First, split the variance line by line into timing and real
Start from the tracker, not the total. For each budget line, set the phased budget to date beside the spend to date and ask one question: did the activity this money was meant to buy happen in the period? Two answers put a line in the timing pile: the work was delivered but nothing was invoiced or accrued, or the activity was never planned for these months and an even split of the year put the money there anyway. In both cases the figures need correcting, not the marketing.
Then look forward. A line can be behind on spend and still be fully promised for the rest of the year, because a signed order never reached the tracker. The guide to tracking spend against budget explains why that matters: committed, spent and invoiced are three different numbers, and a tracker that records only invoices shows marketing behind early in each month and ahead later on.
Everything else is real: a campaign waiting for an order, a platform campaign that would not spend, work nobody had time to start. For each real line, note why it did not happen and whether it still can this year; the scenario planning framework later frames the reforecast's choice.
Neighbouring problems have their own pages. If marketing's figures and finance's ledger disagree, start with the diagnosis for marketing spend not matching the ledger. If outcomes fell short too, the diagnosis for a missed marketing forecast splits the results into volume, rate and timing.
Diagnosis table
Diagnosis
| Symptom | Check | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quiet months show an underspend; the busy months ahead look tight | Each line's phasing against the campaign calendar | A budget phased evenly while spend follows the calendar | Rephase the remaining months to the calendar at the reforecast |
| A line looks behind though the supplier has delivered | Delivered work with no invoice and no accrual | Delivered work never accrued | The line owner sends an accrual note with evidence before the cut-off |
| Headroom looks large, yet suppliers are booked for months ahead | Signed orders and bookings missing from the commitments log | Commitments missing from the tracker | Log commitments the day they are agreed; headroom is budget minus committed |
| Planned work starts weeks late while suppliers wait | Time from agreed quote to raised order, and who could commit | Work waiting for an order or for authority | One accountable role and a deputy per spending decision |
| Paid media lines fall short while campaigns are live | Campaigns held back by targets, and days paused | Platform campaigns that cannot spend | Decide on the target, not the budget; treat paused days as lost |
| Funded lines that nobody has started | Capacity by skill against the work due | A plan that assumed capacity the team lacks | Buy capacity, move the work or release the money |
| The gap is first discussed in the final quarter | Whether past reforecasts raised it as timing or permanent | Underspends not raised at a reforecast | Raise each real gap as keep, move or return, with evidence |
Fix, verify and prevent each cause
A budget phased evenly while spend follows the calendar
The tutorial on building a marketing budget spreads each line across the months in which its cost is actually incurred, which finance reads as the month of delivery: media tracks the campaign calendar and seasonal demand, events land in their own month. An annual total divided by twelve flags variances every month in a seasonal business, and before a peak those flags read as an underspend that is only timing.
Fix: leave the approved budget as approved and, at the next reforecast, rephase the remaining months of the latest forecast line by line to the calendar; ask finance how it wants the change shown, since phasingSpreading each budget line across the months it will actually be spent in, rather than dividing the year evenly, so actuals can be read against plan. feeds a company forecast finance owns.
Verify: lines that follow the calendar show small variances in quiet and busy months alike, and the year total is unchanged.
Prevent: phase next year from the calendar rather than the total, with a note beside each peak naming the campaign behind it.
Delivered work that was never accrued
When a supplier delivers in one month and invoices in a later one, the line looks behind until the bill arrives and then jumps ahead. That is spend already received, not money saved, and offering it back leaves the invoice with nothing to pay it from. The tutorial on estimating marketing accruals gives the method: the line owner lists every supplier with work in the month, separates delivered from merely promised, estimates the delivered part from evidence and sends finance a note before its cut-off; finance books the accrualAn estimate of what was received in a month but not yet invoiced, booked so the cost lands in the month that benefited rather than whenever the invoice arrives. and reverses it when the invoice arrives.
Fix: write the accrual for each uninvoiced delivery in the open month, and ask finance how it wants any invoice received but not yet approved treated, since that is its decision.
Verify: when the invoice arrives the line does not jump, because the accrual reverses against it.
