Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Google Ads & PPC › Account Structure & Management

Hiring and Evaluating a Google Ads Agency

How to hire and judge a Google Ads agency or freelancer: account ownership first, questions to ask, warning signs, scope, access, reporting and how to end it.
Guidebeginner9 min readUpdated

What a paid search provider does

A Google Ads agency or freelancer runs the routine the account management hub describes: a weekly look at spend, search terms and disapprovals; a monthly look at performance against the targets, impression share and budget reallocation; and a quarterly look at structure, bidding and landing pages. Around that routine sit the projects: an audit, a build or restructure, conversion tracking, new campaign types and experiments.

What a provider cannot do is decide what the business is trying to achieve. The objective, the value of a sale or a lead, the margin that sets the most the business can pay for one, and the outcomes that count are business decisions. The guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies covers the selection process, contracts and scorecards for any agency, and the in-house versus agency comparison covers whether to hire at all. This guide adds what is specific to paid search: the account, the conversions, the search terms and the reports. Where one provider will also run other paid platforms and hold the targets and conversion events across them, the guide to hiring and evaluating a performance marketing agency covers that cross-platform layer.

Ownership and access before anything else

The hub's principle is that the business owns its account and grants access to agencies, not the other way around, so that a change of agency does not mean a change of account and the loss of its history and learning. Settle that before any proposal is compared:

  • The account is created by the business, under a login it controls, or already belongs to it. The new account setup tutorial covers creating one that way.
  • The provider is granted access, usually by linking its manager account, and the business keeps its own administrators. The manager accounts and access guide sets out the arrangement and the review that keeps it current.
  • Access is at the lowest level that works. People who only read reports do not need to edit; the business's owner and deputy hold admin.
  • Billing belongs to the business. The pillar's account safety section says payment profiles belong to the business, never to an individual contractor.

A provider that proposes to run the business's advertising in an account it owns is proposing that the business start again from nothing whenever the relationship ends.

Questions to ask before hiring

The answers matter less than whether they are specific. A careful provider answers each with how it works in the account; a careless one answers with reassurance.

QuestionWhat a good answer includes
Who will work on our account, and who covers when they are away?Named people, their roles and how much of their time the account gets
How will conversions be defined, and which will be primary?A short list tied to the business outcome, with the rest secondary, checked against the business's own records
How do you read search terms and add negatives?A regular review of the Search Terms Report, shared lists and a record of what was excluded and why
How will targets be set?From margin or lead value, using a calculation the business can follow, not from an average or a benchmark
What may you change without our approval?A clear line: routine optimisation within agreed limits, with budgets, targets, conversion actions and new campaign types needing sign-off
What will the first month produce?An audit or setup review, a measurement check and a written plan
What will we see each month, and can we check it?Reports built on primary conversions, reconciled with the business's sales or leads
What happens when the relationship ends?The business keeps the account, its history and every list; access is removed in an agreed order

Conversion definitions deserve the most time. Google describes conversion tracking as the way to see what happens after someone interacts with an ad, such as a purchase, a sign-up or a call. Which of those count, and which drive bidding, decides what the account optimises towards. The measurement hub explains primary and secondary actions; agree them in writing before launch. Where sales close offline, as with most lead-generation businesses, ask how closed business will reach the account, for example by Offline Conversion Import, so that bidding learns from outcomes rather than form fills.

Warning signs

  • An account created under the provider. The business does not own its history, and leaving means starting again.
  • Shared logins. Change history stops showing who did what, and access cannot be removed for one person.
  • Reports built on all conversions or on clicks alone. Secondary actions, page views and clicks flatter the figures; the report should lead with primary conversions and the business's own outcomes.
  • Reluctance to share search terms or change history. Both belong to the business's account; a provider that will not show them is hiding what was bought or what was changed.
  • Targets with no derivation. A target cost per acquisition (CPA) or return on ad spend (ROAS) offered without reference to the business's margin is a guess.
  • Guaranteed results. Nobody controls the auction; a promise of a specific outcome before the account has been read is a sales line.
  • Rebuilding before reading. Replacing every campaign before an audit throws away the history and learning the account already has.

The guide to agency reports that look good while sales stay flat shows how several of these combine: platform metrics in the report, over-claimed conversions and existing demand counted as new.

Scoping: audit, build or ongoing management

Three kinds of work are worth separating, because they suit different situations and produce different things.

ScopeWhat it deliversWhen it fits
AuditA prioritised list of findings with evidence, starting with measurementAny existing account, and always before a retainer
Build or restructureCampaigns, conversion actions and lists set up to a written planA new account, or an audit that found the structure in the way
Ongoing managementThe weekly, monthly and quarterly routine, with agreed reportingOnce measurement is trusted and the structure is sound

Start with an audit. The account audit tutorial shows what a good one covers: measurement integrity first, then structure, settings, keywords, search terms, ads, bidding, audiences and landing pages, ending in a scored backlog. The audit is useful whoever does the work afterwards, and it shows how the provider thinks. The agency RFP template structures the request so that several providers answer the same questions and can be scored side by side.

