Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

SEO › SEO Measurement

Hiring and Evaluating an SEO Agency

How to hire and judge an SEO agency or consultant: deciding the scope, questions to ask, warning signs Google describes, deliverables and progress checks.
Guidebeginner10 min readUpdated

What an SEO provider does

Google's page "Do you need an SEO?" describes the useful services that SEO agencies and consultants provide: reviewing a site's content or structure, technical advice on website development such as hosting, redirects, error pages and the use of JavaScript, content development, managing online business development campaigns, keyword research, SEO training, and expertise in particular markets and geographies. It also recommends that site owners become educated consumers before they start looking, by learning how search engines work, so that they can judge what they are offered.

In practice that work falls into four areas, and few providers are equally strong in all of them:

AreaTypical workWhat you need in-house for it to land
TechnicalAudits, crawl and indexing fixes, migrations, site architecture, structured dataDeveloper time to implement and a release process
ContentKeyword research, keyword maps, briefs, writing and refreshing pagesSubject experts to review and someone to approve and publish
AuthorityDigital PR and earning links from relevant sitesSpokespeople, data or stories worth covering
MeasurementSearch Console and analytics set-up, reporting, forecastingAccess to data and someone who acts on the reports

Most SEO recommendations are implemented by the client's own developers and editors. A provider can be excellent and still produce nothing if the business has no capacity to act on its advice, so check the right-hand column before hiring anyone. The comparison of in-house and agency marketing helps decide which parts of the work to buy in at all. When the work is a Business Profile, listings and reviews rather than a website, the guide to hiring and evaluating a local marketing agency covers the questions, warning signs and ownership rules particular to that work.

Audit, project or retainer

The form of engagement should follow the problem.

EngagementSuitsDeliverableWatch for
AuditFinding out what is wrong; a second opinion; preparing a business caseA prioritised list of findings with examples, effort and expected impactGeneric checklists; findings without example URLs or priorities
ProjectA defined job: a migration, a new section, a technical clean-up, a content clusterThe finished work against an agreed specification and dateScope creep; the project ending before results can be read
RetainerContinuing work across technical, content and authorityAgreed monthly deliverables and reportingHours consumed by reporting and meetings rather than work
Training or advisoryBuilding an in-house team's skillsSessions, reviews of the team's work, on-call adviceAdvice the team has no time to apply

Google's page notes that the earlier an SEO is involved the better, and that a redesign or new site launch is a good time to bring one in, because the site can be built search-friendly from the start. A business planning a migration in the next year usually needs a project before it needs a retainer.

Questions to ask before hiring

Google's page offers a list of questions to put to any SEO. They are worth asking in this form, and the answers are more revealing than any credentials:

  • Can you show examples of previous work and share some success stories?
  • Do you follow Google Search Essentials?
  • Do you offer other online marketing services or advice to complement organic search?
  • What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe? How do you measure success?
  • What is your experience in our industry, in our country or city, and with international sites, if relevant?
  • What are your most important SEO techniques?
  • How long have you been in business?
  • How will we communicate, and how often?
  • Will you share all the changes you make to our site, with the reasoning behind your recommendations?

Add questions specific to your situation: who exactly will do the work, how much of their time you will get, which of their recommendations depend on your developers, and how they would handle a result that falls short. Follow up the success stories with the referees, and ask what went wrong as well as what went right. A provider who answers the timeframe question with a confident promise of rankings has answered the warning-signs question too.

Warning signs

Google's page is direct about the risks. It says that no one can guarantee a top ranking on Google, and tells site owners to beware of anyone who claims to guarantee rankings, claims a special relationship with Google or advertises priority submission, which does not exist. It warns about unsolicited emails offering search services, about providers who are secretive or will not explain what they intend to do, and about anyone who creates deceptive content on a client's behalf, such as doorway pages or throwaway domains. It says a site owner should never have to link to their SEO, and to avoid providers who talk about link popularity schemes or submitting a site to thousands of search engines. And it reminds site owners that they are ultimately responsible for the actions of any company they hire.

Google's spam policies for web search, which the guide to Google's spam policies explains for marketers, describe the practices that can cause a site to rank lower or not appear in results at all. Several are things a careless or unscrupulous provider might do in a client's name: link spam, including buying links or exchanging them to manipulate rankings; scaled content abuse, producing many pages mainly to manipulate rankings rather than help people; doorway abuse; cloaking; sneaky redirects; and expired domain abuse. A provider who proposes any of these, however it is worded, is putting your site at risk, not theirs.

Warning signWhat to ask or do
Guaranteed rankings or first-page promisesDecline; ask what they will commit to delivering instead
Claims of a special relationship with Google or priority submissionDecline; neither exists
Secrecy about methods ("proprietary techniques")Ask for a written explanation of every change and every link source
Link packages, networks or a fixed number of links per monthAsk where the links come from and why those sites would link; compare with the link quality guide
Large volumes of thin pages or new domains proposedAsk who the pages are for and what each adds
A requirement to link to the providerDecline
Unsolicited outreach with an alarming auditTreat as a sales tactic; verify any claimed problem in Search Console

Scoping deliverables and access

Write the scope in deliverables, not hours or activities. "Technical SEO support" cannot be checked; "a crawl and indexing audit with prioritised findings and example URLs by the end of month one, and specifications for the top fixes in the format our developers use" can. For each deliverable, state the format, the date, who reviews it and what counts as accepted. State what is out of scope and how changes are priced, as the agency selection and review guide describes for any agency.

