaign brief used once the agency starts and the other planning documents are in the templates library.

Terms used on this page

Where this page is used

Also related

Sources

  1. Institute of Practitioners in Advertising — IPA
  2. Chartered Institute of Marketing — CIM

Related