Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Branding › Brand Foundations

Hiring and Evaluating a Brand Identity Studio

How to choose and judge a brand identity studio or freelancer: the jobs to hire for, what the business keeps, questions, warning signs and weighing proposals.
Guideintermediate18 min readUpdated

What a brand identity studio is hired to do

An identity engagement is not one job. A business that asks a studio for "a rebrand" has not yet said which job it wants. The first decision therefore belongs to the business: which of the four options in the guide to deciding between a refresh and a rebrand it is buying, whether enforcing, refreshing, a new identity or a rename. Each option asks a studio for different work and spends a different amount of the recognition built so far, and a business that has not chosen has not told any studio which of the four options to plan for.

Once the option is chosen, the work divides into the pieces in the table below, which can be bought one at a time. The table is a starting point, as general practice: the studio supplies the middle column, and the business keeps the right-hand column.

JobWhat a studio can doWhat stays with the business
StrategyFacilitate the workshop, as the brand strategy workshop tutorial lays out; any studio draft is input, because the tutorial has the accountable owner write the final wordingThe decisions, the dated sign-off and the page itself
Identity systemPropose routes inside the signed strategy and specify logo, colour, type, imagery, motion and sound, with voice principles where they are in scope, as the identity and voice guide describesThe choice between routes, the cues marked fixed and the brand's committed assets
NamingGenerate and screen candidate names against a brief for search, handles, domains, sound and meaning, as the naming tutorial sets outThe choice, and the legal clearance advice, which comes from a qualified adviser and not from the studio's own assurance
Guidelines and templatesWrite the guidelines and build templates in the tools staff already use, as the templates tutorial describesThe owner, the approval route and the withdrawal of old files
TestingPrepare routes at true size and in real templates, and help run tests with category buyersThe question each test answers, who is tested and how the results are read
RolloutSupply artwork and advice for each surfacePutting the identity live is its own piece of work, ordered by the rebrand rollout tutorial, with an owner for each surface

The strategy row is where the boundary blurs. The in-house or agency comparison notes that an agency which sets the strategy is also setting the brief its own work will be judged against, so a studio that sets the strategy should not be the only judge of whether its routes fit it. A business can still ask for a studio draft; what it keeps is the decision and the final wording.

This page names no fees, day rates, retainer sizes, studios or software, and is not legal advice. Contract wording and questions about who owns files, typefaces or names are for the business's own advisers.

What stays with the business

List what the business holds before a first route is shown. Each item below is something a studio may otherwise have to assume or supply for itself, and each is easier to settle before a first route exists. The briefing tutorial turns these into the brief; this table is the business's side of the engagement.

What the business holdsWhy it staysWhere it is set up
The signed one-page strategyEach route is judged against it, and a strategy held only by the studio leaves with the studioBrand strategy
The cues to keep, with the evidenceA change spends the recognition already built, so each cue is marked before any route exists, as the briefing tutorial's first step has itDistinctive brand assets
The criteria and one accountable personRoutes are judged against them, so they are written before any route exists, as the briefing tutorial's criteria step has it, with one named person signing offRACI matrix
The touchpoint list, with the hardest ones markedThe system is judged where it is hardest to applyRunning a brand consistency audit, which lists each touchpoint with its owner; the briefing tutorial's touchpoint step marks the hardest
The master files and the record of the rights agreedMissing variants get improvised, and ownership and usage rights are agreed in writing before work startsThe scope of work template, in its section on accounts, data and ownership
The asset library and the approved templatesThe library holds approved files only, so the studio's own folders are not the business's librarySetting up a marketing asset library
The decision record, the change log and the ownerThe conditions for revisiting a decision survive a change of studio, and later requests to change the guidelines need decision rightsHandling exceptions and changes to brand guidelines

Ask about each in the written request and record the answer as an obligation in the scope of work. The general agency guide asks that the business own the creative it pays for, except where others hold rights in an image or a performer's contribution, and leaves the contract wording to the business's legal advisers. The same caution applies to typeface licences, which the briefing tutorial lists as part of the handover and sends to a qualified adviser for the wording.

Questions for each shortlisted studio

Put the questions in writing, send the same set to each studio as a request for proposal and read the answers next to one another. The agency request for proposal template gives the format, with a section for data, access and ownership and another for the scoring criteria. The briefing tutorial's shortlist step names the response a studio is asked for in one sentence; the questions below, as general practice, extend it into the points particular to identity work. Prefer answers that name the person for each job, and what the studio needs from the business, to answers that describe the process in general terms.