Agree reporting in advance: which measures, from which sources, in what segments, how often. The SEO KPIs and reporting guide sets out a chain of indicators from coverage to outcomes; ask the provider to report against it rather than against a measure of their own choosing, and to explain movements with annotated causes. Ask also for a change log of everything they change on the site and a list of every link they build or request, with the source.

Access should be the least the work needs, through named accounts that the business controls:

  • Search Console (GSC) and analytics: add the provider as users with the permission level the work requires, rather than handing over ownership. The Search Console tutorial covers adding users.
  • Content management system: individual logins with the narrowest role that allows the agreed work.
  • Server, hosting and code: only if the scope requires it, with changes going through the normal release process. Google's page says that a provider with access to your server should be willing to explain every change they make.
  • No shared passwords, and every account owned by the business, so access can be removed in minutes.

Judging progress in the first months

Organic search results take time. Google's page says that, in most cases, it takes months for an SEO to help a business implement improvements and then see potential benefit. That makes the first months hard to judge on outcomes, so judge them on the work and the leading indicators instead.

PeriodWhat to judgeEvidence
First weeksUnderstanding of the business, quality of the audit, clarity of prioritiesDeliverables against the scope; quality of questions asked
First monthsDelivery of agreed work; recommendations implemented; fixes validatedChange log; Search Console indexing reports; pages published
Following monthsMovement in leading indicators for target clustersImpressions, positions and clicks for the target clusters in Search Console
LaterOutcomes against the forecastNon-brand organic conversions and value from target pages (KPI)

Remember that implementation is often your side of the arrangement. If recommendations sit in a queue because developers are busy, the provider's work cannot show results, and a fair review records that. A two-way scorecard, scoring the provider on delivery and the business on implementation and feedback, keeps the review honest. When outcomes do arrive, judge them on contribution against the full cost of the arrangement (ROI), not on traffic alone, and against the same baseline the provider started from. The SEO measurement hub sets out what each data source can and cannot prove, which helps when a provider's report leans on a single flattering number.

Changing or ending the arrangement

Before ending, check whether the problem is fixable: a clearer scope, a different team or better implementation on your side often rescues an arrangement. Document the issues in reviews and give the provider a fair chance to address them.

When you do end it, plan the handover before giving notice:

  • Documentation: the audit, keyword map, briefs, change log, reports and any forecast, in formats you can use without the provider.
  • Links: the full list of links built or requested for the site (Backlink), with sources, so you can check them against the spam policies. If any were bought or placed in schemes, the responsibility stays with the site, as Google's page makes clear.
  • Work in progress: pages in draft, fixes specified but not shipped, redirects planned.
  • Access: remove the provider's users from Search Console, analytics, the content management system and any server or code access on the last day, and change any credentials that were shared despite the rule above.

The agency offboarding checklist covers the general handover, and the SEO versus PPC comparison is a useful check, before appointing a replacement, on whether the next budget should go to organic search at all.

Illustrative example — not a real result

A tile retailer compares three SEO proposals

Velvetgrout Tiles, an invented online tile retailer, wants help with its category pages and a planned replatforming. It invites three providers to respond to the same brief and scores each from 1 to 5 on five criteria agreed in advance.

CriterionProvider AProvider BProvider C
Understanding of the brief and the replatforming risk425
Clarity about methods and changes414
Deliverables defined with dates325
Relevant experience and references434
Measurement plan using Velvetgrout's own data314
Total out of 2518922

Provider B's proposal promises first-page rankings for 50 keywords within 90 days and a package of 30 links a month from "partner sites" it will not name; Velvetgrout rules it out on those two points alone. It appoints Provider C for a six-month project: a technical audit and category template specification in month one, migration support with a redirect map in months two and three, and four category page rewrites a month in months four to six, each with a monthly report on the agreed indicators. Reviews are set for the end of months three and six, and access is through named Search Console and content system accounts owned by Velvetgrout.

Common mistakes

  • Buying a retainer when the problem is a project. Match the engagement to the job.
  • Hiring without implementation capacity. Recommendations nobody can ship produce nothing.
  • Accepting ranking guarantees. Google says no one can guarantee them; treat the promise as a warning.
  • Not asking about methods and links. You are responsible for what is done in your site's name.
  • Scoping activities instead of deliverables. Nothing can be checked.
  • Sharing passwords or handing over account ownership. Access should be individual, minimal and removable.
  • Judging the first months on outcomes alone. Judge delivery and leading indicators first.
  • Ending without a handover. Documentation, links and access must come back with the work.

Frequently asked questions

Can an SEO agency guarantee first-page rankings?

No. Google's page on hiring an SEO states that no one can guarantee a top ranking on Google, and it tells site owners to be wary of anyone who claims to guarantee rankings, a special relationship with Google or priority submission. A provider can commit to deliverables, such as fixes specified, pages written and reports produced, and to how it will measure progress. Rankings are decided by the search engine.

How soon can I tell whether an SEO agency is working?

Within the first months you can judge the work itself: whether deliverables arrive on time and to standard, whether recommendations are clear and prioritised, and whether fixes that were implemented show up in Search Console. Outcomes such as non-brand clicks and leads take longer, and Google's page on hiring an SEO says improvements typically take months to implement and then to show benefit. Agree in advance which leading indicators you will review at each point.

What access should I give an SEO agency?

The least that lets them do the agreed work, through named individual accounts. Add them as users to Search Console and analytics with the permission level the work needs, give them their own login to the content management system if they will edit pages, and avoid sharing passwords. Keep ownership of every account in the business's name, ask for an explanation of every change they make to the site, and remove access when the work ends.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Sources

  1. Do you need an SEO? — Google Search Central
  2. Spam policies for Google web search — Google Search Central

Related