Why agency agreements renew by default
Nobody decides to keep paying for monthly reports that nobody reads, or to keep routing core work through change requests. It happens because the renewal has no decision attached to it. The relationship continues, the scope written at the start stays in force, and the work quietly moves away from it: some deliverables stop being used, new kinds of work arrive as extras, and the fee model chosen for the original work no longer fits the current one.
The guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies sets the rhythm: operational reviews, monthly performance reviews, a fuller scorecard review, and once a year a look at the scope, the fee model and the terms. This tutorial is that yearly look, timed so the business can still act on what it finds. The agencies and partners hub lists "fees keep rising through change requests" among its common problems and traces it to a loose scope or a fee model mismatched to the work; the renewal review is where both get fixed. When invoices are already climbing mid-term and the renewal is still some way off, the diagnosis for agency fees that keep rising sorts each extra charge by what caused it, from the scope and the fee model to rework and approvals.
The review is not an exercise in squeezing the agency. The agencies hub notes the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising's long-standing argument that the client side shapes the quality of agency work as much as the agency does, and that clear briefs, sensible selection processes and fair remuneration produce better results than adversarial ones. The selecting guide names the matching trap at the negotiation stage: squeezing fees until the agency loses interest. A good renewal review leaves both sides clearer about the work and the price.
The same kind of review for software, built from the same idea of a calendar of notice dates and a decision before them, is in the tutorial on reviewing a marketing tool before it renews. For an affiliate agency, the review also checks the agency's reported sales against the business's own deduplicated and validated figures, which the guide to working with an affiliate management agency explains. For a media agency, the review also checks the terms only a media agreement carries, such as trading status, rebatesA volume-based discount or payment from media owners to an agency or large advertiser, which the agency agreement should assign and report. and audit access, which the guide to setting up a media agency agreement sets out.
Before you start
Gather these before the first step, and allow time for the ones that come from other teams.
- The agreement itself. Find the term, what happens at its end, how and when either side must give notice of a change, and any terms on scope changes. Read your own agreement; if anything is unclear, ask the business's legal advisers or whoever manages suppliers, not the agency.
- The scope and every change since. The original scope, any rescoping, and the change requests raised against it, with what each one covered.
- The fee history. What was invoiced, under which fee model, and how it moved over the term. Finance usually holds this; the marketing finance hub covers how spend and invoices are tracked, and this review uses the record rather than rebuilding it.
- The review record. Scorecards, monthly performance reviews and any issues raised during the term.
- Results from the business's own data. The measures agreed in the scope, read from the business's systems rather than from the agency's reports.
- The people who work with the agency. A short conversation with each in-house colleague who briefs, approves or uses the agency's work.
If the business works with several agencies, run the review for each but keep the timing in one calendar, and read the guide to coordinating several marketing agencies for how a change to one agency affects the others.
The steps
Put every agency's notice date in the calendar
List every agency and freelance partner on an agreement that runs for a term. For each, record the renewal date and, from your own agreement, the last date on which a change can be notified. Put the notice date in the calendar, not the renewal date, and set the review to start far enough ahead of it that re-tendering remains a real option. Name an owner for each review. Where an agreement has no clear end or notice terms, record that as a finding for the business's legal advisers rather than guessing. A calendar built this way turns renewals from surprises into scheduled decisions, and the same calendar can hold the annual scope review the agency guide recommends.
Collect the scope, the fee history and the change requests
Bring the documents together in one place: the current scope with its deliverables and measures, the fee model and how the fee was calculated, the invoiced totals over the term, and every change request with its date, what it covered and what it cost. Ask the agency for its own list of change requests and compare the two; a difference between them is itself a finding. Keep the fee history as finance recorded it. The review is not the place to reconcile invoices, and any question about what was billed goes to whoever owns the budget. If the scope was written with the agency scope of work template, its deliverables, exclusions and change route are already in the fields this comparison reads.