The strategy and the brief. How will you read our strategy page, and what would you challenge in it? What do you need from us before you show a first route? Where would you change the brief, and what would the change cost us? A studio that wants to rewrite the strategy may be telling you the engagement includes a strategy job that should be scoped as one.

Cues to keep. Which of our existing cues would you treat as fixed, and how would you decide? What would you do if a route worked better without a cue that the evidence says buyers link to us alone? The refresh guide puts the burden of proof on whoever wants to change a recognised cue, and the answer shows whether the studio shares that default.

People. Who will design, who will present and what share of their working week is ours? Who covers an absence? For a freelancer, the question about cover is the one to press, and the key-person risk guide counts cover when a second person has actually done the task, so a named deputy who has run the task on the working files is evidence where a promise is not.

Testing. What would you test, with whom and how would you read the result? A sound answer follows the briefing tutorial's testing step.

Accessibility and production. How do you check colour pairs and test at true size, and how do you confirm print colours and typeface licences? The accessible identity guide sets the rules the answer should meet, including approved pairs that pass the WCAG contrast requirements.

Guidelines, templates and handover. What files will we receive, in which formats and tools, and who tests the templates? As general practice, ask for a handover list from an earlier project with the client's details removed, and compare it with the list in the briefing tutorial. Do the guidelines follow the sections of the brand guidelines template, with the owner named? Who at the studio answers questions after handover, and is that part of the scope?

Rounds and review. How do you want feedback to reach you, given the consolidated rounds the agency guide and the briefing tutorial describe? How are rounds counted, and what happens when comments from different people contradict each other?

Rights and files. What rights will we receive over the master files and the identity, which files stay with you and how are typeface and image licences handled? Record the answers in the scope. The usage rights that apply to supplied typefaces and images are agreed in writing, and a qualified adviser checks the wording.

After handover. What support, if any, is part of the scope, and what is priced separately, such as rollout, template upkeep or a retainer for continuing design work? The agency guide's section on scope, fee models and contracts covers how to match a fee model to the work and how scope changes are priced.

Reading earlier work and references

A portfolio shows what a studio can present. On its own it may not show what the client could use afterwards. As general practice, read each case at the point of use and not on the board it was presented on: ask to see the identity on its smallest and hardest touchpoints and in the templates that people who are not designers work from. The briefing tutorial judges a route at true size on the hardest touchpoint, and the identity guide warns that a system only designers can apply correctly will be applied wrongly by everyone else.

The agency guide's selection table sets out what references are for and the trap in shortlisting on awards or reputation alone. For an identity project the concerns worth testing are specific. As general practice, ask a reference for what was in the handover, not for praise, and ask what they would do differently; the table below pairs what to examine with a question for a reference.

What to examineWhat it showsA question for a reference
The identity on its smallest and hardest usesWhether the system was built for use or for a presentationWhich touchpoint was hardest, and did the identity hold there?
The templates and who used themWhether people who are not designers can apply the systemDid staff use the templates, and who answered their questions?
What was kept from the old identityWhether the studio respects recognition already builtWhich cues were treated as fixed, and who decided?
The testingWhether routes were judged on recognition and meaning and not on likingWho was shown the routes, and what were they asked?
The handoverWhether a newcomer could produce correct work from the files aloneWhat did the handover contain, and what was missing?
Life after the projectWhether the system stayed in use or driftedHas the business audited its materials since, and what did it find?

Read the last row with care. An identity that drifts after handover can point to missing templates, an unnamed owner or guidelines nobody could find, as much as to the design, so the answer is evidence about the handover and the client's side of it as well as the studio's.

Warning signs in a proposal

One sign alone does not show a poor studio; ask a further question about each before deciding.

  • Free concepts, routes shown only on boards, or liking as the test. A proposal that leads with unpaid designs, shows boards alone or proposes to ask people which route they prefer skips steps the briefing tutorial sets out. The agency guide reports the IPA's long-standing encouragement of proportionate processes, a limited number of pitching agencies and paying for speculative work to be considered.
  • A strategy written by the studio and then used as the brief. The strategy row of the table near the top of this guide explains why.
  • Existing cues treated as open by default. The framework for distinctive assets sets out the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute's argument about assets, which earn their value only when many buyers recognise them and link them to this brand alone, and says fame takes years of consistent use, so a proposal that discards a recognised cue owes the business a reason.
  • Accessibility left to the end. The identity guide treats accessibility as a specification decided in the identity, so a proposal that leaves it to the end has the order wrong.
  • No templates, no owner and no handover list among the deliverables. The identity guide calls templates the enforcement of the guidelines and a named owner more important than a review process.
  • A name offered as cleared. The naming tutorial sends clearance to a qualified legal adviser; a studio's screening is practical, not legal.
  • Files and rights left vague. If the proposal does not say who holds the master files and the licences, the scope of work is where to ask.
  • The people pitching are not the people doing the work. The agency guide asks the business to meet whoever will do the work and to hear how it will be staffed.
  • Nothing said about rollout or leaving. Rollout is separate work, and an exit with no list of what comes back is an exit the business cannot check.