Reporting that can be checked

A report is only useful if the business can verify it. Four tests:

  • It leads with primary conversions, the ones agreed before launch, and reconciles them with the business's own sales or leads for the same period. Differences are explained, not hidden.
  • It reports against the agreed KPI set, the same measures every month, so changes are visible.
  • It shows what was changed and why, with dates, so that a movement in results can be traced to a decision. Change history in the account is the record; the report should agree with it.
  • It shows what was bought. A summary of the search terms that carried spend, the negatives added and the campaigns that grew or shrank.

The CPA calculator turns spend and outcomes into the cost per result the business can compare with its own maximum.

Judging results after the first months

Judge the process early and the results later. In the first month, check that access was set up properly, that measurement was checked against the business's own records, that the audit was delivered and that reports arrived on time and in the agreed form. Those are within the provider's control from day one.

Results take longer. The Smart Bidding strategies guide notes that Google documents a learning period after a bid strategy is created or significantly changed, during which performance can fluctuate. Conversions also arrive after the clicks that led to them, so the most recent days are always incomplete. Compare like with like: the same months a year earlier where the business is seasonal, the same conversion definitions, and the business's own outcomes rather than the platform's column alone. A provider whose platform figures improve while the business's sales or qualified leads do not has improved the report, not the business.

Changing or ending the arrangement

The agency offboarding checklist gives the order: ownership first, then assets and knowledge, continuity decisions and only then access removal. For Google Ads that means confirming the business holds admin access, collecting the change history, the test log and every shared list, deciding which campaigns keep running through the handover and only then ending the outgoing provider's link. The incoming provider starts in the same account, with its history intact.

The same logic applies to hiring paid search help as to the guide on hiring an SEO agency: the business keeps what it owns, scopes before it commits and judges on outcomes it can verify.

Three proposals compared (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Mossgavel Legal chooses paid search help

Mossgavel Legal, an invented law firm offering family and property law, spends about £4,000 a month on Google Ads through an account a former employee set up. It asks three providers to answer the same RFP and scores each answer from one to five.

CriterionProvider A (agency)Provider B (freelancer)Provider C (agency)
Account ownership5: works in the firm's account via its manager account5: same1: would run campaigns in a new account it owns
Conversion definitions4: primary on qualified consultations, form fills secondary5: same, plus closed matters imported from the case system2: all form fills and calls counted equally
Search terms and negatives4: fortnightly review, shared lists4: weekly review, shared lists3: monthly review
Targets3: from average past cost per lead5: from fee per matter and conversion to client2: from an industry figure
Changes without approval4: clear limits4: clear limits2: not specified
First month5: audit and measurement check4: audit2: full rebuild
Reporting4: primary conversions reconciled monthly5: same, plus closed matters2: clicks and all conversions
Total out of 35293214

The firm rejects Provider C on ownership alone; the score only confirms it. It commissions an audit from Provider B for a fixed fee, with no retainer agreed until the findings are read. The audit finds that a "contact page view" action has been primary since the account began, so the reported cost per lead of £19 hides a cost per qualified consultation nearer £140. The firm agrees a three-month management trial judged on qualified consultations and closed matters, with the account, its history and its lists staying with the firm.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing proposals before settling ownership. A cheaper proposal that runs the account in the provider's name is the most expensive one at the end.
  • Letting the provider define success. Conversions, targets and the outcomes that count are business decisions.
  • Skipping the audit. A retainer without one buys activity before anyone knows what the account needs.
  • Judging on platform figures alone. Reconcile with sales or qualified leads before judging.
  • Judging too early. Learning periods and late conversions make the first weeks unreliable.
  • Granting admin to everyone. Access at the lowest level that works, with the business's own administrators.
  • No agreed limits on changes. Budgets, targets and conversion actions should not move without sign-off.
  • Planning the exit at the end. Agree how access is removed and what the business keeps before the work starts.

Frequently asked questions

Should we hire an agency or a freelancer for Google Ads?

Either can do the work well; the questions are the same. Ask who will actually work on the account, what happens when that person is away, how conversions will be defined and how results will be reported. A freelancer is often closer to the work and an agency usually has more cover and breadth. What matters more than the label is that the business owns the account, access is granted at the lowest level that works, and the reports can be checked against the business's own records.

What should the first piece of work be?

An audit of the existing account, or a setup review for a new one, before any retainer. It shows how the provider thinks, it produces a prioritised list the business keeps whoever does the work, and it tests whether measurement can be trusted. A provider who wants to rebuild everything before reading what is there is skipping the step that matters most.

How soon can we judge whether the agency is working?

Judge the process from the first month: access, measurement checks, the audit, the reports. Judge results only after any learning period from bid strategy changes has passed and enough conversions have accumulated to compare with the period before, and judge them on the business's own outcomes, such as sales or qualified leads, rather than on the platform's conversion column alone.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Where this page is used

Sources

  1. Google Ads Help — Google Ads Help
  2. About conversion tracking — Google Ads Help

Related