Prevent: send an accrual note every month whether or not a line looks behind, and compare each month's estimates with the invoices that follow.
Commitments missing from the tracker
The tutorial on setting up a marketing budget tracker calculates headroom as budget, or latest forecast, minus everything committed, never minus what has been invoiced. A signed agency order or event booking missing from the commitments log makes the money left look larger than it is, so a line can appear underspent for the year while all of it is already committedMoney already promised to suppliers through a signed order, booking or statement of work, tracked apart from what has been spent or invoiced.. At an underspend review, that money is the easiest to offer back by mistake.
Fix: ask everyone who commits money what they have agreed, log each commitment with its order reference, amount, months and break point, and recalculate headroom. Clear the opposite error too: an order left open after the work finished holds headroom nobody needs, as the purchase order tutorial warns, so close it.
Verify: no invoice arrives in later months for work missing from the log.
Prevent: add commitments the day they are agreed, check the log weekly with the people who commit money, and close finished orders at month-end.
Work waiting for an order or for someone with authority to commit
The tutorial on purchase orders and invoice approval puts the order before the work. When nobody can raise it, because the line was never checked, the supplier is not set up or the person allowed to agree the spend is away, the work does not start and the line falls behind for a reason unrelated to need. The guide to setting spending authority lists the decisions that commit money, from agreeing a quote and raising a purchase orderFinance's authorisation for a supplier to deliver against a named cost line, raised for the agreed amount before work starts and used to check the invoice. to raising a platform budget, and gives each one accountable role, a limit finance sets and a named deputy; without the deputy, decisions stall and suppliers wait.
Fix: find who could not act on each stalled line and why, raise the outstanding orders, and agree with finance a delegation table with a holder and deputy for every decision.
Verify: for the next purchases, the wait between quote agreed and order raised shortens and work starts on its planned date.
Prevent: raise orders for known commitments at budget approval, as the budget tutorial's sign-off pack suggests, and review the spending authorityThe written answer to who may make each decision that commits money, such as an order, invoice or budget change, and how far before someone else must agree. table whenever someone joins, leaves or changes role.
Platform campaigns that cannot spend
A paid media line can fall behind while every campaign is live. Google's help page on average daily budgets describes the budget as an average over the month held within a monthly limit, and the Google Ads budgets and pacing guide draws two consequences. A campaign bidding to a target can underspend when the target is hard to reach: the budget matters only once the campaign is limited by it, so the question is the target. And the monthly limit is an upper bound, not an amount owed, so a campaign paused for some days does not spend them later.
Fix: separate campaigns held back by targets from those that were paused. For the first, decide whether the target still fits the economics; loosening it buys results at a higher cost, while keeping it makes the shortfall a real gap for the reforecast. Why one campaign will not spend belongs to Google Ads not spending budget, Meta ads not spending budget and DV360 line item not spending. Record paused days as lost.
Verify: the guide's weekly comparison of spend so far this month with the plan pro-rated to date shows each media line on its phasing or carrying an explained gap.
Prevent: set platform budgets so the month lands close to the phased line, and note a pause in the variance the day it happens.
A plan that assumed capacity the team does not have
Some lines are approved and funded yet untouched, because the people who would do the work are busy. The guide to prioritising work and capacity holds that ranked work becomes a plan only once it is set against the hours available, skill by skill as well as for the team as a whole: a team with hours to spare can still be short of design time, and then the underspend is one money alone cannot cure.
Fix: for each line waiting for people, bring in agency or freelance help for the busy period, as the guide suggests where a specialist is the constraint, move the work to a quarter with room, or drop it and release the money at the reforecast.
Verify: every line due next quarter has a named person and a start date on the roadmap.
Prevent: check the draft budget against capacity by skill before sign-off, so a line is funded only when someone can deliver it.
Underspends not raised at a reforecast
Reforecasts are when marketing raises permanent variances, proposes moves between lines and returns money it will not use well. A gap left out of them waits for the final quarter, where it becomes a hurried spend or a clawback made without marketing's view.