Compare the scope with the work actually done
Lay the scope out as a list of deliverables and, beside each, what the agency actually delivered and whether the business used it. Then add the work the agency did that is not in the scope, which the change requests and the review record will show. Three patterns usually appear. Some deliverables are produced and not used. Some work arrives repeatedly as change requests and is really part of the job. And some scope items were never asked for. Ask the in-house colleagues which deliverables they rely on and which they would not miss. The result is a picture of the work as it is, which is what the next agreement should describe.
Read results against the business's own measures
Judge results on the measures the scope agreed, read from the business's own data. The diagnosis of agency reports that look good while sales are flat sets out how to put the agency's figures beside the business's record and which gaps to check. For each KPIA metric tied directly to an objective., compare the end of the term with the BaselineAn estimate of what a metric would have done without a given change, campaign or promotion, against which the effect is measured. at its start, and where the counts are small, read them as ranges, as the guide to reading small numbers in marketing reports advises, rather than drawing conclusions from a single month's movement. Where the scope tied the agency to a commercial outcome, look at its contribution to ROIProfit relative to cost. on the business's terms. Note which results the agency could influence and which depended on the business.
Hear the agency's view of you as a client
Ask the agency for its own review of the relationship before you share your conclusions. Use the client side of the two-way scorecard from the agency guide: the quality of briefs, the consistency of feedback, how quickly approvals came, and whether the agency had the access to results it needed. Ask, too, what the agency would change in the scope and the fee model, and which work it thinks is under- or over-priced. Many problems that look like agency problems turn out to be client problems, and some of the change requests you found may trace back to late or changing briefs.
Check the fee model against how the work has changed
The agency guide and the agencies hub describe the main fee models, from retainers and project fees to time and materials, commission and performance-related elements, and how each one shapes behaviour. Ask whether the model chosen at the start still fits the work as it now is. A retainer suits continuous work with a stable scope; if much of the work now arrives as projects, the model is working against both sides. A fee that rises with spend or activity rewards more rather than better. Write down the mismatches you find and the model that would fit better, but leave the figures and the budget to the people who own them.
Choose to renew, rescope, re-tender or exit
Bring the findings together and choose one of four outcomes. Use the weighted scoring matrix to score the incumbent on criteria agreed before scoring, such as quality of thinking, execution, results, responsiveness and fit with the current work, and score any alternative on the same criteria. Renew when the scope and model still fit and results are sound. Rescope when the agency is worth keeping but the work has drifted. Re-tender when the work has changed beyond what the agency was chosen for or when documented reviews have not fixed persistent shortfalls. Exit when the work should move in-house or stop. If the agency is falling short but could recover, an improvement plan may come before any of these, as the tutorial on turning round an underperforming agency relationship sets out.
Negotiate from the evidence
Take the findings to the agency as a list, not a demand. Each item should point to the evidence behind it: a deliverable nobody used, a kind of work that should move into the scope, a measure the business wants to be judged on, a fee model that no longer fits. Agree the new scope first and the fee second, since the fee should follow the work. Keep the IPA's point in view: fair remuneration gets better work than an adversarial squeeze. Any change to the agreement's terms, and any question about notice or dispute provisions, goes to the business's legal advisers. For media agencies, the terms of buying are a separate negotiation covered in negotiating media buys and insertion orders.
Record the outcome and the next review date
Write a short record of the review: the outcome, the reasons, the new scope and measures, what changed in the fee model, and anything the business agreed to do differently as a client. Share it with the agency and with the in-house colleagues who work with it. Put the next notice date and the next review in the calendar, and link the new measures into the regular performance reviews so the next renewal starts from evidence rather than memory. If the outcome is to re-tender, the agency request for proposal template starts the process; if it is to exit, the agency offboarding checklist covers the handover. The quarterly cycle in running a quarterly planning session is a natural place to feed the new scope into the team's plan.
