What agencies and partners are for
A partner should do something the team cannot do as well, as cheaply or as quickly on its own. That covers four broad needs. Depth: specialist skills such as media buying, creative production, technical SEO or research that the team does not need full-time. Capacity: extra hands for a launch, a season or a period when the team is short. Perspective: an outside view and creative ideas from people who are not inside the company's assumptions. Reach: presence in markets, channels or media relationships the team does not have.
If a partner is not meeting one of those needs, it is probably doing work that belongs in-house or does not need doing at all. The in-house versus agency comparison works through which kinds of work sit better on each side.
The Institute of Practitioners in Advertising, the trade body for UK agencies, has long argued that the client side shapes the quality of agency work as much as the agency does: clear briefs, sensible selection processes and fair remuneration produce better results than adversarial ones. The manager's job is to be a client that gets the agency's best work, which means being clear about objectives, honest in feedback and consistent about how success is judged against agreed measures, whether a KPIA metric tied directly to an objective. for a channel or a longer-term brand measure such as Share of VoiceYour share of market visibility..
In-house, agency, freelance, platform partner
| Option | What it offers | Main drawbacks | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|
| In-house team | Business knowledge, control, continuity, speed on familiar work | Fixed cost; limited specialist depth; hard to scale up and down | Strategy, brand, data, measurement, always-on work |
| Agency | Specialist depth, scale, cross-client experience, creative range | Cost; distance from the business; account team turnover | Media buying, creative, specialist channels, campaigns |
| Freelancer | Flexible specialist capacity with low overhead | Availability; single-person dependency; needs close management | Surge work, specific skills, short projects |
| Platform partner | Product knowledge and early access to the platform's guidance | Advice aligned to the platform's interests; no accountability for results | Account reviews, new features, technical setup questions |
Most teams use a mix. The useful question is not which option to choose but which work goes to which, and who owns the joins between them.
The core guides
In-house vs agency marketing compares the two models on cost structure, speed, specialist depth, control of data and brand, scale and knowledge retention, and shows how to design a hybrid where each side owns what it is best at. Start there if you are questioning whether a partner should be doing the work at all.
Selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies covers the whole relationship: shortlisting and pitching, scopes, fee models and contracts, service levels and ways of working, briefing well, scorecards and review cadence, and how to manage a transition or exit cleanly. For the brief itself, the campaign brief guide covers what a good brief contains. The wider management job, of which partners are one part, sits in the marketing management hub. For search providers specifically, the guide to hiring and evaluating an SEO agency applies the same cycle with the questions and warning signs Google publishes for anyone hiring an SEO. Before an agency is appointed, the tutorial on checking an agency's claimed results tests the case studies it shows against the strength of the evidence behind each claim and sets the figures its referees give from their own records beside the agency's own.
Further guides
Further guides cover the parts of the cycle that come once a roster is in place: making several partners work as one, deciding what happens at renewal and fixing a relationship that is falling short:
- Coordinating several marketing agencies — who owns the joins, an in-house or lead agency integrator, shared measures, joint planning and reviews.
- Reviewing an agency's scope and fees before renewal — a tutorial for notice dates, the scope against the work done, the fee model, results, both sides' views and a clear decision.
- Turning round an underperforming agency relationship — a tutorial for evidence against scope, the client's share of the cause, a written plan, review points and a decision.
Fee models in brief
How an agency is paid shapes how it behaves, so the fee model is a management decision as much as a commercial one. The main models, described here in outline without figures, are these.
Retainer. A regular fee for an agreed scope of ongoing work. It gives both sides predictability and suits always-on services. The risk is scope drift, in either direction, so the scope needs reviewing regularly.
Project fee. A fixed fee for a defined piece of work. It suits campaigns and one-off projects with clear deliverables. The risk is that changes become expensive change requests, so the brief needs to be stable.
Time and materials. Payment for the hours actually worked at agreed rates. It is flexible and transparent but gives the agency little reason to be efficient, and needs close tracking.
Commission or percentage of spend. Common in media buying, where the fee is linked to the media budget. It is simple, but it rewards spending more rather than spending well, so it is often combined with other measures.
Performance-related. A share of the fee depends on agreed results. It aligns incentives when the results are within the agency's control and measured fairly, and creates disputes when they are not. Tie any bonus to measures both sides trust and that reflect real outcomes, such as contribution to ROIProfit relative to cost. rather than a platform-reported figure alone.
Greywater Gin changes its fee model
Greywater Gin, an invented spirits brand, paid its media agency a commission on spend. Over 2 years media spend grew by 40%, while sales from paid channels grew by about 10%. The marketing manager moved the agency to a retainer covering planning and buying, plus a performance bonus worth up to 15% of the retainer, linked to new customer acquisition measured in the brand's own data. In the first half-year under the new model, the agency recommended cutting 2 underperforming placements it had previously defended, and media spend fell slightly while new customers held steady.
Common agency problems
| Symptom | Likely cause | Where to start |
|---|---|---|
| The agency delivers what was asked, not what was needed | Weak brief; objective unclear | Selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies |
| Fees keep rising through change requests | Scope too loose or fee model mismatched to the work | Selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies, Reviewing an agency before renewal |
| Nobody can say whether the agency is any good | No scorecard or review cadence | Selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies |
| We cannot tell how far to trust the results a shortlisted agency shows | The results shown at selection have not been tested for what they prove, whose work they were or whether they carry over | Checking an agency's claimed results |
| The agency keeps falling short after reviews | Shortfalls never written against the scope; the client's own share of the cause unchecked | Turning round an underperforming agency |
| Knowledge walks out when the agency team changes | Documentation and data owned by the agency | In-house vs agency marketing |
| The team waits on the agency for routine changes | Always-on work outsourced that should be in-house | In-house vs agency marketing |
| Several agencies blame each other for results | No owner of the joins between partners | In-house vs agency marketing, Coordinating several agencies |
| Changing agency stalls the work for months | No transition plan or exit terms | Selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies |
| Agency reports show growth while sales stay flat | Platform figures judged instead of the business outcome | Agency reports look good but sales are flat |
| Results fell soon after a new agency took over | Accounts, tracking, exclusions or definitions lost in the handover | Results dropped after changing agency |
When one of these symptoms is already visible, the marketing management troubleshooting section works through its causes one at a time, with a check, a fix and a prevention habit for each.