Strategy, evidence, identity, templates or rollout first

As general practice, split the engagement into separately priced pieces. Where one piece depends on another, the order below applies. It draws on the table near the top of this guide, with the evidence behind the cues added and testing taken with the routes:

  1. The strategy page, if there is no signed one. The briefing tutorial's "Before you start" section explains why it is settled before identity work, so, when it is missing, buy the workshop facilitation or a draft as its own piece, with the accountable owner writing the final wording and signing it.
  2. The evidence behind the cues to keep. The business can collect what is in use and what buyers recognise with its own audit and tracker, and a studio can help read it.
  3. Identity routes and testing. Run them as the briefing tutorial's review and testing steps describe.
  4. Guidelines, templates and handover. The project is not finished without them; the briefing tutorial's handover step and table list what a complete handover holds.
  5. Rollout. A separate piece, with its own scope and an owner for each surface.

The agency guide describes a paid or limited task as an alternative to a full pitch, because it shows how the agency thinks about the problem without rewarding the slickest presentation. For an identity project, as general practice, a useful task is narrow: show how the cue we have fixed would be applied to the hardest touchpoint, and say what you would test. It tests process and judgement, it gives the studio something to be paid for and it asks for no finished designs.

Weighing proposals and appointing

Score the proposals with the weighted scoring matrix, applying its rules, and add the identity criteria and gates set out here.

For an identity engagement, as general practice, the criteria draw on the five questions the briefing tutorial says an identity brief must settle: how well the proposal reads what the identity has to express, how it treats what must survive, how it plans for where the system has to work, what exactly will be delivered and who will own and maintain it. Take what will be delivered and who will own and maintain it together as one criterion, templates and handover, and split where the system has to work into testing and accessibility and production. Add the studio's people and cover, and the clarity of its rounds and fee model. The gates are the business's own conditions, set before any proposal is read, for example the master files and rights agreed in writing for the business's adviser to check, a handover list or a named person who will do the work. Give each studio the same brief and score against criteria agreed in advance, and ask someone from the business who will work with the studio to take part, as the general agency guide asks.

The same matrix can be used to compare a studio, a freelancer and an in-house designer, each scored against the same criteria. The in-house or agency comparison puts brand ownership with the business whoever does the work. A freelancer's scope is the one the guide to freelancing in digital marketing describes from the freelancer's side, which makes it a useful check on what a client should expect to see written down.

Record the choice in a decision log, using the marketing decision log template, and, as general practice, put in the entry the options scored, the gate results, the alternative run of the weights and the conditions under which the decision would be reopened. Once a studio is appointed, the agency onboarding checklist sets up access, who approves and when the first review falls.

Judging the work as it goes, and after handover

While the project runs, the briefing tutorial's consolidated rounds and its handover step apply, so this guide adds only the business's side. The agency guide counts willingness to challenge among the things a task should reveal, so a studio that questions a part of the brief with evidence is doing the job it was hired for. The business owes the studio the same discipline in return: a decision-maker who answers on time, and comments tied to the written criteria. The project ends at a checked handover and not at an approved route.

Handover shows what was delivered, not whether the identity succeeds. Whether people use it shows in the consistency audit and, as general practice, the date of the first one is set at handover. Whether buyers recognise it shows in the brand tracker, read against a baseline recorded before anything changed, and the refresh guide reports the IPA's argument that brand-building activity works slowly but lasts. Neither reading judges the studio alone. The audit tutorial traces each gap to its cause, and the cause may be a template, an old file or a guideline gap rather than the design.

If the work goes badly during the project, improving an underperforming agency starts with the written scope and the evidence, and asks what share of the cause lies with the business.

Changing studio without losing the files

A studio can be changed, but only if the business holds what the next one will need. As general practice, collect before notice is given, and at the latest at handover: everything in the briefing tutorial's handover table, with the brand guidelines in an editable form, the templates in the tools they were built in, the testing records and the decision record added. The agency offboarding checklist is the list for any agency exit, from who owns the accounts to removing access, and the scope's exit and handover section is where those items are promised in advance.

