First, lay one period's invoices and change requests beside the scope
Start from the record, not from the size of the latest invoice. Take a recent closed period, such as the last quarter, and gather the invoices as finance recorded them, every change request raised in the period showing when it was raised, the work it asked for and its price, and the scope currently in force. Request the agency's own record of the change requests as well; the tutorial on reviewing an agency before renewal treats a difference between the two lists as a finding in its own right. This is not a reconciliation: questions about what was billed go to whoever owns the budget, and matching invoices to orders is covered by the tutorial on purchase orders and invoice approval.
Then make the comparison the renewal tutorial describes: the scope as a list of deliverables, beside each what the agency delivered and whether anyone used it, and below it the work the agency did that the scope never mentions. Sort every charge above the base fee by what caused it, using the causes in the table below as the piles, and put a charge that fits two piles where its fix would sit. Then read two things: which pile is largest, and which charges recur. A kind of request that appears every month is not an exception; it is part of the job the scope never caught up with.
If the worry is less the cost than a fee that grows with spend while sales stand still, the diagnosis for agency reports that look good while sales are flat treats that incentive as its own cause. For a media agency, the trading terms, rebates and audit rights belong to the guide to setting up a media agency agreement, not to this page.
Diagnosis table
Diagnosis
| Symptom | Check | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ordinary requests arrive as change requests, each priced on its own | Whether the scope names deliverables, their frequency and what is out | A scope that never said what is out of scope | Rewrite the scope with deliverables, exclusions and a priced change route |
| The fee grows with volume, or continuous work has become a run of projects | How the fee is calculated and what shape the work now has | A fee model that no longer fits the work | Match the model to the work as it is now |
| Invoices carry reports or assets nobody in-house relies on | Each deliverable against the colleagues who receive it | An agreement that renewed by default | Remove unused deliverables; decide before the notice date |
| Extra rounds and reworked items appear on the invoice | The brief at signature against the brief at delivery; who sent feedback | The client side causing rework | Signed briefs before work starts; one consolidated round of feedback |
| Two agencies bill for similar work, or one bills to fix another's files | Change requests that touch another agency's work | Overlapping agencies and joins nobody owns | One accountable owner per join; one plan, calendar and brief |
| The same always-on task is billed every month | Which charges are continuous work that depends on knowing the business | Routine work the business could run in-house | Decide work type by work type; write the split into scopes |
| Nobody can say who agreed some of the extras | Who approved each request, and whether an order existed first | Change requests approved by whoever the agency asks | One named approver per agency; an order before work starts |
Fix, verify and prevent each cause
A scope that never said what is out of scope
The guide to selecting, briefing and reviewing agencies treats the scope as the document that matters most in the relationship and traces most fee disputes to a vague one, since then neither party can say whether a given request falls inside it. A scope with no exclusions turns each ordinary request into a negotiation priced one at a time, and where the price of a scope change was never settled ahead of the first one, as the guide advises it should be, every change is priced as it comes.
Fix: rewrite the scope with the agency scope of work template: each deliverable with how often it arrives, the related work that is out of scope, and a change route setting out how out-of-scope work is requested, quoted and signed off before anyone starts on it. That scope becomes the statement of workA supplier's written confirmation of what it will deliver, by when, at what price and how it will invoice, against which the order is raised. the invoices are matched against.
Verify: take the next few requests and check that both sides can tell from the wording alone whether each one is included.
Prevent: keep a shared change log and read it at every scorecard review; the template treats a scope that only ever expands by change request as one due for a rewrite.
A fee model that no longer fits the work
The renewal tutorial describes how a fee model picked for the work at the outset stops fitting the work done now. A retainerA standing fee paid regularly to an agency or supplier for continuous work with a stable scope, as distinct from project fees, time and materials or commission. fits work that runs continuously against a scope that holds still; once a large share of the work comes in project-shaped pieces, those pieces are billed as extras. And a fee tied to spend or activity pays for volume, not improvement, so the bill climbs as volume does, whether or not the work got better.
Fix: at the next scope review, describe the work as it now is and choose the model that fits each part: a retainer for continuous work, project fees for defined pieces, time and materials only where the work is uncertain and tracked. Agree the scope first and the fee second, and leave the figures to the budget holder and the terms to the business's legal advisers.
