Why the comparison that matters is the local pack
The competitor analysis guide defines competitors as the alternatives customers weigh at the moment of decision, and looks at them across search, ads, content, social, pricing and reviews. For a local business that moment is unusually visible. A search for the service, with a place or without one, returns a map with a few businesses beside it, the Local PackThe map and short list of business listings shown for searches with local intent., and the person searching usually picks from that list without looking further. The rivals who matter are the ones who share it, which may not be the firms the owner thinks of as competitors.
Google's help page on local ranking, listed in the sources, says local results are based mainly on relevance, distance and prominence. Relevance is how well a profile matches what was searched; distance is how far the business is from the place in the search or from the searcher; prominence is how well known the business is, and the page names reviews and information from across the web among its inputs. The local SEO hub explains the three in full. The page publishes no weights, so a comparison cannot say which difference put a rival first. What it can do is show where the business describes itself less fully, gives readers less recent evidence or is simply less visible than the firms beside it, and those are things an owner can work on.
A local benchmark is therefore a working sheet of observations, not a score. It records what each profile shows and what each firm does, for a fixed set of searches, from the places customers search from. It does not estimate rankings, borrow a published average or promise that matching a rival's detail will move anything.
Before you start
- The local keyword research. The local keyword research tutorial is the prerequisite: it lists services in customers' words and the places they name, reads the results page for each pattern and decides which searches the profile carries. This tutorial starts from that list.
- The business's own profile (GBPLocal listing on Google Search and Maps.) as it stands, with its categories, services, hours, attributes and photos, and access to its performance section.
- A way to search as a customer would: a private browser window with the place named in the query, or a person in the area willing to search on a phone.
- A spreadsheet with one column per business, the business's own first, and one row per thing compared. The competitor analysis template can be adapted; keep its structure, and use only the rows below.
- The Google Ads account, if the business advertises, for the auction insights report.
The steps
Choose the searches that decide the business's work
From the keyword research, pick the few searches that bring most of the work that pays: usually the main service on its own, the main service with the main town, an urgent or near me form if customers use one, and any second service the business wants more of. Label each with its Search IntentThe goal behind a search query: to learn, to find a site, to compare or to act. so the sheet records whether the searcher wants to act now or is still comparing. Keep the list short. Every search added multiplies the work of each round, and a comparison repeated faithfully on a handful of searches is worth more than a large one done once.
Search from inside the area and record who appears
Searching from the office or from home gives a skewed result: it is close to the business, and the owner's account and history differ from a customer's. Follow the diagnosis for a Business Profile not showing instead: search each term in a private window with the area named, or ask someone in the area to search on a phone. For each search, record the businesses in the local pack and the order on the day, whether the business itself appears and the date. Repeat from a second area customers come from, because distance changes the list. The rivals who appear for most of the searches in most of the places are the set the rest of the sheet compares.
Compare categories and services
Open each rival's profile and record its primary category, any additional categories and the services it lists. The Business Profile tutorial asks owners to look at the categories of the businesses that appear for the priority searches and, where they differ, to question which is right. That is a question, not an instruction to copy: a category describes what a business is, and one that does not fit breaks the guidelines. The more useful finding is often in services. A rival that lists the exact service searched for, in customers' words, is easier to match to the search than a profile that leaves it out.
Compare reviews: count, recency and replies
Record each firm's rating, its review count, the date of its most recent reviews and whether the owner replies, including to the critical ones. The reviews and reputation guide explains why readers look at the newest reviews and at the replies under the negative ones, and why a high rating from old reviews reads as a business that stopped caring. Note what reviewers praise and blame across the set as well: if every rival is criticised for missed appointments, punctuality is a position worth claiming. Copy nothing from a rival's review routine that the reviews guide marks as off limits, however well it seems to work.
Compare photos, hours and attributes
Record how many photos each profile shows and how recent they look, whether they show real work, staff and premises or stock images, whether hours are complete with special hours set for holidays, and which attributes each firm has set. These are the details a person reads after shortlisting. A profile that shows the van, the team and recent jobs gives a reader more reason to call than one with a logo and nothing else. Where a rival claims an attribute or hours the business could honestly claim too, note it as a gap.
Compare location and service pages
Follow each profile's website link and record where it lands: a homepage, a service page or a Location PageA web page dedicated to one physical location or service area, with its address, hours, services and local detail.. Note whether the page names the service and the area, shows real local work and states the same name, address and phone number as the profile. A service-area businessA business that serves customers at the customer's location, such as a plumber or cleaner, listing the areas it serves rather than a shopfront. that visits customers is held to the service area pages guide, which explains where pages for places served become thin doorways; a rival with a page for every town is not automatically doing better, and the sheet should say whether its pages carry anything specific.
