Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Local Marketing › Local Presence

Hiring and Evaluating a Local Marketing Agency

How to hire and judge a local marketing provider: ownership of the profile and listings, questions on reviews and ads, warning signs, reports and handover.
Guidebeginner18 min readUpdated

What a local marketing provider is hired to do

A provider can take on parts of the local system that the local marketing pillar sets out: being found, being chosen, being reached, being remembered and, for a business with several sites, being repeatable. In practice the work falls into a few strands.

StrandWhat the provider can take onWhat stays with the businessStandard to hold it to
Profile and listing upkeepVerifying and completing the Business Profile (GBP), entering the name as it appears on signage, proposing categories, listing services, hours and photos, and watching for edits nobody madeDecisions on the name, address, categories and areas served, and ownership of the profileThe Business Profile tutorial
Details across the webSearching for listings, auditing the name, address and phone (NAP) each one shows, correcting each source and reporting duplicatesThe master record, and approval of each change to itThe citations and NAP guide
ReviewsSetting up the ask, monitoring new reviews and drafting repliesWhere the ask sits in the customer journey, who approves a reply and who deals with a complaintThe reviews and reputation guide
Local advertisingBuilding and running lead-unit and geo-targeted campaigns, rating and disputing leadsThe accounts, the budget and its ceiling, and answering the callsThe Local Services Ads guide and the geo-targeted campaigns guide
Pages and contentDrafting area or location pages and posts about the work doneThe facts, the photos and the jobs describedThe service area pages guide
ReportingA monthly table with notes beside itThe booking records the table is checked againstThe tutorial on measuring Business Profile results

Community activity sits outside the table on purpose. The community marketing guide says a sponsorship earns its keep only if the business attends, posts about it, is named by the sponsored body and renews, so, as general practice, a provider can help plan and record that work while the business itself turns up and posts about it.

Whether to buy any of this in is a question that comes first, and the in-house against agency comparison covers it. Once the answer is to buy, the agency selection and review guide supplies the process: the shortlist, the request, the meetings, scope and fees, the contract, service levels, reviews and exits. This page adds what is particular to local work. When the job is the visibility of a website in search rather than the profile and the listings, the guide to hiring an SEO agency applies, and when the job is paid search accounts the Google Ads agency hiring guide does.

What stays in the business's own name

The local work runs through a handful of accounts and records, and the same rule applies to them as the manager accounts guide sets for ad accounts, which the locked-out diagnosis carries over to the profile: the business holds them and grants the provider access, rather than the other way round. The diagnosis for a business locked out of its own profile shows what the end of a relationship looks like when a provider held the profile and ownership was not moved.

AssetWhy the business holds itWhat the provider receives
The Business ProfileThe owner role decides who holds it, and Business Profile Help sets out what each role can doA manager role with the access the work needs
The account that owns itIts setup is what the locked-out diagnosis's prevention section sets out, so that one person leaving cannot lock the business outNo owner role
Listing and directory loginsCorrections go to the source and listings are claimed where the platform allows, so the claimed listing should sit with the businessAccess recorded in the register, as general practice
Ad accounts and billingThe business creates them and links the provider, and payment belongs to the business, as the manager accounts guide sets outAccess at the level the work needs
Analytics, tagged links and any tracking numberThe monthly table depends on them, and a tracking number put on the profile leaves the main number in place as an additional oneRead access, and write access to tags while the engagement lasts, as general practice
The master record, naming rule and change logThey record what the profile should say and why it changedRead access to the master record and the naming rule, with changes requested and not made, and an entry in the change log for each edit the provider makes, as general practice
The reply guideline and the escalation listThey are the business's voice and its limitsDrafting access, as general practice

Record the arrangement in the register that the locked-out diagnosis describes. The access review tutorial builds a register across all tools and sets the triggers that keep it up to date, and a dated access review checks it as people join and leave on both sides. Name one accountable person for the profile, for instance in a RACI matrix, and, as general practice, put that person on the business's side.

If the profile already exists, ask at the start who holds it. Profiles made by a web designer, a previous agency or a member of staff are the cases the locked-out diagnosis and the diagnosis for duplicate listings work through, and the business should settle ownership and duplicates before any provider optimises anything.

Questions for each shortlisted provider

Put the same questions to each provider in writing; the agency request for proposal template sets them beside the scoring criteria. As general practice, weigh the detail in each answer above its confidence: a specific provider walks through how the work is done in the profile and the ad accounts, and a vague one reassures.