Renewal questions at a glance
| Question | Where the answer comes from | What it can lead to |
|---|---|---|
| When must a change be notified? | The business's own agreement, read with its legal advisers | The review start date and the calendar |
| Is every deliverable in the scope used? | The scope, the in-house users and the review record | Removing unused work from the scope |
| Is regular work arriving as change requests? | The change request log from both sides | Moving that work into the scope |
| Did results move on the business's own measures? | The business's data against the baseline at the start | Renew, rescope or an improvement plan |
| How does the agency rate the business as a client? | The client side of the two-way scorecard | Changes to briefing, feedback and approvals |
| Does the fee model fit the current work? | The fee history and how the work has changed | A different model or a rescoped fee |
| Would another agency serve the work better? | Weighted scoring of the incumbent and any alternative | Re-tender or renewal on new terms |
| What happens next, and when? | The review record | The next notice date and review in the calendar |
A flooring maker reviews its search agency (illustrative)
Moxquith Flooring rescopes its search retainer
Moxquith Flooring, an invented flooring manufacturer selling to trade buyers and through its own website, paid a search agency a monthly retainer of £6,500 under a 12-month agreement that continued unless notice was given. The marketing manager put the notice date in the calendar and started the review 10 weeks before it.
The scope listed 5 monthly reports. Asking the 4 colleagues who received them showed that 3 were no longer opened: they had been built for a product range the business had since dropped. Over the year the agency had raised 14 change requests, 11 of them for landing pages for new collections, totalling £19,800 on top of the retainer. Landing page work had become part of the job but was still priced as an exception.
Results from Moxquith's own order and enquiry data showed trade enquiries from search 18% above the baseline at the start of the term. The agency's own review of Moxquith as a client scored briefing 2 out of 5: collection launch dates often reached the agency less than a fortnight ahead.
Scored against one alternative on the same 6 criteria, the incumbent came out ahead. The manager chose to rescope rather than re-tender: the 3 unused reports were dropped, a set number of collection landing pages a quarter moved into the retainer, the fee was agreed from the new scope, and Moxquith committed to sharing launch dates with the quarterly plan. The record of the review set the next notice date and a mid-term check on the landing page allowance.
Verify it worked
Check the review against the evidence, not against how the meetings felt.
- Every agency on a term agreement has a notice date in the calendar and a named owner for its review.
- The scope sits beside what was delivered, with a note of which deliverables the business used and which work arrived as extras.
- Your change request list and the agency's list lie side by side, and each difference is noted as a finding.
- Each KPI is read from the business's own data against its starting baseline. The agency's view of you as a client is on file.
- The record names the outcome, the reasons, the new scope and measures, and the next notice date.
If it goes wrong
- The notice date has already passed. The review was timed from the invoice or the renewal. Ask the business's legal advisers which outcomes remain open.
- The two change request lists disagree. Requests were agreed informally or logged differently. Record the gap as a finding and send billing questions to the budget owner.
- The agency's report looks good but the business's figures do not. The two use different sources or definitions. Judge on the measures in the scope, read from your own data.
- The agency's view of you blames briefs or approvals. Some change requests may trace back to late or changing briefs. Record what the business will do differently.
- The fee talk stalls. The conversation led with a cut. Agree the new scope first, then let the fee follow the work.
Next steps
- Read in-house versus agency if the review points to exit because the work should move in-house.
- Read selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies to keep the two-way scorecard running between renewals.
Common mistakes
- Starting at the invoice. By then the notice date has usually passed. Work back from the date in your own agreement.
- Reviewing the agency against the original scope only. The work has moved. Compare the scope with what was actually done and used.
- Treating change requests as exceptions forever. Work that arrives every month as an extra belongs in the scope, priced as part of it.
- Judging results on the agency's own report. Read the measures from the business's own data, against the baseline at the start of the term.
- Skipping the agency's view of the client. Some of the problems you find will trace back to briefs, feedback and approvals.
- Leading with a fee cut. Agree the scope first and let the fee follow the work; squeezing fees costs the business the agency's best attention.
- Re-tendering by habit. A tender costs both sides time. Re-tender when the evidence says the work or the results need it.
- Reading contract terms without advice. Notice, renewal and dispute terms belong to the agreement and the business's legal advisers.
