Skip to content
Faisal Mahmud TusherDigital marketing, SEO & analytics
with Faisal Tusher

Marketing Frameworks

Expected Value for Marketing Decisions

Expected value for marketers: weighting each outcome by its probability to value leads, rank tests and compare risky options, with an example and the limits.
Frameworkintermediate8 min readUpdated

What expected value is

Many marketing choices pay off only sometimes. A lead may become a customer or may not. A test may find a better page or may find nothing. A new channel may work or may waste its budget. Comparing such options by their best case flatters the risky ones; comparing them by their worst case flatters the timid ones. Expected value compares them by their average.

The calculation has three steps. First, list the outcomes that matter for each option, such as "the lead closes" and "the lead does not close". Second, give each outcome a probability, so that the probabilities for one option add up to the whole. Third, give each outcome a value, then multiply each value by its probability and add the products. The result is the value the option would produce on average across many similar choices. Costs can be included as negative values, or subtracted at the end, so long as every option is treated the same way.

The guide to valuing a lead by pipeline stage is the clearest example on the site: a lead is worth the margin of the deal it may become multiplied by the share of leads at that stage that go on to close. The guide to conversion events and values across ad platforms uses that figure as the Conversion Value for each lead type, the lead-generation equivalent of revenue for a shop, so that value-based bidding pursues the leads worth most rather than the cheapest. This page describes the idea those guides apply and where else it helps.

Where marketers use it

DecisionThe outcomesWhere the probabilities come fromWhere the values come from
Valuing a lead or enquiry by typeBecomes a customer, or does notThe share of past leads of that type that closed, read from closed cohortsContribution margin of the resulting deal or order
Setting a conversion value for biddingThe conversion leads to a sale, or does notThe same closed-cohort rates, by lead type or stageDeal margin, agreed with finance
Ranking a test backlogThe test wins, finds nothing or losesThe team's own past test results, or a stated judgementThe value of a win if rolled out, less the cost of running the test
Building a forecastEach funnel step converts, or does notThe business's own measured rates, by sourceExpected value per sale, from margin
Choosing between a safe and a risky betEach plausible result of each optionHistory where it exists; otherwise judgements with rangesThe margin each result would produce, less the cost of the bet

In lead generation, the value of a lead is the most a lead from that source can cost before it stops paying for itself. The CPA calculator turns a lead value and a close rate into a maximum cost per lead, which is a quick way to check that a target and the value behind it agree. The probability in that calculation is usually the Win Rate or a stage-to-close rate, and the value is Contribution Margin rather than revenue, for the reasons the lead valuation guide gives.

In testing, the guide to prioritising tests lists expected value as one way to score a backlog: the probability of winning multiplied by the value of a win, set against cost. It calls this the most honest framing of what a test is worth and notes that it needs calibrated probabilities most teams do not have. A test whose Hypothesis rests on strong research deserves a higher probability than one based on a hunch, and a test on a page few people see has a small value even if it wins.

In forecasting, a marketing forecast is a chain of expected values. The guide to a missed marketing forecast describes it as spend multiplied by an expected response, then by conversion rates down the funnel, then by an expected value per sale. When the forecast misses, the same structure shows which probability or value was wrong.

Calibrating the probabilities

Expected value is only as good as its probabilities, and the most common failure is a guess written as a number. Four habits keep the probabilities honest.

Use the business's own history first. A close rate read from the business's own closed cohorts, or a win rate from its own past tests, describes its market and its process. A rate borrowed from an article describes someone else's. The lead valuation guide warns that a published close rate says nothing about yours.

Mark what is measured and what is assumed. The forecast guide asks for every rate to be labelled as measured or assumed, with its source and date, and for assumed rates to be reviewed first. The same rule applies to any expected value: the reader should be able to see which inputs are evidence and which are judgement.

State judgements as ranges. Where there is no history, write a low and a high probability as well as a central one, and calculate the expected value for each. If the decision is the same across the range, the uncertainty does not matter; if it changes, the decision depends on a figure nobody knows, and that is worth knowing.

Check the probabilities against what happens. Keep a record of the probabilities used and the outcomes that followed. If tests rated likely to win rarely do, or leads valued highly rarely close, the probabilities are systematically too optimistic and should be corrected. Refresh values on a schedule, so that a rate from an old cohort does not keep steering budgets after the market has moved.

Worked example: a solar installer values enquiries by type (illustrative)

Illustrative example — not a real result

A solar installer values its enquiries by type

Ophelvrin Solar, an invented solar panel installer, treats every enquiry the same: one bid, one follow-up call.

