What an identity brief must settle that a campaign brief does not
A creative briefA short document telling the people making creative work what it must achieve, for whom, with which message and within which limits. directs one piece of work inside an identity that already exists. The creative brief template assumes the logo, colours, type and voice are settled and asks for a proposition, a tone and a format. An identity brief commissions the system itself, so it cannot assume any of that. It has to answer five questions a campaign brief never asks.
First, what does the identity express? The answer is the one-page strategy from the brand strategy guide: audience, position, promise, personality and the assets the brand has committed to. Second, what must survive? Any cue buyers already link to the brand is worth more than a new one, and the brief has to say which cues are fixed. Third, where must the system work? An identity that looks right on a presentation board can fail on a mobile banner, a van or a text message. Fourth, what exactly will be delivered? Fifth, who will own and maintain it afterwards?
Leaving any of these open hands the decision to the designer's assumptions. The identity guide warns that an identity built without a strategy is then defended on taste. When an identity project disappoints, the cause is often a brief that left these five questions open rather than the design itself.
Before you start
Have a signed one-page brand strategy. If the strategy is still being argued, the identity project will become the place where it is argued, at a much higher cost; settle it first. Agree the decision rights with a RACI matrix: one accountable person signs off the brief, the chosen route and the handover, and the people who will be consulted are named in advance so their views arrive in one place. Collect the brand as it appears today: logo files, colours in use, templates, signage, packaging, ads and social profiles.
Decide how the studio will be chosen. The agency selection guide covers shortlisting, chemistry meetings and contracts, and the agency request for proposal template turns the brief into questions every shortlisted studio answers in the same form. Finally, decide whether this is a refresh of an existing identity or a new one, because the brief for each differs in how much it fixes. The guide to deciding between a brand refresh and a rebrand makes that call before the brief is written. The guide to hiring and evaluating a brand identity studio adds what a studio is hired to do, the questions to put to each one and how to weigh the responses.
The steps
Confirm the strategy and the assets to keep
Attach the signed strategy page to the brief and quote the lines the identity must express: who the brand is for, what it promises and how it behaves. Then list the existing cues and mark each as keep, open or retire. The distinctive brand assets framework reports the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute's argument that an asset must be both widely recognised and uniquely linked to one brand; a cue that already does both is fixed in the brief, and the designer's job is to make it more prominent, not to replace it. Where the evidence is thin, mark the cue as open and plan to test it.
List the touchpoints the system must work on
Write down every touchpointAny interaction between a person and a brand, paid, owned or earned, before, during or after a purchase. the identity will appear on, grouped by type: screens (website, app, email, social avatars and posts, ads in each format), print (stationery, letters, leaflets), physical (signage, vehicles, uniforms, packaging) and the smallest uses (favicons, profile pictures, text messages, appointment reminders). Mark the touchpoints most people see. The identity guide's channel matrix applies here: each channel allows different assets, and the brief should name the hardest ones, because a system that survives those survives everywhere.
Define deliverables, files and who owns them
List what the project must hand over: master logo files in every version and format needed, the colour palette with values for print and screen, typefaces and their licences, imagery and illustration direction, motion and sound direction if needed, brand voiceThe consistent personality a brand expresses in its words across channels, with tone adjusting to the situation and the audience. principles if they are in scope, written guidelines and the templates for the touchpoints listed. State that file ownership and usage rights, including typeface and image licences, will be agreed in the contract. As general practice businesses aim to own the master files and the right to adapt them, but this is a legal question: take advice from a qualified adviser on the contract wording. This tutorial makes no claim about intellectual property law.
Write the brief and the criteria routes will be judged by
Write the brief in plain language: the business and its situation, the strategy page, the assets to keep, the touchpoints, the deliverables, the decision-makers, the budget and the timing. Then write the criteria every route will be judged by, before any route exists. Draw them from the strategy and the touchpoint list. Does it express the personality? Does it keep the fixed cues prominent? Does it work at the smallest size on the hardest touchpoint? Could buyers mistake it for a competitor? Is it simple enough for non-designers to apply? Criteria written in advance are what make feedback about the brief rather than taste.
Shortlist and ask for a response to the brief, not free designs
Send the brief to a short list of studios or freelancers chosen through the agency selection guide's process. Ask each to respond to the brief: how they read the problem, what they would research and test, how they would run reviews, what they would deliver and how they handle files and handover. Avoid asking for unpaid concepts. Designs produced without a briefing conversation or research are guesses, and they invite a choice on looks rather than on the response to the problem. Send the same request for proposalA document sent to shortlisted agencies or sellers giving each the same facts and questions and the published scoring criteria, so responses compare. to every studio on the shortlist. The request for proposal template makes responses comparable.
Hold the briefing call and get the brief played back
Once a studio is appointed, brief it in a call or meeting, not only in writing, and invite questions. The agency guide's habit applies: ask the studio to play the brief back in its own words before work starts, and correct any reading that differs from yours. Agree the review dates, who attends each review and how feedback will be given. Run the agency onboarding checklist for access to files, the approval route and the first review date.