Note who advertises and where
Run the searches again and note which rivals show paid ads above or beside the local pack. If the business advertises, the auction insights tutorial reads the advertisers who appeared in the same auctions by Impression ShareShare of eligible impressions you received., overlap and position above, with the limit that it covers only auctions the business took part in. Record what the ads offer and which page they open. This row explains a rival who appears everywhere for a service without strong reviews: it may be buying the visibility rather than earning it, which is a choice for the business's budget, not a profile gap.
Note community and press presence
Search each rival's name with the town and note where it is mentioned: sponsorships, events, partner businesses, local press, club and school pages. The help page counts information from across the web among the inputs to prominence, and the local content and community marketing guide explains that such mentions follow from being present in the area rather than from asking strangers for links. A rival that is well known locally will be chosen by people who recognise the name. The guide to PR for a small local business shows how to earn the same kind of coverage with the business's own stories.
Sort gaps into fix, cannot change and must not copy
Go down the sheet and give every difference one of three labels. Fix: things the business controls and the guidelines allow, such as missing services, unanswered reviews, old photos, incomplete hours or a website link to the homepage. Cannot change: distance from the searcher, the age of a rival's business and anything else outside the owner's control; these explain a result but deserve no effort. Must not copy: anything that breaches Google's guidelines for representing a business. The most common is a name with services or places added, which the guidelines prohibit and which the diagnosis for a suspended Business Profile names as a usual cause of suspension. Report such a listing through the routes Business Profile Help gives, record the date, and move on. A SWOT built from the sheet keeps the rival-driven threats apart from the business's own weaknesses, if the owner wants the findings in that form.
Choose a short list of changes and a date to repeat
Pick the fixes that touch the searches chosen in the first step and that the business can sustain, rather than every gap at once. Write each as an action with an owner and a date, and record it in the notes column of the monthly table from the tutorial on measuring Business Profile results, so the profile's own figures can show whether anything changed. Set a date to repeat the sheet with the same searches and places. The second round is where the comparison earns its keep: it shows whether the fixes held, whether a new rival arrived and whether a reported name was ever corrected.
The local presence hub sets this comparison beside the reputation and community work most of the fixes lead back to.
A locksmith compares itself with the three firms beside it (illustrative)
Belzorak Locksmiths benchmarks its local pack
Belzorak Locksmiths, an invented two-van locksmith that visits customers and hides its address on its profile, chose four searches: locksmith, locksmith with the town name, emergency locksmith and lock change. Searched in a private window from two districts its customers live in, the same three rivals appeared in 7 of the 8 local packs; Belzorak appeared in 5.
| Row | Belzorak | Rival A | Rival B | Rival C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reviews and rating | 41, rated 4.8 | 126, rated 4.6 | 58, rated 4.9 | 212, rated 4.4 |
| Most recent review | 5 months ago | Last week | 3 weeks ago | Yesterday |
| Owner replies | None | Most | All | Few |
| Emergency service listed | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Photos of real work | 4, all from launch | 30, recent | 22, recent | 9, stock |
| Website link lands on | Homepage | Service page | Service page | Homepage |
| Paid ads on the searches | No | No | Yes | Yes |
Rival C's name read as its trading name followed by "Emergency 24hr Locksmith", which its van and website did not show. The owner marked it must not copy and reported it. Distance from the second district went under cannot change. The three fixes were asking every customer for a review with a reply to each, adding the emergency service with a plain description, and posting photos of recent jobs fortnightly. A quarter later Belzorak had 63 reviews, all answered, appeared in 7 of the 8 packs, and Rival C's name was unchanged, so the owner reported it a second time and noted the date.
Common mistakes
- Searching from the shop. A search near the premises from the owner's own account shows a list customers never see.
- Comparing with the industry instead of the pack. The few firms shown beside the business are the comparison that decides the call.
- Copying a rival's name. Service words in the name breach the guidelines; report it, never match it.
- Adding categories because a rival has them. A category describes what the business is; one that does not fit is a breach, not a tactic.
- Treating the sheet as a ranking forecast. Google publishes no weights; the sheet shows gaps, not causes.
- Working on what cannot change. Distance explains a result but rewards no effort.
- Fixing everything at once. A short list done well, recorded in the notes, shows what helped.
- Never repeating it. One round is a snapshot; the second shows whether anything moved.
