What this template is for
Use the template for a full competitive pass: before a positioning decision, a product or market launch, a pricing change, an annual plan, or when a new competitor appears and the team needs to decide whether it matters. It is the periodic deep analysis; the ongoing watch between passes is a lighter monitoring routine that feeds it.
Several related documents serve different readers. The competitor analysis guide describes the grid and the position map in prose with a checklist and a monitoring routine. The competitive intelligence guide covers collecting evidence ethically and keeping it current. The competitive battlecard guide sets out the card a sales representative uses in a live deal against one named competitor, which is shorter, tactical and written for a different reader. The messaging house is where the analysis's positioning conclusions end up. This template is the analyst's copyable grid and per-competitor teardown that sits upstream of all of them.
An analysis is only as current as its oldest observation, so the template carries a source and a date for every claim and a refresh date for the whole. Without those, a confident grid becomes a misleading one within months.
The template
Copy the table into a shared document. The comparison grid and the teardowns become their own tabs: the grid with competitors as columns and dimensions as rows, the teardown with one section per competitor.
| Field | What to write |
|---|---|
| Question and decision | The decision the analysis informs, the segment it is read for, and the date the decision is due |
| Competitive set | Direct competitors, indirect alternatives and the do-nothing option, with why each is in the set |
| Comparison grid | Competitors as columns and dimensions as rows: segment served, position, price model, proof and channels |
| Position and claims | What each competitor claims, quoted in its own words, and where the claim is made |
| Offer and pricing | Packaging, the price points a buyer can see, and the terms that matter to the segment |
| Channels and share of voice | Where each competitor is visible in search, social, advertising and press, and how prominent it is |
| Customer view | Strengths and weaknesses in customers' words, from reviews, interviews and win-loss notes |
| Position map | Two attributes the segment values as axes, each competitor placed, and the empty space marked |
| Implications and actions | What changes in positioning, messages, offers or channels, each with an owner and a date |
| Sources and refresh date | Where each observation came from, when it was collected, and when the analysis is next refreshed |
Fill the first two rows before collecting anything. They decide which competitors and which dimensions are worth the time.
How to fill each section
Question and decision
Write the decision the analysis informs and the segment it is read for. The competitor analysis guide explains that analysis should feed positioning, channel and content choices and segment choice, and should not become a to-do list of competitor tactics. A question such as "should we launch group classes for this segment" decides which dimensions matter; "what are competitors doing" decides nothing.
Competitive set
List direct competitors, indirect alternatives that solve the same problem another way, and the option of doing nothing or doing it yourself, with a line on why each is included. The guide's starting point is to ask who buyers actually compare, which interviews and win-loss notes reveal better than a category list. The STP framework helps here: the set depends on the segment, and a competitor that is irrelevant to one segmentDividing a market or customer list into groups that need different offers or messages. can be the main alternative for another.
Comparison grid
Build the grid with competitors as columns and dimensions as rows: segment served, position claimed, price model, proof offered and channels used, plus any dimension the decision needs. The competitor analysis guide recommends reading across each row to see where the market clusters and where there is space. Keep cells short; detail belongs in the teardowns.
Position and claims
Quote what each competitor claims, in its own words, and note where the claim is made: the home page headline, the ad copy, the sales deck. The positioning guide explains how occupied positions are ruled out and empty ones become candidates. Quote rather than summarise, because paraphrase smooths away the differences the analysis is looking for. If the analysis will inform comparative advertising, remember that the Advertising Standards Authority's codes require comparisons to be fair and verifiable.
Offer and pricing
Record packaging, the price points a buyer can see and the terms that matter to the segment: contract length, cancellation, guarantees, trials. The pricing and packaging guide covers how packaging communicates position. Record only what a buyer can see or what customers report; a price obtained under false pretences is not evidence the business should hold.
Channels and share of voice
Note where each competitor is visible and how prominent it is: rankings for the terms the segment searches, paid search presence, social activity, advertising in ad libraries, press and partnerships. The share of voice guide explains how to measure Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility. and why the trend matters more than the level. Group search terms by Search IntentThe goal behind a search query: to learn, to find a site, to compare or to act., since a competitor that dominates informational queries and one that buys the commercial ones are competing in different places.
Customer view
Record strengths and weaknesses in customers' words from reviews, interviews and win-loss notes. The competitive intelligence guide covers sources and the ethics of collection. Competitors' complaints map unmet needs; their praise maps positions already occupied. A SWOT per major competitor can organise this row, as long as it is built from evidence rather than opinion.
Position map
Choose two attributes the segment values, draw them as axes, place each competitor where its claims and reviews put it, and mark the empty space. The competitor analysis guide treats empty regions as candidate positions and crowded ones as places where competing means outspending. Choose axes from what buyers say they weigh, not from what the business happens to be good at.
Implications and actions
Write what changes as a result: positioning, messages, offers, channels, content. Give each action an owner and a date. The competitor analysis guide is clear that the analysis exists to feed decisions; a final section of observations with no actions means it has not. Messaging consequences go into the messaging house; deal-level consequences go to the battlecards.