Verify: in the period after the change, less of each invoice arrives as extras, and no line rises simply because volume rose.
Prevent: at each yearly review, ask whether the model still fits the work, not only whether the price is right.
An agreement that renewed by default
No one chooses to go on paying for monthly reports that go unread. The renewal tutorial puts it down to a renewal with no decision built into it: the original scope carries on unchanged while the work drifts away from it, and some deliverables keep being made and invoiced.
Fix: ask each in-house colleague who receives a deliverable whether they rely on it, and remove what nobody would miss. From your own agreement, diary the last date for notifying a change rather than the renewal date, and begin the review while renewing, rescoping, re-tendering and exiting are all still possible.
Verify: the next invoice no longer carries the removed deliverables, and the review record names the outcome and the next notice date.
Prevent: keep every agency's notice date in one calendar with a named owner, so that renewal is a decision taken on a date rather than something that happens.
The client side causing rework
Some of the rise is the business's own. The tutorial on turning round an underperforming agency relationship checks the business's own part through the two-way scorecard's client side: whether briefs held steady and were clear, whether comments came as one consistent round, and whether sign-offs arrived when needed. When a signed creative briefA short document telling the people making creative work what it must achieve, for whom, with which message and within which limits. changes after work starts, or comments arrive late and from several people one after another, the agency redoes work, and redone work is billed; the selecting guide counts contradictory feedback from several stakeholders among the chief reasons work arrives late and costs more.
Fix: for the rework charges that trace to the business, make the signed brief the starting point for work, send any later change back through the same signature, and name one person, with authority to decide, who consolidates every comment into a single round against the brief.
Verify: the next projects show one round of feedback and fewer change requests citing a brief that moved.
Prevent: write the client's side of the service levels into the scope, as the template does: how fast feedback and approvals arrive and how far ahead the agency hears about new work.
Overlapping agencies and joins nobody owns
The guide to coordinating several marketing agencies traces most roster problems to joins nobody owns: one agency waiting for another's files, two agencies briefing the same supplier differently, a media plan booked for formats the creative agency never made. Gaps like these come back as extra work: an asset remade to fit, a second brief, a task both agencies were asked to do.
Fix: map the joins between agencies, give each one a single accountable owner, usually in-house, and brief each campaign once to every agency from one plan, one calendar and one brief. The RACI matrix is the right shape for those rows: agencies can be responsible for work across a join, but, as the coordinating guide puts it, a join with two accountable owners has none. Write into each scope what that agency owns and who it hands work to.
Verify: in the next period, no task appears on two agencies' invoices, and any charge for repairing another agency's work can be traced to a named join.
Prevent: whenever an agency is added or replaced, revisit the joins map and update every affected scope and RACI row before the new one starts.
Routine work sent to the agency
The comparison of in-house and agency marketing makes the decision one type of work at a time. Continuous work that depends on knowing the business, such as always-on channels and routine changes, often sits better in-house; specialist depth, surge capacity and an outside view are what agencies are for. Routing routine changes through an agency adds a briefing loop to every one, and the comparison warns against judging by headline costs, because the full cost of each side includes management time, recruitment, tools and turnover.
Fix: for each kind of always-on charge, ask whether it depends more on business knowledge or on specialist depth, then either move it into the retainer or bring it in-house once the team can run it, and write the new split into every affected scope.
Verify: work that moved in-house no longer returns as agency change requests, and the agency's scope no longer lists it.
Prevent: revisit the split when the mix of work changes, not only when the bill does. When work leaves an agency, the diagnosis for results that dropped after changing agency lists what a handover can lose, from account history to exclusions.
Change requests approved by whoever is asked
The guide to setting spending authority opens with this pattern: a junior marketer agreeing extra agency work on a call. It treats agreeing a quote or a statement of work as the real commitment, whatever paperwork follows, and gives each decision that commits money one named holder. When change requests go to whoever the agency happens to ask, the extras are committed by people who were never told whether they could.
