Three numbers: committed, spent and invoiced
Most confusion between marketing and finance about spend comes from using one word for three different things.
Committed is money promised: a signed insertion orderThe contract for a direct or guaranteed media buy, recording what will run, where, when, at what price and what happens if it does not run., an agency statement of work, an event booking, a purchase order raised. Once committed, the money is no longer available to spend elsewhere, even though nothing has been delivered. Marketing needs to track commitments because they are the only reliable way to avoid spending the same money twice across a large team.
Spent is the value of what has been delivered: the media that ran, the work the agency did, the event that happened. This is what finance wants recognised in each month's accounts, because it matches the cost to the period that benefited from it.
Invoiced is what suppliers have billed. Invoices arrive late, early, in batches, in other currencies, and sometimes for several months at once. Finance pays invoices, but the profit and loss should not depend on when a supplier gets round to sending one.
A budget tracker that shows only one of these will mislead. A tracker with just invoices makes marketing look underspent early in the month and overspent later. A tracker with just platform spend misses fees and production. The right view shows all three side by side for each cost line, with the budget beside them, so the remaining headroom is always budget minus committed, not budget minus invoiced. The tracker records money against budget lines rather than what each unit of media cost, which is the job of a media cost history kept from your own buys built from the same orders and invoices. The same distinction matters when the total has to fall, and the guide to cutting a marketing budget across channels starts a cut from the list of commitments and their break points.
Purchase orders, invoices and accruals
Finance controls marketing spend through a small set of documents. Knowing what each does and when it is needed avoids most month-end friction.
| Document | What it is | When marketing needs it | What goes wrong without it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase order | Finance's authorisation for a supplier to deliver against a cost line | Before work starts with an agency, freelancer or media supplier | Invoices cannot be paid; suppliers chase marketing; spend escapes the tracker |
| Statement of work or insertion order | The supplier's agreement on scope, price and timing | At commitment | Disputes over what was agreed; invoices that do not match the plan |
| Invoice | The supplier's bill | After delivery or on agreed billing dates | Cost cannot be paid; accrual cannot be released |
| Goods received or approval | Confirmation that what was invoiced was delivered | When the invoice arrives | Paying for undelivered work; approval delays |
| Accrual | A month-end entry recognising cost delivered but not yet invoiced | At each month-end for any uninvoiced delivery | Cost lands in the wrong month; variance reports show false under- and overspends |
| Prepayment | A cost paid in advance and released over the months it covers | For annual subscriptions or deposits, if finance's policy applies | One month shows a large overspend and the rest look underspent |
Accruals deserve special attention because they are the line owner's job. At month-end, finance needs to know what was delivered but not invoiced: media that ran on an agency's account, a project halfway through, a freelancer's days. The owner provides the figure, with a note of the evidence; finance books it and reverses it when the invoice arrives. An accrual is an estimate, and finance accepts estimates. What it does not accept is silence followed by a surprise invoice months later. The tutorial on estimating marketing accruals at month-end shows the owner how to build that estimate for each kind of supplier and check it against the invoices that follow. Affiliate commission is the line where the amount owed is still changing at month-end, and the tutorial on closing the month on affiliate commissions validates, estimates and matches it before the figure reaches finance.
The monthly reconciliation
Once a month, after finance closes the books, match marketing's tracker to the ledger line by line. The reconciliation answers one question: does every cost in the ledger correspond to a cost in the tracker, and the other way round?
Work through it in order. First, pull the ledger extract for marketing's cost centres from finance. Second, compare each cost line's ledger total with the tracker's spent figure for the month. Third, for each difference, find the cause: a cost coded to the wrong line or cost centre, an accrual missed or duplicated, a currency or tax difference, a cost marketing did not know about, or a timing difference between delivery and booking. Fourth, correct what can be corrected, either by asking finance to recode or by updating the tracker, and record the rest as known differences.
Most reconciliations find the same handful of causes repeatedly. Agency-billed media arrives with the fee combined and needs splitting. Platform spend in one currency is invoiced in another. Software is booked to a central technology cost centre in some months and to marketing in others. Once these patterns are known, they can be fixed at source, with clearer purchase orders, agreed codes and a standing note to finance, and the reconciliation gets faster each month. Where software lines keep growing, the tutorial on reviewing marketing tool licences and seats compares what each licence bills for with what the team actually uses. The marketing budget month-end close checklist turns this routine, with the accruals, variance notes and forecast around it, into a list to tick each month.
A reconciled month is the only safe basis for reporting return. Return on ad spend (ROASRevenue generated per unit of ad spend.) or return on investment (ROIProfit relative to cost.) calculated on unreconciled cost will be wrong, and finance will know.
Explaining variances
A variance is the gap between the budget, or the latest forecast, and the actual. Finance does not expect zero variances; it expects them explained, quickly and specifically. Agree a threshold with the finance business partner below which no explanation is needed, so attention goes to the variances that matter. The management by exception framework sets out the principle behind the threshold: a tolerance agreed in advance, a named person who acts when a line breaks it, and a short summary for the lines inside it.