Sources and refresh date
List the source and collection date of each observation, and set the date of the next full refresh. The competitive intelligence guide covers keeping intelligence current between passes. Prices and claims change without notice; an undated cell cannot be trusted.
Filled example
Below, the analysis is completed for an invented business. Competitors are described by type rather than named; the figures, observations and names are illustrative.
Glenfarrow Languages: competitor analysis for adults relocating abroad
| Field | Glenfarrow's analysis |
|---|---|
| Question and decision | Should Glenfarrow reposition its one-to-one Spanish and German courses for adults relocating abroad for work, and if so, against which alternative? Segment: professionals with a move date three to nine months away. Decision due at the planning meeting on 15 May |
| Competitive set | Direct: a large tutor marketplace (buyers compare tutors there first in 9 of 14 interviews). Indirect: a subscription language app (most interviewees had tried one); local evening classes at a further education college (cited by older interviewees). Do nothing: self-study with free videos and the employer's relocation pack. Excluded: immersion schools abroad, which no interviewee considered before the move |
| Comparison grid | Segment: marketplace serves everyone; app serves casual learners; evening classes serve local hobby learners; Glenfarrow serves adults with a deadline. Price model: marketplace per lesson, £15 to £40 by tutor; app monthly subscription, £10; evening classes per term, £180 for ten weeks; Glenfarrow 12-week course, £720. Proof: marketplace tutor ratings; app user numbers; college accreditation; Glenfarrow course completion stories. Channels: marketplace and app dominate search and app stores; college relies on its prospectus |
| Position and claims | Marketplace: "Find the perfect tutor for you" (home page). App: "Learn a language in five minutes a day" (app store listing). Evening classes: "Meet new people and learn together" (prospectus). Glenfarrow currently: "Personal language lessons online" (home page), which no buyer could tell apart from the marketplace |
| Offer and pricing | Marketplace: no structure between lessons, quality varies by tutor, cancel any time. App: no speaking practice with a person, free tier. Evening classes: fixed term dates that rarely match a move date. Glenfarrow: fixed course with a plan to the move date, one tutor throughout, refund if the first two lessons do not suit |
| Channels and share of voice | Commercial search terms ("online Spanish tutor") held by the marketplace in organic results and ads. Relocation-intent terms ("learn German before moving to Berlin") answered mostly by forums and expat blogs; no competitor runs ads on them. App heavy in paid social; marketplace light. Glenfarrow appears for none of the relocation terms |
| Customer view | Marketplace reviews praise choice and price, criticise inconsistency and "starting again with every tutor". App reviews praise habit-building, criticise "can't hold a conversation after a year". Evening class reviews praise the social side, criticise pace. Glenfarrow's own reviews praise "a plan to my move date" in 11 of 30 reviews |
| Position map | Axes: structure towards a deadline (low to high) and speaking time with a person per week (low to high). App: high structure, almost no speaking. Marketplace: high speaking, low structure. Evening classes: medium on both. Empty space: high structure and high speaking time, which is where Glenfarrow's reviews already place it |
| Implications and actions | Reposition around "fluent enough for your first day, by your move date" (owner: founder, 30 May). Rewrite the home page and course pages to lead with the move-date plan (owner: marketing lead, 20 June). Build a content set and a small search campaign for relocation-intent terms (owner: marketing lead, 30 June). Add a "starting with us after a marketplace tutor" page answering the inconsistency complaint (owner: head tutor, 15 June). Do not compete on per-lesson price |
| Sources and refresh date | Fourteen customer interviews, March to April. Competitor sites, app store listing and college prospectus captured 18 April. Search results checked 22 April from a UK location, signed out. Reviews sampled 20 to 25 April. Next full refresh 1 November; monthly check of competitor home pages and prices |
The repositioning was approved at the May meeting. The actions went into the quarter's plan, and the "move-date plan" pillar became the roof of the new messaging house.
Common mistakes
- No decision at the start. An analysis without a question becomes a scrapbook. Write the decision and the segment first, and collect only what bears on them.
- Only direct competitors. Buyers often weigh an app, a spreadsheet or doing nothing alongside the obvious rivals. Include the alternatives they actually consider.
- Paraphrased claims. Summaries erase the differences between competitors' positions. Quote their words and note where they appear.
- Features instead of the customer view. A feature table shows what competitors built, not what buyers value. Use reviews, interviews and win-loss notes.
- Axes chosen to flatter. A position map drawn on attributes the business is good at shows an empty space that buyers do not care about. Take axes from what the segment weighs.
- Copying competitor tactics. Their choices fit their position. Act on what the analysis says about yours.
- Observations without owners. "Competitor X is strong in search" changes nothing. Turn each finding into an action with an owner and a date.
- Undated evidence. Prices and claims change. Date every observation and set the next refresh.
The messaging house that carries the analysis's conclusions and the other planning documents are in the templates library.