Review routes against the brief in consolidated rounds
When the studio presents its routes, judge each against the written criteria, in order, before anyone says whether they like it. Collect every stakeholder's comments, resolve contradictions internally and send one consolidated set of feedback from the accountable person, as the agency guide recommends. Tie each comment to a criterion or a touchpoint: "the mark disappears on the appointment reminder" is actionable; "it feels cold" needs translating into which line of the personality it misses.
Test the leading route with category buyers and in real templates
Test the leading route in two ways. With category buyers, not staff or loyal customers, show it in context and ask what kind of business it suggests, what it seems to promise and whether it reminds them of anyone else. That checks recognition, meaning and confusion with rivals. It is not a vote on liking, because whether people like a design says little about whether they will recognise it or read it correctly. In real templates, apply the route to the hardest touchpoints from the list and look at them at true size, on real devices and in real light.
Check accessibility and production before sign-off
Accessibility is a specification, as the identity guide says, so check it before the route is final. Every colour pair used for text should pass the contrast requirements of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAGThe W3C's Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, the widely used standard for making web content usable by people with disabilities.), and colour should never be the only way information is shown, as the brand guidelines template and the landing page accessibility guide state. Check production too: print colours on real stock, the logo embroidered or cut in vinyl if those uses exist, the typefaces licensed for web and app use, and email fallbacks for type.
Take the handover: master files, guidelines, templates, asset library and an owner
Do not sign off the project until the handover is complete and checked, using the table below. Load the approved files into one asset libraryThe single home for approved marketing files, holding one current copy of each with its version, rights, expiry, alternative text and usage notes., remove retired files from shared drives, and name the person who will own the guidelines, answer questions and run the brand consistency audit. Putting the new identity live across every surface is a separate piece of work, sequenced by the tutorial on rolling out a rebrand.
What a complete handover contains
A handover is complete when someone who has never met the studio could produce correct work from what was delivered. The table lists what to check before final sign-off.
| Item | What to check | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Master logo files | Every version, colour variant and format in the deliverables list, named consistently | Missing variants get improvised |
| Colour specification | Values for print and screen, approved text and background pairs that pass contrast | Prevents near-identical colours in use |
| Typefaces | Files, licences covering every use, and fallbacks for email and systems | Unlicensed or missing fonts get substituted |
| Imagery, motion and sound direction | Written rules with reference examples | Keeps video and photography recognisable |
| Voice principles | Principles with "this, not that" examples, if in scope | The words are policed less than the logo |
| Guidelines | Short, organised by the user's question, matching the brand guidelines template | People need answers, not a design book |
| Templates | Editable templates for the touchpoints most people see, locked where tooling allows | People copy what exists |
| Asset library | Approved files only, in one place, with retired files removed | Retired files that remain get used |
| Ownership record | The contract terms on files and rights, kept with the assets | Avoids disputes when a supplier changes |
| Named owner | The person who answers questions and runs the audit | Guidelines without an owner freeze |
A dental group briefs its new identity (illustrative)
Pentrobble Dental briefs and takes handover of a new identity
Pentrobble Dental, an invented group of 5 dental practices, briefs a new identity after its practices have drifted into 3 different logos. The brief attaches the signed strategy page and marks its teal as a committed asset: in a survey of 300 local adults, 41% linked the teal to Pentrobble without the name shown. The touchpoint list runs to 23 items and names 4 as hardest: the text-message appointment reminder, the app icon, the reception screen and the external sign seen from the road. Four studios respond to the brief, and none is asked for free designs. The appointed studio plays the brief back in a call and presents 3 routes. The partners prefer a fine-line route that impressed them on a presentation board, but at the size of the appointment reminder its mark becomes unreadable, so it fails the first criterion and is dropped. The second route keeps the teal prominent and is tested with 20 local adults who are not patients. Most read it as a modern, calm practice and none confuses it with another dental group. Contrast checks remove 1 pale teal and grey pair from text use. After 2 consolidated rounds, the handover includes master files, guidelines, templates for signage, letters, reminders and social posts, and an asset library. The practice manager at the largest site is named as owner, with the first consistency audit booked for 12 months later.
Common mistakes
- Briefing before the strategy is signed. The identity project becomes the place the strategy is argued, at design rates.
- Leaving the cues to keep unstated. A studio that is not told what to keep will reasonably assume everything is open, and recognition built over years is thrown away.
- Judging routes on a presentation board. A route that only works large has not been tested. Put it on the hardest touchpoints at true size.
- Feedback from everyone, directly. Contradictory comments from several stakeholders cause late, expensive work. Consolidate them and send one set against the criteria.
- Testing for liking. Preference says little about recognition or meaning. Ask what the route suggests and whom it reminds people of.
- Treating accessibility as a final polish. Contrast and colour rules decided late force changes to work already approved.
- Signing off without the templates. Guidelines alone do not stop drift. Templates for the most-seen touchpoints do most of the work.
- No owner at handover. A system without a named owner starts drifting on the day it launches. The brand foundations section places the identity between the strategy and architecture work it depends on.