It reads the past 12 months by enquiry type. Of 600 home enquiries, 48 became installations (8%), each leaving a contribution margin of £1,800, so a home enquiry is worth 0.08 × £1,800 = £144. Of 80 farm enquiries, 12 became installations (15%) at £6,500 each, so a farm enquiry is worth £975. Of 150 small business enquiries, 15 became installations (10%) at £4,000 each, so a small business enquiry is worth £400.

Ophelvrin keeps half of each value as margin and sets cost-per-enquiry ceilings at the other half: £72 for home, £487.50 for farm and £200 for small business enquiries, and passes the three values to its ad platforms as conversion values. Farm enquiries now get a site visit within 5 working days; home enquiries keep the follow-up call.

The farm value rests on only 12 installations, so Ophelvrin also calculates it at 10% and 20%, which gives £650 and £1,300. Farm enquiries remain the most valuable type either way, and the values will be refreshed each quarter.

Limits and criticisms

The answer is only as good as the probabilities, and those are often guesses written as numbers. A figure such as a test's chance of winning can look precise in a spreadsheet while resting on nothing more than optimism. Expected value gives a false sense of rigour when the inputs are weak, which is why the prioritisation guide notes that most teams lack calibrated probabilities.

An average hides the spread. Two options with the same expected value can carry very different risk: one may reliably produce a modest result, the other may usually produce nothing and occasionally a large win. The expected value treats them as equal, and a business may reasonably prefer the steady one.

It suits many small, repeated bets better than one large bet. Across hundreds of leads or dozens of tests, results tend towards the average. A single large commitment gets no such chance: the business experiences one outcome, not the average, and a bad one may be unaffordable. For choices like that, the worst outcome deserves as much attention as the expected one.

And outcomes that are hard to value tend to be left out. Brand effects, learning, customer goodwill and the option to try again later rarely appear in the calculation, because nobody can put a number on them, and options whose benefits are mostly of that kind are systematically undervalued.

The experimentation loop runs the test cycle from research and hypothesis to learning; expected value is one way to decide which test enters the loop next, and the loop's results are what calibrate the probabilities over time. Scenario planning builds a few plausible futures rather than averaging over them, and is the better tool when the spread of outcomes matters more than the average or when probabilities cannot be estimated at all. The comparison of scenario planning and expected value sets the two side by side and shows how to price repeated bets inside each scenario rather than averaging the scenarios. One-way and two-way doors sorts choices by how reversible they are, which helps decide when an expected value is enough to act on and when an irreversible downside should outweigh it. Where the options differ on qualities that cannot be priced, such as fit, support or ease of use, the comparison of expected value and the weighted scoring matrix explains when to score criteria instead and how to use an expected value as one criterion. The marketing frameworks library lists the other planning frameworks by the decision they serve.

Common mistakes

  • Guesses presented as measurements. Mark each probability as measured or assumed, with its source.
  • Borrowed rates. Another business's close or win rate does not describe this one.
  • Revenue instead of margin. Value outcomes by what the business keeps.
  • Treating a lead's expected value as revenue. It is a planning figure, not money received.
  • Ignoring the spread. Compare the range of outcomes, not only the average, before a large bet.
  • Using averages for a bet that cannot be repeated. One irreversible choice needs its worst case weighed.
  • Never checking calibration. Compare past probabilities with what happened and correct them.
  • Stale values. Refresh the values on a schedule so old cohorts do not steer new budgets.

Frequently asked questions

Is the expected value of a lead the same as its revenue?

No. A lead's expected value is the margin of the deal it may become multiplied by the share of similar leads that have closed, so it is a planning figure for the average lead of that kind, not money anyone has received. Most individual leads are worth nothing and a few are worth a full deal. It belongs in budgets, bids and comparisons between sources, never in a revenue report.

What if the business has no history to estimate probabilities from?

Write the probability down as a judgement with a range, say whose judgement it is and what it is based on, and treat the result as a rough ranking rather than a value. Then plan to replace the judgement with the business's own figure as outcomes arrive. A range that is wide but honest is more useful than a single figure that looks precise because someone typed it into a spreadsheet.

When should a team ignore expected value and choose the safer option?

When the worst outcome would do damage the business cannot absorb, for example a commitment that could exhaust the budget, lose a key customer or harm the brand in a way that cannot be undone. Expected value assumes the business can play the same kind of bet many times and let the averages work out. A single large, irreversible bet does not give that chance, so the downside matters more than the average.

Terms used on this page

Tools to try

Frameworks

Where this page is used

Also related

Related