Each material variance needs three things: the cause, whether it is timing or permanent, and what happens next. Timing variances reverse on their own: a campaign moved a month later shows an underspend now and an overspend next month, and the full year is unchanged. Permanent variances do not: a supplier price increase, a cancelled event, a channel that could not absorb planned spend. Permanent variances change the full-year forecast and must be carried into the next reforecast. When the whole budget is behind plan and finance asks whether the money is still needed, the diagnosis for an underspent marketing budget splits the gap line by line into timing and activity that is genuinely not happening, cause by cause.
Write variance explanations in finance's language: which line, how much, timing or permanent, full-year effect. Avoid campaign jargon. "Paid social underspent because creative approval slipped; spend moves into next month; no full-year change" is a complete explanation. "Optimising towards efficiency" is not.
Variances in outcomes matter as much as variances in cost. If a line is on budget but its key performance indicator (KPIA metric tied directly to an objective.) is well below plan, finance will eventually ask why spending continues. Report cost and outcome variances together, so the conversation is about value rather than just money. The marketing P&L template carries these explanations as variance notes beside each line, next to the revenue and margin the spend produced.
Reforecasting and reallocation rules
Reforecasts are the formal points at which the full-year view is updated. They are when marketing should raise permanent variances, propose moving money between lines and return money it will not use well.
Agree reallocation rules at the start of the year, ideally as part of the sign-off pack in the budget-building tutorial. Typical rules cover who can move money between lines within marketing without asking finance, the size of move that needs finance approval, whether contingency can be released between reforecasts, and whether underspends can be carried forward or must be returned. The same question arises for money held for branches or franchisees, and the guide to running a shared local marketing fund sets the unspent-money rule in advance alongside the claims each site makes.
Moves between lines should follow evidence. Money should go to lines whose marginal return is above target and come from lines that cannot spend well or whose returns have fallen. Moving money because one line is underspent and another is popular, without outcome evidence, is how budgets drift away from their objectives. A budget reallocation memo puts each proposed move, its evidence and its approval on one page, and records the version of the budget sheet that changed. Where paid media is allowed to flex with results rather than follow a fixed line, the target-led paid media budget tutorial writes these rules into one agreement with a ceiling, a floor and a stopping rule.
Platform budgets and pacing are a separate, finer-grained layer. A daily campaign budget in an ad platform controls delivery within the month; the marketing budget controls the month and the year. The Google Ads budgets and pacing guide covers how platform budgets behave, and they should be set so that the month's platform spend lands close to the phased line, not left to run until someone notices.
Working with finance systems
Finance systems vary from a spreadsheet and an accounting package to a full enterprise planning tool, but the principles hold. Marketing's tracker should use the same cost codes and cost centres as the ledger, so a ledger extract can be matched automatically. Purchase orders should reference the budget line, so every commitment can be traced. Invoices should be approved by the line owner promptly, because late approval delays payment and strains supplier relationships. The tutorial on raising purchase orders and approving marketing invoices walks one purchase from the decision to buy to a closed order.
Keep marketing's tracker as a working tool, not a rival ledger. The ledger is the record; the tracker adds commitments and outcome measures the ledger does not hold. When they disagree after reconciliation, the ledger wins and the tracker is corrected.
Where platform spend is also loaded into a data warehouse for reporting, the guide to loading ad platform data into a warehouse explains how that daily spent figure is kept in step with the platforms and reconciled to them before it reaches the tracker.
The Chartered Institute of Marketing treats financial control as a core marketing competence, and in practice that means a named owner for the tracker, a standing month-end routine and a shared calendar of close dates and reforecasts. How marketing costs then appear in the company's accounts is covered in the marketing P&L guide, and the wider budgeting picture in the budgeting hub. The marketing budget calculator is useful for quick what-if checks when a reforecast proposes a new total.
A regional gym chain's month-end reconciliation
Fernlea Fitness, a chain of nine gyms, budgeted £42,000 of marketing for April. The tracker showed £38,500 spent, but the ledger showed £29,800. Reconciliation found three causes: £6,200 of paid social run by the agency in April had not been accrued because the invoice was due in May; £1,900 of leaflet printing had been coded to the operations cost centre; and £600 was a currency difference on a platform invoice. After the accrual and recoding, the ledger showed £37,900 against budget, a £4,100 underspend. Of that, £3,000 was a timing variance from a referral campaign moved to May and £1,100 was permanent, from a cancelled sponsorship, which marketing returned at the June reforecast.
The seasonal peaks guide to the budget calculator shows how to set a peak total and pace it by day, which gives the variance report its baseline.
Common mistakes
- Tracking invoices instead of commitments. Headroom calculated on invoices looks larger than it is, and teams commit money that is already promised.
- Leaving accruals to finance. Finance cannot know what an agency delivered last week; without marketing's input, costs land in the wrong month.
- Explaining variances in campaign language. Finance needs line, amount, timing or permanent, and full-year effect, not optimisation narratives.
- Spending underspends at year end. Late, hurried spend buys poor results and teaches finance that marketing budgets are padded.
- Letting platform budgets run unpaced. Daily platform settings that ignore the phased line produce monthly variances that were entirely avoidable.
- Keeping a rival ledger. A tracker that disagrees with the ledger and is never corrected becomes a second version of the truth, and the ledger always wins.