QuestionWhat a specific answer shows
Where will the profile be held, and who will own it?The business's own account as owner, with at least two owners it employs, and the provider as a manager
What name, address, categories and areas will the profile carry, and who decides?The name as it appears on signage, an address the business can use, an address hidden for a business that goes to its customers, and a named decision-maker in the business
How will you find duplicates and details that differ across the web?Searches by name, phone and address, a classified list of what was found, correction at the source and duplicates reported with evidence
How will you ask customers for reviews, and what will you refuse to do?The same ask to each customer at the point of satisfaction with a direct link, and a refusal of incentives, selective asking, staff or family reviews, review stations, bursts and bought reviews
Who drafts replies, who approves them and who posts them?A reply guideline, a named approver, and complaints and private details routed to the business first
Which edits will you make without asking?As general practice, none to the name, address, categories or areas served, and each other edit logged with its date, person and reason
How will calls and website clicks from the profile be counted?Tagged links, calls counted once and the main number kept as the number customers see elsewhere
For ads: which location option, which exclusions and what do you read in the location report?For a business whose customers must be in the area, the presence option, which counts people in the area or regularly there, not people merely interested in it, exclusions, a location report read after a set period, and for the lead unit a note on each dispute
What will the first piece of work deliver?An audit or a review of the current set-up, a baseline recorded before changes begin and a written plan
Who will do the work, and who steps in when they are absent?Named people with their roles, and a named deputy
What happens when we end the arrangement?The business keeps the profile, the accounts and the records, and the order for removing access is agreed in advance

Each answer on ownership, naming, duplicates, reviews and counting has a standard in one of the guides linked above, so the table asks for the answer and does not restate the standard. The rows on the first piece of work and on cover when someone is away are general practice. Once providers are shortlisted, the claimed results tutorial tests the case studies each one shows. Where the profile will be held is not a scored row. The weighted scoring matrix treats a must-have as a gate, pass or fail, so a proposal that plans to hold the profile in the provider's account is out however it scores on rows such as reviews, data, reports and exit.

Warning signs in a local proposal

  • A profile created or held in the provider's account. The locked-out diagnosis lists this as a cause of lost access, and the agency offboarding checklist starts with ownership.
  • Words added to the business name. The guidelines for representing a business expect the profile to carry the name the business really trades under. A name padded with a service word, a place name, a slogan or a phone number breaches them, can get the profile suspended and can be reported by a rival, as the suspended profile diagnosis explains.
  • An address that is not the business's to use. A virtual office, a mailbox or a shared desk does not meet the standard, and a business that travels to its customers hides its address and names its areas instead.
  • A profile for each service or town. One profile per location is the rule. Extra profiles are duplicates that split reviews and clicks and put both profiles at risk.
  • A review count promised by a date, or reviews supplied. A promised number invites the shortcuts that the question on reviews asks the provider to refuse, and the multi-location reviews guide says as much of review-count targets for branches. Paying a service to supply reviews breaches platform policy and, according to the reviews guide, consumer law too, though its table is general direction and not legal advice, and the diagnosis for disappearing reviews shows what happens to reviews asked for the wrong way. The reviews guide names two regulators, the Competition and Markets Authority for the UK and the Federal Trade Commission for the US, and says both treat undisclosed incentives and fake reviews as consumer protection matters.
  • A promised position in the map results. The SEO agency guide records Google's own advice that nobody can promise a top position in search. The benchmarking tutorial records that Google's local ranking help names three factors, relevance, distance and prominence, with no weights, and distance depends on where the searcher is, so a position promised before anyone has searched from where customers search has no evidence behind it.
  • A bulk submission before an audit. Sending the business's details to a long list of directories before anyone has searched for what already exists can introduce inconsistent copies, as the citations guide says of submission packages, and the duplicate listings diagnosis traces some duplicates to bulk uploads. The citations guide audits first and corrects at the source, and the listings guide treats a listing platform as a delivery mechanism, with the master record kept by the business.
  • A tracking number on everything. A number that replaces the main number across listings breaks the match the citations guide depends on, and the measuring tutorial lists it among its mistakes.
  • A report with no bookings in it. Impressions and profile actions with no link to the booking record cannot show whether the work paid, and the profile reports only its own figures, so a comparison with a rival or a published average has no source.

Audit, clean-up, ads or ongoing work

As general practice, buy the work in pieces, so that each can be judged and ended on its own, with a bounded first piece that shows how the provider thinks before an ongoing arrangement starts.