Fix: at the next reforecastA rebuild of the full-year view of the budget from actual spend and what marketing now knows, done at the points finance sets; not a fresh budget., build each line's latest estimate as the tutorial on reforecasting a marketing budget describes, mark every change timing or permanent, and give each real gap a proposal: keep it where the activity will still happen this year, move it to a line that has shown it can use the money well, or return it. For larger gaps, the scenario planning framework presents the choice as cases with the condition under which each applies, such as an order raised by an agreed date, so the decision is made before the signpost arrives. Each move goes on a budget reallocation memo; shifting money from a slow line to a favoured one with no evidence of outcomes is how a budget drifts from its objectives.
Verify: the approved latest estimate agrees with the revised budget and no line carries an unexplained gap into the last quarter.
Prevent: make the underspend a standing item at every monthly review, so it reaches each reforecast already explained.
Prevention: phasing from the calendar, commitments logged weekly and the underspend raised at every reforecast
All seven causes share one trace: a monthly variance nobody split. The Chartered Institute of Marketing counts financial control among a marketer's core skills, which the tracking guide puts into practice as a named owner for the tracker and a standing month-end routine. Prevention adds three habits to that routine, one for each way a gap hides.
Phase from the calendar. When the budget is built and at every reforecast, phase each line to the months its campaigns, events and production actually fall in, with the reason for each peak written down, so a variance on it is worth reading.
Log commitments as they happen and check them weekly. Every order, booking and statement of work enters the log the day it is agreed, the people who commit money confirm each week that nothing is missing, and finished orders close at month-end. The monthly accrual note, checked against the invoices that follow, belongs in the same routine.
Raise the underspend at every reforecast. Each monthly variance note names the line and the amount, says whether the gap will close by itself or not and what it does to the year's total, and each real gap carries its keep, move or return proposal forward. Around these habits sit the smaller checks: weekly pacing on platform lines, a delegation table with deputies, and a capacity check before a line is funded. Close dates, formats and approval limits stay finance's; marketing's part is to arrive with the gap already split. The marketing finance troubleshooting hub lists the other diagnoses for problems that show once the numbers reach finance.
An outdoor equipment retailer separates timing from real underspend (illustrative)
Fiskelbrae Outdoor splits its mid-year underspend
Fiskelbrae Outdoor, an invented outdoor equipment retailer with a marketing budget of £480,000, is told at its mid-year review that marketing is £69,000 behind: £171,000 spent against £240,000 phased. Finance wants to know whether the money is still needed.
The head of marketing splits the gap line by line. £35,000 is phasing: the budget was divided evenly by month, but most campaign spend falls in the weeks before the walking season, in the second half of the year, and phased to the calendar the first half would have carried £205,000. Another £9,000 is a show stand delivered in April with no accrual, invoiced in July. Separately, a signed £18,000 agency order for the autumn content programme was missing from the tracker, so the year's headroom looked £18,000 larger than it was.
The remaining £25,000 is real. Two paid search campaigns are £8,000 behind because their target cost per order holds delivery back; the team checks the margin and keeps the targets. A £7,000 video series waited a month for a purchase order while the only person able to raise one was on leave. A £10,000 catalogue never started, because the one designer was booked on the spring range.
At the reforecast the retailer rephases its remaining months, adds the accrual and the agency order, and logs commitments and accruals monthly. The video series keeps its money and runs a month late. The paid search line gives back £16,000, the first half's shortfall and the same again expected. The catalogue's £10,000 moves to email on a reallocation memo, with the spring send results as evidence, and finance sets a limit of £10,000 up to which the marketing manager may raise orders as deputy.
Common mistakes
- Answering the review with the total. One figure mixes timing and real gaps.
- Offering back money already promised. Check the commitments log before returning anything.
- Treating an unaccrued delivery as a saving. The invoice will arrive.
- Raising the budget of a campaign held back by its target. More budget changes nothing.
- Waiting for paused days to be made up. The monthly limit is a ceiling, not a debt.
- Funding work nobody has time to do. The money waits as long as the people do.
- Spending the gap in the final weeks. Hurried spend buys poor results.
- Moving money because another line is popular. A move needs outcome evidence on a memo.