Two things need care at a change. The first is the old files: a retired logo that stays downloadable gets used, so retired files are removed from the shared folders and the studio's access to them is ended as part of the exit, and the asset library is the only place the approved set lives. The second is the committed assets. A new studio may arrive with its own taste, and a change in studio is not a decision to change the cues; those need the leadership decision the exceptions guide describes.

Weighing three proposals for a rope maker (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Vyllamont Ropeworks weighs three studio proposals

Vyllamont Ropeworks, an invented maker of rope and netting for farms and garden suppliers with 14 staff, runs two logos after buying a smaller rival and chooses a new identity. A survey of 200 buyers finds that 38% name the business when shown only the coloured marker thread woven through each rope, while almost none tie the thread to another maker, so the thread is marked fixed in the brief and the strategy page is signed before any studio is asked to quote. Before reading a proposal, the managing director and the sales lead share 100 points across seven criteria: reading of the brief 20, cues to keep 20, templates and handover 20, testing 15, accessibility and production 10, people and cover 10, and clarity of rounds and fees 5. One gate applies: ownership of the master files and permission to adapt the identity must pass to the business, in wording its adviser can check. Studio A, the largest, shows the strongest boards and treats the thread as open, but keeps the master files under a licence, which fails the gate, so it is dropped before any scoring. A freelancer and a small studio are each marked from 1 to 5 using written anchors, in the order the criteria are listed: the freelancer scores 4, 4, 3, 4, 4, 2 and 2 and totals 350 out of 500, and the small studio scores 4, 5, 4, 3, 4, 4 and 3 and totals 400. Re-run with the weight on people and cover raised to 20 and the weight on testing cut to 5, as a sceptical colleague suggests, the totals read 330 and 410, so the leader holds. The small studio is appointed after a paid task in which it applies the thread to the woven end tag and the van door and says what it would test. The decision record names the gate result, both runs of the weights and the condition for reopening: a second change of ownership.

The brand foundations section lists the guides to the strategy, identity and architecture decisions a studio works from.

Common mistakes

  • Hiring before choosing the option. A studio asked for "a rebrand" has not been told which option is wanted. Choose between enforcing, refreshing, a new identity and a rename first, and hire for that.
  • Letting the studio write and judge the strategy. A studio that sets the strategy is also setting the brief its own work is judged against. The business signs the page.
  • Choosing on the boards. A portfolio read only as presentations may not show how the studio's earlier work held up in use.
  • Weighting after reading. The weighted scoring matrix has the weights agreed and dated before any option is scored, which for this choice means before any proposal is opened.
  • Leaving rights for the contract stage. Files, typefaces and images are asked about in the written request and checked by a qualified adviser, so the answers are on record before the price is agreed.
  • Appointing without an owner. After handover, questions about the guidelines have nobody to go to.
  • Buying rollout as if it came with the design. Putting the identity live is separate work with its own scope.
  • Treating the audit or the tracker as a verdict on the studio alone. Both read the whole system, including the templates, the owner and the business's own habits.

Frequently asked questions

What is a brand identity studio hired to do, and what stays with us?

As general practice, the studio designs the system inside a strategy the business has already signed: it proposes routes, specifies the logo, colour, type, imagery, motion and sound, with voice principles where in scope, builds the templates and prepares the files. The business keeps the strategy and its sign-off, the list of cues buyers already recognise, the choice between routes, the master files, the record of what was agreed about rights and the person who will look after the guidelines. The site's agency guidance keeps strategy and brand ownership with the business for the same reason: an agency that sets the strategy is also setting the brief its own work will be judged against.

Can the studio that designs the identity also write the brand strategy?

It can run the workshop, and any draft it offers is input, but the business has to decide, write the final wording and sign; the workshop tutorial warns that a facilitator who also advocates one answer makes a session feel rigged. A strategy written by the studio becomes the brief the studio is judged against, which is the position the site's in-house or agency guidance describes. If the studio helps, treat the strategy as a piece of work of its own, finished and signed before identity work begins, so that each route answers a brief the business can defend and keep if it later changes studio.

Should we choose a studio, a freelancer or an in-house designer?

As general practice, decide by the work rather than the label. With a studio, ask who covers an absence; with a freelancer, ask for a named deputy and for the files to be held where the business can reach them; an in-house designer suits continuing work and keeps the knowledge, but a one-off identity project can need depth the team cannot justify employing. Whichever is chosen, the same safeguards apply: a signed strategy, criteria written in advance, files in the business's hands and a named owner for the guidelines.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Sources

  1. Institute of Practitioners in Advertising — IPA
  2. Ehrenberg-Bass Institute for Marketing Science — Ehrenberg-Bass Institute
  3. Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) — W3C

Related