WorkHanded overCheck before paying
Local auditA ranked list of findings against the guidelines, a duplicate search, an audit of details across the web and a comparison with the rivals shown beside the business, each finding with an ownerThat ownership and duplicates rank above anything cosmetic, and that the rivals were searched from inside the area, as the benchmarking tutorial sets out
Clean-upA corrected profile, corrections to the record put to the business for approval, corrected listings, duplicates reported or merged, a draft naming rule for the business to adopt and a change logEach correction against the log, then a fresh search by name, phone and address
Review routineThe ask, its link, a monitoring view, a reply guideline and an escalation listThe setup against the review request launch checklist
Local adsCampaigns inside the business's accounts, with locations, exclusions, assets and a lead routineWho owns the accounts, the location setting, and the location report read after a period set in advance
Ongoing workThe routine the Business Profile tutorial sets out and a monthly reportThat the change log carries dates and that the report ties to bookings

The agency scope of work template shows how to write a statement of work with the exclusions written down, so that nobody assumes someone else is writing the review replies or watching for edits; as general practice, write one for each piece. Where the ongoing work runs on a retainer, the statement of work should say, as general practice, which of the table's items the retainer covers and which are agreed separately.

Many sites: the centre keeps the record

For a business with branches, franchisees or practices, the provider works inside the centre's frame and not instead of it. The listings at scale guide makes the master record the single source of truth for each site's details and has the central account own the profiles, with local managers added as managers with limited rights. As general practice, the provider should be one of those managers, taking changes from the record and not inventing them. Ask how a change reaches each copy of the record; the opening hours change SOP is the shape of an answer for a change to hours.

Reviews follow the split in the multi-location reviews guide: a named replier at each site, a central guideline and an escalation list. As general practice, a provider can monitor and draft within that, and it cannot replace the local voices the guide wants at each site. Reports are read site by site against each site's own history, and branches ranked on review counts is a mistake the same guide warns against.

Who decides what is the subject of the comparison of centralised and local control, whose hybrid model gives the centre the system and the locations the relationship with their own area. As general practice, the provider's scope should mirror that split, and the proposal should say which decisions it takes for the centre and which go back to a site.

Local reports that tie back to bookings

Agree these reports at the outset, in forms the business can test against its own records:

  • The profile's own figures, month by month. Read them the way the measuring tutorial does, remembering that the profile reports only its own figures.
  • Tagged links read in analytics. Ask for website clicks from the profile under their own source, as the measuring tutorial sets out.
  • Calls counted once. Ask for one count of record, and use the guide to measuring calls and chats to decide which calls are enquiries.
  • Where the customer heard of the business, asked at booking. The answer sits in the business's own booking record, so the business can read it without relying on the provider's figures.
  • Reviews as a routine. Volume, recency and replies, with the reply time agreed in advance.
  • A dated change log beside the table. Without it a change in the figures cannot be traced to its cause later, and an edit nobody logged cannot be told apart from one the public suggested.
  • For ads, the location report and the lead notes. Where clicks came from, and the note kept for each disputed lead.

Check the provider's figures against the booking record before accepting any of them. The measuring tutorial builds the table and the checks, and the guide to reading small numbers says what a month with a handful of calls can and cannot show.

Judging the early months

The early work can be judged, as general practice, on what the business can verify, and results later. Early on, look for the changes that the business can verify itself: ownership moved and the register complete, a naming rule written, duplicates searched for and resolved or reported, the audit of details across the web logged with its corrections, the review ask live with replies on time, the change log kept and the first report delivered on the agreed date. These checks can be read before calls and bookings can, so they are the business's first evidence that the work was delivered; treat them as leading indicators only once they have been shown to precede bookings.

Calls, direction requests and bookings take longer to read. Fix the date and the measure ahead of the work, from the business's own booking lead times and the season it trades in, as the service area expansion guide does for its own trial. For that to work, record a baseline first: the profile's performance history, the number, recency and replies of its reviews, the details as they stand across the web and who appears beside the business in the local pack. The benchmarking tutorial and the measuring tutorial each record part of it.

When the provider's work disappoints, the underperforming agency tutorial gathers evidence against the scope and asks how much of the cause lies with the business before anyone is replaced. At renewal, the renewal review tutorial tests the scope and the fees afresh.

Changing provider without losing the profile

The ending starts with ownership. Confirm that the business's own account holds the owner role and that its owners can sign in, then reduce or remove the provider's access. The reverse order is the mistake the locked-out diagnosis lists, because an agency's access removed before ownership has moved leaves nobody able to reply to a review.

As general practice, start the inventory when the engagement starts and update it as each item changes, so that the handover is a list and not a search: the register with each role, the master record and change log, the naming rule, the reply guideline and escalation list, the tagged-link conventions and any tracking number with the name of who holds it, the ad accounts and the lead notes, the baseline and the monthly tables. The agency onboarding checklist records what a new provider is given, and the offboarding checklist then gives the order for the old provider's exit.

Results can fall after a change even when nothing is lost: the page on results after an agency change lists what a handover quietly drops, such as exclusions and tracking. The page on an agency that withholds ad accounts covers an outgoing provider that keeps the ad accounts, including what to export and what can be recovered.