Fix: write the spending authorityThe written answer to who may make each decision that commits money, such as an order, invoice or budget change, and how far before someone else must agree. for each agency into the delegation table, with the role that may agree a change request, the limit finance sets and a deputy, and tell the agency in writing whose agreement counts. Raise the purchase orderFinance's authorisation for a supplier to deliver against a named cost line, raised for the agreed amount before work starts and used to check the invoice. before work starts and check each invoice against both the order and the work delivered, as the purchase order tutorial does; work outside the scope billed without an updated order is a query, not an approval.
Verify: every change request in the next period carries the named approver and an order made before work began.
Prevent: put the approver's role into the scope's change route and check at each review that no extra reached an invoice without one.
Prevention: a scope that matches the work, one approver for change requests and a renewal decision on a date
Each cause above shows up the same way: a charge above the base fee that no decision accounts for. Keep one change log both sides can see, with the date, what each request covered, what it cost, who caused it and who approved it, and read it each quarter beside the scope. A request that recurs moves into the scope at the next review; one that traces to a changed brief or late feedback goes into the client's half of the scorecard; one that touches another agency's work goes to the owner of that join.
Between those quarterly readings, keep three agreements standing. One is a scope that matches the work: deliverables with their frequency, the nearby work that is out, and a change route that prices a request before work starts. The second is one approver for change requests on each agency, with a purchase order raised at the moment of agreement and every invoice matched to it. The third is a renewal decision on a date: each agency's notice date in one calendar, a review that starts early enough for every outcome to stay open, and a short record of the outcome with the next notice date, as the renewal tutorial sets out. A small RACI with rows for the scope, change requests, feedback on each brief and each join between agencies shows who is accountable for each agreement, and a row with two accountable names is the gap to close first. Fit all of it into the review cadence the selecting guide already sets: the change log read at the fuller scorecard review, and the scope, fee model and terms looked at once a year, with each invoice matched to its order as it arrives, as the purchase order tutorial does.
Keep the aim in view. The agencies hub and the renewal tutorial cite the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising for the long-held case that a client influences the quality of its agency's work as much as the agency itself does, and that paying fairly gets better results than squeezing fees. The selecting guide lists squeezing fees until the agency loses interest as a trap, and the renewal tutorial adds that the business then gets the agency's least attentive work. The routine pays for the work the business needs and stops paying for work it does not; it is not a way to drive the fee down for its own sake. When rising fees arrive with other management symptoms, the marketing management troubleshooting hub helps decide where to start.
A kitchen maker finds why its creative agency costs more every quarter (illustrative)
Jundlefar Kitchens
Jundlefar Kitchens, an invented maker of fitted kitchens selling through 6 showrooms, paid its creative agency the same monthly retainer for a year while each quarter's invoices rose. By the fourth quarter the total was about 40% above the retainer alone.
The marketing manager laid that quarter's 22 change requests beside the scope. 13 were for monthly social assets and showroom offers the scope never mentioned, priced one at a time. 5 were second rounds after the sales director changed briefs that had already been signed. 3 repeated work the media agency had also been asked to do, recutting the same video into the formats on the media plan. The last one was a genuine one-off project. The requests had been approved by 4 different managers, whichever one the agency happened to ask, and only 2 had a purchase order raised before work started.
Jundlefar rewrote the scope around the work actually done, bringing a set number of social assets and showroom offers inside a revised retainer. The brand manager now consolidated all feedback, the sales director's included, into one round, and owned the join between creative and media, with both agencies on one calendar. Every change request went to the head of marketing as named approver, with a purchase order raised before work began.
The next quarter brought 4 change requests, each with an order and the named approver, and none for rework after a signed brief. The revised retainer was higher than the old one, but the quarter's total was lower than any of the previous 3, and the agency's score for Jundlefar as a client on feedback rose from 2 to 4 out of 5.
Common mistakes
- Cutting the fee before sorting the charges. The causes stay where they were, and a squeezed agency gives its least attentive work.
- Assuming every extra is the agency's doing. Changed briefs and scattered feedback are billed too.
- Pricing recurring work one request at a time. Work that arrives every month belongs in the scope.
- Agreeing extras on a call. A yes from whoever is asked is a commitment nobody authorised.
- Letting the agreement renew because nobody looked. Deliverables nobody uses carry on with it.
- Adding an agency without mapping the joins. The gaps between agencies come back as extra work.
- Bringing work in-house on headline cost alone. Weigh the whole cost of each option against the work's actual volume.