A plastering firm weighs three local proposals (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

Tofouth Plastering weighs three proposals

Tofouth Plastering, an invented firm that plasters walls and ceilings in people's homes, has two plasterers and a part-time office manager. Its profile hides the workshop address and lists the towns it serves, but it was set up years ago by the web designer, who still holds the owner role, and nobody has searched for duplicates. The owner sends the same questions to three providers: a local marketing agency, a freelancer and a company selling a bundle of directory listings and reviews. Before reading any reply she settles one gate, that the profile must end up owned by an account the firm holds, and four weighted rows, and she scores each answer from 1 to 5.

Criterion and weightAgencyFreelancerListings bundle
Reviews: the ask and the replies (30%)43not scored
Data: duplicates, details across the web and the change log (25%)53not scored
Reports that tie to bookings (25%)44not scored
Handover and exit (20%)45not scored
Weighted score (out of 5)4.253.65fails the gate

The bundle plans to create a new profile in its own account and promises a block of reviews within the month, so it fails the gate before any score counts. The agency scores higher on data because its first deliverable is a stand-alone paid audit, not a rebuild. The audit confirms that the web designer still holds the owner role and finds that a second listing at the old workshop address carries nine reviews and that the name field has "Plastering Specialists" added after the signage name. Before it changes anything the agency records the baseline: 8 calls from the profile in the same quarter a year earlier, and from then on an answer on each booking to where the customer heard of the firm. Its first jobs are the ownership transfer to an account with the owner and the office manager as owners, the name restored to match the van signage, and the second listing reported for merging with evidence, so that the nine reviews move across to the surviving profile. After a quarter the table shows 12 calls from the profile. The owner treats counts this small as a reason to keep reading, not as proof, and the change log lists the ownership move, the name correction and the duplicate report with their dates, so whatever the table shows can be read against what changed.

The local presence hub places this guide beside the reputation and community work that a provider will be asked to support.

Common mistakes

  • Hiring for a ranking. Google's local ranking help publishes no weights, as the benchmarking tutorial records, and nobody outside the platform can promise a position. Hire for the work the business can verify, and judge results on bookings.
  • Letting the provider create the profile for convenience. The cost arrives when the relationship ends, as the locked-out diagnosis shows. Create it in the business's account and add the provider as a manager.
  • Approving a name with a keyword in it. The profile name is the signage name. Write that as a naming rule the provider must follow.
  • Setting a review target. A number to hit invites shortcuts. Agree the routine, the reply time and the escalation list, and read what customers write.
  • Handing complaints to the provider unaided. A complaint is a complaint before it is a review. Route it to a named person in the business first.
  • Reading the report without the bookings. The profile's figures are one part of the picture, so lay them beside the booking record and the answers customers give about where they heard of the business.
  • Judging on a single month. Small counts move for reasons unconnected to the work. Read the trend against the profile's own history and the same period a year before.
  • Skipping the baseline. Without one, the first report has nothing to be compared with and each later argument is about definitions.
  • Removing access before ownership has moved. Check the owner role first at each offboarding.

Frequently asked questions

What should a local marketing provider be responsible for, and what stays with us?

The provider does the work: keeping the profile and listings accurate, auditing and correcting the details held elsewhere, running the review routine, managing local ads and reporting. The business keeps the owner role on the profile and the accounts around it, decides the name, address, categories and areas served, writes the facts the provider works from, places the review request in its own customer journey and answers for the budget. The provider is added as a manager with the access the work needs, so the profile, its reviews and its history stay in the business whichever provider holds that access.

Should the provider reply to our reviews for us?

As general practice, it can draft replies in the voice of a written guideline, and it can post them where the business has agreed a named approver and a list of what must come to the business first. A complaint, or anything that touches a customer's private details, belongs with someone in the business, because a reply is written for the next reader and carries the business's name. Decide the split in writing before the provider has access to reply.

When can a local provider's results be judged fairly?

As general practice, the work can be judged early, through checks the business can see for itself: ownership moved to its own account, a naming rule written, duplicates searched for and dealt with, the audit of details across the web logged, the review routine running and the first report delivered with a baseline in it. Calls, direction requests and bookings need longer, read against the profile's own history and the same period a year earlier. Agree the date and the measure before the work starts, and treat small counts with the caution they deserve.

Terms used on this page

Frameworks

Sources

  1. Google Business Profile Help — Google Business Profile Help
  2. Guidelines for representing your business on Google — Google Business Profile Help
  3. Google Ads Help — Google Ads Help
  4. Local Services Ads Help — Google
  5. Competition and Markets Authority — GOV.UK
  6. FTC business guidance — Federal Trade Commission

Related